The Werewolf Game
Game #2725: C&I(XXIV)The Arrows and the Guns
This private game is moderated by StewieGriffin. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 6 rounds.
RFM
Thanks Randy. Sorry for the late late post. I have been struggling with a tummy bug the last few days, and have had internet connection problems recently.
"as the indians got near the bushes, one of the cowboys tried to make a break for it, but they didn't get far, with one well aimed arrow stopping them in their tracks, the cowboy, (or girl as it was a woman) felt nothing but searing pain as an arrow penetrated straight through her back the indians surrounded the culprit, The name is bobby, she said, you may have got to me, but you will never find the other two she mocks.
Continuing she says, I was the one who took out your old foolish chief indians, while she struggled for breaths, he looked so peaceful in his sleep when I slit his throat, having heard enough they began to ready their arrows, unaware that bobbi had distracted them with her talking in order to take out her gun, and took one last shot, hitting david straight between the eyes,
Infuriated with losing his brother this way, steve wrestled the gun off bobbi and filled her with lead, firing at least six shots to the chest and head in a fit of pure rage, before mourning the loss of his bro.
don't worry steve, we are all in this gogeather said baby, she's right replies Randy, bobbi did say there were two more out there, but if we work as a team we can get through this, but we need to be cautious and watch each other's backs, everyone agreed. But was it a case of too little too late
The indians confidence was growing, the fact that they knew how many were left and the fact that they had finally gotten one of the enemies was a bit of weight off their shoulders, but they were only a third of the way there, and the other two may not be as easy to get"
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 06:37:31---
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
Thanks Randy. Sorry for the late late post. I have been struggling with a tummy bug the last few days, and have had internet connection problems recently.
"as the indians got near the bushes, one of the cowboys tried to make a break for it, but they didn't get far, with one well aimed arrow stopping them in their tracks, the cowboy, (or girl as it was a woman) felt nothing but searing pain as an arrow penetrated straight through her back the indians surrounded the culprit, The name is bobby, she said, you may have got to me, but you will never find the other two she mocks.
Continuing she says, I was the one who took out your old foolish chief indians, while she struggled for breaths, he looked so peaceful in his sleep when I slit his throat, having heard enough they began to ready their arrows, unaware that bobbi had distracted them with her talking in order to take out her gun, and took one last shot, hitting david straight between the eyes,
Infuriated with losing his brother this way, steve wrestled the gun off bobbi and filled her with lead, firing at least six shots to the chest and head in a fit of pure rage, before mourning the loss of his bro.
don't worry steve, we are all in this gogeather said baby, she's right replies Randy, bobbi did say there were two more out there, but if we work as a team we can get through this, but we need to be cautious and watch each other's backs, everyone agreed. But was it a case of too little too late
The indians confidence was growing, the fact that they knew how many were left and the fact that they had finally gotten one of the enemies was a bit of weight off their shoulders, but they were only a third of the way there, and the other two may not be as easy to get"
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 06:37:31---
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
Well that settles that - David was human... I was curious about David, though I was leaning towards him being human.
I'm off to work, just checked in to see if the round had ended and it had just changed to days. I think night timed out again - probably setting up LH. I haven't checked to see when she signed in last, but before I went to bed, it was still 2 days. The fact that David cleared her with the logic of why she changed her vote, makes me think she is human... but at least one wolf wants to still keep suspicion on her. If David was still in the game, I might have figured that he was working his game magic to clear her... but it was just his normal good game logic (in my humble opinion at this time). I will review that clearing before proceeding, and wait to hear about Bradon.
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
I'm off to work, just checked in to see if the round had ended and it had just changed to days. I think night timed out again - probably setting up LH. I haven't checked to see when she signed in last, but before I went to bed, it was still 2 days. The fact that David cleared her with the logic of why she changed her vote, makes me think she is human... but at least one wolf wants to still keep suspicion on her. If David was still in the game, I might have figured that he was working his game magic to clear her... but it was just his normal good game logic (in my humble opinion at this time). I will review that clearing before proceeding, and wait to hear about Bradon.
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
I have to say I am not surprised at all to see that David was eaten. It did not seem like anyone was truly questioning his identity, and buttons clearly pointed that out right before the round was about to end. She also gave jayo a second vote, probably hoping that if bradon were to log on within the last 58 minutes of the round that she would be able to cast a third vote for jayo and tie it up.
I have high suspicions for buttons this round. When she posted about David being human it was almost as if she was hinting to her fellow wolf that they should eat David last night. When I was catching up on the last few posts during the night I found her post about David suspicious, it was kind of just out of the blue and did not really seem to fit, now with him being eaten I suspect buttons that much more.
The logic is there. She gave a second vote to jayo to try and help bradon, her fellow wolf out, if she would log in in time and tie the votes. Also, that her post about David being so human at the end of the round, trying to point out that that is who the wolves should target last night. I am going to cast a vote for her already, knowing that the round has just started but I am feeling VERY good about this vote this round.
I have high suspicions for buttons this round. When she posted about David being human it was almost as if she was hinting to her fellow wolf that they should eat David last night. When I was catching up on the last few posts during the night I found her post about David suspicious, it was kind of just out of the blue and did not really seem to fit, now with him being eaten I suspect buttons that much more.
