The Werewolf Game
Game #1771: 2 day ww game.
This game is moderated by AndrewWalker. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 8 rounds.
Does anyone have ANY idea why the wolves would have picked FreeSarah to be eaten?
I sure haven't!
I sure haven't!
have no idea...i was out the last round due to sickness and so therefore didnt pay attention to any posts
Maybe it was random?
".......and die like a soldier who never forgets what is due his own honor and that of his country." William B. Travis
".......and die like a soldier who never forgets what is due his own honor and that of his country." William B. Travis
well this early it is usually just a random pick. three posts in the first 15 minutes of a round, keep up the disscussion, it really does make the game much more enjoyable. well since there is no special hints or things like that, I am just overseeing everything, stay active and i will try to check back in tonight and tommorow.
Disco isn't dead, it lives on in me!
Disco isn't dead, it lives on in me!
But even randomly... FreeSarah was the least of their worries. She hasn't really mentioned who she's actually suspicious of (besides voting for fedsat) and to be honest, I was actually a bit suspicious of her.
Even if fedsat was a wolf, there were other people that were more... I don't know, targetable? Like myself... I'm actually a bit insulted, especially if fedsat was a wolf and I turned out to be the person who started the votes for a wolf yet I got overlooked during the night round for some person who just followed my vote.
INSULTED I SAY!
In other words, this makes no sense. Are there any inactives left? This could be the work of inactive wolves.
---This message was edited on 2009-10-06 17:22:08---
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
Even if fedsat was a wolf, there were other people that were more... I don't know, targetable? Like myself... I'm actually a bit insulted, especially if fedsat was a wolf and I turned out to be the person who started the votes for a wolf yet I got overlooked during the night round for some person who just followed my vote.
INSULTED I SAY!
In other words, this makes no sense. Are there any inactives left? This could be the work of inactive wolves.
---This message was edited on 2009-10-06 17:22:08---
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
Well last round was very active with all players except for gap6297 voting... Which means if night timed out then gap could be an inactive wolf.
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
omg i should keep track on what's happening here... st*pid typhoon came back... got classes suspended so.. yea...
i'm not gonna vote yet...
but maybe i'll go with majority
"Puns are a sign of intelligence, deeply buried,"-Alistair Oh
i'm not gonna vote yet...
but maybe i'll go with majority
"Puns are a sign of intelligence, deeply buried,"-Alistair Oh
wettwilly10 wrote:
Well bloom7 self-admittedly was inactive in the last round. So if he's a wolf, and fedsat was also a wolf, and the 3rd wolf was also inactive or distracted... Sunfire47 was last on 2 days ago...
But then bloom7 voted for fedsat, which would be odd if they were both wolves!
Then again, maybe FreeSarah just looked too tasty to resist.
---This message was edited on 2009-10-07 04:02:29---
But even randomly... FreeSarah was the least of their worries... This could be the work of inactive wolves.
Well bloom7 self-admittedly was inactive in the last round. So if he's a wolf, and fedsat was also a wolf, and the 3rd wolf was also inactive or distracted... Sunfire47 was last on 2 days ago...
But then bloom7 voted for fedsat, which would be odd if they were both wolves!
Then again, maybe FreeSarah just looked too tasty to resist.
---This message was edited on 2009-10-07 04:02:29---
After some little pondering, I would like to throw the following observations out there for discussion...
a) gap6279 has made few comments and voted for no one - does this make him a seer or a wolf?
b) sunfire47 voted for no one in the first round, then alicat120 in the second round for no obvious reason
c) alicat120 voted gap6297 first round, bloom7 in the second
d) if the majority was right and fedsat was a wolf, then everyone who voted for him is human
e) there was reasonable cause to suspect savannahlz9, so votes for her may or may not be wolves
Based on all these factors, my suspects for wolfdom are (in my order of suspiciousness)
1. alicat120
2. sunfire47
3. gap6279
a) gap6279 has made few comments and voted for no one - does this make him a seer or a wolf?
b) sunfire47 voted for no one in the first round, then alicat120 in the second round for no obvious reason
c) alicat120 voted gap6297 first round, bloom7 in the second
d) if the majority was right and fedsat was a wolf, then everyone who voted for him is human
e) there was reasonable cause to suspect savannahlz9, so votes for her may or may not be wolves
Based on all these factors, my suspects for wolfdom are (in my order of suspiciousness)
1. alicat120
2. sunfire47
3. gap6279
I like that thinki but I think sunfire47's weird activity would be because she would be uninterested in the game or not bothered to be involved.. I'll check how active ahe has been in the discussion to see if she has been involved
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
Well, she has made only one post and it didn't look like she was very interested in it so that lowers my suspicion of her.. I still won't vote for anyone yet.
