|
| Posted by gaiapeach1 | 03/11/06 |
| Wow, that was beautiful. Very long and complex, not a single dead give away in the whole thing, and FUNNY!!! I was cackling halfway through the story. Thank you. :lol: |
|
| Posted by Lui312 | 03/11/06 |
| long long long i think ill try my luck on short ones |
|
| Posted by Brainy_1 | 03/11/06 |
| I love, love, love this!! :D And of course the names!! Right down to Capriel!! :) It was great fun to read and to figure out! Wonderful job! As usual! :D |
|
| Posted by sgtammo | 03/14/06 |
| Another fine teaser. Very enjoyable. |
|
| Posted by zakp | 03/16/06 |
| Good but toooo long!!! :-? |
|
| Posted by OldChinaHand | 03/17/06 |
| After weed-whacking through all the long passages a couple element are final reveled...and a simple solution is presented. A bit long for an a.m. teaser. 8) |
|
| Posted by redraptor50 | 03/18/06 |
| :D GREAT ONE norcerkri, KEEP these coming, Loved it :D |
|
| Posted by Warrior_Poet | 03/20/06 |
| This was the greatest teaser I've seen on here. Thanks :) |
|
| Posted by t_bay | 03/23/06 |
| tooooooooo long and it took to long to get interesting so i stopped reading maybe i'll finish when i have a week to devote to reading it |
|
| Posted by nellie188 | 03/26/06 |
| toooooooooooooooooooooooooooo
long that was pateticly boring. :o |
|
| Posted by ChristheGreat | 04/02/06 |
| it was good but it was a bit too long |
|
| Posted by bowwows1 | 04/10/06 |
| it was REALLY long...actually it was way too long..and after i read a couple of sentences i became bored |
|
| Posted by Psychic_Master | 04/15/06 |
| yeah, after the first couple of sentences i got bored. sorry. too long. |
|
| Posted by irar1792 | 04/16/06 |
| i didnt finish reading it, way too long |
|
| Posted by alis99 | 04/18/06 |
| The mst boring ever realy sorry never bothered reading it realy sorry but i hate it! |
|
| Posted by alis99 | 04/18/06 |
| The mst boring ever realy sorry never bothered reading it realy sorry but i hate it! |
|
| Posted by katie56 | 04/18/06 |
| Way too many words! I didn't bother reading all of it because I was almost asleep halfway through it!Next time, go for shorter teasers. :-? :D |
|
| Posted by gnosys | 04/28/06 |
| I'm confused. What's Nora going to say to the press? (Not "Elementally, my Deere-Watt scion," since this can only be said to the heir.) And I assume homeS' ancestory refers to the linguistic origins of the Great Lakes' names... but who were the Winnebago shaman and German trader? Do BOTH relate to Lake Superior? What was the significance of the other names -- Hya Watt, for instance? (Related to Hiawatha? Or some pun on "XXX what" I didn't get?) In the midst of all this complexity, the solution to the mystery was fairly straightforward (except -- what effect would the hydrogen-oxygen mix have on Watt,Sr. before he lit up -- would he have no way of noticing, would switching light hydrogen for heavier nitrogen result in the O2 pooling near the floor? -- and what was the point of filling the room with an artificial mix exactly the same as the natural mix in the atmosphere, to begin with?) The mention of water vapor early on was a major giveaway.
In short, this was very interesting in its particulars, but I'm not sure that it adds up to a satisfying whole, at least as a mystery. |
|
| Posted by patm | 05/29/06 |
| First time trying a Mystery Teaser. I loved this story--the puns made me groan gleefully! I figured out that the air would burn, but didn't get it all--forgot my HS chemistry. One detail: At the beginning, it said Sei smoked cigars, at the end he had a pipe--did he switch because of the cancer? Or did the son forget because he was nervous? Keep it coming! :) |
|
| Posted by didida | 06/03/06 |
| I got it at first but OOPS :oops: I changed it, great job! 8) |
|
| Posted by cyberstar5150 | 06/26/06 |
| Beautiful teaser, but a lot was highly unnecessary (i.e. the history of the name homeS).
