The Werewolf Game
Game #1545: C&I (9) The Great Battle. Part 1
This private game is moderated by StewieGriffin. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 9 rounds.
Reserved for el mod
Gratsias Senior trolly.
Well As I am sure all want to know if they shot a cowboy last round... and the answer is...(Drumroll to ad to the suspense)
No... Unfortunately those cowboys have done it again... They have killed a fellow indian and are laughing it up... But maybe this time will be different... Maybe!!!
4 vs 12...
---This message was edited on 2009-05-12 15:53:11---
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
Gratsias Senior trolly.
Well As I am sure all want to know if they shot a cowboy last round... and the answer is...(Drumroll to ad to the suspense)
No... Unfortunately those cowboys have done it again... They have killed a fellow indian and are laughing it up... But maybe this time will be different... Maybe!!!
4 vs 12...
---This message was edited on 2009-05-12 15:53:11---
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
YAY! First post! I win!
Night timed out. I stayed with it as night was counting down.
Well, I can't say that I'm not worried about how it looks that Daffid was eaten. I'm being set up by Radioguy's post and Daffid's votes for me. But how are you guys supposed to believe me?!
That makes me quite suspicious of those I've been suspicious of: Snow and froggy esp. I'll probably vote for them again, depending on what happens.
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
Night timed out. I stayed with it as night was counting down.
Well, I can't say that I'm not worried about how it looks that Daffid was eaten. I'm being set up by Radioguy's post and Daffid's votes for me. But how are you guys supposed to believe me?!
That makes me quite suspicious of those I've been suspicious of: Snow and froggy esp. I'll probably vote for them again, depending on what happens.
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
Wow, we have a lousy track record... we've now shot two of our own, and lost 4.
I'm thinking we need to get on the ball pretty soon if we want to win this.
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
I'm thinking we need to get on the ball pretty soon if we want to win this.
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
jtolley, I have NO reason to believe you are a wolf. But you are crying foul and pointing at me, which makes me wonder where your thinking is. Please explain your suspicion of me. If you feel you were being set up, how are you connecting this with me? IDK about froggy, but for myself, I know I'm human, and I've done nothing suspicious.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
I have no idea who to vote for, anyone got ideas?
Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚
Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚ Å‚
rexlamos wrote:
I do... But i ain't telling.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
I have no idea who to vote for, anyone got ideas?
I do... But i ain't telling.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
ICUB42 wrote (Last round):
The only reason I voted for ICUB last round, is because of what I said before (see above). I wasn't saying she was the reason, I just said she could be the reason. If you are truly human, ICUB, then I apologize. And in this game, I'm also truly human.
I have my eye on froggy and WittyKitty. The way they jumped on me after what ICUB said seems wolfish to me. I'm going to wait and see what the others say before I cast my vote.
---This message was edited on 2009-05-12 17:33:51---
guamgirl wrote:
Wrong guamgirl, I'm human. And seriously if I was wolf, would I be that stupid? NO, I wouldn't. That would be suicidal! Come on, think about it. Obviously, I'm being framed. And anyone with experience and common sense would know that. Unless you're a wolf? I'm suspicious of you guamgirl, but I'm also suspicious of Pope too.
So if I'm not around next round, I hope everyone keeps their eyes on guamgirl. But for now, I'm voting for Pope_Greg4.
I'm going to vote for ICUB. She could be the reason Radioguy was eaten.
Wrong guamgirl, I'm human. And seriously if I was wolf, would I be that stupid? NO, I wouldn't. That would be suicidal! Come on, think about it. Obviously, I'm being framed. And anyone with experience and common sense would know that. Unless you're a wolf? I'm suspicious of you guamgirl, but I'm also suspicious of Pope too.
So if I'm not around next round, I hope everyone keeps their eyes on guamgirl. But for now, I'm voting for Pope_Greg4.
The only reason I voted for ICUB last round, is because of what I said before (see above). I wasn't saying she was the reason, I just said she could be the reason. If you are truly human, ICUB, then I apologize. And in this game, I'm also truly human.
I have my eye on froggy and WittyKitty. The way they jumped on me after what ICUB said seems wolfish to me. I'm going to wait and see what the others say before I cast my vote.
---This message was edited on 2009-05-12 17:33:51---
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
StewieGriffin wrote:
Lol.
rexlamos wrote:
I do... But i ain't telling.
I have no idea who to vote for, anyone got ideas?
I do... But i ain't telling.
Lol.
I think I need a TWG For Dummies book
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
Guam, you can keep your eye on me as much as you want, but I am 100% human in this game. As far as jumping on you after what ICU said, I was in the middle of making my post when she posted. I almost simulposted with Witty, who was obviously thinking along the same lines as I was. You might want to note the closeness of the times between those three posts: ICU posted at 07:16AM, Witty at 08:45AM, and me at 08:46AM. You can also note that I stated I was reading back through all the posts from the prior rounds which is why I didn't even see ICU or Witty's posts when I posted due to the time it took copying and pasting quotes in between getting my son off to school. I'm also wondering if your sudden suspicion of me is because I voted for you last round. Sounds wolfy to me.
