The Werewolf Game
Game #3271: The One Where The Seer Isnt Shot
This private game is moderated by The_Spider. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 7 rounds.
Well, you chumpies have hit your first wolf, let's see if the good times roll
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 07:14:49---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 07:14:49---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Humans: rolu and doom bc of their votes in round 3
Lean wolf: whov and deb
unknown: bRIN and Jayo
Vote: whov but is changeable
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 20:27:36---
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Lean wolf: whov and deb
unknown: bRIN and Jayo
Vote: whov but is changeable
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 20:27:36---
Adventures happen because you say yes!
rolugomi, I'm convinced you're human now. What are your reads? Do you think it was Debs, bussing, or a combination of the two?
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
It only takes four votes for someone to be shot and we've got two wolves still among us - bfftwer's early vote is exactly what I was warning against last round. There's no one to protect, and unless you plan on not being here later in the round, please hold your votes!!
bfftwer voted for Hydra1234
bRIN voted for Hydra1234
debc1 voted for Jayo
doomfeathers voted for bfftwer
Hydra1234 voted for bRIN
Jayo voted for Hydra1234
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Tikka voted for bfftwer
whoviandeb voted for Hydra1234
rolu was first to suggest Hydra last round, and he had previously voted him in round 3, so I believe him to be human.
bRIN's vote for Hydra was a reaction to my initial vote for her, so could be human or wolf.
debc stayed out of the Hydra vote altogether, I've leaned human thus far, but might be wrong?
doom voted for Hydra in round 3 but was against voting for him this round, seems wolfish
Jayo voted for Hydra, but it was a late vote, could be human or wolf
bfftwer was second to vote Hydra, seems to be easily changeable every round, leaning human
whoviandeb was last to vote for Hydra, which seems suspicious, but I think she's 100% human.
There may be some bias there.
Voting doom. I've be wary of him for most of the game, but seeing how persuasive he is, I didn't want to make myself a target. But the time for caution is over.
It's a disease, not a punch line
bfftwer voted for Hydra1234
bRIN voted for Hydra1234
debc1 voted for Jayo
doomfeathers voted for bfftwer
Hydra1234 voted for bRIN
Jayo voted for Hydra1234
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Tikka voted for bfftwer
whoviandeb voted for Hydra1234
rolu was first to suggest Hydra last round, and he had previously voted him in round 3, so I believe him to be human.
bRIN's vote for Hydra was a reaction to my initial vote for her, so could be human or wolf.
debc stayed out of the Hydra vote altogether, I've leaned human thus far, but might be wrong?
doom voted for Hydra in round 3 but was against voting for him this round, seems wolfish
Jayo voted for Hydra, but it was a late vote, could be human or wolf
bfftwer was second to vote Hydra, seems to be easily changeable every round, leaning human
whoviandeb was last to vote for Hydra, which seems suspicious, but I think she's 100% human.
There may be some bias there.
Voting doom. I've be wary of him for most of the game, but seeing how persuasive he is, I didn't want to make myself a target. But the time for caution is over.
It's a disease, not a punch line
whoviandeb wrote:
Oh, for crying out loud. I not only voted him round 3, but nearly got him shot, and this was before bussing would have been at all beneficial. I'm human.
What on Earth? Why would you be cautious of drawing attention? That's a wolf thing to do. If you're human and you believe someone convincing, as you say, is wolf, you draw attention to it, not stand by and let them win the game. I wasn't especially suspicious of whoviandeb before. I am now.
I know it's irrelevant now since rolugomi is pretty much confirmed town, but whoviandeb tried to shoot him round 3, so they're not partners.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 09:53:18---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
doom voted for Hydra in round 3 but was against voting for him this round, seems wolfish
Oh, for crying out loud. I not only voted him round 3, but nearly got him shot, and this was before bussing would have been at all beneficial. I'm human.
Voting doom. I've be wary of him for most of the game, but seeing how persuasive he is, I didn't want to make myself a target. But the time for caution is over.
What on Earth? Why would you be cautious of drawing attention? That's a wolf thing to do. If you're human and you believe someone convincing, as you say, is wolf, you draw attention to it, not stand by and let them win the game. I wasn't especially suspicious of whoviandeb before. I am now.
