The Werewolf Game
Game #3271: The One Where The Seer Isnt Shot
This private game is moderated by The_Spider. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 7 rounds.
Thanks
Harry died,
carry on
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 11:00:55---
Just love each other
Harry died,
carry on
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 11:00:55---
Just love each other
Three way tie and kzmonopoly was shot and he was human.... Ugh
Would put in a vote for Hydra, but I'll hold off cause I was wrong before
Just love each other
Would put in a vote for Hydra, but I'll hold off cause I was wrong before
Just love each other
Huh. I was definitely considering voting for Harry today.
Sophie and bRIN, do either of you have a lean either way on the other?
Sophie and bRIN, do either of you have a lean either way on the other?
Vote: DevisDan
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Lots of discussion yesterday- good help to figuring out who are wolves
Holding off voting for now
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Holding off voting for now
Adventures happen because you say yes!
I'll get an SPV in to look like I am active.
Also, the Eagles deflated the football to win.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 14:02:38---
All fields of science are just applied physics.
Also, the Eagles deflated the football to win.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 14:02:38---
All fields of science are just applied physics.
Putter eating feels like the work of more experienced wolves, I'd tentatively rule out the new guys forming at least 2 of the 3 wolves.
With no S for my V to P I'll go for a changeable vote.
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
With no S for my V to P I'll go for a changeable vote.
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Lots of discussion yesterday- good help to figuring out who are wolves
Holding off voting for now
Holding off voting for now
What specifically did you find helpful?
Still feeling suspicious of Hydra, even more so, voting accordingly
Just love each other
Just love each other
Tikka wrote:
What specifically did you find helpful?
Being fairly new, I'm not too good at reading people yet. Many suspicions were voiced last round is all I meant really.
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Lots of discussion yesterday- good help to figuring out who are wolves
Holding off voting for now
Holding off voting for now
What specifically did you find helpful?
Being fairly new, I'm not too good at reading people yet. Many suspicions were voiced last round is all I meant really.
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Putting a changeable vote on whov
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Tikka wrote:
At this point in time, Brin is being Brin...I'd say human but that doesn't mean anything this early on. Gonna look over last round discussion and see if I get any feels.
Huh. I was definitely considering voting for Harry today.
Sophie and bRIN, do either of you have a lean either way on the other?
Sophie and bRIN, do either of you have a lean either way on the other?
At this point in time, Brin is being Brin...I'd say human but that doesn't mean anything this early on. Gonna look over last round discussion and see if I get any feels.
doomfeathers wrote:
Any reason your so Absolutely sure?
Vote: DevisDan
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
Any reason your so Absolutely sure?
Hydra wrote:
Why do you want to look active?
bfftwer wrote:
Being fairly new, I'm not too good at reading people yet. Many suspicions were voiced last round is all I meant really.
If you had to take a guess about a couple of people based on what's happened so far, what would those guesses be?
Sophie wrote:
Let me know if you do.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 16:56:42---
I'll get an SPV in to look like I am active.
Why do you want to look active?
bfftwer wrote:
Being fairly new, I'm not too good at reading people yet. Many suspicions were voiced last round is all I meant really.
If you had to take a guess about a couple of people based on what's happened so far, what would those guesses be?
Sophie wrote:
Gonna look over last round discussion and see if I get any feels.
Let me know if you do.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 16:56:42---
Tikka wrote:
bfftwer wrote:
Being fairly new, I'm not too good at reading people yet. Many suspicions were voiced last round is all I meant really.
If you had to take a guess about a couple of people based on what's happened so far, what would those guesses be?
I'm thinking Dan, deb, Tikka, Jayo, and rolu are human but don't know to trust my instincts
Adventures happen because you say yes!
bfftwer wrote:
Being fairly new, I'm not too good at reading people yet. Many suspicions were voiced last round is all I meant really.
If you had to take a guess about a couple of people based on what's happened so far, what would those guesses be?
I'm thinking Dan, deb, Tikka, Jayo, and rolu are human but don't know to trust my instincts
Adventures happen because you say yes!
posting a vote for Rolu this round . He seemed to spear head the vote against KZ and seems to be trying the same thing this round [against Hydra] Just my feeling.