I'm not ready to even think about voting at this point as I want to see what others have to say and we cannot afford to shoot any more humans. I also want to go back and see what possible reason the wolves had to eat Daffidd besides his voting for Jtolley. At this point, I'm not really getting any wolf vibes from Jtolley, so I'm guessing the wolves are trying to set him up.
I'll be back later when I have more time.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
I'm not ready to even think about voting at this point as I want to see what others have to say and we cannot afford to shoot any more humans. I also want to go back and see what possible reason the wolves had to eat Daffidd besides his voting for Jtolley. At this point, I'm not really getting any wolf vibes from Jtolley, so I'm guessing the wolves are trying to set him up.
I'll be back later when I have more time.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
I think the wolves are trying to set jtolley up as well. I don't like his suspicion of me. . . . but that's something he'll have to figure out. . . I AM HUMAN jtolley! But seriously, I do believe he's being set up.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Well, there's no way I'm voting yet either. Sometimes I wonder why I play these games with such experience players! You're all such good liars! (nothing personal)
I've read what you said guamgirl, but I've believed you before and you was a wolf. So, I'll have to think about that. So like froggy, I'm going to sit back and see what everyone else has to say. I'll check back in after bit.
ICUB42: I as in me. C is to notice. U, not you, someone else. B for be. 4 is for fore. And 2 should be too.
I've read what you said guamgirl, but I've believed you before and you was a wolf. So, I'll have to think about that. So like froggy, I'm going to sit back and see what everyone else has to say. I'll check back in after bit.
ICUB42: I as in me. C is to notice. U, not you, someone else. B for be. 4 is for fore. And 2 should be too.
You make some good points ICUB42. I think quam is someone to watch. I've been wondering about froggy as well, but at the moment, guam has been sounding pretty wolfish.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Well, we are off to a bad start... we humans really need to pick this up
I think we should really think this vote through. It is an important vote, I suggest avoiding petty fish votes that many off you have been doing lately. To be honest with you, I'm interested in seeing how jtolley responds to both froggys and snows comments, that conflict is looking promising for a good vote. Someone there may be a wolf. But everyone else is also a suspect.
I think we should really think this vote through. It is an important vote, I suggest avoiding petty fish votes that many off you have been doing lately. To be honest with you, I'm interested in seeing how jtolley responds to both froggys and snows comments, that conflict is looking promising for a good vote. Someone there may be a wolf. But everyone else is also a suspect.
kayy
I'll be active now
I kept forgetting bout it last timeee
I'll be active now
I kept forgetting bout it last timeee
I've been reading through the last round and found this from Pope:
I'm not saying that I think ICU is a wolf, although she could be, but could Pope have been our Seer? He seemed so adamant in his "Calling ICU out" and stating in all caps that she is a wolf. He also brought up jtolley as another of our four wolves as have a few other players. Since we now know that Pope was human, it made me stop and think.
I can understand why ICU voted for Pope and Pope voted for ICU - both being votes to break the tie between them even though it ended up keeping the tie. However, I do still have my suspicions of guam. Guam voted for ICU last round and I don't think a wolf would vote for a fellow wolf unless they had to for self preservation. So I don't think ICU and guam are both wolves, and they may very well both be human.
I also don't think snowy is a wolf because she does tend to play differently when she is a wolf in the games I've played with her. She's playing more human than wolf to me, but I could be wrong here as well.
I'm off to make dinner, but I'll be back later to go through the rest of the last few rounds' posts and see if anything else stands out.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
ICUB42 wrote:
This part of your post is what ALL wolves say just to seem human. ICUB I'm calling you out, YOU ARE A WOLF! The other person I saw gunning for me with absolutely no real purpose but its not like me is: jtolley.
As for that, you guys are dead wrong, Look at the people who are gunning for me, they are your wolves.
So there are two out of the 4 wolves who I see wolfy.
So if I'm not around next round, I hope everyone keeps their eyes on guamgirl. But for now, I'm voting for Pope_Greg4.
This part of your post is what ALL wolves say just to seem human. ICUB I'm calling you out, YOU ARE A WOLF! The other person I saw gunning for me with absolutely no real purpose but its not like me is: jtolley.
As for that, you guys are dead wrong, Look at the people who are gunning for me, they are your wolves.
So there are two out of the 4 wolves who I see wolfy.
I'm not saying that I think ICU is a wolf, although she could be, but could Pope have been our Seer? He seemed so adamant in his "Calling ICU out" and stating in all caps that she is a wolf. He also brought up jtolley as another of our four wolves as have a few other players. Since we now know that Pope was human, it made me stop and think.