The logic is there. She gave a second vote to jayo to try and help bradon, her fellow wolf out, if she would log in in time and tie the votes. Also, that her post about David being so human at the end of the round, trying to point out that that is who the wolves should target last night. I am going to cast a vote for her already, knowing that the round has just started but I am feeling VERY good about this vote this round.
Hello....I am at work, but stopped by to see how things were going.........Soccer, I respect your logic- and I will be on later when I have more time to talk to you.........
I am not going to put out a vote, because I don't have time right now to read through everything.
"I can do all things through Him that strengthens me."
I am not going to put out a vote, because I don't have time right now to read through everything.
"I can do all things through Him that strengthens me."
The wolves have made an interesting choice, David was the one that was sticking out to me but I'm happy I was wrong cos I probably would have been taking a closer look at him this round
3rd night in a row that the wolves have munched on the one I voted for, that's either coincidence or a frame up
I like the logic behind ur vote Soccerguy, what got me was towards the end as Buttons tried to rally against me was that she used the kind of ambiguous reasoning that got under my skin these last few games
buttons03 wrote:
Of course, anyone can be open to suspicion but as I'm human, this kind of 'reasoning' just bugs me.
I was suspicious of David as I thought he was appearing to be quite helpful and I've seen wolves go to great lengths to 'help' but I guess he was just really trying to analyse things after all!! (Sorry David)
I may not have expressed these reasons in the last round, but that's what they were.
I'll join the buttons vote for sure
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
3rd night in a row that the wolves have munched on the one I voted for, that's either coincidence or a frame up
I like the logic behind ur vote Soccerguy, what got me was towards the end as Buttons tried to rally against me was that she used the kind of ambiguous reasoning that got under my skin these last few games
buttons03 wrote:
Jayo is going after him, without very good justification. Between my other reasons, and this one, I am going to vote Jayo
Of course, anyone can be open to suspicion but as I'm human, this kind of 'reasoning' just bugs me.
I was suspicious of David as I thought he was appearing to be quite helpful and I've seen wolves go to great lengths to 'help' but I guess he was just really trying to analyse things after all!! (Sorry David)
I may not have expressed these reasons in the last round, but that's what they were.
I'll join the buttons vote for sure
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
I will not vote yet, as I would like to know if Bradon was a wolf, but I agree with the logic to all above.
Last round, I was slightly suspicious of Teddybair, as I posted near the end of the round, but I would like to know whether we shot any wolves before voting or sharing my suspicions.
Last round, I was slightly suspicious of Teddybair, as I posted near the end of the round, but I would like to know whether we shot any wolves before voting or sharing my suspicions.
Bradon was a Wolf!, Stewie announced it at the end of last round
---This message was edited on 2012-05-29 15:16:10---
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
---This message was edited on 2012-05-29 15:16:10---
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Urgh, there's just something about your posts, Jayo, which just makes it so hard to trust you this game.
Anyway, I did suspect buttons03 in a previous round, but I sort of left it for a bit after going for bradon, but I might be interested in coming back to that initial suspicion. I am looking at scrub, but I need to go to school, so I'll post more in depth later!
Anyway, I did suspect buttons03 in a previous round, but I sort of left it for a bit after going for bradon, but I might be interested in coming back to that initial suspicion. I am looking at scrub, but I need to go to school, so I'll post more in depth later!
Well GA, after the last game I played with you, forgive me if I don't worry too much
Haha, doesn't seem to matter what I post in these last few games, players are still suspecting innocent posts
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Haha, doesn't seem to matter what I post in these last few games, players are still suspecting innocent posts
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
I'm going to wait a little while to vote, though I agree that Buttons could be a good vote given that Bobbi was a wolf. I just want to go through the rounds a bit more carefully before I decide.
I am getting more confused by the round, but I do have three (four) suspects now.
Jayo - I was set to return a vote for Jayo, but he did state his reasons for being suspicious of David. Thank you for that. However Jayo is still at the center of every decision. This still keeps me highly concerned.
Soccerguy - I am getting the sense though that Soccerguy is not the indian he seemed. Last round, he stated that he was suspicious of Teddy - but never voted. Now he is starting a majority very early in the round on Buttons - who seemed pretty consistent last round about Jayo. So I went back and looked at the rest of his posts. They are not very helpful. I have only played one game with him, but it seems he is not posting the same as last game.
Buttons and Babyjuice- I agree that Button's voting at the end of the round has raised an alarm because she could have been giving Bradon a way back in the game. And Babyjuice changing her vote to Teddybair when she felt Bradon was a shoo-in with three votes when she could hvae cast the deciding vote also raised an alarm for me. Why would she change her vote from one non-majority to another? It just seems odd that she changed to Teddybair after Soccerguy suggested he was going to vote that way.
Overall, I think that voting late is better than changing a vote late in a round. But I think that not voting is the kicker for me, so I am leaning toward Soccerguy for now. I would love to hear what others have to say before I vote. I'll be back on before I go to bed.
Jayo - I was set to return a vote for Jayo, but he did state his reasons for being suspicious of David. Thank you for that. However Jayo is still at the center of every decision. This still keeps me highly concerned.
Soccerguy - I am getting the sense though that Soccerguy is not the indian he seemed. Last round, he stated that he was suspicious of Teddy - but never voted. Now he is starting a majority very early in the round on Buttons - who seemed pretty consistent last round about Jayo. So I went back and looked at the rest of his posts. They are not very helpful. I have only played one game with him, but it seems he is not posting the same as last game.