I know it's irrelevant now since rolugomi is pretty much confirmed town, but whoviandeb tried to shoot him round 3, so they're not partners.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 09:53:18---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Doom, what does bussing mean?
I suspected, and am now a lot more convinced, that one of the wolves is a little new.
And Jayo still seemed suspicious, and he anted to convince us that the wolves were experienced.
Top suspects right now are Jayo and doomfeathers.
Others could be either whoviandeb or debc, and may bRIN
Tikka was the only one I was sure was human.
If only we'd voted Hydra rounds earlier...
Holding off for now because of whoviandeb's reasoning, don't want wolves to take over the voting
Just love each other
I suspected, and am now a lot more convinced, that one of the wolves is a little new.
And Jayo still seemed suspicious, and he anted to convince us that the wolves were experienced.
Top suspects right now are Jayo and doomfeathers.
Others could be either whoviandeb or debc, and may bRIN
Tikka was the only one I was sure was human.
If only we'd voted Hydra rounds earlier...
Holding off for now because of whoviandeb's reasoning, don't want wolves to take over the voting
Just love each other
Sorry. Bussing is wolves voting off other wolves for human credit. The term comes from "throwing [a wolf partner] under the bus".
rolugomi wrote:
Same.
Edit:
Could I know your reasoning for this? Sorry, I'm a little new myself.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 10:19:03---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
rolugomi wrote:
Holding off for now because of whoviandeb's reasoning, don't want wolves to take over the voting
Same.
Edit:
I suspected, and am now a lot more convinced, that one of the wolves is a little new.
Could I know your reasoning for this? Sorry, I'm a little new myself.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 10:19:03---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Round 3, Jayo wrote
In round 2, when Putter was eaten, his only comments were:
and
In round 1, his comments were
and
None of this was indicative of experience, or being good at WW. Jayo thus seemed to imply that the wolves were eating Putter only because of his reputation. I highly doubt experienced wolves would do that, or at least I hope they wouldn't.
In fact, before Tikka, the eatings seemed random, and not just that, but bad choices. Why eat people that had been pointed out as targets? (By me)
I think Jayo was trying to lead us in the wrong direction,
Just love each other
Putter eating feels like the work of more experienced wolves, I'd tentatively rule out the new guys forming at least 2 of the 3 wolves.
In round 2, when Putter was eaten, his only comments were:
Ugh that is annoying Spider announced it at the end of the round. We had no idea but rolu jokingly predicted it... The fact is that someone
I am voting randomly right now.
I am voting randomly right now.
and
Wow what a win. Congrats spid. Luckily I put my money on the eagles..
I think brin mentioned she has been getting killed early so I have to find a new target..
I think brin mentioned she has been getting killed early so I have to find a new target..
In round 1, his comments were
Wow 2 games going on at once interestin
voting bff
voting bff
and
That was the golden age. There was a dark point not too long ago we were struggling to even get a 10 player game going...
Sam hunt has been afk for far too long (5 days) so I nominate them as tribute with a 2nd vote.
Sam hunt has been afk for far too long (5 days) so I nominate them as tribute with a 2nd vote.
None of this was indicative of experience, or being good at WW. Jayo thus seemed to imply that the wolves were eating Putter only because of his reputation. I highly doubt experienced wolves would do that, or at least I hope they wouldn't.
In fact, before Tikka, the eatings seemed random, and not just that, but bad choices. Why eat people that had been pointed out as targets? (By me)
I think Jayo was trying to lead us in the wrong direction,
Just love each other
Hm. That seems like a decent point.
I'm not sure what to do since all my previous suspects just shot a wolf; I'm on the whoviandeb wagon for now.
I'm going to lose Internet soon until sometime this afternoon, but I'll look over Tikka later. The obvious person to shoot her would have been bRIN, but I'm reluctant to vote her because I have nothing concrete and we have to hit a wolf this round.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
I'm not sure what to do since all my previous suspects just shot a wolf; I'm on the whoviandeb wagon for now.
I'm going to lose Internet soon until sometime this afternoon, but I'll look over Tikka later. The obvious person to shoot her would have been bRIN, but I'm reluctant to vote her because I have nothing concrete and we have to hit a wolf this round.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
I voted early because I knew I would be around all day as I am always online for schoolwork
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
I don't know if I will be on later. I still think send is suspicious and her not voting hydra last round convinced me more. Still not sure about Jayo
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
At work, little time
It is not this deb, trust me on this.
