The Werewolf Game
Game #3385: Extra roles? (try 2 :) )
This private game is moderated by tEMfLAks. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 7 rounds.
Slamm was the Cupid's apprentice. 1 more wolf team member, good job humans, Sorry wolf :O you're alone.
Invincible was nothing? (sorry :O)
did i say there hAD 2 be a real wolf (not team member) in each tb? cpaal eq rpta pai eq bsjqa ujshg eq aerdap
Also, Yeesha has immunity for the day.
(she had immunity for the night, but now its over )
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 14:55:44---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Invincible was nothing? (sorry :O)
did i say there hAD 2 be a real wolf (not team member) in each tb? cpaal eq rpta pai eq bsjqa ujshg eq aerdap
Also, Yeesha has immunity for the day.
(she had immunity for the night, but now its over )
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 14:55:44---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Wasn't expecting an early night ending, but I won't say no. I'll wait for Slamm and Invincible's ID before I do to much, but I do have something to say already. I had been PMing Slamm previously (because I am the anarchist and I wasn't sure who's team she was really on), and yesterday she sent me this PM:
I voted for her, as did almost everyone else, but if she was a wolf there wouldn't have been a night. So, this morning, I sent her this:
and she replied:
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 16:04:55---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
I voted for her, as did almost everyone else, but if she was a wolf there wouldn't have been a night. So, this morning, I sent her this:
and she replied:
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 16:04:55---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Okay if slamm was the human apprentice, she would have been in the wolf TB (correct me if I'm wrong, Tem). Therefore she would have known if Yeesha was a wolf or not. So those posts confuse me...
Yeesha, was there anything more to the second PM? You didn't show the part where a signature would be (but you did for the other two).
Waiting for IDs also, currently leaning Yeesha vote.
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Yeesha, was there anything more to the second PM? You didn't show the part where a signature would be (but you did for the other two).
Waiting for IDs also, currently leaning Yeesha vote.
My wiki trail is now public! :D
There wasn't, but I'll take a better screenshot
Edit: Done
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 14:50:57---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Edit: Done
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 14:50:57---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
It doesn't look any different...
(For clarification, I'm asking about the PM you sent her)
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 14:56:26---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
(For clarification, I'm asking about the PM you sent her)
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 14:56:26---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
What are you looking for? I screenshotted the entire message.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
I'm wanting a screenshot of the PM you sent her that shows the signature also (or else I won't know if you sent her more than that but you just cut the screenshot off so we couldn't see it)
My wiki trail is now public! :D
My wiki trail is now public! :D
It doesn't have a signature
Edit: Sorry, I thought you were talking about the third message. I just edited it again. Is that better?
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 15:08:35---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Edit: Sorry, I thought you were talking about the third message. I just edited it again. Is that better?
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 15:08:35---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Yeah, thanks. Okay, if I can't vote Yeesha this round... I don't know. She's the only logical choice.
Benches, tem, french french french.
Voting myself ATM, I guess.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 15:22:56---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Benches, tem, french french french.
Voting myself ATM, I guess.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 15:22:56---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
So, how to we know fun is the librarian? I was not privy to those conversations.
He sent the same message in the TB, which inclines me to believe him.
My wiki trail is now public! :D
My wiki trail is now public! :D
I'm fairly sure he's telling the truth. If Fun's the librarian, I think we can trust him.
Although it's still a bit strange that he revealed and didn't get eaten - that's almost as dangerous as a seer role. But that's the only thing I have against him at the moment.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Although it's still a bit strange that he revealed and didn't get eaten - that's almost as dangerous as a seer role. But that's the only thing I have against him at the moment.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Here is one of Fun's posts from round three post:
tEMfLAks wrote:
Yeah Tem, this quote shows you said there is one wolf (not wolf team) in each box.
I know you guys don't have your box anymore, so you can't fact check. No one said Fun was crazy/wrong about this quote from Tem back in round 3. Is this a correct quote?
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:53:11---
tEMfLAks wrote:
There is 1 wolf here, and 1 in the other TB. I mean wolf,not wolf team member who could be a human.
Yeah Tem, this quote shows you said there is one wolf (not wolf team) in each box.
I know you guys don't have your box anymore, so you can't fact check. No one said Fun was crazy/wrong about this quote from Tem back in round 3. Is this a correct quote?
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:53:11---
scrub88 wrote:
But there's 3 wolves, and Alien was the only one not in the talkboxes. And I doubt it's Alien.
Edit: I only remember people mentioning it in the talkbox (I don't remember word for word the exact message), but that seems right. I don't remember if it was in color, though.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:43:52---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Here is one of Fun's posts from round three post:
tEMfLAks wrote:
tEMfLAks wrote:
There is 1 wolf here, and 1 in the other TB. I mean wolf,not wolf team member who could be a human.