Buttons and Babyjuice- I agree that Button's voting at the end of the round has raised an alarm because she could have been giving Bradon a way back in the game. And Babyjuice changing her vote to Teddybair when she felt Bradon was a shoo-in with three votes when she could hvae cast the deciding vote also raised an alarm for me. Why would she change her vote from one non-majority to another? It just seems odd that she changed to Teddybair after Soccerguy suggested he was going to vote that way.
Overall, I think that voting late is better than changing a vote late in a round. But I think that not voting is the kicker for me, so I am leaning toward Soccerguy for now. I would love to hear what others have to say before I vote. I'll be back on before I go to bed.
I am even more confident that buttons is a wolf now. She didn't really add anything at all (although I know she said she would come back later) she didn't even say anything about her behavior last round. I would think if she were human she would've at least had some minor excuse to pull but at the time I am sure she couldn't think of anything to defend her suspicious wolfish behavior.
Also, scrub having you suspect me really makes no difference since as I did state once last round you are on my radar, and during night time I went back and reread over some posts and thought you would have been a great accomplice for buttons.
My top 2 suspicions right now are buttons and scrub, in that order. I have a good feeling that both are our last two wolves. The logic is there for buttons as I stated previously in the round. As for scrub, most of you played in the last reunion game and can attest that he is playing the exact same game (when he was a wolf last game). I know that randy said last round that he agreed bradon and scrub were playing a similar game style. Bradon was a wolf, chances are that scrub could be too.
Also, scrub having you suspect me really makes no difference since as I did state once last round you are on my radar, and during night time I went back and reread over some posts and thought you would have been a great accomplice for buttons.
My top 2 suspicions right now are buttons and scrub, in that order. I have a good feeling that both are our last two wolves. The logic is there for buttons as I stated previously in the round. As for scrub, most of you played in the last reunion game and can attest that he is playing the exact same game (when he was a wolf last game). I know that randy said last round that he agreed bradon and scrub were playing a similar game style. Bradon was a wolf, chances are that scrub could be too.
Last round teddybair posted
This is why I suspected teddybair before, and even more so with the fact that Bradon actually WAS a wolf.
I could be wrong, but I'm just stating the way I'm thinking right now.
I do agree with buttons possibly being a wolf, but for now I am going to vote for teddybair.
EDIT: Scrub- what do you mean I switched to Teddy after soccer posted it? I didn't have time to read all the posts, so maybe I missed something. I am not joining the current majority for this round, but I may later in the round.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-29 18:05:13---
I totally understand the logic behind encouraging people to get behind a vote so the wolves can't sway it, but going through the rounds I don't really see anything to implicate Bobbi as a likely wolf. The problem is no one really sticks out much to me again this game. A few people have said something that made me look twice, but Bobbi wasn't one of them yet. Of those with votes already I'm going back and forth between Scrub and Longhorn, and still leaning more toward Longhorn. But if I put someone else in a majority and they aren't a wolf, then I realize that makes it easier for the wolves to come on and sway the vote.
I'm really exhausted right now and need to go to bed. I don't want to spread the vote out further, yet I also don't feel right about not voting at all or joining a majority that I don't fully agree with. For now I'm going to have to go with someone without a vote yet just to make it harder for the wolves to sway the vote if Bobbi is actually a wolf. At this point she really doesn't stick out to me, but I know I could easily be wrong.
Voting Randy this round, partly because of a vague suspicion I can't fully put my finger on, and partly just because he doesn't have a vote yet.
I'm really exhausted right now and need to go to bed. I don't want to spread the vote out further, yet I also don't feel right about not voting at all or joining a majority that I don't fully agree with. For now I'm going to have to go with someone without a vote yet just to make it harder for the wolves to sway the vote if Bobbi is actually a wolf. At this point she really doesn't stick out to me, but I know I could easily be wrong.
Voting Randy this round, partly because of a vague suspicion I can't fully put my finger on, and partly just because he doesn't have a vote yet.
This is why I suspected teddybair before, and even more so with the fact that Bradon actually WAS a wolf.
I could be wrong, but I'm just stating the way I'm thinking right now.
I do agree with buttons possibly being a wolf, but for now I am going to vote for teddybair.
EDIT: Scrub- what do you mean I switched to Teddy after soccer posted it? I didn't have time to read all the posts, so maybe I missed something. I am not joining the current majority for this round, but I may later in the round.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-29 18:05:13---
Yes Soccer, I did say both Bobbi and Scrubs seemed to be playing a bit like last game, hence why I voted for Bobbi. Now, I am not quite ready to jump on a Scrub vote, because though they may seem like it, I am not quite sure about Scrub yet. I just got home from a very long day... need to have my dinner and get a couple calls made before it gets too late. With 13 hours to go, I think I can wait just a bit before jumping on a vote.
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
Okay- now that I have a minute, I will make my case, and have you guys decide.
Soccer, I totally understand your thoughts, and if I didn't know me, and know my style of play I would think that I was a wolf too. I offer you a few reasons as to my innocence:
"With 58 minutes left in the round, I have to log a vote. I am going to go with Jayo for previously stated reasons as well as his going after David. David seems human to me, and he is working hard at trying to help us figure out what is going on.....Jayo is going after him, without very good justification. Between my other reasons, and this one, I am going to vote Jayo."
