Brain Teasers
Brain Teasers Trivia Mentalrobics Games Community
Personal Links
Your Favorites
Puzzle
Hang Glider
Sudoku
Beanstalk
Pirate's Booty
Word Search
Code Breaker
Math Path
Disco
Tetris
Battleship
Sliding Tile
Twiddle
Strategy
Cookie World
Food Fight
Chess
Checkers
Werewolf
Who's the Boss?
Entertaining
Pac-Man
Caption Game
Click The Button
Zoo Keeper
Add to Google delicious Add to del.icio.us

More ways to get Braingle...
rss

The Werewolf Game #2998

< Back to the game list

This game is moderated by Rhythmic. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.

Voting Discussion
This game finished in 7 rounds.

Discussion of Round #3

Round: 0  1  2  3  4  5  6  7  

AuthorMessage
RhythmicAus


Posted: 01:33PM Nov 20, 2013

23 hrs and 51 mins left of the day...
PianistChris was a werewolf. Skybet was not the seer.


---This message was edited on 2013-11-20 13:34:20---

"For me, the saxophone is a way of expression" - Kenneth Thomson
Back to Top 
changhill*us


Posted: 01:35PM Nov 20, 2013

Wow that was a fast round and good shot. Waiting to get home before I post more.

*rawr*
Back to Top 
bradon182001*us


Posted: 01:40PM Nov 20, 2013

What he ^ said. Love short nights. Will SPV for now, be back after others have had a chance to check in. SPV caberet once again.

Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 01:57PM Nov 20, 2013

well golly people that was nice....skybet eating makes sense. Dfram and Chang should be off the hook as well....gonna SPV, let me think for a little but not sure there is too much to take away as for suspect following Chris' demise

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
dfamina


Posted: 01:58PM Nov 20, 2013

Can't say that this eating is all that surprising, either. Checking in for now, and SPVing, which will likely be changed later. That was quite an exciting Round Two, everyone.
Back to Top 
Longhorn_fanAus


Posted: 02:03PM Nov 20, 2013

geeze....that was super fast. I leave for lunch and it is night. I come back it is day. WOW

Glad Chris was a wolf. Good thing we still have a seer. I would think they have had a chance to have 2 divinations now as I believe everyone voted in the last 2 rounds.

For the time being I am going to place a SPV. I will be back after more people have posted and the round develops a bit.


Like what you love, and love what you got.
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 02:21PM Nov 20, 2013

Crisp always does something really stupid to get himself shot as a wolf (well if you can call barely posting really stupid)

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
Longhorn_fanAus


Posted: 02:36PM Nov 20, 2013

Wow....crazy day.
Armed intruder in hospital. we are on lockdown


Like what you love, and love what you got.
Back to Top 
nidhoggAgb


Posted: 02:38PM Nov 20, 2013

Agree that this probably clears changhill and dfamina, don't have any other ideas though. I'll come back later and see what's happened before voting
Back to Top 
jeminyten


Posted: 02:51PM Nov 20, 2013

PC's lack of post isn't too helpful in finding other wolves but at least we've made some progress on the clearing front.

Chris voted for bradon two rounds in a row but I can't draw any conclusions from that. I don't want to SPV at this stage in the game but I really can't find anything to go on and it's probably the most useful thing I can do at the moment.


I had a signature but then I forgot it 0.o
Back to Top 
HarryPutter*ca


Posted: 03:30PM Nov 20, 2013

I don't think a wolf would vote for their partner if they don't even have a chance to get back on and switch their vote That's way too dangerous. So for that reason I would err on the side of human for bradon. I would consider chang pretty human, but not sure on dfam (though obviously he would get the benefit of the doubt).

I'll do a semi-random spv


Cloud nine gets all the publicity, but cloud eight actually is cheaper, less crowded, and has a better view.
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 03:40PM Nov 20, 2013

Any reason you came up with Brady....just cause of the way things went down last round?

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
caberetAus


Posted: 04:47PM Nov 20, 2013

Wahooooey! 1 down...

I never like when players post their 'clears' publicly. Not this early in the game. It seems to be a way for wolf partners to 'talk' to each other in a TB-free game. I've done it. You've done it... Following this logic, I find both Spider and nidhogg suspicious. My vote will go to 1 or the other of them.

LH - I hope everything is resolved peacefully!

Edit: I switched my vote from nidhogg to Spider because there's already a vote on nidhogg and I'm not overly confident about my detection method.