Hey
Don't know why you were all primed to get rid of Harry. Mute now, but still.
Going to go for doom for now, the only way you know for sure is 1. You are the seer or 2. You are a wolf.
And I am also weary of the team ups.
Subject to change if I am convinced
This space is intentionally left blank.
Don't know why you were all primed to get rid of Harry. Mute now, but still.
Going to go for doom for now, the only way you know for sure is 1. You are the seer or 2. You are a wolf.
And I am also weary of the team ups.
Subject to change if I am convinced
This space is intentionally left blank.
debc1 wrote:
Not really sure what you're saying here.
"All primed"?
Team ups?
Hey
Don't know why you were all primed to get rid of Harry. Mute now, but still.
Going to go for doom for now, the only way you know for sure is 1. You are the seer or 2. You are a wolf.
And I am also weary of the team ups.
Subject to change if I am convinced
Don't know why you were all primed to get rid of Harry. Mute now, but still.
Going to go for doom for now, the only way you know for sure is 1. You are the seer or 2. You are a wolf.
And I am also weary of the team ups.
Subject to change if I am convinced
Not really sure what you're saying here.
"All primed"?
Team ups?
Without going into too much analysis, here's my readings thus far:
Most likely humans: Sophie, Tikka
Humans I'm suspicious or unsure about: doomfeathers, Brin, Hydra, rolu
Humans I don't have a good read on yet: bfft, deb, Devis, Jayo
I am going for Brin for now, mostly because she doesn't have a vote yet, but also because she's one of the four on my suspicious list. But I'm up for a change if someone has more solid reasoning.
It's a disease, not a punch line
Most likely humans: Sophie, Tikka
Humans I'm suspicious or unsure about: doomfeathers, Brin, Hydra, rolu
Humans I don't have a good read on yet: bfft, deb, Devis, Jayo
I am going for Brin for now, mostly because she doesn't have a vote yet, but also because she's one of the four on my suspicious list. But I'm up for a change if someone has more solid reasoning.
It's a disease, not a punch line
All primed- hot to vote him out
Team ups- I will vote someone if you vote that person too or the like.
This space is intentionally left blank.
Team ups- I will vote someone if you vote that person too or the like.
This space is intentionally left blank.
Sophie-Drake wrote:
debc1 wrote:
The reason I am so sure is that Tikka is acting EXACTLY how I did my first few townie (human) games on mafiascum.
Edit: To be clear, I'm voting DevisDan not because he nearly got Tikka shot per se but because he listed no reasons for doing so. In fact, he didn't even post who he was voting for.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 18:40:39---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Any reason your so Absolutely sure?
debc1 wrote:
Going to go for doom for now, the only way you know for sure is 1. You are the seer or 2. You are a wolf.
The reason I am so sure is that Tikka is acting EXACTLY how I did my first few townie (human) games on mafiascum.
Edit: To be clear, I'm voting DevisDan not because he nearly got Tikka shot per se but because he listed no reasons for doing so. In fact, he didn't even post who he was voting for.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 18:40:39---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Sophie again coming on my radar like last round.
Would a wolf be so insistent on shooting one particular human (kz) when any human shooting is equally valid?
I may have been wrong on kz and I may be wrong still, but Hydra and Sophie are my suspects
Just love each other
Would a wolf be so insistent on shooting one particular human (kz) when any human shooting is equally valid?
I may have been wrong on kz and I may be wrong still, but Hydra and Sophie are my suspects
Just love each other
debc1 wrote:
OK. Well I think I'm the only one who mentioned being suspicious of Harry. He was a human (seer) in my first game. In that one HP was very involved in deciding who would be shot and cared a lot about keeping people he had human leans on from being shot. In this game he popped in late in the day with a random comment about not wanting to vote for bRIN anymore. He didn't seem particularly concerned about who would get shot as a result of his vote change (I believe he ended up voting someone with no votes). I felt that he may have been trying to avoid controversy as a wolf by removing himself from putting bRIN in a majority, as well as buddying up to her with the comment that he didn't actually want her to be shot early. Fortunately, the wolves shot him, because I was completely on the wrong track with that.