I think this is the post that bugs Soccer. I didn't mean to get David into trouble with the wolves, I was backing him up because he made perfect sense to me. So much so, that I kinda figured I would be eaten overnight- that is why I logged in real quick earlier, to see if I made it. That way, the wolves ATE me, and SET David up. But, instead its working the OPPOSITE WAY. They ATE him and SET me up. I was surprised when I did survive, and then double surprised when I had been voted for. I made a quick post (my boss was standing in the door waiting to go to another campus), to try to stop a domino voting effect for myself before I had time to post again. I know that once one name shows up, usually regardless of their answer, they end up dead. I was trying to avoid a "sheep" vote for me, because we need to get a wolf this round. For whatever it's worth, that is/was my motivation.
Jayo and his motivations seem suspect to me. I am going to lay them out, and see what you guys think. I am not going to vote for him, but unless he or someone else comes up with a good reason to not vote for him, I am going to put my vote on him this round.
1. Everyone he votes for end up eaten by wolves. He may be signaling the wolves who to vote for, by his vote. How else would they all end up dead?
2. His suspects are emotionally motivated posts. He went after Scrub because Scrub suspected him. Scrub laid out reasons WHY he thought what he thought, and instead of explaining his motivations and why he is HUMAN, he calls Scrub's logic faulty (without defending why) and logs a vote for Scrub. I don't have a problem with him thinking Scrub is a wolf, he's done some things that would bring him up on my radar, but voting someone because they voted for you isn't helpful. Now, in this round, he is going after me for the same reasons he went after scrub. Soccer is voting for me too.....but he has laid out points as to why he is voting for me. His vote is a calmly thought out, rational decision.
3. He tends to follow the group vote.....the only time I have ever been a wolf, that is what I did. I didn't want to stand out. (It didn't work by the way) NOT having a well thought out stance will get you killed every time. Don't sheep vote! LOL
4. David said "As of now, I think jayo is peaking my radar. I hesitate to say it, but...Jayo, if you find me suspicious, why wouldn't you vote for me? (for the record, I'm not asking any of you to vote for me ). The "settling" for scrub seems off to me, but I'm not entirely sure it is wolfish behavior. I've never played with you before, but it seems more like just misdirected emotion than true wolfish behavior. But, I could easily be wrong. For those of you who have played with jayo before, how is his behavior compared to past games?"
David suspected Jayo......and ENDED UP DEAD. He tried to give him the benefit of the doubt, but in the end, that may be what got him.
For these reasons, as well as the fact that through three rounds Jayo has been at the top of multiple deased individual's lists, I am thinking Jayo.
I am into hearing rebuttal to my thoughts, and holding off on a vote, because I don't want to make a mistake with voting. I would say that if I am not shot by players, but eaten this next round, vote Jayo.
"I can do all things through Him that strengthens me."
Soccer, I totally understand your thoughts, and if I didn't know me, and know my style of play I would think that I was a wolf too. I offer you a few reasons as to my innocence:
"With 58 minutes left in the round, I have to log a vote. I am going to go with Jayo for previously stated reasons as well as his going after David. David seems human to me, and he is working hard at trying to help us figure out what is going on.....Jayo is going after him, without very good justification. Between my other reasons, and this one, I am going to vote Jayo."
I think this is the post that bugs Soccer. I didn't mean to get David into trouble with the wolves, I was backing him up because he made perfect sense to me. So much so, that I kinda figured I would be eaten overnight- that is why I logged in real quick earlier, to see if I made it. That way, the wolves ATE me, and SET David up. But, instead its working the OPPOSITE WAY. They ATE him and SET me up. I was surprised when I did survive, and then double surprised when I had been voted for. I made a quick post (my boss was standing in the door waiting to go to another campus), to try to stop a domino voting effect for myself before I had time to post again. I know that once one name shows up, usually regardless of their answer, they end up dead. I was trying to avoid a "sheep" vote for me, because we need to get a wolf this round. For whatever it's worth, that is/was my motivation.
Jayo and his motivations seem suspect to me. I am going to lay them out, and see what you guys think. I am not going to vote for him, but unless he or someone else comes up with a good reason to not vote for him, I am going to put my vote on him this round.
1. Everyone he votes for end up eaten by wolves. He may be signaling the wolves who to vote for, by his vote. How else would they all end up dead?
2. His suspects are emotionally motivated posts. He went after Scrub because Scrub suspected him. Scrub laid out reasons WHY he thought what he thought, and instead of explaining his motivations and why he is HUMAN, he calls Scrub's logic faulty (without defending why) and logs a vote for Scrub. I don't have a problem with him thinking Scrub is a wolf, he's done some things that would bring him up on my radar, but voting someone because they voted for you isn't helpful. Now, in this round, he is going after me for the same reasons he went after scrub. Soccer is voting for me too.....but he has laid out points as to why he is voting for me. His vote is a calmly thought out, rational decision.
3. He tends to follow the group vote.....the only time I have ever been a wolf, that is what I did. I didn't want to stand out. (It didn't work by the way) NOT having a well thought out stance will get you killed every time. Don't sheep vote! LOL
4. David said "As of now, I think jayo is peaking my radar. I hesitate to say it, but...Jayo, if you find me suspicious, why wouldn't you vote for me? (for the record, I'm not asking any of you to vote for me ). The "settling" for scrub seems off to me, but I'm not entirely sure it is wolfish behavior. I've never played with you before, but it seems more like just misdirected emotion than true wolfish behavior. But, I could easily be wrong. For those of you who have played with jayo before, how is his behavior compared to past games?"