But there's 3 wolves, and Alien was the only one not in the talkboxes. And I doubt it's Alien.
Edit: I only remember people mentioning it in the talkbox (I don't remember word for word the exact message), but that seems right. I don't remember if it was in color, though.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:43:52---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
(Scrub, I think that is correct; Yeesha, I don't think it was in color)
Yeesha, we only have one wolf left, and the wolf in our TB is the only one not accounted for. So it has to be you or Fun. We have 3? rounds left, so it's autowin no matter what we do. Should we shoot Funfor?
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:44:33---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Yeesha, we only have one wolf left, and the wolf in our TB is the only one not accounted for. So it has to be you or Fun. We have 3? rounds left, so it's autowin no matter what we do. Should we shoot Funfor?
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:44:33---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
I wish we could avoid shooting Fun if possible - he's the librarian, and I really doubt he's the wolf. Honestly someone like oddrey sounds more wolfy to me. He's been inactive and kind of quieter than normal (compared to other games I checked), but he was on today, and the night also ended early for once.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
(Oddrey is a she) She wasn't in the TB, though. Unless something new comes up, I am almost certain the wolf is the only person we can't shoot.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:47:08---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:47:08---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
She wasn't in a talkbox? I thought you were the only one not in one.
Although....if we really took Tem's message at face value, that would mean that there's a wolf that wasn't in any talkbox. Are there more people that weren't in a talkbox, that would at least let us consider that?
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Although....if we really took Tem's message at face value, that would mean that there's a wolf that wasn't in any talkbox. Are there more people that weren't in a talkbox, that would at least let us consider that?
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
I meant in our talkbox. And Tem said there was definitely one wolf in each TB after we shot one, right? So I don't think we can consider people not in TBs - besides, I might have been the only one not in a TB.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:51:06---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:51:06---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Okay, that makes more sense. We already had the two wolves (Whatever and Squee), but I doubt she left you out because you were a wolf and there was only one wolf per talkbox (I think she forgot). Never mind that theory then.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
It's pretty weird. I didn't get anything last night.
Wolf's inactive maybe?
I'm inclined to Yeesha, but if we can't shoot her, I don't feel anyone particular.
Holding off voting.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:59:05---
Wolf's inactive maybe?
I'm inclined to Yeesha, but if we can't shoot her, I don't feel anyone particular.
Holding off voting.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 17:59:05---
Also, it appears that the last wolf is simple.
When Squee would answer with 'huggable cacti', they would answer Jade plant.
Similar for the 2nd night.
That kind of makes me less suspicious of Alien and Yeesha.
When Squee would answer with 'huggable cacti', they would answer Jade plant.
Similar for the 2nd night.
That kind of makes me less suspicious of Alien and Yeesha.
AlienChipBrain wrote:
In my talkbox: Sky, Scrub, Smithy, Oddrey, InvincibleGal, and Squeelover
In the other talkbox: Rove, Spider, Fun, Yeesha, Slam, and Cute
Not in a talkbox: Alienchipbrain and speddyeddy
I meant in our talkbox. And Tem said there was definitely one wolf in each TB after we shot one, right? So I don't think we can consider people not in TBs - besides, I might have been the only one not in a TB.
In my talkbox: Sky, Scrub, Smithy, Oddrey, InvincibleGal, and Squeelover
In the other talkbox: Rove, Spider, Fun, Yeesha, Slam, and Cute
Not in a talkbox: Alienchipbrain and speddyeddy
You didn't get anything from last night? If the wolf didn't answer, then you should get a clue about them, right?
I thought one of the inactives sounded like the most logical choice (maybe Speddy? When Squee made a list in one of the rounds, she just brushed her off like 'but I doubt it's her' without giving the explanations she did to some of the others.). But this night ended early, and that kind of messes that up. I'm going to vote oddrey, because I doubt it's Fun or Alien, and I'm ruling out the inactives for the time being. But oddrey was on today, which might have been the reason this night ended early, and not the others.
I'll be inactive tomorrow. I'd say just analyze everyone's posts, and the night times and stuff, and see if anything stands out. To me, Fun, Alien, and the inactives are no's, and that leaves Scrub and oddrey, of which oddrey fits the bill much better.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
I thought one of the inactives sounded like the most logical choice (maybe Speddy? When Squee made a list in one of the rounds, she just brushed her off like 'but I doubt it's her' without giving the explanations she did to some of the others.). But this night ended early, and that kind of messes that up. I'm going to vote oddrey, because I doubt it's Fun or Alien, and I'm ruling out the inactives for the time being. But oddrey was on today, which might have been the reason this night ended early, and not the others.