With teamups, I am guessing you meant doomfeathers when talking to bRIN during Round 2?
All primed- hot to vote him out
Team ups- I will vote someone if you vote that person too or the like.
Team ups- I will vote someone if you vote that person too or the like.
OK. Well I think I'm the only one who mentioned being suspicious of Harry. He was a human (seer) in my first game. In that one HP was very involved in deciding who would be shot and cared a lot about keeping people he had human leans on from being shot. In this game he popped in late in the day with a random comment about not wanting to vote for bRIN anymore. He didn't seem particularly concerned about who would get shot as a result of his vote change (I believe he ended up voting someone with no votes). I felt that he may have been trying to avoid controversy as a wolf by removing himself from putting bRIN in a majority, as well as buddying up to her with the comment that he didn't actually want her to be shot early. Fortunately, the wolves shot him, because I was completely on the wrong track with that.
With teamups, I am guessing you meant doomfeathers when talking to bRIN during Round 2?
rolugomi wrote:
You and Sophie are my strongest human leans at this point.
You seem more invested and willing to take risks than when you were a wolf in Supernatural.
Sophie tends to sound kind of stilted as a wolf, whereas in this round her thoughts seem pretty genuine to me. (Game 3255 is probably the most invested of her wolf games that I've read, if an example would help). My impression is that as a human she also tends to be paranoid of players who are more active and controlling (for lack of a better word) so while I disagree with her lean on you I don't think she's a wolf for it.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 19:16:12---
Sophie again coming on my radar like last round.
Would a wolf be so insistent on shooting one particular human (kz) when any human shooting is equally valid?
I may have been wrong on kz and I may be wrong still, but Hydra and Sophie are my suspects
Would a wolf be so insistent on shooting one particular human (kz) when any human shooting is equally valid?
I may have been wrong on kz and I may be wrong still, but Hydra and Sophie are my suspects
You and Sophie are my strongest human leans at this point.
You seem more invested and willing to take risks than when you were a wolf in Supernatural.
Sophie tends to sound kind of stilted as a wolf, whereas in this round her thoughts seem pretty genuine to me. (Game 3255 is probably the most invested of her wolf games that I've read, if an example would help). My impression is that as a human she also tends to be paranoid of players who are more active and controlling (for lack of a better word) so while I disagree with her lean on you I don't think she's a wolf for it.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 19:16:12---
rolugomi wrote:
Rolu, Yes they have been known to come in and point at people, to get others to vote for a particular human then apologize when they're wrong and do it again in the next round. I've seen it in games a few times.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
Sophie again coming on my radar like last round.
Would a wolf be so insistent on shooting one particular human (kz) when any human shooting is equally valid?
I may have been wrong on kz and I may be wrong still, but Hydra and Sophie are my suspects
Would a wolf be so insistent on shooting one particular human (kz) when any human shooting is equally valid?
I may have been wrong on kz and I may be wrong still, but Hydra and Sophie are my suspects
Rolu, Yes they have been known to come in and point at people, to get others to vote for a particular human then apologize when they're wrong and do it again in the next round. I've seen it in games a few times.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
Although in this case, I think I believe Devis Dan might be a wolf. Hunch wise, he's got my wolf radar going but I don't have a tangent reason.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
doomfeathers wrote:
This is what I am talking about.
Do you play the same all the time, let alone the same as someone else?
Tiki-not only that but with rolo. I just find it somewhat suspect, but I don't recall Sophie doing that(dang I need to reread again)
This space is intentionally left blank.
Vote: DevisDan
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
This is what I am talking about.
Do you play the same all the time, let alone the same as someone else?
Tiki-not only that but with rolo. I just find it somewhat suspect, but I don't recall Sophie doing that(dang I need to reread again)
This space is intentionally left blank.
Ok, Where did I read that?? I don't know!!
Sticking with my vote
This space is intentionally left blank.
Sticking with my vote
This space is intentionally left blank.
doomfeathers wrote:
Tikka is a little suspicious, maybe because the way Tikka interacts with us.