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
a. if gap hasn't voted then they are probably not the seer who has to vote in both parts (meaning both who to shoot and who to discover)
b. I had voted for sunfire earlier in the round for inactivity and later changed my vote to bloom7, which is probably why sunfire47 voted for me
c. I voted for gap in the first round because they had been on but not posting, and bloom7 in the second round because at the beginning of the round someone had posted three possible suspects, two of which many people had voted for and one of which they hadn't, I voted for the last one
d. the key word is "if", we don't know if we have gotten a wolf, also a wolf might have voted for them just to stay out of suspicion
I don't get why gap posted in white earlier when refering to the wolves, that seems suspicious to me personally
b. I had voted for sunfire earlier in the round for inactivity and later changed my vote to bloom7, which is probably why sunfire47 voted for me
c. I voted for gap in the first round because they had been on but not posting, and bloom7 in the second round because at the beginning of the round someone had posted three possible suspects, two of which many people had voted for and one of which they hadn't, I voted for the last one
d. the key word is "if", we don't know if we have gotten a wolf, also a wolf might have voted for them just to stay out of suspicion
I don't get why gap posted in white earlier when refering to the wolves, that seems suspicious to me personally
Part of me absolutely wants to think we got a wolf at some point. Having 3 wolves all be inactive causing this vote, is actually just scary. Even to think that the wolves just might not be voting is even scarier.
Maybe we have wolves that are active, just not voting. Sorry im not being particularly helpful. Im just trying to throw possibilities out there.
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
Maybe we have wolves that are active, just not voting. Sorry im not being particularly helpful. Im just trying to throw possibilities out there.
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
gap6297 wrote:
Or the night could have timed out. Does anyone know if the night timed out?
♥ ♥ a kiss is just a kiss til its with the one u love...a hug is just a hug til its with the one ur thinking of ♥ ♥
Maybe it was random?
Or the night could have timed out. Does anyone know if the night timed out?
♥ ♥ a kiss is just a kiss til its with the one u love...a hug is just a hug til its with the one ur thinking of ♥ ♥
savannahlz9 wrote:
It's impossible to tell for sure if the night times out, because if the last wolf doesn't vote until less than an hour before dawn then the round still won't end until the scheduled end time.
However it's suspicious that both nights have gone through right to the scheduled end time - so certainly high probability that at least one wolf is inactive or refusing to vote.
Or the night could have timed out. Does anyone know if the night timed out?
It's impossible to tell for sure if the night times out, because if the last wolf doesn't vote until less than an hour before dawn then the round still won't end until the scheduled end time.
However it's suspicious that both nights have gone through right to the scheduled end time - so certainly high probability that at least one wolf is inactive or refusing to vote.
alicat120 wrote:
Does the seer HAVE to vote for someone to shoot? Cannot they just vote for who to discover that night, and NOT vote to shoot anyone?
(never having been a seer myself, I don't know how it works - the rules page though seems to imply that voting is not mandatory, by not mentioning that it IS mandatory)
a. if gap hasn't voted then they are probably not the seer who has to vote in both parts (meaning both who to shoot and who to discover)
Does the seer HAVE to vote for someone to shoot? Cannot they just vote for who to discover that night, and NOT vote to shoot anyone?
(never having been a seer myself, I don't know how it works - the rules page though seems to imply that voting is not mandatory, by not mentioning that it IS mandatory)
I've been a seerer in previous games, and unless I was confused (which is possible but not probable) they do have to vote in the round to vote for who do discover. However, the seer doesn't have to vote at all in either field.
I would hope that the seer is someone that is voting though so that we have some hope from that.
I would hope that the seer is someone that is voting though so that we have some hope from that.
alicat120 wrote:
The seer could have been shot or eaten by now though. I hope not but it could be the case.
♥ ♥ a kiss is just a kiss til its with the one u love...a hug is just a hug til its with the one ur thinking of ♥ ♥
I've been a seerer in previous games, and unless I was confused (which is possible but not probable) they do have to vote in the round to vote for who do discover. However, the seer doesn't have to vote at all in either field.
I would hope that the seer is someone that is voting though so that we have some hope from that.
I would hope that the seer is someone that is voting though so that we have some hope from that.
The seer could have been shot or eaten by now though. I hope not but it could be the case.
♥ ♥ a kiss is just a kiss til its with the one u love...a hug is just a hug til its with the one ur thinking of ♥ ♥
Just to confirm what ali said, yes, I was also the seer before and you have to vote in order to divine someone.
It almost makes you think that the first to vote might actually be the seer who's just itching to divine someone. I'll have to remember that next game. Too bad I didn't think about that sooner. Like, 2 or 3 games ago when I was the seer.