I can understand why ICU voted for Pope and Pope voted for ICU - both being votes to break the tie between them even though it ended up keeping the tie. However, I do still have my suspicions of guam. Guam voted for ICU last round and I don't think a wolf would vote for a fellow wolf unless they had to for self preservation. So I don't think ICU and guam are both wolves, and they may very well both be human.
I also don't think snowy is a wolf because she does tend to play differently when she is a wolf in the games I've played with her. She's playing more human than wolf to me, but I could be wrong here as well.
I'm off to make dinner, but I'll be back later to go through the rest of the last few rounds' posts and see if anything else stands out.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
:O I'm sorry for not voting last round! Life has been getting in the way and I haven't been able to be as active as I wanted to be! By the time I cane back night had started, and I haven't been able to get back here until now...
I'll try my best to be as active as I can be but I can't garuntee that I'll be able to get a -good- vote in every round. I will try though.
School is definately catching up to me since it's the end of the year and I have to start studying and catching up on homework. I'm sorry, I'll say it once more XD
I guess I'll see you guys when I see you then... *sigh again*
I'll try my best to be as active as I can be but I can't garuntee that I'll be able to get a -good- vote in every round. I will try though.
School is definately catching up to me since it's the end of the year and I have to start studying and catching up on homework. I'm sorry, I'll say it once more XD
I guess I'll see you guys when I see you then... *sigh again*
froggygg wrote:
I don't think Pope was the seer. Stewie stated in the last round that if Radio was the seer he would have mentioned it. I think if Pope was the seer, he would have told us.
I'm still leaning towards ICU as a wolf, but I don't have any real evidence, so I'm holding my vote for now.
Math and alcohol don't mix. Please, don't drink and derive. ~~I believe in Jesus Christ as my Savior. If you do too and aren't scared to admit it, then copy & paste this in your signature.~~
could Pope have been our Seer?
I don't think Pope was the seer. Stewie stated in the last round that if Radio was the seer he would have mentioned it. I think if Pope was the seer, he would have told us.
I'm still leaning towards ICU as a wolf, but I don't have any real evidence, so I'm holding my vote for now.
Math and alcohol don't mix. Please, don't drink and derive. ~~I believe in Jesus Christ as my Savior. If you do too and aren't scared to admit it, then copy & paste this in your signature.~~
I see no reason to believe ICUB42 is a wolf. Can you show me what you see in this?
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
I don't see any clues... Huh. I'll wait until tomorrow before deciding who to vote for.
Viva la vie boheme :)
Viva la vie boheme :)
unfortunately I have another test to study for (this is the last one, I swear! It's a calc III final...ew...) so my comments will be brief. Im only taking a five minute break
Snowy and froggy, I will respond to your comments in the morning and try to articulate why I think you're suspicious. But, Your guys' insistence of humaness and the fact that no one has understood where I'm coming from is making think I'm pigeon-holing my beliefs, which usually causes me to suck in most games, and actually causes me to ALWAYS shoot the seer (Yes, always, so I guess by extension, snow is the seer! ). So in all, I may end up looking more closely at ICUB, guam, and that situation. Things usually clear up for me in the end game (if I make it there) where I can synthesize everything that has happened.
But, I have to study! I will think about it in bed as I try to fall asleep tonight!
I should also warn you guys that I am going to Georga for the National Science Olympiad tourney so I will also be less active over the weekend (I know, as if that weren't enough!) Sorry!
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
Snowy and froggy, I will respond to your comments in the morning and try to articulate why I think you're suspicious. But, Your guys' insistence of humaness and the fact that no one has understood where I'm coming from is making think I'm pigeon-holing my beliefs, which usually causes me to suck in most games, and actually causes me to ALWAYS shoot the seer (Yes, always, so I guess by extension, snow is the seer! ). So in all, I may end up looking more closely at ICUB, guam, and that situation. Things usually clear up for me in the end game (if I make it there) where I can synthesize everything that has happened.
But, I have to study! I will think about it in bed as I try to fall asleep tonight!
I should also warn you guys that I am going to Georga for the National Science Olympiad tourney so I will also be less active over the weekend (I know, as if that weren't enough!) Sorry!
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
I don't care what your reasons are. . . but I'm glad you are starting to focus on someone other than me! IF, and I say IF you are human, we need to work together - we're losing too many and so far, there's NO hint as to who may be a wolf. Not a one!
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Yes we got no one yet. I don't know about Paladin, since this is his first game I cannot really judge him. He's talking about a little off topic things. If he's human he could use a little reading on our posts. Maybe at least he would have an idea, a little idea.
@Lava
It's ok RL always has to come first.
shutting up or down has the same meaning, why need the up and down? just keep it shut!
@Lava
It's ok RL always has to come first.
shutting up or down has the same meaning, why need the up and down? just keep it shut!
Since we still have more than enough time before the votes are due, I'm also going to wait until tomorrow to check out the last few rounds.
Nite everyone.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
Nite everyone.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
ICUB42 wrote:
That was before, and in a different game. This is a new game, and I am listed as a human. Please believe me when I say that.