On the other hand though, Rolu is veeeerryy suspicious. I have a detailed reason but I will keep it for the moment.
Doom, do you know why I haven't told you guys who I would vote? Because I did not find any reason to tell you guys. I mean, I am beginner for God's sake. And I also thought telling who I would vote would throw me off.
So now I know that I must tell you guys my vote so yeah, Im voting for Rolu.
Edit: Im little firmed to this decision but my vote could be changed
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 20:46:45---
I think, therefore I am!
Vote: DevisDan
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
I get that you're new and all, but you left your vote on the one person I'm absolutely sure is human with no reasoning either for that or for voting her in the first place. Care to explain yourself?
Tikka is a little suspicious, maybe because the way Tikka interacts with us.
On the other hand though, Rolu is veeeerryy suspicious. I have a detailed reason but I will keep it for the moment.
Doom, do you know why I haven't told you guys who I would vote? Because I did not find any reason to tell you guys. I mean, I am beginner for God's sake. And I also thought telling who I would vote would throw me off.
So now I know that I must tell you guys my vote so yeah, Im voting for Rolu.
Edit: Im little firmed to this decision but my vote could be changed
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 20:46:45---
I think, therefore I am!
Well, looks like Im going to die. Advanced goodbye guys
I think, therefore I am!
I think, therefore I am!
DevisDan wrote:
There's still 13 hours left and only two votes on you things can change a lot in that amount of time
edited because i accidentally put 12 instead of 13
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 20:56:23---
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Well, looks like Im going to die. Advanced goodbye guys
There's still 13 hours left and only two votes on you things can change a lot in that amount of time
edited because i accidentally put 12 instead of 13
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 20:56:23---
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Day
It takes 6 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
bfftwer voted for whoviandeb
bRIN voted for DevisDan
debc1 voted for doomfeathers
DevisDan voted for rolugomi
doomfeathers voted for DevisDan
Hydra1234 voted for debc1
Jayo voted for Sophie-Drake
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Sophie-Drake voted for rolugomi
Tikka voted for Jayo
whoviandeb voted for bRIN
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
There is a tie with rolo and dan
Do share your thoughts
Edit
It is getting late in the states
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 22:38:21---
This space is intentionally left blank.
It takes 6 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
bfftwer voted for whoviandeb
bRIN voted for DevisDan
debc1 voted for doomfeathers
DevisDan voted for rolugomi
doomfeathers voted for DevisDan
Hydra1234 voted for debc1
Jayo voted for Sophie-Drake
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Sophie-Drake voted for rolugomi
Tikka voted for Jayo
whoviandeb voted for bRIN
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
There is a tie with rolo and dan
Do share your thoughts
Edit
It is getting late in the states
---This message was edited on 2018-02-05 22:38:21---
This space is intentionally left blank.
Switching my vote to Dan for now
I believe rolu is human
Adventures happen because you say yes!
I believe rolu is human
Adventures happen because you say yes!
For the record, I was not planning on keeping my vote on Dan. He is acting a little weird, but I don't think he's a wolf. I'll take a closer look at stuff in the morning.
@DevisDan Well, if you want to contribute nothing because you're a beginner...
Also, you don't need to be so dramatic. We have another 11 hours and someone else also has two votes anyway. And if you think you're going to die, you should list your reads for our later reference since we will know your alignment for certain.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
@DevisDan Well, if you want to contribute nothing because you're a beginner...
Also, you don't need to be so dramatic. We have another 11 hours and someone else also has two votes anyway. And if you think you're going to die, you should list your reads for our later reference since we will know your alignment for certain.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
I'm switching to DevisDan due to a lack of contribution. So far, I have only seen SPV posts, clarification questions, and an early obituary. rolugomi has contributed to voicing suspicions as well as having a lot of experience with WW. I feel if we shoot Devis, we have the same chance of shooting a wolf as shooting rolugomi, but we won't lose a meaningful contributor.
All fields of science are just applied physics.