Umm, but anyway. To help the seer out (due to this new knowledge of the game we now have), we should probably throw a few votes out there.
Gymflip and Raven don't seem to be posting much. If nothing else, they just arent bringing much to the table. I'll come back in a bit after I've thought about it. Think maybe 20 minutes and I'll try to vote.
EDIT: a few spelling errors. Heck, I might halfta edit it again later... whatever.
---This message was edited on 2009-10-07 17:39:00---
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
It almost makes you think that the first to vote might actually be the seer who's just itching to divine someone. I'll have to remember that next game. Too bad I didn't think about that sooner. Like, 2 or 3 games ago when I was the seer.
Umm, but anyway. To help the seer out (due to this new knowledge of the game we now have), we should probably throw a few votes out there.
Gymflip and Raven don't seem to be posting much. If nothing else, they just arent bringing much to the table. I'll come back in a bit after I've thought about it. Think maybe 20 minutes and I'll try to vote.
EDIT: a few spelling errors. Heck, I might halfta edit it again later... whatever.
---This message was edited on 2009-10-07 17:39:00---
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
sorry I haven't been posting much I was sick and had to do hw....wettwilly I don't really understand what you mean by not bring much to the table because yes you use other peoples knowlege but you sort of have to rely on yourself because you dont know if the wolf is feeding you false information
LiveLaughLove
LiveLaughLove
Still, there are wolves who just lie low, either not posting or posting just enough. Those are the wolves that make the game impossible. Even the humans who don't post make the game harder for those playing. You hadn't posted all round, so you made that list of people who hasn't posted. Thats all I'm saying.
You can't really take anything said in these games about your gameplay personally, gym. Now if I had said something to the gist of, "That player is a lazy doody face and I wannna vote him out" then yeah, thats kind of a personal attack.
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
You can't really take anything said in these games about your gameplay personally, gym. Now if I had said something to the gist of, "That player is a lazy doody face and I wannna vote him out" then yeah, thats kind of a personal attack.
To be nobody but myself in a world which is doing its best, night and day, to make you everybody else-- means to fight the hardest battle which any human being can fight, and never stop fighting. E.E. Cummings
You know what.. someone's gonna have to open the voting so I'll go for gap because I'm getting reallly suspicious of her
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
TheBrainBender wrote:
I will also go with gap for now. I will check back in the morning
♥ ♥ a kiss is just a kiss til its with the one u love...a hug is just a hug til its with the one ur thinking of ♥ ♥
You know what.. someone's gonna have to open the voting so I'll go for gap because I'm getting reallly suspicious of her
I will also go with gap for now. I will check back in the morning
♥ ♥ a kiss is just a kiss til its with the one u love...a hug is just a hug til its with the one ur thinking of ♥ ♥
wettwilly10 wrote:
that made me LAUGH!!!.....................................
Disco isn't dead, it lives on in me!
"That player is a lazy doody face and I wannna vote him out" then yeah, thats kind of a personal attack.
that made me LAUGH!!!.....................................
Disco isn't dead, it lives on in me!
I confess! I confess!
That... what I wrote earlier about suspecting alicat120, sunfire47 and gap6279 was a load of nonsense. Indeed I'm surprised that no one has picked me up yet on the many logical inconsistencies in my statements. However such is the nature of social experiments, that they often present unexpected results.
Ahem.
Anyway, if fedsat WAS a wolf, then the ONLY thing we can deduce with reasonable certainty is that the people he voted for in rounds 1 and 2 were probably human - ie Mianabelle and savannahlz9. Because of this, anyone who did NOT vote for shooting one of those two is also, probably, human. Thus alicat120, sunfire47, and gap6279 would be the people I LEAST suspect of being wolves.
The point in casting suspicion on them was to see if anyone else immediately jumped on the bandwagon, pointing "Yes, yes, wolves!" In that case that person (or persons) would be most likely to be a wolf.
Sadly this ploy doesn't seem to have worked very well - or did it? TheBrainBender was fairly supportive of shooting one or any of my spurious suspects! He also voted very quickly with fedsat to shoot savannahlz9 last round.
Having said that, I don't rule gap6279 out as a wolf. He didn't vote for savannahlz9, but he did try and cast suspicion on her in discussion, and his lack of voting may be a consequence of inactivity at critical points in the game. That would also explain FreeSarah being eaten, particularly if the 3rd wolf was also someone who couldn't log on during the night, and it was just a random vote.
So at this point in time my suspicions (for real this time) swing between TheBrainBender and gap6279. While pn_16 also voted for savannahlz9 I think that can probably be explained as a revenge vote on behalf of Mianabelle.