---This message was edited on 2013-11-20 17:02:01---

"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Back to Top 
mbrady89Aus


Posted: 06:48PM Nov 20, 2013

First of all, I got on to read yesterday and try to find something useful and it said there were 23hrs and 58mins left in night round... i was sad. Anyway, I'm going to put in a vote for spider because he seems to be playing more aggressively than he did as human last game. Also, my "conscience cop" is kicking in and pretending to be better than others isn't okay.
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 07:39PM Nov 20, 2013

Cab, you honestly believe its some secret underground knowledge that the person, who late in the round, broke a tie and got a wolf shot is likely 'clear' , honestly?!

and Brady, who said I'm pretending '

but on a serious note, if we want to talk about no person is inherently any better than someone else, fine thats cool, but this somewhat pervasive delusion that there is absolutelty no skill disparity in a game of skill needs to stop

also, I think there may be a new bot invasion, i saw like 30 strange random letter string usernames pop up all at once......be afraid


---This message was edited on 2013-11-20 20:26:34---

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
dfamina


Posted: 10:31PM Nov 20, 2013

Popping in real quick before I head off to sleep, but there's not much to draw from in this round so far. More grief for Spider, etc.

I'll be back in the morning to gather my thoughts and I'll change my vote accordingly.
Back to Top 
HarryPutter*ca


Posted: 12:24AM Nov 21, 2013

We're all equally friends

It's good that mbrady is now going after someone...excellent. I'll change to a non-voter.


Cloud nine gets all the publicity, but cloud eight actually is cheaper, less crowded, and has a better view.
Back to Top 
HarryPutter*ca


Posted: 12:25AM Nov 21, 2013

bradon182001 voted for caberet
caberet voted for The_Spider
changhill voted for changhill
dfamina voted for Longhorn_fan
HarryPutter voted for nidhogg
jeminy voted for nidhogg
Longhorn_fan voted for bradon182001
mbrady89 voted for The_Spider
The_Spider voted for jeminy

majorities tied up


Cloud nine gets all the publicity, but cloud eight actually is cheaper, less crowded, and has a better view.
Back to Top 
jeminyten


Posted: 02:02AM Nov 21, 2013

I feel really useless in this game

I'm quite happy at where my vote is. I'd rather a nidhogg majority than a Spid one. Apart from that nothing more to add.


I had a signature but then I forgot it 0.o
Back to Top 
nidhoggAgb


Posted: 03:41AM Nov 21, 2013

I'm assuming that The Spider will be saved if it comes down to a two-way tie between us, which isn't a great situation for me
I might not be able to get on before the round ends (long journey today) so I'll vote for Longhorn now, not through certainty... but she does seem a bit suspicious and it adds another majority. Good luck guys
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 06:01AM Nov 21, 2013

Well its odd because the reason, outside of nighogg's, i was voted for in Rd 2 was because i was too active in Round 1, and because Im too aggressive all game. These are like textbook things described about me as a player, so its a bit disturbing. Cab's reasoning is pretty tenuous (as I find it also fairly typical play to say who you feel is human and do it quite often)

not a whole lot to go off of, wont swtich my vote to Hog yet as that would essentially force this round down a one way street. For the record, I anticipated from the outset both Brady (morality police) and Nidhogg being problems for me this game, so I suggest I would have at least tried to eat one of them Rd1.

Beyond that, we still have a non-voter or two iirc.....ill see if any alternatives come up, but will switch to nidhogg if i have to...oh I was assuming i had 3 votes on me....regardless, I will see where things stand when i look over the game


---This message was edited on 2013-11-21 06:02:24---

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
dfamina


Posted: 07:19AM Nov 21, 2013

I don't have much inclination to have LH in a majority. I haven't yet seen anything from her that stands out. (I do hope all went well, by the way.) I don't have any hunches about Spider, either. As far as I can tell, he's playing as always.

I do agree with what Spider said, though. Cab hasn't had much of a presence this game, and her one post containing substance also gave a pretty weak reason for voting the way she did. I don't care much for mbrady's reason for voting, either. He went the "morality police" route last time and turned out to be wolf, but I know that every game's different. Still, it seems to have nothing to do with any amount of suspicion, and he's instead making it personal. I don't know that I could see them working together, but I've never been any good at pair analysis.

I believe I'm voting cab this time around, but I would like to see what Smithy has to say.
Back to Top 
changhill*us


Posted: 07:56AM Nov 21, 2013

df, I will join you on that LH vote. But unless people are gonna get focused. we will need to address the nihogg/spider vote.