Froggy, I believe that you are human. My "sudden suspicion" was because of the posts I read from you and Witty. Now that you pointed out the timing, it now makes sense to me.
At this point, I'm not sure who to vote for. I'm going to bed. Goo'nite everyone!
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 06:30:40---
I've read what you said guamgirl, but I've believed you before and you was a wolf. So, I'll have to think about that. So like froggy, I'm going to sit back and see what everyone else has to say. I'll check back in after bit.
That was before, and in a different game. This is a new game, and I am listed as a human. Please believe me when I say that.
Froggy, I believe that you are human. My "sudden suspicion" was because of the posts I read from you and Witty. Now that you pointed out the timing, it now makes sense to me.
At this point, I'm not sure who to vote for. I'm going to bed. Goo'nite everyone!
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 06:30:40---
as promised, I'm going to change gears a bit and focus on the main conversation going on. My suspicions for snow and froggy were that they had defensive and unisightful posting, but no one else seems to bother with it, so I'm going to focus on guamgirl and ICUB, one of which I bet is a wolf.
Froggy had this very nice post about guamgirl last round:
I actually picked up on those quotes by guam as I was reading last round's posts. They are suspicious for two reasons:
1) She highlights that this is her brother: Now, I'm not saying this is true at all, but I would guess that if there are relatives in a WWG and one is a wolf, they would try to get rid of the human relative. It makes sense to get rid of those who know your behavior best.
2) She highlights that Radioguy had something important to say in his posts: This sounds like an excuse to vote for ICUB without sounding wolfish. This could also be why daffid was eaten. I suspect the wolves are trying (unsuccessfully) to blame people.
I'm going to start things off with a vote for guam while keeping an eye on ICUB. If guam is human, that's who my vote will likely go to next round. I can't guarantee if I'll be on later, so I am voting now.
And where is smithy? I found him one of the most helpful people in round one...where has he run off to?
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
Froggy had this very nice post about guamgirl last round:
As I was reading back through all the posts, I noticed that guamgirl hasn't said much, but from playing other games with her, she usually is pretty quite. However, she did post and state: "I can't believe my brother got eaten so soon. I wonder what he said last round that the wolves didn't like? Something to think on." Since Radio is guam's brother, it might be a little difficult to be in the same game where one is a wolf and the other is not, as it might be too hard to hide it. She then posted again and stated: "I'm going to vote for ICUB. She could be the reason Radioguy was eaten."
I actually picked up on those quotes by guam as I was reading last round's posts. They are suspicious for two reasons:
1) She highlights that this is her brother: Now, I'm not saying this is true at all, but I would guess that if there are relatives in a WWG and one is a wolf, they would try to get rid of the human relative. It makes sense to get rid of those who know your behavior best.
2) She highlights that Radioguy had something important to say in his posts: This sounds like an excuse to vote for ICUB without sounding wolfish. This could also be why daffid was eaten. I suspect the wolves are trying (unsuccessfully) to blame people.
I'm going to start things off with a vote for guam while keeping an eye on ICUB. If guam is human, that's who my vote will likely go to next round. I can't guarantee if I'll be on later, so I am voting now.
And where is smithy? I found him one of the most helpful people in round one...where has he run off to?
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
Wow....I have no idea who to point a finger at? These wolves are good and most likely very experienced. They chose to eat Daffidd who posted three times and voting for jtolley twice. Could be a nice frame job. Not much to go on. Will look at past rounds to see if anything sticks out.
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Even heroes have the right to bleed
SEPTILLIONGOLDS wrote:
You know everything you need to know about me... I'm new, and indian
As far as getting an idea, I have... but I have my own style. Granted, I have no history in this game, but if I were a wolf/cowboy I'd be ten times as lost
Now I'm just looking to see who I think is lying, because SOMEBODY out there is.
And just for the record, perhaps old habits die hard, but shouldn't we be using the correct terminology here? Cowboys and Indians, not wolves and humans.
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
Yes we got no one yet. I don't know about Paladin, since this is his first game I cannot really judge him. He's talking about a little off topic things. If he's human he could use a little reading on our posts. Maybe at least he would have an idea, a little idea.
You know everything you need to know about me... I'm new, and indian
As far as getting an idea, I have... but I have my own style. Granted, I have no history in this game, but if I were a wolf/cowboy I'd be ten times as lost
Now I'm just looking to see who I think is lying, because SOMEBODY out there is.
And just for the record, perhaps old habits die hard, but shouldn't we be using the correct terminology here? Cowboys and Indians, not wolves and humans.
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
I just reviewed last rounds voting and found it very interesting. There were two quick votes for ICUB early in the round (votes by kwelchans and HermioneGranger). Then there were two votes for Pope (an indian) to even it up (SEPT and shaidar9haran).
Guamgirl ended the tie with a vote for ICUB. Votes are now 3 for ICUB and 2 for Pope.