David suspected Jayo......and ENDED UP DEAD. He tried to give him the benefit of the doubt, but in the end, that may be what got him.
For these reasons, as well as the fact that through three rounds Jayo has been at the top of multiple deased individual's lists, I am thinking Jayo.
I am into hearing rebuttal to my thoughts, and holding off on a vote, because I don't want to make a mistake with voting. I would say that if I am not shot by players, but eaten this next round, vote Jayo.
"I can do all things through Him that strengthens me."
This is sort of a tough call by me... but due to the time table of the game and the fact that it ends just about the time I wake up (and no, I will not set my alarm earlier just to try and wake up to change my vote ... lol) I need to vote fairly soon. I will try and check back before I go to bed in about 3 hours... but with my back still giving me some problems, there's no promise in that.
You make some good points Buttons, the bottom line is that if Jayo is a wolf and he is leading the vote against you, then you are right in defending yourself the way you did.
I think it is quite safe to say that Buttons and Jayo are not our two remaining wolves. This does not mean that neither of them are wolves, but I believe that both of them are not.
Soccer started the Buttons vote with Jayo willing to go along with that.
David is playing the way he used to play, using logic in his thinking and I think this may have triggered his demise before mine, as I sort of figure this may be my last round.
Knowing Bradon is a wolf, I looked back at her comments before she saw a vote on her. She asked Jayo why if he thought David was a wolf, why wouldn't he vote for him instead of Scrub? Sounded like a good idea then, but now I wonder if it was just a way to defend Scrub and remove a vote on him.
I said Scrub was on my radar. I have to stick with my own convictions and advice in many games. Go with your instinct. My vote is for Scrub.
Soccerguy... you are on my radar too... I think you used somebody who had some votes on last round to start a majority vote on this round.
I sort of think Jayo and Buttons are both human, though like I said, it is possible one of them is a wolf.
I feel pretty confident that GA is human and I feel that babyjuice is human.
If Scrub or Soccerguy are not wolves, then Teddy might fall into this role. One thing I know for fact, we do not have 5 wolves, so my radar has a couple dust spots on it that needs to be cleaned up.
Edit... I didn't say anything about longhorn... yes, she could be a wolf; but David's reasoning in why she probably isn't was a fairly good idea... though she was not on for the last couple rounds, the time at night timed out and this could be attributed to her. And unless I miss her comment, she was online today and did not post anything in the game, maintaining a low profile... she's very very low on my radar; almost not even a blimp.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-29 23:20:26---
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
You make some good points Buttons, the bottom line is that if Jayo is a wolf and he is leading the vote against you, then you are right in defending yourself the way you did.
I think it is quite safe to say that Buttons and Jayo are not our two remaining wolves. This does not mean that neither of them are wolves, but I believe that both of them are not.
Soccer started the Buttons vote with Jayo willing to go along with that.
David is playing the way he used to play, using logic in his thinking and I think this may have triggered his demise before mine, as I sort of figure this may be my last round.
Knowing Bradon is a wolf, I looked back at her comments before she saw a vote on her. She asked Jayo why if he thought David was a wolf, why wouldn't he vote for him instead of Scrub? Sounded like a good idea then, but now I wonder if it was just a way to defend Scrub and remove a vote on him.
I said Scrub was on my radar. I have to stick with my own convictions and advice in many games. Go with your instinct. My vote is for Scrub.
Soccerguy... you are on my radar too... I think you used somebody who had some votes on last round to start a majority vote on this round.
I sort of think Jayo and Buttons are both human, though like I said, it is possible one of them is a wolf.
I feel pretty confident that GA is human and I feel that babyjuice is human.
If Scrub or Soccerguy are not wolves, then Teddy might fall into this role. One thing I know for fact, we do not have 5 wolves, so my radar has a couple dust spots on it that needs to be cleaned up.
Edit... I didn't say anything about longhorn... yes, she could be a wolf; but David's reasoning in why she probably isn't was a fairly good idea... though she was not on for the last couple rounds, the time at night timed out and this could be attributed to her. And unless I miss her comment, she was online today and did not post anything in the game, maintaining a low profile... she's very very low on my radar; almost not even a blimp.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-29 23:20:26---
When you Love someone, Love them with all your heart as you never know what can happen today!
I think that scrub is a wolf right now... We just shot a wolf, which means we have a lot more info than we would if we had shot three humans, yet he claims that he is more confused, which just seems to me like a statement he's just thrown in without thinking too much about it...
He has listed four suspects even though there are only two wolves, and also hasn't made an effort to try and pair any of his suspects up, but has accused each individually. It always strikes me odd when people lay out several more suspects than the number of wolves remaining in the game, as it gives them an easy option to shoot several humans, and still appear innocent as there are still two suspects alive that they suspect who could be the pair.
I definitely feel RGW4's last post seems very human! I am willing to trust him a bit, and I even half agree with him on the teddybair vote.
soccerguy definitely seems human from his last post.
I have no idea what Jayo is on about at his (what seems like to me to be) a dig at me from a previous game, but our last previous game I was a wolf, and he got shot, and that doesn't make much sense for his comment towards me... the only reason I can think of is that he is a little upset that he lost that game.
I am going to add a second vote on scrub88 because it makes sense to me!