*rawr*
Back to Top 
changhill*us


Posted: 08:04AM Nov 21, 2013

bradon182001 voted for caberet
dfamina voted for caberet

mbrady89 voted for The_Spider
caberet voted for The_Spider

HarryPutter voted for nidhogg
jeminy voted for nidhogg


Longhorn_fan voted for bradon182001
nidhogg voted for Longhorn_fan
The_Spider voted for jeminy
changhill voted for changhill

Sorry about the double post, I needed a look at the current voting list. From just an observational view. We need a stronger majority than just 2/3 votes. Why is spider not in a majority? or nidhogg?I think being a realist, I am looking at a nidhgg-lh combo or a jeminy-brandon combo. Still no word from smithy this round.


*rawr*
Back to Top 
dfamina


Posted: 08:07AM Nov 21, 2013

Chang, I just moved off of LH - she was just my SPV in the beginning, and I don't have anything substantial on her yet. While I'm certainly keeping an eye on Spid/nidhogg, I don't suspect Spider. I know it looks like I'm pretty adamantly defending him, but I haven't yet seen a good reason for folks to keep suspecting him. I'll admit that I'm not the best WWG player out there, so perhaps I'm just missing something. Really, though, I see him having to defend his actions as a player more than as a human.

nidhogg, I don't have a read on just yet.

Edit: I swear that simul-post thing happens to me at least once every round.

To address your most recent post, chang, more than one person has defended bradon this round, so I don't know that I could base a suspicion of her off of jem's post alone. Unless you have another reason? I don't know if I've ever played with her or if she's always this quiet, but I just realized that I've been overlooking her posts entirely. (Talk about a lack of presence.) All I see from her is a pretty hot trail on cab, which I didn't notice until after I'd voted.

I don't have the strongest of suspicions for cab, so I could be persuaded, but I still can't help but think that her reasoning this round is as flimsy as they come.


---This message was edited on 2013-11-21 08:14:05---
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 08:13AM Nov 21, 2013

I already explained why im not in a majority (firstly there are 5 hours left) secondly, all it does it create an arms race and you end up locking yourself into your own fate......whats the rush, I'll defend myself when it comes to it keep your shirt on

i dont know if I really agree with Harry's reasoning for thinking Bradon is human.....Chris did get back on he just never posted again....but not sure I really want to vote her, she does owe us another post though


---This message was edited on 2013-11-21 08:33:51---

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
Longhorn_fanAus


Posted: 08:39AM Nov 21, 2013

Good morning all.

yesterday was on the strange side to say the least.....The gunman was apprended and taken to jail. He was POed at his ex-wife, an employee atthe hospital.

Anyhow on with game.

I am really not sure on the nidhogg/spider thing.

I honestly think Spider and Harry might be a good choice.

Dan is not offering any reasons for voting the player he is voting. He is such a good player but yet it seems he is doing a lot of trash talkig to others. I think that Cab's post made a very good point abhout the public "clears" and in all honesty I never thought of it the way she posted. In that aspect I think Cab is a human. When she is a wolf she does not offer a lot of insight.

Harry still had that one post that I am just not sure about when he mentioned contributing to the game.....just was not a harry statement.

Nidhogg, IDK....I am not too familer with him but he seems to be posting often and being defensive, but not overly defensive.

OK now that I have posted this........wait for it........the rebutle

get ready, here it comes.


Like what you love, and love what you got.
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 09:06AM Nov 21, 2013

Other players have raised Cab's point in the past and I couldnt disagree more with it. There is not a single player in this game who needs to be told Dfam/Chang are likely cleared. Since when does eliminating humans from the suspect pile = wolf play, its actually one of the cornerstones of human play (granted a clear based on secret/indisputable information (i.e a clue or reward) is something different, but this info is available to all. Besides, the wolves are hunting the seer at this point in time...making my need to stick my neck out to get Chang/dfam eaten even more tenuous...ESPECIALLY after my 'partners' correctly ate another would be clear in Sky for his role in the Chris shooting.

my vote is an SPV, I have 4 hours to make my decision, and as Ive explained for now the third time, since I am in a tied situation, I do not like to take a direction too early as it tends to force the round down one path before it is neccessary.

it would also be easier if some people didnt seem to interpret a one post limit into this round. Harry is a bit 'stand offish' but not going that way at this stage.

bradon182001 voted for caberet
caberet voted for The_Spider
changhill voted for changhill
dfamina voted for caberet
HarryPutter voted for nidhogg
jeminy voted for nidhogg
Longhorn_fan voted for The_Spider
mbrady89 voted for The_Spider
nidhogg voted for Longhorn_fan
The_Spider voted for caberet

more suspcious of bradon than Cab at this point but changed my vote to Cab, at least I cant get revenge voted..