ICUB ties it up with a vote for Pope. 3-3
WittyKitty breaks the tie with a vote for Pope. 4-3
Pope evens the score with a vote for ICUB. 4-4
Late in the round, rexlamos votes for Pope to eventually lead to his shooting. Futhermore, rex had posted only twice in round 1, once in round 2 and once this round. With the tie break and the lack of activity and any kind of help at all, I'm voting for rexlamos. If I am right, and he is a cowboy, I think that ICUB is one also. This may get me eaten but could potentially give us a huge advantage.
Let's see how fast the wolves (cowboys) pounce on me!
Edit to add: Is it also a coincedence that Radioguy also called out jtolley, rex AND voted for ICUB then got eaten? Was he a threat? Hopefully this round will answer those questions.
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 20:24:19---
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Guamgirl ended the tie with a vote for ICUB. Votes are now 3 for ICUB and 2 for Pope.
ICUB ties it up with a vote for Pope. 3-3
WittyKitty breaks the tie with a vote for Pope. 4-3
Pope evens the score with a vote for ICUB. 4-4
Late in the round, rexlamos votes for Pope to eventually lead to his shooting. Futhermore, rex had posted only twice in round 1, once in round 2 and once this round. With the tie break and the lack of activity and any kind of help at all, I'm voting for rexlamos. If I am right, and he is a cowboy, I think that ICUB is one also. This may get me eaten but could potentially give us a huge advantage.
Let's see how fast the wolves (cowboys) pounce on me!
Edit to add: Is it also a coincedence that Radioguy also called out jtolley, rex AND voted for ICUB then got eaten? Was he a threat? Hopefully this round will answer those questions.
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 20:24:19---
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Green = Known human's vote
Red = Those voting for a known human
Blue = A vote from an unknown to an unknown
Round 1 said:
Round 2 said:
Okay. Right now, I want to point my attention to 3 of the players who voted for Pope: Septillion, rexlamos, and shaidar. None of them voted in Round 1, but all of them voted for Pope in Round 2. I haven't heard much speculation about them in the rounds (except the post right above this one). They seem to just be flying under the radar. I agree with Superman's post about Rex. It's possible that fingers have been pointing in every direction but the wolves'. Hermione hasn't been very helpful, either, and seems to be flying under people's radars.
The four known humans voted for: jtolley, Septillion, and ICUB.
These people voted for humans twice: Snowmonster.
These people have voted for humans once: froggy, kwelchans, LavaIcee, Smithy, ICUB, rexlamos, Septillion, Shaid, and Witty.
These people have not voted for humans: jtolley, Paladin, and Superman77.
These people haven't voted: iluvgum.
Jtolley has twice voted for Snowy who voted for known humans twice, but he was also voted by Daffidd twice.
Paladin is a new player. He voted for Septillion in Round 1 along with 2 known humans, but he voted for Superman in Round 2 who hasn't voted for a human so far.
Superman voted for Witty in Round 1. However, Super voted for jtolley in Round 2 who hasn't voted for a known human so far.
All three of those players have been very active and not afraid to voice their opinions. I think that even if one or two of them are wolves (I don't believe all three would be since one of them voted for another), it won't be as detrimental as if some of the less active players are wolves.
iluvgum hasn't voted at all yet and has only made one post (I believe). She's flying under the radar, also.
Snowmonster has voted for humans twice, however, I know that the first couple of rounds are hard. I will be keeping my eye out for her, though.
Septillion hasn't contributed much to the game and has been on the defensive side.
ICUB has been very active but also has been under a lot of suspicion. I really don't know what to think of her right now.
Guam has been under a good deal of speculation because her brother got eaten the first night.
Froggy has been active and contributed to the game a fair amount. She isn't really striking me as human or wolf right now.
Everyone else has been fairly quiet and not contributed too much.
Septillion and Rex are at the top of my list right now. Rex's vote for Pope which sealed Pope's fate is rather curious, though, and would be something that a wolf would do. So for now, my vote is for Rexlamos.
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 12:42:55---
Livin' that mom-life...
Red = Those voting for a known human
Blue = A vote from an unknown to an unknown
Round 1 said:
CHRISTA94 voted for SEPTILLIONGOLDS
Daffidd voted for jtolley
froggygg voted for CHRISTA94
ICUB42 voted for iluvgum
jtolley voted for snowmonster
kwelchans voted for CHRISTA94
LavaIcee voted for CHRISTA94
Paladin voted for SEPTILLIONGOLDS
Pope_Greg4 voted for SEPTILLIONGOLDS
Radioguy voted for ICUB42
Smithy voted for CHRISTA94
snowmonster voted for Daffidd
Superman77 voted for WittyKitty
WittyKitty voted for jtolley
At dusk, CHRISTA94 was shot with the silver bullet.
Radioguy was eaten.