I'll be inactive tomorrow. I'd say just analyze everyone's posts, and the night times and stuff, and see if anything stands out. To me, Fun, Alien, and the inactives are no's, and that leaves Scrub and oddrey, of which oddrey fits the bill much better.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Hey Fun, is there any reason to try and crack your coded message? Is it still relevant?
Funfor1 wrote:
Do we know for sure Squee gave that answer? That sounds like her, though.
Edit: Also, if I had to pick my favorite plant, it would probably be a fruit tree (of some kind, maybe asian pear?), or a redbud maybe? I also like spearmint, we have some in our yard and it's great to pick (although I don't like to chew it, it isn't the best). And my favorite animal is a squee (Alien can confirm).
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 18:21:25---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Also, it appears that the last wolf is simple.
When Squee would answer with 'huggable cacti', they would answer Jade plant.
When Squee would answer with 'huggable cacti', they would answer Jade plant.
Do we know for sure Squee gave that answer? That sounds like her, though.
Edit: Also, if I had to pick my favorite plant, it would probably be a fruit tree (of some kind, maybe asian pear?), or a redbud maybe? I also like spearmint, we have some in our yard and it's great to pick (although I don't like to chew it, it isn't the best). And my favorite animal is a squee (Alien can confirm).
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 18:21:25---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
to the ghost: You can now communicate with someone. Now is a good time to use that skill.
Did anyone ever receive annything from the baker?
What does a human apprentice do?
Did anyone ever receive annything from the baker?
What does a human apprentice do?
scrub88 wrote:
The ghost can only communicate if dead by now.
What on earth
to the ghost: You can now communicate with someone. Now is a good time to use that skill.
Did anyone ever receive annything from the baker?
What does a human apprentice do?
Did anyone ever receive annything from the baker?
What does a human apprentice do?
The ghost can only communicate if dead by now.
What on earth
The ghost could reveal - either they'll get eaten, and they'll be able to use their power, or, more likely, the wolf won't shoot them to prevent them from using their ability, and they'll have a sort of night immunity.
Although, a lot of the eatings haven't made sense (lining up with my oddrey theory). Why not shoot one of the mostly cleared people? Why shoot Invincible last round, who hasn't been super active, over Fun, who revealed to be the librarian, currently the most dangerous role in the game for the wolf? Wouldn't it make more sense if it was random shootings, or by someone who wasn't paying enough attention to the game to know that Fun was librarian?
I don't have a lot to go on here, but I think the oddrey theory makes sense. I'm voting her, and I'll be back Monday to respond to any PMs and change my vote if I need to.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Although, a lot of the eatings haven't made sense (lining up with my oddrey theory). Why not shoot one of the mostly cleared people? Why shoot Invincible last round, who hasn't been super active, over Fun, who revealed to be the librarian, currently the most dangerous role in the game for the wolf? Wouldn't it make more sense if it was random shootings, or by someone who wasn't paying enough attention to the game to know that Fun was librarian?
I don't have a lot to go on here, but I think the oddrey theory makes sense. I'm voting her, and I'll be back Monday to respond to any PMs and change my vote if I need to.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
my bad. So only Invinciblegal could reach out.
Someone said that Spider was color blind earlier. I don't know he is, but I am.
So this whole green is true, red if false thing is a challenge to me.
tem: Since black is either, how do we know that Slam was Cupid's apprentice? Or that InvincibleGal was a plain human? Your first message of the day is all in black.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 19:10:42---
Someone said that Spider was color blind earlier. I don't know he is, but I am.
So this whole green is true, red if false thing is a challenge to me.
tem: Since black is either, how do we know that Slam was Cupid's apprentice? Or that InvincibleGal was a plain human? Your first message of the day is all in black.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-06 19:10:42---
Does Yeesah have immunity this round? This message is also in black.
My rule of thumb has been to believe anything that is said unless it's in red.
My wiki trail is now public! :D
My wiki trail is now public! :D
scrub88 wrote:
I know from what Invincible told me and from how she has been acting that she did have at least one role. All I know is she was not allowed to say outright the answers to coded messages that she sent or reveal her role. (Unless she was just tricking us, she did that with one message)
If you want me to ask her, PM me and I'll do it Monday.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
tem: Since black is neither, how do we know that Slam was Cupid's apprentice? Or that InvincibleGal was neither? Your first message of the day is all in black.
I know from what Invincible told me and from how she has been acting that she did have at least one role. All I know is she was not allowed to say outright the answers to coded messages that she sent or reveal her role. (Unless she was just tricking us, she did that with one message)
If you want me to ask her, PM me and I'll do it Monday.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
AlienChipBrain wrote:
But I don't think we can assume black is true. Look at the clue tem gave us in the first post of the round. It translates green is true, red is false, black is either.