Brin- who is send?
The working together is throwing me off
Will be back after work, so don't end the round!!
This space is intentionally left blank.
It is not this deb, trust me on this.
Brin- who is send?
The working together is throwing me off
Will be back after work, so don't end the round!!
This space is intentionally left blank.
debc1 wrote:
I believe when bRIN said send she was referring to you as she voted for you
Adventures happen because you say yes!
At work, little time
It is not this deb, trust me on this.
Brin- who is send?
The working together is throwing me off
Will be back after work, so don't end the round!!
It is not this deb, trust me on this.
Brin- who is send?
The working together is throwing me off
Will be back after work, so don't end the round!!
I believe when bRIN said send she was referring to you as she voted for you
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Rolu I don't know how on earth my comment was trying to mislead anyone?
In fact the comment, with the experienced Hyrda shot and flipped wolf still stands to my mind. I suggested it was unlikely that new players made up 2/3 of the wolves. Even if I was a wolf this would actually then be true!
Voting snapshot (see Last round) from when Work finally allowed me to weigh in on things:
Day
It takes 5 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
bfftwer voted for Hydra1234
bRIN voted for rolugomi
debc1 voted for Jayo
doomfeathers voted for bfftwer
Hydra1234 voted for bRIN
Jayo voted for Hydra1234
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Tikka voted for bRIN
whoviandeb voted for bRIN
At the time Brin was in the majority 3-2 over Hydra. I commented at the time that I felt Rolu was human as he admitted he is a fairly bad liar so as he seemed much more comfortable this game I read that as having been dealt a human card at the start of the game.
Therefore I trusted his vote on Hydra and joined him, putting Hydra in a tie with Brin.
Doom you stated last round that the wolves were driving the Hydra vote, but I can't see the logic behind your comment. Was it that you knew Hydra was a wolf, and wanted to set up the targets for next round in advance or were you trying to play down the validity of the target and divert votes away from him?
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
In fact the comment, with the experienced Hyrda shot and flipped wolf still stands to my mind. I suggested it was unlikely that new players made up 2/3 of the wolves. Even if I was a wolf this would actually then be true!
Voting snapshot (see Last round) from when Work finally allowed me to weigh in on things:
Day
It takes 5 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
bfftwer voted for Hydra1234
bRIN voted for rolugomi
debc1 voted for Jayo
doomfeathers voted for bfftwer
Hydra1234 voted for bRIN
Jayo voted for Hydra1234
rolugomi voted for Hydra1234
Tikka voted for bRIN
whoviandeb voted for bRIN
At the time Brin was in the majority 3-2 over Hydra. I commented at the time that I felt Rolu was human as he admitted he is a fairly bad liar so as he seemed much more comfortable this game I read that as having been dealt a human card at the start of the game.
Therefore I trusted his vote on Hydra and joined him, putting Hydra in a tie with Brin.
Doom you stated last round that the wolves were driving the Hydra vote, but I can't see the logic behind your comment. Was it that you knew Hydra was a wolf, and wanted to set up the targets for next round in advance or were you trying to play down the validity of the target and divert votes away from him?
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
doomfeathers wrote:
What on Earth? Why would you be cautious of drawing attention? That's a wolf thing to do. If you're human and you believe someone convincing, as you say, is wolf, you draw attention to it, not stand by and let them win the game. I wasn't especially suspicious of whoviandeb before. I am now.
I know it's irrelevant now since rolugomi is pretty much confirmed town, but whoviandeb tried to shoot him round 3, so they're not partners.
I'm always cautious in early rounds because I don't like getting shot. I've played enough games in the past where I've been aggressive early on, gotten wrongfully shot and could only yell "I told you so" at my screen. Middle game is where I really start to play.
And I'm not letting you or any other wolf win this game. I'm also not partners with rolu or anyone because humans dont have partners.
The "town" stuff still confuses me.
It's a disease, not a punch line
What on Earth? Why would you be cautious of drawing attention? That's a wolf thing to do. If you're human and you believe someone convincing, as you say, is wolf, you draw attention to it, not stand by and let them win the game. I wasn't especially suspicious of whoviandeb before. I am now.