Daffidd voted for jtolley
froggygg voted for CHRISTA94
ICUB42 voted for iluvgum
jtolley voted for snowmonster
kwelchans voted for CHRISTA94
LavaIcee voted for CHRISTA94
Paladin voted for SEPTILLIONGOLDS
Pope_Greg4 voted for SEPTILLIONGOLDS
Radioguy voted for ICUB42
Smithy voted for CHRISTA94
snowmonster voted for Daffidd
Superman77 voted for WittyKitty
WittyKitty voted for jtolley
At dusk, CHRISTA94 was shot with the silver bullet.
Radioguy was eaten.
Round 2 said:
Daffidd voted for jtolley
froggygg voted for guamgirl
guamgirl voted for ICUB42
HermioneGranger voted for ICUB42
ICUB42 voted for Pope_Greg4
jtolley voted for snowmonster
kwelchans voted for ICUB42
Paladin voted for Superman77
Pope_Greg4 voted for ICUB42
rexlamos voted for Pope_Greg4
SEPTILLIONGOLDS voted for Pope_Greg4
shaidar9haran voted for Pope_Greg4
snowmonster voted for Daffidd
Superman77 voted for jtolley
WittyKitty voted for Pope_Greg4
At dusk, Pope_Greg4 was shot with the silver bullet.
Daffidd was eaten.
froggygg voted for guamgirl
guamgirl voted for ICUB42
HermioneGranger voted for ICUB42
ICUB42 voted for Pope_Greg4
jtolley voted for snowmonster
kwelchans voted for ICUB42
Paladin voted for Superman77
Pope_Greg4 voted for ICUB42
rexlamos voted for Pope_Greg4
SEPTILLIONGOLDS voted for Pope_Greg4
shaidar9haran voted for Pope_Greg4
snowmonster voted for Daffidd
Superman77 voted for jtolley
WittyKitty voted for Pope_Greg4
At dusk, Pope_Greg4 was shot with the silver bullet.
Daffidd was eaten.
Okay. Right now, I want to point my attention to 3 of the players who voted for Pope: Septillion, rexlamos, and shaidar. None of them voted in Round 1, but all of them voted for Pope in Round 2. I haven't heard much speculation about them in the rounds (except the post right above this one). They seem to just be flying under the radar. I agree with Superman's post about Rex. It's possible that fingers have been pointing in every direction but the wolves'. Hermione hasn't been very helpful, either, and seems to be flying under people's radars.
The four known humans voted for: jtolley, Septillion, and ICUB.
These people voted for humans twice: Snowmonster.
These people have voted for humans once: froggy, kwelchans, LavaIcee, Smithy, ICUB, rexlamos, Septillion, Shaid, and Witty.
These people have not voted for humans: jtolley, Paladin, and Superman77.
These people haven't voted: iluvgum.
Jtolley has twice voted for Snowy who voted for known humans twice, but he was also voted by Daffidd twice.
Paladin is a new player. He voted for Septillion in Round 1 along with 2 known humans, but he voted for Superman in Round 2 who hasn't voted for a human so far.
Superman voted for Witty in Round 1. However, Super voted for jtolley in Round 2 who hasn't voted for a known human so far.
All three of those players have been very active and not afraid to voice their opinions. I think that even if one or two of them are wolves (I don't believe all three would be since one of them voted for another), it won't be as detrimental as if some of the less active players are wolves.
iluvgum hasn't voted at all yet and has only made one post (I believe). She's flying under the radar, also.
Snowmonster has voted for humans twice, however, I know that the first couple of rounds are hard. I will be keeping my eye out for her, though.
Septillion hasn't contributed much to the game and has been on the defensive side.
ICUB has been very active but also has been under a lot of suspicion. I really don't know what to think of her right now.
Guam has been under a good deal of speculation because her brother got eaten the first night.
Froggy has been active and contributed to the game a fair amount. She isn't really striking me as human or wolf right now.
Everyone else has been fairly quiet and not contributed too much.
Septillion and Rex are at the top of my list right now. Rex's vote for Pope which sealed Pope's fate is rather curious, though, and would be something that a wolf would do. So for now, my vote is for Rexlamos.
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 12:42:55---
Livin' that mom-life...
Superman, you've made some really good points. As I've stated several times, I have my suspicions of guam and ICU but by the voting, I don't see them both as wolves. From what you posted, ICU could be a wolf and rex could have voted for pope (breaking the tie at the last second - a wolfy trait) to protect a fellow wolf - being ICU. I know that ICU used the fact that she would not be so obvious as to eat Radio since he had voted for her in the round he was eaten. However, it does take more than one vote to eat someone. Maybe the fellow wolves didn't think about how it would point to ICU if Radio were eaten and ate Radio to protect ICU as well as themselves from Radio's pointing finger. This does make sense.