All fields of science are just applied physics.
see? ill die. Its Inevitable. just because in your eyes guys i haven't contributed anything doesn't mean I dont want to. There were just hindrances in my part for instance, there were thing that was mention in-game and was not mentioned on the rules. Like, how can i fully contribute if i have still to learn new rules in-game and cannot read it on the game rules?
No matter. It was fun until no one wants to teach the newbie anymore
I think, therefore I am!
No matter. It was fun until no one wants to teach the newbie anymore
I think, therefore I am!
Dan, if any consolation, the way people are piling up to vote for you will at least give us some good wolf suspects for next round if you turn out to be human.
In fact, I'll go out on a limb and help you out, because we need new players to stick around. I've switched to rolu. If someone else switches, it will tie things up, give you a chance.
It's a disease, not a punch line
In fact, I'll go out on a limb and help you out, because we need new players to stick around. I've switched to rolu. If someone else switches, it will tie things up, give you a chance.
It's a disease, not a punch line
DevisDan wrote:
I would like to know your reason for why rolu is very suspicious to you. That would be a good start with contributing more.
Like, how can i fully contribute if i have still to learn new rules in-game and cannot read it on the game rules?
I would like to know your reason for why rolu is very suspicious to you. That would be a good start with contributing more.
I put Hydra to 2 votes. I trust him the least out of everyone who has votes at the moment.
I get the impression that the wolves are more invested in the outcome of today's shot than last round.
I get the impression that the wolves are more invested in the outcome of today's shot than last round.
I think his reason is plainly because I haven't told you my thoughts and why I vote someone
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 07:19:55---
I think, therefore I am!
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 07:19:55---
I think, therefore I am!
DevisDan wrote:
Who are you referring to when you say "his"?
You said "On the other hand though, Rolu is veeeerryy suspicious. I have a detailed reason but I will keep it for the moment." That's the reason I was interested in.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 07:35:54---
I think his reason is plainly because I haven't told you my thoughts and why I vote someone
Who are you referring to when you say "his"?
You said "On the other hand though, Rolu is veeeerryy suspicious. I have a detailed reason but I will keep it for the moment." That's the reason I was interested in.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 07:35:54---
Hydra1234 wrote:
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
Switching vote to Hydra. Like I said, I never thought DevisDan was actually a wolf; my vote was posturing, and I didn't expect people to hop on the wagon (Dan's recent posts have been rather odder, but I still think he's just newbie human who refuses to have any self-confidence or give things a decent try). I'll be investigating this wagon (bfftwer, bRIN, and Hydra1234) for suspects. I'm suspicious in particular of bfftwer, who has posted only SPVs and a few leans without reasoning, and doesn't have the excuse of never having played before.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 09:02:21---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
I'm switching to DevisDan due to a lack of contribution. So far, I have only seen SPV posts, clarification questions, and an early obituary. rolugomi has contributed to voicing suspicions as well as having a lot of experience with WW. I feel if we shoot Devis, we have the same chance of shooting a wolf as shooting rolugomi, but we won't lose a meaningful contributor.
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
Switching vote to Hydra. Like I said, I never thought DevisDan was actually a wolf; my vote was posturing, and I didn't expect people to hop on the wagon (Dan's recent posts have been rather odder, but I still think he's just newbie human who refuses to have any self-confidence or give things a decent try). I'll be investigating this wagon (bfftwer, bRIN, and Hydra1234) for suspects. I'm suspicious in particular of bfftwer, who has posted only SPVs and a few leans without reasoning, and doesn't have the excuse of never having played before.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 09:02:21---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
I'll put it out there that bfftwer's 2 completed games are 3269 (Human) and 3270 (Wolf). My feelings about her contributions this round are kind of mixed. If we're (bfftwer and I) still alive tomorrow, I'll probably talk about those thoughts more; the reason I haven't is that I don't want to overly influence her behavior by doing so.
doomfeathers wrote:
My main concern with Dan at this point is that if he really believes that rolu is as suspicious as he said then I don't know why he went the "woe is me I'm for sure going to die" route rather than trying to explain more about rolu.