He has listed four suspects even though there are only two wolves, and also hasn't made an effort to try and pair any of his suspects up, but has accused each individually. It always strikes me odd when people lay out several more suspects than the number of wolves remaining in the game, as it gives them an easy option to shoot several humans, and still appear innocent as there are still two suspects alive that they suspect who could be the pair.
I definitely feel RGW4's last post seems very human! I am willing to trust him a bit, and I even half agree with him on the teddybair vote.
soccerguy definitely seems human from his last post.
I have no idea what Jayo is on about at his (what seems like to me to be) a dig at me from a previous game, but our last previous game I was a wolf, and he got shot, and that doesn't make much sense for his comment towards me... the only reason I can think of is that he is a little upset that he lost that game.
I am going to add a second vote on scrub88 because it makes sense to me!
Randy - I think you are safe for tonight unless Jayo changes his vote. That's a joke people, just in case you take me too seriously.
GA - I am more confused because I did not suspect Buttons or Soccerguy before this round. And yet Soccerguy has jumped to number two on my list of suspects. Buttons and Babyjuice are low on my radar, but still more suspicious than the rest of the players. I also find Babyjuice's explanation of suspicion on Teddy very reasonable - something worth considering in future rounds if I get there.
I take it that except for Randy, no one is seeing my take on Soccerguy's charge this round - which is fine. I gave the logic behind what I am seeing and asked for your opinions. That is why I asked you for your opinions. I wish I had heard more from Teddy or Longhorn Fan before I voted, but I am going to have to vote for Jayo again. He has been on my radar since the very first round, and nothing he has done has convinced me to vote otherwise.
In my defense, I play in hunter mode most every game - and I thank you for noticing that I played more like my normal self last game than I have before. And some of you have only seen me last game when I was a wolf. This is my usual game. GA and Teddy played with me when I was the seer. This is how I play. I am looking at peoples' play this game - what decisions were made and why.
What I don't understand is why (if you base your opinion of my play on this game alone) you find me suspicious, given that David was human. I said the same thing about Longhorn Fan before David did - yet everybody believed him. If you don't believe me - look at the clock (mine is 4: 07 vs. his 5:25). I guess he just said it better. And if you look at his 3:56 post, which he posted while I was writing my 4: 07 post, we say essentially the same thing about the frame job. I only disagreed with him a little because I think the C wolf is Jayo while he thought it was somebody else.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 00:40:08---
GA - I am more confused because I did not suspect Buttons or Soccerguy before this round. And yet Soccerguy has jumped to number two on my list of suspects. Buttons and Babyjuice are low on my radar, but still more suspicious than the rest of the players. I also find Babyjuice's explanation of suspicion on Teddy very reasonable - something worth considering in future rounds if I get there.
I take it that except for Randy, no one is seeing my take on Soccerguy's charge this round - which is fine. I gave the logic behind what I am seeing and asked for your opinions. That is why I asked you for your opinions. I wish I had heard more from Teddy or Longhorn Fan before I voted, but I am going to have to vote for Jayo again. He has been on my radar since the very first round, and nothing he has done has convinced me to vote otherwise.
In my defense, I play in hunter mode most every game - and I thank you for noticing that I played more like my normal self last game than I have before. And some of you have only seen me last game when I was a wolf. This is my usual game. GA and Teddy played with me when I was the seer. This is how I play. I am looking at peoples' play this game - what decisions were made and why.
What I don't understand is why (if you base your opinion of my play on this game alone) you find me suspicious, given that David was human. I said the same thing about Longhorn Fan before David did - yet everybody believed him. If you don't believe me - look at the clock (mine is 4: 07 vs. his 5:25). I guess he just said it better. And if you look at his 3:56 post, which he posted while I was writing my 4: 07 post, we say essentially the same thing about the frame job. I only disagreed with him a little because I think the C wolf is Jayo while he thought it was somebody else.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 00:40:08---
I can attest to what Scrub is saying about this being his normal game ~ one of the reasons I always hope we're on the same side is because I've played with him when he's human and when he's a wolf and I haven't found any tells to distinguish between the two. So most games I'm both hoping he's human (I've been human every game I've played with him) and keeping him on my suspect list because I know he's very hard to catch as a wolf. This game has been no different.
Also, I apologize for not being as active as usual this week. It's been a rough week here, and it looks unlikely that we will have internet access beyond tomorrow. Hopefully this "blackout" from internet won't last too long, but I have no idea. We need to find another provider, but living in the middle of nowhere makes that difficult. I really don't like satellite.
Also, I do actually understand the suspicion that's on me, and given my last two games have been so off I would suspect me too. Unfortunately in this case it has more to do with some physical challenges and interesting circumstances in RL that have come up. I don't want to use RL as an excuse for bad playing, but I honestly didn't expect all of this when I signed up for this game. I thought I was doing better physically, and I didn't expect to lose internet in the middle of the game. I know I haven't been very helpful to the humans this time, and the only thing I can say is that it won't help the humans to waste a bullet on me. Also, wolves, please eat me tonight instead of an active player. Since the night rounds are timing out every time it is unlikely that I will still have internet by the time the next round starts, and I don't want to be the cause of holding up the game even more.
Randy, I really hope your back starts feeling better really soon. I know how painful back issues can be. Sending prayers your way.
I've really enjoyed playing with all of you the past few months, and I hope it won't be too many weeks before I can join in again. Hopefully by then I'll be back on my game.