That... what I wrote earlier about suspecting alicat120, sunfire47 and gap6279 was a load of nonsense. Indeed I'm surprised that no one has picked me up yet on the many logical inconsistencies in my statements. However such is the nature of social experiments, that they often present unexpected results.
Ahem.
Anyway, if fedsat WAS a wolf, then the ONLY thing we can deduce with reasonable certainty is that the people he voted for in rounds 1 and 2 were probably human - ie Mianabelle and savannahlz9. Because of this, anyone who did NOT vote for shooting one of those two is also, probably, human. Thus alicat120, sunfire47, and gap6279 would be the people I LEAST suspect of being wolves.
The point in casting suspicion on them was to see if anyone else immediately jumped on the bandwagon, pointing "Yes, yes, wolves!" In that case that person (or persons) would be most likely to be a wolf.
Sadly this ploy doesn't seem to have worked very well - or did it? TheBrainBender was fairly supportive of shooting one or any of my spurious suspects! He also voted very quickly with fedsat to shoot savannahlz9 last round.
Having said that, I don't rule gap6279 out as a wolf. He didn't vote for savannahlz9, but he did try and cast suspicion on her in discussion, and his lack of voting may be a consequence of inactivity at critical points in the game. That would also explain FreeSarah being eaten, particularly if the 3rd wolf was also someone who couldn't log on during the night, and it was just a random vote.
So at this point in time my suspicions (for real this time) swing between TheBrainBender and gap6279. While pn_16 also voted for savannahlz9 I think that can probably be explained as a revenge vote on behalf of Mianabelle.
Just because I agreed with fedsat doesn't make me a wolf. Also if you checked I disgreed with Sunfire47 being a wolf and I didn't say anything about your points talking about if fedsat was a wolf or not and what is would mean. The only peson I suspect is gap, the person you suspect too. I can prove all these through statements I made this round which, as you can check, have not been edited.
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
mathisnice, rush2, Wolf_Spirits93, MAvanzi, miniffer, morpheus25, grilledcheese, Metalizer, 4wheels and TheBrainBender are the BEST!!!!
Now that everybody's suspecting for somebody, I think I'm getting confused.
Are there 2 wolves or 3?
How would we know that the one eaten or shot is a human/seer/werewolf?
Are there some people who already abandoned the game even if they are still alive (in the game, of course!) ?
The wolves may just be tricking us now. There are only 3 possibilities:
1. The wolves are active and not posting bec. they are being careful of what they say.
2. The wolves are active and posting bec. they want to trick us.
3. The wolves are inactive.
Are there 2 wolves or 3?
How would we know that the one eaten or shot is a human/seer/werewolf?
Are there some people who already abandoned the game even if they are still alive (in the game, of course!) ?
The wolves may just be tricking us now. There are only 3 possibilities:
1. The wolves are active and not posting bec. they are being careful of what they say.
2. The wolves are active and posting bec. they want to trick us.
3. The wolves are inactive.
ravenclaw_07 wrote:
Are there 2 wolves or 3?
How would we know that the one eaten or shot is a human/seer/werewolf?
Are there some people who already abandoned the game even if they are still alive (in the game, of course!) ?
Since this is a clueless game, there is no way of knowing for sure how many wolves are left, as it is not revealed whether the person shot was human or not. I think you can safely assume that the people who've been eaten were human though - I don't think it's even possible for the wolves to vote to eat another wolf.
The seer... the seer... who is - or was - the seer?
Anyway, I've decided to vote for... gap6279. At the moment I think fedsat being 1 of the wolves, and the other 2 being inactives (for most if not all of the time) makes the most sense for how the game has played out so far.
Are there 2 wolves or 3?
How would we know that the one eaten or shot is a human/seer/werewolf?
Are there some people who already abandoned the game even if they are still alive (in the game, of course!) ?
Since this is a clueless game, there is no way of knowing for sure how many wolves are left, as it is not revealed whether the person shot was human or not. I think you can safely assume that the people who've been eaten were human though - I don't think it's even possible for the wolves to vote to eat another wolf.
The seer... the seer... who is - or was - the seer?
Anyway, I've decided to vote for... gap6279. At the moment I think fedsat being 1 of the wolves, and the other 2 being inactives (for most if not all of the time) makes the most sense for how the game has played out so far.
PS. If I get eaten tonight, obviously after gap6279 it should be sunfire47 who is shot next, if the theory of "the wolves are inactives" is to be pursued.
having read previous discussions.... i think gap is a wolf
"Puns are a sign of intelligence, deeply buried,"-Alistair Oh
"Puns are a sign of intelligence, deeply buried,"-Alistair Oh
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!