Hydra1234 wrote:
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
I'm switching to DevisDan due to a lack of contribution. So far, I have only seen SPV posts, clarification questions, and an early obituary. rolugomi has contributed to voicing suspicions as well as having a lot of experience with WW. I feel if we shoot Devis, we have the same chance of shooting a wolf as shooting rolugomi, but we won't lose a meaningful contributor.
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
My main concern with Dan at this point is that if he really believes that rolu is as suspicious as he said then I don't know why he went the "woe is me I'm for sure going to die" route rather than trying to explain more about rolu.
Ok I understand now,
Tikka wrote:
My bad, I thought you meant the other way around. I'll explain my suspicions on my next post
Tikka wrote:
Sorry. I was just overreacting. Maybe because I was so excited in this game and it had turned out bad for me( by bad i meant the answers to my questions were not so clear for me).
I'll make it up to you guys, I'll try to be cooperative and open.
I think, therefore I am!
Tikka wrote:
DevisDan wrote:
Who are you referring to when you say "his"?
You said "On the other hand though, Rolu is veeeerryy suspicious. I have a detailed reason but I will keep it for the moment." That's the reason I was interested in.
I think his reason is plainly because I haven't told you my thoughts and why I vote someone
Who are you referring to when you say "his"?
You said "On the other hand though, Rolu is veeeerryy suspicious. I have a detailed reason but I will keep it for the moment." That's the reason I was interested in.
My bad, I thought you meant the other way around. I'll explain my suspicions on my next post
Tikka wrote:
doomfeathers wrote:
My main concern with Dan at this point is that if he really believes that rolu is as suspicious as he said then I don't know why he went the "woe is me I'm for sure going to die" route rather than trying to explain more about rolu.
Hydra1234 wrote:
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
I'm switching to DevisDan due to a lack of contribution. So far, I have only seen SPV posts, clarification questions, and an early obituary. rolugomi has contributed to voicing suspicions as well as having a lot of experience with WW. I feel if we shoot Devis, we have the same chance of shooting a wolf as shooting rolugomi, but we won't lose a meaningful contributor.
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
My main concern with Dan at this point is that if he really believes that rolu is as suspicious as he said then I don't know why he went the "woe is me I'm for sure going to die" route rather than trying to explain more about rolu.
Sorry. I was just overreacting. Maybe because I was so excited in this game and it had turned out bad for me( by bad i meant the answers to my questions were not so clear for me).
I'll make it up to you guys, I'll try to be cooperative and open.
I think, therefore I am!
I'll admit that was indeed counterproductive, but I don't think it was wolfish in this situation. I think maybe he's just a little insecure (no offense intended) and doesn't expect to have any influence what happens or something. The whole guilt trip about people not wanting to teach the newbie was just BEGGING for annoyance votes, and I don't think even newbie wolves would be that indiscreet. There's more going on with him than just winning the game.
And this question I forgot to answer:
debc1 wrote:
No, my playstyle changes somewhat from game to game, but it stays decently consistent in each game. I recognize this one from my past. If Tikka's a wolf, I'll put pineapple on my pizza.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
And this question I forgot to answer:
debc1 wrote:
This is what I am talking about.
Do you play the same all the time, let alone the same as someone else?
Do you play the same all the time, let alone the same as someone else?
No, my playstyle changes somewhat from game to game, but it stays decently consistent in each game. I recognize this one from my past. If Tikka's a wolf, I'll put pineapple on my pizza.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
doomfeathers wrote:
First off, I never said DevisDan was wolf. He has an equal probability as anyone else to be a wolf or human, but he has not contributed anything meaningful for this game, whereas the other candidate for being shot, rolugomi, has contributed a lot and voiced clear, logical suspicions. New players are also generally a wild card (i.e. see Aviator in this game) and much harder to discern than other players, so I feel if we remove an unknown variable, it can be easier to find other werewolves.
All fields of science are just applied physics.