Cute punchline @ the end. |
|
| Posted by BPKANERVA | 07/13/06 |
| I gave up on it, it was just tooooooooooo looooooooong |
|
| Posted by Write2Right | 08/04/06 |
| Hahaha, wonderfully written, I just hope that your other teasers are like this one! Very difficult, but very humorous. I'm definitely going to remember that last line -- "Elementally, my Deere-Watt scion."
:D Five Stars :D |
|
| Posted by EKBsnookiepie | 08/11/06 |
| Tooooooooooooo Looooooooooooooooooooooooong :o |
|
| Posted by vbguy101 | 08/16/06 |
| Way too long |
|
| Posted by TheSmartest | 09/20/06 |
| This was too long. I don't normally mind a long story, just so long as it gets interesting by the third or fourth sentence. I read the first paragraph and was sill bored, so I quit reading. Even the answer was too long. I looked at how long it was and didn't even bother to read it. :-? :roll: :-? |
|
| Posted by celtic_knot | 11/20/06 |
| Too long. But it was good. |
|
| Posted by keke9307 | 12/11/06 |
| that was really long yet it was some great writing and i loved how hard it was to figure out. it took me about 10 minutes and i had to re-read it about 2 times till i finally got the answer. :oops: 8) :D :) |
|
| Posted by ka_3na | 12/17/06 |
| ang haba! :roll: |
|
| Posted by doog | 01/02/07 |
| Great Stuff. I really didn't think of working it. Steeping in it was too much fun. more :D |
|
| Posted by shabz4lyf | 02/19/07 |
| aha! 8) |
|
| Posted by McBobby1212 | 03/02/07 |
| your either gonna love it or hate it. for me, it was a good story. if you think of it as a story, than it's great. if you think of it as a teaser, then it's too long. i liked it. great job! |
|
| Posted by preppygirl | 07/17/07 |
| im sorry but that was just long
and thats comin from a girl who read harry potter and the goblet of fire twice in a day |
|
| Posted by dudebomb93 | 11/01/07 |
| IT was easy for me to get it. |
|
| Posted by sourdough | 07/14/08 |
| SourDough didn't like this one, it was :
MUCH TOO LONG :-?
MUCH TOO EASY 8D
'nuff said!
$D :o |
|
| Posted by srpwuzhere | 11/15/08 |
| too long... :-?
i got bored and skipped to the end.
lolz xD |
|
| Posted by Calehay | 12/28/08 |
| It's very difficult to tell who is speaking during the long dialogue sections. If you could revise those, I think this would be a very interesting teaser. |
|
| Posted by norcekri | 01/02/09 |
| Calehay, I'm not sure what you're looking for in the dialogue sections. There are no more than two uncredited utterances at any point in the teaser. Perhaps it isn't clear to you when only two people are conversing?
Also, my experience with editorial changes is very poor: the reviewers reject, at a frightful rate, alterations for grammar, spelling, and readability. I quit submitting them long ago. |
|
| Posted by Calehay | 01/21/09 |
| Some of it has to do with a lack of indentation. There's also some sentences where you explain the action of the person who isn't speaking, such as:
"I've seen the security footage. Volumes of whitish vapor -- water?" Nora nodded.
This is a statement by homeS isn't it? Maybe you should move the "Nora nodded." in front of Nora's text.
It's little things like that. I didn't mention, I really like the dialogue, and I think it's written well. I just think there's some things that make it a little difficult to read. |
|
| Posted by norcekri | 01/24/09 |
| Got it; thanks for the response. Yes, Nora's nod would be better placed in the next paragraph.
Yes, the lack of indentation bothers me, too. It's in the original text, but the Braingle submission software strips out the leading blanks. At the time, the Powers That Be asked us to avoid using HTML tags, which left me with a flat left margin. |
|
| Posted by Gwendalla | 08/18/11 |
| I don't think it's too long! I love teasers that actually take some time to read. This teaser wasn't: so she did this, and he said that, done. I appreciated it. It may have taken an eternity to write and type it out! Although, indentation would've been the icing on the cake. Thank you for the lovely teaser! |
|
| Posted by norcekri | 08/22/11 |
| Thanks for the comment -- and the support.
I *did* use indentation -- the Braingle text processing removed it.
When I was contributing, I did my best to keep the teasers from being give-away puzzles. Finding the critical clue in two lines of dialogue is what some people want; I decided to add the longer style to the site, including a little character development. |