I'm still trying to figure out my vote, so I'll try to come back in a few minutes with something at least. I just realized that after typing all that out I hadn't actually decided who to vote for yet. It has sooo been one of those weeks!
Edit: I've been going in circles trying to figure out who the wolves could be. The two people I suspect the least are GA and Randy since they voted for Bobbi last round when it would have been very easy to lead the vote elsewhere. I've been going back and forth on Longhorn for the past couple of rounds, and this round I think I'm going to go with her. I realize that David's logic makes sense as far as her being a possible clear because of two of her comments; however, even after that was established as likely the night rounds have continued to time out with her being the only inactive. If everyone had established she was likely clear (and she actually was), wouldn't it have made sense for the wolves to just eat her instead of letting the rounds time out time after time? Unless there are some here who really like the long rounds (which I doubt) that doesn't make any sense to me. Also, while Bobbi did go after her (making her seem more clear), if I were a wolf I would rather an inactive wolf get shot over me, especially if it could help the wolves win the game by "clearing" me. I would never do that to an active fellow wolf, but if a fellow wolf was repeatedly making the nights time out and not posting I wouldn't have a problem with it at all. Just my two cents. Voting Longhorn.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 03:28:38---
Also, I apologize for not being as active as usual this week. It's been a rough week here, and it looks unlikely that we will have internet access beyond tomorrow. Hopefully this "blackout" from internet won't last too long, but I have no idea. We need to find another provider, but living in the middle of nowhere makes that difficult. I really don't like satellite.
Also, I do actually understand the suspicion that's on me, and given my last two games have been so off I would suspect me too. Unfortunately in this case it has more to do with some physical challenges and interesting circumstances in RL that have come up. I don't want to use RL as an excuse for bad playing, but I honestly didn't expect all of this when I signed up for this game. I thought I was doing better physically, and I didn't expect to lose internet in the middle of the game. I know I haven't been very helpful to the humans this time, and the only thing I can say is that it won't help the humans to waste a bullet on me. Also, wolves, please eat me tonight instead of an active player. Since the night rounds are timing out every time it is unlikely that I will still have internet by the time the next round starts, and I don't want to be the cause of holding up the game even more.
Randy, I really hope your back starts feeling better really soon. I know how painful back issues can be. Sending prayers your way.
I've really enjoyed playing with all of you the past few months, and I hope it won't be too many weeks before I can join in again. Hopefully by then I'll be back on my game.
I'm still trying to figure out my vote, so I'll try to come back in a few minutes with something at least. I just realized that after typing all that out I hadn't actually decided who to vote for yet. It has sooo been one of those weeks!
Edit: I've been going in circles trying to figure out who the wolves could be. The two people I suspect the least are GA and Randy since they voted for Bobbi last round when it would have been very easy to lead the vote elsewhere. I've been going back and forth on Longhorn for the past couple of rounds, and this round I think I'm going to go with her. I realize that David's logic makes sense as far as her being a possible clear because of two of her comments; however, even after that was established as likely the night rounds have continued to time out with her being the only inactive. If everyone had established she was likely clear (and she actually was), wouldn't it have made sense for the wolves to just eat her instead of letting the rounds time out time after time? Unless there are some here who really like the long rounds (which I doubt) that doesn't make any sense to me. Also, while Bobbi did go after her (making her seem more clear), if I were a wolf I would rather an inactive wolf get shot over me, especially if it could help the wolves win the game by "clearing" me. I would never do that to an active fellow wolf, but if a fellow wolf was repeatedly making the nights time out and not posting I wouldn't have a problem with it at all. Just my two cents. Voting Longhorn.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 03:28:38---
Story is up, sorry for it being so late.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
I want to say one thing to the wolves - STOP timing out the nights. It is so ridiculously primary school stuff. If the next night times out, after the game we'll see who the wolves are and I'll remove you from my friends list (assuming you're on it in the first place ) because it is so unnecessary!
I'm sticking with scrub88 because I feel good about this vote!
I'm sticking with scrub88 because I feel good about this vote!
I second that GA, timing out is a pretty irritating idea at the best of times
I think in the next game that I mod I will penalise wolves for this tactic
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
I think in the next game that I mod I will penalise wolves for this tactic
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Sorry this post will be short I am just on my way to work but I will explain more next round (assuming I am here).
I am going to change my vote to scrub. The votes are way too split up right now and with me not being able to log on just before nighttime comes I am nervous that buttons and/or scrub will change their vote to help manipulate the voting in their way.
As I said before I suspect buttons and scrub, in that order. I am just as happy to shoot scrub this round and therefore am going to give him a 3rd vote. Sorry if it is wrong but I really do have a gut feeling about him. I will explain more about this next round but I need to leave now.
I am going to change my vote to scrub. The votes are way too split up right now and with me not being able to log on just before nighttime comes I am nervous that buttons and/or scrub will change their vote to help manipulate the voting in their way.
As I said before I suspect buttons and scrub, in that order. I am just as happy to shoot scrub this round and therefore am going to give him a 3rd vote. Sorry if it is wrong but I really do have a gut feeling about him. I will explain more about this next round but I need to leave now.
Morning morning y'all.
Glad Bradon was a wolf. congrats on shooting her.
Sorry I have been off the radar. Holiday and all kinda caught up to me.