I know it's irrelevant now since rolugomi is pretty much confirmed town, but whoviandeb tried to shoot him round 3, so they're not partners.
I'm always cautious in early rounds because I don't like getting shot. I've played enough games in the past where I've been aggressive early on, gotten wrongfully shot and could only yell "I told you so" at my screen. Middle game is where I really start to play.
And I'm not letting you or any other wolf win this game. I'm also not partners with rolu or anyone because humans dont have partners.
The "town" stuff still confuses me.
It's a disease, not a punch line
I'll need to read over the last couple of rounds again, it's messy which is annoying as it should be a bit clearer now that we finally shot one.
Placeholder vote for now, it's changeable.
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Placeholder vote for now, it's changeable.
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
**Under construction **
Rolo-leaning human
Doom-leaning human
17 year old biff-leaning human
Jayo-I am so on the fence with you but for now perhaps human with a lot of peach fuzz
Now who does that leave:
Brin
Who
I think those are our last 2 wolves
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 21:03:55---
This space is intentionally left blank.
Rolo-leaning human
Doom-leaning human
17 year old biff-leaning human
Jayo-I am so on the fence with you but for now perhaps human with a lot of peach fuzz
Now who does that leave:
Brin
Who
I think those are our last 2 wolves
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 21:03:55---
This space is intentionally left blank.
After reading all the discussion this round I have come up with an update list of suspicions
I believe rolu is human for sure
lean wolf: doom and Jayo
unknown: whov, bRIN, and debc
EDIT: will most likely change vote later
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 21:28:39---
Adventures happen because you say yes!
I believe rolu is human for sure
lean wolf: doom and Jayo
unknown: whov, bRIN, and debc
EDIT: will most likely change vote later
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 21:28:39---
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Switching my vote to Jayo in case I can't make it back on to see other people's final thoughts
Planning on sleeping in as I have a snow day!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Planning on sleeping in as I have a snow day!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Will go with brin
This space is intentionally left blank.
This space is intentionally left blank.
Jayo wrote:
Since I was still suspicious of rolugomi, I thought Hydra had at best a 70/30 chance for flipping wolf, so I figured bfftwer was a safer kill. Then I happened to notice the wagon composition, freaked out, and posted that the wolves were trying to kill Hydra. Fortunately, nobody listened.
@whoviandeb No worries; you're not the one I'm trying to convince. I'll keep your defense in mind, but screaming about just how human you are doesn't exactly remove suspicion for me.
Also, nuts. I meant human. Whenever I accidentally say "town", I mean "human". This is Werewolf, not Mafia.
Voting whoviandeb since bfftwer is no longer.
Edit: On second thought, considering recent performance, I'm just going to follow rolugomi if I'm online whenever he gets around to voting. Beep beep I'm a sheep!
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 22:54:50---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Doom you stated last round that the wolves were driving the Hydra vote, but I can't see the logic behind your comment. Was it that you knew Hydra was a wolf, and wanted to set up the targets for next round in advance or were you trying to play down the validity of the target and divert votes away from him?
Since I was still suspicious of rolugomi, I thought Hydra had at best a 70/30 chance for flipping wolf, so I figured bfftwer was a safer kill. Then I happened to notice the wagon composition, freaked out, and posted that the wolves were trying to kill Hydra. Fortunately, nobody listened.
@whoviandeb No worries; you're not the one I'm trying to convince. I'll keep your defense in mind, but screaming about just how human you are doesn't exactly remove suspicion for me.
Also, nuts. I meant human. Whenever I accidentally say "town", I mean "human". This is Werewolf, not Mafia.
Voting whoviandeb since bfftwer is no longer.
Edit: On second thought, considering recent performance, I'm just going to follow rolugomi if I'm online whenever he gets around to voting. Beep beep I'm a sheep!
---This message was edited on 2018-02-08 22:54:50---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
doomfeathers wrote:
What do you mean I am no longer?
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Voting whoviandeb since bfftwer is no longer.
What do you mean I am no longer?
Adventures happen because you say yes!
You're voting someone else now.
(Last post edited.)
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
(Last post edited.)
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
ohhh I see. Thanks for the clarification
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
doom- what are you current suspicions?
