The Chocolate Catastrophe

Four girls (Nikki, Tara, Clarissa, and Cindy) all wanted to buy their friend Cleo gifts for her birthday. However, when they got to her house, they realized they had all given her chocolates and an extra gift.

Chocolates: cherry cordials, chocolate truffles, Hershey's chocolate, or Reese's Pieces.

Extra Gift: a movie, a CD, a board game, or makeup.

Who gave what?

The person who bought the cherry cordials also bought a CD.

One person bought chocolates and an extra gift that both started with the same letter as her first name.

Tara did not give makeup.

Nikki was about to buy a board game for Cleo, but in the end decided that she should buy something else.

Clarissa did not buy a CD.

Tara bought Cleo's favorite chocolate.

Nikki was about to buy Cleo's favorite chocolate, but decided not to in the end.

Cleo's favorite chocolates are chocolate truffles.

Clarissa knew that Cleo wanted new mascara, so she decided to buy that for her.

Nikki bought Reese's Pieces.

Tara bought the board game Clue.