I believe she is telling us that the post Fun referred to back in round 2 could not be trusted. But then what else in black can't be trusted?
My rule of thumb has been to believe anything that is said unless it's in red.
But I don't think we can assume black is true. Look at the clue tem gave us in the first post of the round. It translates green is true, red is false, black is either.
I believe she is telling us that the post Fun referred to back in round 2 could not be trusted. But then what else in black can't be trusted?
I'll be back Monday. Goodnight!
My wiki trail is now public! :D
My wiki trail is now public! :D
So I just read round zero. The human apprentice is in a talkbox with another human. With only one wolf role active now, it would be a good time for both to come forward. At least you can both verify the other's word.
I was the Demagogue.
Fun is the librarian.
Yeesha is the Anarchist.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-07 07:22:33---
I was the Demagogue.
Fun is the librarian.
Yeesha is the Anarchist.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-07 07:22:33---
scrub88 wrote:
No, I was just revealing I was the librarian there, but I gave you an uncoded version alrdy.
Hey Fun, is there any reason to try and crack your coded message? Is it still relevant?
No, I was just revealing I was the librarian there, but I gave you an uncoded version alrdy.
So far, we know the roles of almost all of the dead players: Whatever - wolf, Spider - seer, Cutebunny - Cupid, Rove - 2nd seer, Squeelover - wolf, Smithy - 2nd anarchist, Slamngirl - wolf apprentice to Cupid, and InvincibleGal - human.
I am not voting Funfor because his claim to be the librarian has gone unchallenged. What I mean is that if he were the wolf claiming to be the librarian, then a challenge coming from someone would narrow the game down to two possibilities.
What we really need to lock this game down is the identities of two players: the baker and the human apprentice. The ghost, like me, is nice but not very verifiable.
From the baker, just give us a list of the players you sent treats to, especially if they are still alive and can verify your claims.
From the human apprentice, who are you apprenticing should be good enough because that other person can confirm your apprenticeship.
You guys need to understand there is only one wolf. That player can't challenge you or their game is up. They can't claim to be you first because when you challenge their claim the game is down to two players.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-07 07:51:52---
I am not voting Funfor because his claim to be the librarian has gone unchallenged. What I mean is that if he were the wolf claiming to be the librarian, then a challenge coming from someone would narrow the game down to two possibilities.
What we really need to lock this game down is the identities of two players: the baker and the human apprentice. The ghost, like me, is nice but not very verifiable.
From the baker, just give us a list of the players you sent treats to, especially if they are still alive and can verify your claims.
From the human apprentice, who are you apprenticing should be good enough because that other person can confirm your apprenticeship.
You guys need to understand there is only one wolf. That player can't challenge you or their game is up. They can't claim to be you first because when you challenge their claim the game is down to two players.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-07 07:51:52---
What if the baker sent a treat to a wolf?(the wolf doesn't challenge, but doesn't confirm either)
I feel the wolf isn't into the discussion much(or is inactive), as I wasn't eaten.
I feel the wolf isn't into the discussion much(or is inactive), as I wasn't eaten.
And oh, if you're human, don't claim to be something you aren't.
Smithy had no other role, right?
I have no idea who to vote, but I do feel like maybe Alien voting herself may be an attempt to get suspicion off. I don't really suspect scrub. Honestly, I don't really have a clear feeling, so I'm either going to vote Alien or maybe Sky just to be different.
"Eat a mushroom every day. Why? Then I know you're listening to me." - Riverperson, my personal role model
"Eat a mushroom every day. Why? Then I know you're listening to me." - Riverperson, my personal role model
Also - talkbox? Am I missing something...? What's the point of talkboxes in this game?
"Eat a mushroom every day. Why? Then I know you're listening to me." - Riverperson, my personal role model
"Eat a mushroom every day. Why? Then I know you're listening to me." - Riverperson, my personal role model
Getting info about who are wolves, maybe?
Talkboxes have at least 1 wolf(or at least member) in it.
Honestly, this is the 1st game where I'm so confused as to not even knowing how many people have roles.
Talkboxes have at least 1 wolf(or at least member) in it.
Honestly, this is the 1st game where I'm so confused as to not even knowing how many people have roles.
Voting oddrey, subject to change.
P.S. Don't vote when a wolf could end the round.
P.S. Don't vote when a wolf could end the round.
speddy - were you given a role at the beginning of the game? Go look at private messages at the top of the screen.
You seem like you would have been a prime candidate for the ghost.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-07 13:09:45---
You seem like you would have been a prime candidate for the ghost.
---This message was edited on 2020-06-07 13:09:45---
All I know is I'm not the wolf so I'll vote for Alienchipbrain to tip the scale in my favor
I don't really know who to vote for, but it doesn't really matter. As Alienchipbrain said, a win is in the bank.
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!