Hydra1234 wrote:
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
Switching vote to Hydra. Like I said, I never thought DevisDan was actually a wolf; my vote was posturing, and I didn't expect people to hop on the wagon (Dan's recent posts have been rather odder, but I still think he's just newbie human who refuses to have any self-confidence or give things a decent try). I'll be investigating this wagon (bfftwer, bRIN, and Hydra1234) for suspects. I'm suspicious in particular of bfftwer, who has posted only SPVs and a few leans without reasoning, and doesn't have the excuse of never having played before.
I'm switching to DevisDan due to a lack of contribution. So far, I have only seen SPV posts, clarification questions, and an early obituary. rolugomi has contributed to voicing suspicions as well as having a lot of experience with WW. I feel if we shoot Devis, we have the same chance of shooting a wolf as shooting rolugomi, but we won't lose a meaningful contributor.
But why is Dan a wolf? Are SPV posts, clarification questions, and early obituaries things wolves would be more likely to post?
Switching vote to Hydra. Like I said, I never thought DevisDan was actually a wolf; my vote was posturing, and I didn't expect people to hop on the wagon (Dan's recent posts have been rather odder, but I still think he's just newbie human who refuses to have any self-confidence or give things a decent try). I'll be investigating this wagon (bfftwer, bRIN, and Hydra1234) for suspects. I'm suspicious in particular of bfftwer, who has posted only SPVs and a few leans without reasoning, and doesn't have the excuse of never having played before.
First off, I never said DevisDan was wolf. He has an equal probability as anyone else to be a wolf or human, but he has not contributed anything meaningful for this game, whereas the other candidate for being shot, rolugomi, has contributed a lot and voiced clear, logical suspicions. New players are also generally a wild card (i.e. see Aviator in this game) and much harder to discern than other players, so I feel if we remove an unknown variable, it can be easier to find other werewolves.
All fields of science are just applied physics.
For me rolu seems to lead the votes here. When he said kzmono is his vote, kz died. When he voted for aviator(though I understand coz he was inactive), aviator died. Whoever he voted, the others seems to follow regardless the reason. If he's a wolf, I imagine him smiling for the game turned out on his favor. If he's not, then his votes are helping the wolves.
Also, there's something in his posts that I can't shake off, or it's just that I do not know how rolu acted on previous games that might give me reinforcements on whether rolu is a wolf or not.
Though I'm afraid my reasoning might be shallow. Well, at least rolu is acting suspicious in my perspective.
I think, therefore I am!
Also, there's something in his posts that I can't shake off, or it's just that I do not know how rolu acted on previous games that might give me reinforcements on whether rolu is a wolf or not.
Though I'm afraid my reasoning might be shallow. Well, at least rolu is acting suspicious in my perspective.
I think, therefore I am!
Went to sleep early last night because I've been dealing with a cold or flu that has been keeping me up (Don't worry, I don't think its contagious over the internet).
Come back and Dan is getting a lot of flak for what is admittedly a very unorthodox way of playing, but as a new player, is it indicative of wolf? I'm not sure.
Someone (Jayo) made a point this round about wolves being experienced because they ate Putter. I don't see why, he made no useful comments last round, and so he must mean just by reputation, which is sad. Anyway, puts Jayo on my radar.
Just to confirm, that suspect list includes Hydra, Jayo, and possibly Sophie.
Dan, I don't believe I voted for Aviator, so I don't know how i got people to join in. And second, I was the only kz vote for a while until the end, and even then he was only shot because of a tie.
As for playing style, even I'm not sure about it. I'm not new, per se, but I've been gone for over 5 years and this is only my second game back, still working on figuring out what works and what doesn't.
Three way tie (3 votes each) between Hydra, Dan and Myself. Tempted to just leave as is.
But that wouldnt help humans if I end up shot.
And just in case there's last minute maneuvering, here's the current voting list
bfftwer voted for DevisDan
bRIN voted for DevisDan
debc1 voted for doomfeathers
DevisDan voted for rolugomi
doomfeathers voted for Hydra1234
Hydra1234 voted for DevisDan
Jayo voted for Sophie-Drake
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Sophie-Drake voted for rolugomi
Tikka voted for Hydra1234
whoviandeb voted for rolugomi
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 09:43:08---
Just love each other
Come back and Dan is getting a lot of flak for what is admittedly a very unorthodox way of playing, but as a new player, is it indicative of wolf? I'm not sure.