I trash talked' you because you took one incident 18 months or so ago where I ate you in round one, and managed to contort it into "spider generally eats me in Round 1"

its a discussion based game in which you put me in a majority, and you sarcastically allude to my rebutal. I guess it would be fine if I opened up by calling everyone pipsqueaks right

oh and Smithy, to address your question from back in Round 2, the 'inkling' I had about you didnt develop until after Trains was revealed as human, it got me thinking a bit about the round, its a very minor thing anyway


---This message was edited on 2013-11-21 09:41:03---

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
bradon182001*us


Posted: 09:48AM Nov 21, 2013

Not sure what to think of HP . He's being unusually laid back, but if I remember correctly, he did say once that he didn't really get involved in a game until the later rounds, so will hold off making any kind of decision about his identity

I'm still good with my Cab vote. The fact that she seems to be coasting along not really offering anything except indecision of her detection method just doesn't sound like the human Cab. She's normally more confident, just seems to be trying to stay out of everything. That's really all I have to go on.

I'm also trying to get some feel for some of the others that I haven't played with before, or very little at best. I really don't see anything that I can grab on to and say "that's wolfie," so leaving my vote where it is.

LH, glad everything went okay for you yesterday. I worked in a hospital that had a similar situation, really scary and what a relief you feel when the all clear in sounded.

.


Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Back to Top 
Longhorn_fanAus


Posted: 11:55AM Nov 21, 2013

Voting for Round #3
Day
It takes 6 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.

bradon182001 voted for caberet
caberet voted for The_Spider
changhill voted for changhill
dfamina voted for caberet
HarryPutter voted for nidhogg
jeminy voted for nidhogg
Longhorn_fan voted for The_Spider
mbrady89 voted for The_Spider
nidhogg voted for Longhorn_fan
The_Spider voted for caberet

Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet
_______
Voting list as of 1 hour and 30 minutes left


Like what you love, and love what you got.
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 11:56AM Nov 21, 2013

dfam any chance of going nidhogg i was hoping jem (on but didnt post) or Harry might side with me...or even Chang or Mr Elusive himself might but its getting rather late here

seriously is this how this round is gonna trickle down...booo...like half of you


---This message was edited on 2013-11-21 12:17:10---

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
dfamina


Posted: 12:16PM Nov 21, 2013

I think I could go with nidhogg. I don't think Smithy will show up before the round ends, or with enough time to really evaluate things if he does. nidhogg is a wild card for me, and to be honest, I don't like having absolutely no read on someone. I know that sounds weird, but it'll nag at me as long as he's here.

Changing my vote to nidhogg, final answer.
Back to Top 
HarryPutter*ca


Posted: 12:20PM Nov 21, 2013

I'll keep my vote though it's unfortunate smithy didnt even SPV

Cloud nine gets all the publicity, but cloud eight actually is cheaper, less crowded, and has a better view.
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 12:25PM Nov 21, 2013

bradon182001 voted for caberet
caberet voted for The_Spider
changhill voted for changhill
dfamina voted for nidhogg
HarryPutter voted for nidhogg
jeminy voted for nidhogg
Longhorn_fan voted for The_Spider
mbrady89 voted for The_Spider
nidhogg voted for Longhorn_fan
The_Spider voted for nidhogg

Smithy, he's a straight shooter with upper management written all over him


Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
The_SpiderAus


Posted: 01:19PM Nov 21, 2013

Chang switched over to Jem....though I kind of find 'throwaway' votes odd at this point...at least it's not on me....and I actually like his vote, Jem would be in the mix of my suspects list for the moment

Let the games, begin!
Back to Top 
RhythmicAus


Posted: 01:26PM Nov 21, 2013

Night posting: 23 hours, 58 minutes left
nidhogg was human


"For me, the saxophone is a way of expression" - Kenneth Thomson
Back to Top 

 




You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
   



Users in Chat : None 

Online Now: 5 users and 363 guests

Copyright © 1999-2014 | Updates | FAQ | RSS | Widgets | Links | Green | Subscribe | Contact | Privacy | Conditions | Advertise

Custom Search





Sign In A Create a free account