Scrubb sounds like a good place to go and with less than an hour in the round I guess I will pile on that and hope for the best.
Xfingers crossedX here's hoping
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Glad Bradon was a wolf. congrats on shooting her.
Sorry I have been off the radar. Holiday and all kinda caught up to me.
Scrubb sounds like a good place to go and with less than an hour in the round I guess I will pile on that and hope for the best.
Xfingers crossedX here's hoping
Like what you love, and love what you got.
This will be my last game for awhile as well. Life is getting busier, so I will see you around Thanksgiving again. I have enjoyed playing with all of you a lot since I found you this past winter. I must add that this game is the least active I have played in, and I find it just as frustrating as you do that the nights have timed out.
You are wrong to blame the wolves though. Inactive humans are a blessing to wolves, and they will leave inactive humans around because they won't vote to shoot the wolves. This changes votes to 50-50 votes and wolves might survive.
David said this well. If all three wolves were active, then three humans would have been cleared due to inactivity. GAME OVER. If I am right about Jayo, then two wolves would still have been cleared- except that Cab was eaten.
Jayo (and LF) - perhaps you have not been a wolf for awhile, but I have. You need to log in at night even if you are human to keep the game moving. This is twice now that you have complained about wolves not voting. I can only hope that the night you did not logon, you did not do it on purpose. Because if you did it on purpose just to get yourself cleared, then youbhave no right to complain about the play of the wolves. And even though I am voting for you, I hope you are not a wolf because you can't unfriend yourself.
I guess what I am trying to say is that every game players have to prove themselves by how they play. Not whether they log on or not. To make the game the most fun, all players have to be active. Both during the day and the night.
I forgot to add. You guys are good hunters. This is why I play with you. I made my case, and you see the game differently. No hard feelings, and good luck.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 08:50:21---
You are wrong to blame the wolves though. Inactive humans are a blessing to wolves, and they will leave inactive humans around because they won't vote to shoot the wolves. This changes votes to 50-50 votes and wolves might survive.
David said this well. If all three wolves were active, then three humans would have been cleared due to inactivity. GAME OVER. If I am right about Jayo, then two wolves would still have been cleared- except that Cab was eaten.
Jayo (and LF) - perhaps you have not been a wolf for awhile, but I have. You need to log in at night even if you are human to keep the game moving. This is twice now that you have complained about wolves not voting. I can only hope that the night you did not logon, you did not do it on purpose. Because if you did it on purpose just to get yourself cleared, then youbhave no right to complain about the play of the wolves. And even though I am voting for you, I hope you are not a wolf because you can't unfriend yourself.
I guess what I am trying to say is that every game players have to prove themselves by how they play. Not whether they log on or not. To make the game the most fun, all players have to be active. Both during the day and the night.
I forgot to add. You guys are good hunters. This is why I play with you. I made my case, and you see the game differently. No hard feelings, and good luck.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 08:50:21---
I am logging on from my phone to cast a vote, and while I understand the Scrub vote, what Teddy said makes sense- Scrub is playing the same way he always does. I am going to hold off on a Scrub vote, and go with my original thought- Jayo. I know this doesn't change anything, but I am going to stick with my original instinct. In case it gets me eaten overnight, here is my suspects:
Jayo- for previously stated reasons.
LH- nights keep timing out, and LH hasn't been on regularly. I think soccer has had some good points about why she may be human, so I have not voted for her.
Soccer- I am not sure if he is a helpful human or cunning wolf. I am on my phone, so I cannot go check rounds and see where his votes went.
Scrub- he is a tie for me with Soccer, helpful human, cunning wolf? If scrub turns out to be a wolf, I would be interested in who he voted with, or who voted with him.
Anyway, if I don't make the night round, I thought I would put up my thoughts.
EDIT: Copied the voting list so we would have it.
Day
It takes 5 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
babyjuice voted for teddybair
buttons03 voted for Jayo
GreenApples27 voted for scrub88
Jayo voted for buttons03
Longhorn_fan voted for scrub88
RGW4 voted for scrub88
scrub88 voted for Jayo
soccerguy0428 voted for scrub88
teddybair voted for Longhorn_fan
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 09:00:40---
"I can do all things through Him that strengthens me."
Jayo- for previously stated reasons.
LH- nights keep timing out, and LH hasn't been on regularly. I think soccer has had some good points about why she may be human, so I have not voted for her.
Soccer- I am not sure if he is a helpful human or cunning wolf. I am on my phone, so I cannot go check rounds and see where his votes went.
Scrub- he is a tie for me with Soccer, helpful human, cunning wolf? If scrub turns out to be a wolf, I would be interested in who he voted with, or who voted with him.
Anyway, if I don't make the night round, I thought I would put up my thoughts.
EDIT: Copied the voting list so we would have it.
Day
It takes 5 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
babyjuice voted for teddybair
buttons03 voted for Jayo
GreenApples27 voted for scrub88
Jayo voted for buttons03
Longhorn_fan voted for scrub88
RGW4 voted for scrub88
scrub88 voted for Jayo
soccerguy0428 voted for scrub88
teddybair voted for Longhorn_fan
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 09:00:40---
"I can do all things through Him that strengthens me."
Stewie - I lovvvvvve your stories. Make mine glorious, please.
Teddy - wish you the best!
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 09:07:01---
Teddy - wish you the best!
---This message was edited on 2012-05-30 09:07:01---
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!