At this point, I'm leaning heavily towards a vote for either ICU or rex. ICU has been much more active than rex so far. I understand why ICU would vote for pope and why pope voted for ICU as they were trying to save themselves from being shot. That said, the last second tie breaking vote made by rex without posting why he was voting, does make him more suspect to me. I'm going to vote for rex but will change my vote if anything else is found or brought to light as to why I should change my vote.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
At this point, I'm leaning heavily towards a vote for either ICU or rex. ICU has been much more active than rex so far. I understand why ICU would vote for pope and why pope voted for ICU as they were trying to save themselves from being shot. That said, the last second tie breaking vote made by rex without posting why he was voting, does make him more suspect to me. I'm going to vote for rex but will change my vote if anything else is found or brought to light as to why I should change my vote.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
Post above edited and vote locked.
Livin' that mom-life...
Livin' that mom-life...
YES, it's true that I voted for a human twice. .. but without knowing whether they were a wolf or not, I made sure my vote didn't cause them to get shot.
Again, I'd like to know what evidence there is against ICUB42. I see no reason to suspect her.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Again, I'd like to know what evidence there is against ICUB42. I see no reason to suspect her.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Some very interesting points made... wow, you guys are GOOD!
Things look awfully suspicious for rexlamos and SEPT... still going to hold off on my vote and make it count, but I certainly know how I'm leaning now.
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
Things look awfully suspicious for rexlamos and SEPT... still going to hold off on my vote and make it count, but I certainly know how I'm leaning now.
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
I think that the only reason to suspect her....right now...would be if rexlamos turns out to be a wolf and his vote was the deciding vote to save ICUB and shoot Pope.
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Personally, I strongly feel she is being set up. I just do not see the evidence.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Only time will tell Ms. Snowy. A penny for your thoughts......how about telling us who you think is a wolf....cowboy....you know what I mean....
Edit to add color...
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 15:31:00---
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Edit to add color...
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 15:31:00---
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Apologies for my recent inactiveness; it's exam period in the UK too, had a couple to study for, but I'm done until Monday now so should be able to partake a little more. Nice to know I was missed, jtolley.
After reading through all of this and last round, one thing that's struck me is guam's defence - seemingly based more on personal pleas than factual or logical reasoning. Saying "please believe me" is an extremely weak defence in this game and leads me to think this reliance on such statements is perhaps due to a lack of factual or logical reasoning proving innocence. Someone to look out for.
I'm also weary of iluvgum's play. I've played in a few games where the wolves simply haven't posted, thus have evaded suspicion and eventually won the game. A hollow victory, and a frustrating way to lose a game, so that might be something to watch too.
Superman makes some interesting points about ICUB and rexlamos that are certainly worth considering. Froggy and Snowy are also on my watch list, too, although obviously some of my suspects are at each other's throats so it's unlikely they all, if any, are wolves. Snowy seems suspicious to me for reasons I can't quite put my finger on, but then she's suspicious to me in every game I've ever played with her, and usually turned out to be human, so that's probably not worth looking in to too much!
Having lived off of about four hours sleep for the past few nights due to studying, I'm a little tired. I'll post again in the morning when my brain's working and try to contribute something a little more coherent and insightful than these ramblings.
After reading through all of this and last round, one thing that's struck me is guam's defence - seemingly based more on personal pleas than factual or logical reasoning. Saying "please believe me" is an extremely weak defence in this game and leads me to think this reliance on such statements is perhaps due to a lack of factual or logical reasoning proving innocence. Someone to look out for.
I'm also weary of iluvgum's play. I've played in a few games where the wolves simply haven't posted, thus have evaded suspicion and eventually won the game. A hollow victory, and a frustrating way to lose a game, so that might be something to watch too.
Superman makes some interesting points about ICUB and rexlamos that are certainly worth considering. Froggy and Snowy are also on my watch list, too, although obviously some of my suspects are at each other's throats so it's unlikely they all, if any, are wolves. Snowy seems suspicious to me for reasons I can't quite put my finger on, but then she's suspicious to me in every game I've ever played with her, and usually turned out to be human, so that's probably not worth looking in to too much!
Having lived off of about four hours sleep for the past few nights due to studying, I'm a little tired. I'll post again in the morning when my brain's working and try to contribute something a little more coherent and insightful than these ramblings.
I decided to vote for rexlamos. I'm hoping he is a wolf.
Snowy, I'm on your side here. I just don't see any real evidence against ICUB other than the fact that Rexlamos may be a wolf. However, if that is the case then we should vote for rexlamos, not ICUB. ICUB is a wolf because Rexlamos did something wolfy which would have aided ICUB... wouldn't this make Rex the most suspicious. I think it would make more sense to shoot rexlamos and see what happens (since stewie nicely reveals the outcome of a shooting). If he is a wolf then go after ICUB, if not then I think you'll see how gun happy you all got there. At the moment I'm leaning toward Rex, but the round is still early so anything might happen.
shaidar9haran wrote:
Didn't I say this??? Or am I nuts???
Edit to add: Which reminds me of a famous line in a great movie: "I used to think you were crazy, now I can see your nuts!" What movie?