Someone (Jayo) made a point this round about wolves being experienced because they ate Putter. I don't see why, he made no useful comments last round, and so he must mean just by reputation, which is sad. Anyway, puts Jayo on my radar.
Just to confirm, that suspect list includes Hydra, Jayo, and possibly Sophie.
Dan, I don't believe I voted for Aviator, so I don't know how i got people to join in. And second, I was the only kz vote for a while until the end, and even then he was only shot because of a tie.
As for playing style, even I'm not sure about it. I'm not new, per se, but I've been gone for over 5 years and this is only my second game back, still working on figuring out what works and what doesn't.
Three way tie (3 votes each) between Hydra, Dan and Myself. Tempted to just leave as is.
But that wouldnt help humans if I end up shot.
And just in case there's last minute maneuvering, here's the current voting list
bfftwer voted for DevisDan
bRIN voted for DevisDan
debc1 voted for doomfeathers
DevisDan voted for rolugomi
doomfeathers voted for Hydra1234
Hydra1234 voted for DevisDan
Jayo voted for Sophie-Drake
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Sophie-Drake voted for rolugomi
Tikka voted for Hydra1234
whoviandeb voted for rolugomi
---This message was edited on 2018-02-06 09:43:08---
Just love each other
I'm guessing that Dan mixed up Aviator's and samurai's names, since you (rolu) were the first vote for both samurai and KZ. Although, I would argue that bRIN and HP were moreso the ones that made the samurai shot happen.
I'd still prefer to see Hydra shot here. Dan seems fairly genuine with his theory that rolu, if a wolf, is cackling that everything is going to plan.
I'd still prefer to see Hydra shot here. Dan seems fairly genuine with his theory that rolu, if a wolf, is cackling that everything is going to plan.
I felt like i must say something but I don't know what to say at this point . At least in my part the fun is back
I think, therefore I am!
I think, therefore I am!
Hydra1234 wrote:
rolugomi and Dan were tied at two votes each. whoviandeb, myself, debc1, Sophie-Drake, Jayo, and bRIN each had a vote. Why was Dan more worthy of death than any of them? It's round 3. Had you seriously no wolf leads among all of them?
@Dan Thanks much for explaining your reasoning.
My opinion:
You're right in that rolugomi is (always) worthy of suspicion. But I don't think he's controlling this game quite to the extent you think. kzmonopoly was voted out only because I joined him on that vote, and I came to suspect him independently of rolugomi. It is true that rolugomi was focused strongly on him, so if Hydra also flips human, you will have some evidence for your suspicions.
In any case, do what you think best, and don't worry about shallow reasoning if it's the best you've got. This is Werewolf.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
First off, I never said DevisDan was wolf. He has an equal probability as anyone else to be a wolf or human, but he has not contributed anything meaningful for this game, whereas the other candidate for being shot, rolugomi, has contributed a lot and voiced clear, logical suspicions. New players are also generally a wild card (i.e. see Aviator in this game) and much harder to discern than other players, so I feel if we remove an unknown variable, it can be easier to find other werewolves.
rolugomi and Dan were tied at two votes each. whoviandeb, myself, debc1, Sophie-Drake, Jayo, and bRIN each had a vote. Why was Dan more worthy of death than any of them? It's round 3. Had you seriously no wolf leads among all of them?
@Dan Thanks much for explaining your reasoning.
My opinion:
You're right in that rolugomi is (always) worthy of suspicion. But I don't think he's controlling this game quite to the extent you think. kzmonopoly was voted out only because I joined him on that vote, and I came to suspect him independently of rolugomi. It is true that rolugomi was focused strongly on him, so if Hydra also flips human, you will have some evidence for your suspicions.
In any case, do what you think best, and don't worry about shallow reasoning if it's the best you've got. This is Werewolf.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Huh. If rolugomi gets shot and flips human, we should check his wagon just to be sure. It's mostly quiet people, I think.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
A very good and active round, but not quite one that has produced a dead wolf
The wolves are closing in
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The wolves are closing in
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!