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Ugh. whoviandeb still a little because of her response. Jayo because rolugomi says so. You because of reasons stated earlier and your possible connection to Jayo. A few others because they exist. Pretty much everybody except rolugomi.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Oddly enough, I'm also suspicious of everyone except rolu.
I think, doom, your style of play reminds me a lot of how our moderator Spider plays. It's fairly aggressive and I have a tendency to always think he's a wolf, too.
UGH, I dislike all these games with no seer. It has a tendency to reveal my inability to read people.
I'm going to keep my vote where it is for now, but might revisit it before I go to bed tonight.
It's a disease, not a punch line
I think, doom, your style of play reminds me a lot of how our moderator Spider plays. It's fairly aggressive and I have a tendency to always think he's a wolf, too.
UGH, I dislike all these games with no seer. It has a tendency to reveal my inability to read people.
I'm going to keep my vote where it is for now, but might revisit it before I go to bed tonight.
It's a disease, not a punch line
One time I got killed by the wolves instead of humans as human (terms changed). It was the happiest day of my Mafia career.
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Post from bfftwer deleted on 2018-02-09 00:50:43.
Post from bfftwer deleted on 2018-02-09 00:54:47.
Jayo- you haven't said anything as to who you think are possible wolves yet. Any suspicions?
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Where is rolugomi, anyway?
Switching vote to Jayo to tie things up. I feel like it's the right thing to do somehow.
bRIN hasn't been slammed by wolves, so she might be human.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-09 01:14:43---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Switching vote to Jayo to tie things up. I feel like it's the right thing to do somehow.
bRIN hasn't been slammed by wolves, so she might be human.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-09 01:14:43---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Wondering the same thing doom. His vote could be essential
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Practically nobody's up and you haven't joined the bRIN wagon to secure the kill. Unless you and she are partners or you plan on staying up all night, I guess you're human after all.
Well, I'm off to bed. If you are wolf, you outlasted me and deserve your victory.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-09 01:22:49---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
Well, I'm off to bed. If you are wolf, you outlasted me and deserve your victory.
---This message was edited on 2018-02-09 01:22:49---
Doom Son of Loki shows one of his many trickster faces. Tell me Lokison, what do you have up your sleeve? --HarriDansker
I feel that bRIN may be a possibility but I still also feel Jayo might be a wolf too so have a tie in a way keeps my options open if that makes sense. I could not stay awake all night even if I wanted to lol. Heading to bed as well. Guess the game decides who's getting shot tonight. Hoping its a wolf!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
Adventures happen because you say yes!
doomfeathers wrote:
The logic here is truly painful.
You expect wolves to slam Brin!?
It only makes it more likely Brin is a wolf if 'wolves' arent piling on.
I have no understanding how you draw the conclusions that you do short of being a wolf trying to obfuscate things or just a terrible reader of the game.
Bff you are doing the exact same thing you did last game when you were a wolf.
I played a role in shooting wolf #1 and again you immediately put me on the line of fire.
Again awful move as shooting me puts us into LYLO and you would be a prime target, exactly like last game.
So much weak logic that I'm just exasperated and just wish the humans good luck for the next round, you're gonna need it!
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Where is rolugomi, anyway?
Switching vote to Jayo to tie things up. I feel like it's the right thing to do somehow.
bRIN hasn't been slammed by wolves, so she might be human.
Switching vote to Jayo to tie things up. I feel like it's the right thing to do somehow.
bRIN hasn't been slammed by wolves, so she might be human.
The logic here is truly painful.
You expect wolves to slam Brin!?
It only makes it more likely Brin is a wolf if 'wolves' arent piling on.
I have no understanding how you draw the conclusions that you do short of being a wolf trying to obfuscate things or just a terrible reader of the game.
Bff you are doing the exact same thing you did last game when you were a wolf.
I played a role in shooting wolf #1 and again you immediately put me on the line of fire.
Again awful move as shooting me puts us into LYLO and you would be a prime target, exactly like last game.
So much weak logic that I'm just exasperated and just wish the humans good luck for the next round, you're gonna need it!
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Bff deleting posts isn't helping your situation
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
Dovie'andi se tovya sagain
After the ridiculous efforts of our seer, and 3 rounds of futility, the humans said we're mad as hell, and we're not gonna take it anymore.
In putting down Jayo, the humans are potentially one round from victory
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
In putting down Jayo, the humans are potentially one round from victory
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!