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 17:51:49---
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Snowy, I'm on your side here. I just don't see any real evidence against ICUB other than the fact that Rexlamos may be a wolf. However, if that is the case then we should vote for rexlamos, not ICUB. ICUB is a wolf because Rexlamos did something wolfy which would have aided ICUB... wouldn't this make Rex the most suspicious. I think it would make more sense to shoot rexlamos and see what happens (since stewie nicely reveals the outcome of a shooting). If he is a wolf then go after ICUB, if not then I think you'll see how gun happy you all got there. At the moment I'm leaning toward Rex, but the round is still early so anything might happen.
Didn't I say this??? Or am I nuts???
Edit to add: Which reminds me of a famous line in a great movie: "I used to think you were crazy, now I can see your nuts!" What movie?
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 17:51:49---
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Is it possible that ICUB and all those defending her are cowboys? The strategy of this game eludes me so far, but this seems suspicious to me.
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
I think for now I'm gonna have to go with majority and vote rexlamos. Like I said, within the next 24 hours I may not be online again, so here it goes...
Viva la vie boheme :)
Viva la vie boheme :)
Superman77 wrote:
Edit to add: Which reminds me of a famous line in a great movie: "I used to think you were crazy, now I can see your nuts!" What movie?
Austin Powers... Goldmember, I believe?
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
Edit to add: Which reminds me of a famous line in a great movie: "I used to think you were crazy, now I can see your nuts!" What movie?
Austin Powers... Goldmember, I believe?
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
Hmmm... Interesting round so far...(No it's not a hint or anything so don't look into it or anything)
The Votes so far this round are as follows:
froggygg voted for rexlamos
guamgirl voted for rexlamos
HermioneGranger voted for rexlamos
jtolley voted for guamgirl
Superman77 voted for rexlamos
WittyKitty voted for rexlamos[
I will be adding the voting lists to the Reserved for mod section from now on./color]
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 18:34:11---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
The Votes so far this round are as follows:
froggygg voted for rexlamos
guamgirl voted for rexlamos
HermioneGranger voted for rexlamos
jtolley voted for guamgirl
Superman77 voted for rexlamos
WittyKitty voted for rexlamos[
I will be adding the voting lists to the Reserved for mod section from now on./color]
---This message was edited on 2009-05-13 18:34:11---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
StewieGriffin wrote:
I will be adding the voting lists to the Reserved for mod section from now on.
Huh?
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
I will be adding the voting lists to the Reserved for mod section from now on.
Huh?
"The greatest cause of unhappiness in the world today is trading what we want most for what we want now."
First post of each round... The voting list will be up at the top of the page..
The first post is always(well most of the time) saved for the mod to give out info and stuff.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
The first post is always(well most of the time) saved for the mod to give out info and stuff.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
I'm hoping whoever we vote off is a wolf. We need to figure this out. And if Rex is a wolf, please note that doesn't mean I am. I still swear I'm being set up. Over and over it seems like I keep having to say I'm human. Time will tell that I am!
With fingers crossed and holding my breath, I'm placing my vote for Rex .
ICUB42: I as in me. C is to notice. U, not you, someone else. B for be. 4 is for fore. And 2 should be too.
With fingers crossed and holding my breath, I'm placing my vote for Rex .
ICUB42: I as in me. C is to notice. U, not you, someone else. B for be. 4 is for fore. And 2 should be too.
Paladin wrote:
In this game, anything is possible. Yes, it could be that those who are so strongly defending ICU could be wolves/cowboys. It is also possible that ICU is human/indian and so are those defending her. I know that didn't really answer your question, but each game is different as well as the playing styles of those playing. Don't worry, you'll quickly get the hang of it after you have a game or two under your belt.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
Is it possible that ICUB and all those defending her are cowboys? The strategy of this game eludes me so far, but this seems suspicious to me.
In this game, anything is possible. Yes, it could be that those who are so strongly defending ICU could be wolves/cowboys. It is also possible that ICU is human/indian and so are those defending her. I know that didn't really answer your question, but each game is different as well as the playing styles of those playing. Don't worry, you'll quickly get the hang of it after you have a game or two under your belt.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
Paladin wrote:
Excellent! An Austin Powers fan!
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Superman77 wrote:
Edit to add: Which reminds me of a famous line in a great movie: "I used to think you were crazy, now I can see your nuts!" What movie?
Austin Powers... Goldmember, I believe?
Edit to add: Which reminds me of a famous line in a great movie: "I used to think you were crazy, now I can see your nuts!" What movie?
Austin Powers... Goldmember, I believe?
Excellent! An Austin Powers fan!
Even heroes have the right to bleed
Well, people are sticking with rexlamos. Froggy's logic appeals to me, so I guess I'll change my vote to keep things moving. But, I would really start to like looking at guam and ICUB more closely...
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
"Your theory is crazy, but it's not crazy enough to be true" ~Neils Bohr
I will join the vote for rexlamos. I do feel ICUB42 is human and if there's a connection with rex and she, then I'll join the vote against him. Hopefully we'll get a wolf this round.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!