The Werewolf Game
Game #525: Werewolf Game
This game is moderated by WittyKitty. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 6 rounds.
Wow, Cinn, you posted the exact same animal as me. Who else would think of pink spotted giraffes? *laughs*
On with round 2!
No, Mocha, it isn't a problem that you post a lot. *smirks*
Oh, and Mocha says she will miss you all.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 15:42:00---
Livin' that mom-life...
On with round 2!
No, Mocha, it isn't a problem that you post a lot. *smirks*
Oh, and Mocha says she will miss you all.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 15:42:00---
Livin' that mom-life...
Well, can't say I blame the wolves prefering mocha to a grizzled old dessert goat like me. We lost a lot with that attack. Sorry to see that result. It was a pretty fast turn-around. So, we're back in daylight.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Oh Mocha - what a lost - See you in the boomper box. We'll get those wolves!!!!
Cin, I think you and I are in trouble. I've captured the onlines for the last few hours - minus about 30-45 min a lunch run. I've got to go through the names. It may not be a lot of help but if I see anything I'll let you know. I'll at least get the last 30 min posted. I'm picking up the granddaughter in half an hour.
Sorry I don't feel like the animals anymore. yuck. this game is going to be mean I feel it.
Edit - For sure human is GCcrazygurl09 still not on line.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 15:53:13---
Celebrate the moment!
Cin, I think you and I are in trouble. I've captured the onlines for the last few hours - minus about 30-45 min a lunch run. I've got to go through the names. It may not be a lot of help but if I see anything I'll let you know. I'll at least get the last 30 min posted. I'm picking up the granddaughter in half an hour.
Sorry I don't feel like the animals anymore. yuck. this game is going to be mean I feel it.
Edit - For sure human is GCcrazygurl09 still not on line.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 15:53:13---
Celebrate the moment!
Oh, shoot. I think I was on in the last hour, making me prime suspect for wolf. I can assuredly say that I am not a wolf, but of course my words cannot be taken at face value.
Face...That gives me an idea... What if comments for werewolf had to be video posted (like with a webcam)... it would make you really try to disguise your lies... just a cool thought
Lol I think I lost my ability to the art of defending myself when I was cleared in round 2 last game, and didn't have to defend myself (except to beetle, who proceeded to vote for me). Man, I am so deep in the hole right now! I didn't vote last round because I went to bed, and when I got home from school, it was night. So I came back now, and it's day...If we really believe that minlo is a wolf, that makes me prime suspect because I didn't vote for him. However, I think we just shot him because he didn't care about the game, making him more of a fish vote.
Kudos to the real wolves for eating the most talkative and analytical player...
And in my own defense, cyndy also did not vote for minlo, but for zonarita...why?
Zon, You're right. You and cinn will probably be next on the wolves' list
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
Face...That gives me an idea... What if comments for werewolf had to be video posted (like with a webcam)... it would make you really try to disguise your lies... just a cool thought
Lol I think I lost my ability to the art of defending myself when I was cleared in round 2 last game, and didn't have to defend myself (except to beetle, who proceeded to vote for me). Man, I am so deep in the hole right now! I didn't vote last round because I went to bed, and when I got home from school, it was night. So I came back now, and it's day...If we really believe that minlo is a wolf, that makes me prime suspect because I didn't vote for him. However, I think we just shot him because he didn't care about the game, making him more of a fish vote.
Kudos to the real wolves for eating the most talkative and analytical player...
And in my own defense, cyndy also did not vote for minlo, but for zonarita...why?
Zon, You're right. You and cinn will probably be next on the wolves' list
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
Considering the time the round changed, some of our students (and/or teachers) might not be wolves because they couldn't get on until after school is out. I guess that time is highly variable based on people's R/L locations, but if you are just getting on, wouldn't hurt to post. I've been on and off most of the day.
Just a thought for what it is worth. Also, if you see an invitation to the Boomer talk box, come check it out. It is a kind of Braingle retreat for some of us. (You can say Hi to Mocha there) .. No game discussion though!
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 17:23:41---
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Just a thought for what it is worth. Also, if you see an invitation to the Boomer talk box, come check it out. It is a kind of Braingle retreat for some of us. (You can say Hi to Mocha there) .. No game discussion though!
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 17:23:41---
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Poor Mocha
I hope we'll get a chance to play together again sometime.
This is a screen shot within 2 min of the end of round one - (I do think Bo took one too. If you've not pulled the players out - you might post the whole screen.)
Online in the last 5 minutes zonahobo, mocha613, WittyKitty, mythmaster, girl63160,
Online in the last 15 minutes Christina_S,
Online in the last 30 minutes cyndy296,
What it means to me - 5 min are probably folks still logged on - Hobo has posted obviously not hidding (He's still doing editor duties so he is usually on all day); mocha is lost to us; Witty our mod; Myth and girl haven't posted here yet. Myth came back and changed his vote - obviously watching game.
If there is a delay before the round ends Christiana and Cyn seem most suspcious - I captured the link before signing on that is why my name is not on the list. In the last game you'll remember my name was posted as I was on when Cin was not.
please share what you glean from the screen shot. We've got to talk as much as we can before everyone goes back into fear mode. Any help you think it has to us and what we really can not get from it.
Dach good question - I'd also like to know - Cyn was on when we were all moving votes to the non playing this morning.
And in my own defense, cyndy also did not vote for minlo, but for zonarita...why?
I've got to get that granddaughter - I'll not be back for awhile - We have cleared at least one person as human.
Celebrate the moment!
Wow...I didn't even get a chance to vote
But what can you do(I will try and vote on this round) *that is my goal*
So does any body have a "game" plan as to what we should do now?
Because I am at a lost...
Time heals ALL wounds
But what can you do(I will try and vote on this round) *that is my goal*
So does any body have a "game" plan as to what we should do now?
Because I am at a lost...
Time heals ALL wounds
Well dach, being on near round change could put you up a little on the suspicion list, but coming forth and posting as you did was a good move for a human (or wolf ). I'm glad you posted as you did. I wouldn't call you my "prime suspect" at the moment. Help the humans and you slide down into the comfort zone during the day. At least a little suspicion can be some protection from the wolves at night so it works both ways.
I don't feel all that strongly that minlo was a wolf, but If you don't play you pay in the day!. (That could be a human motto to go with the wolve's "If you can't beat them, eat them."
I am going to vote early for Mythmaster. I think he voted without cause for Huffle (likely a human) and seemed to be in the right place at the wrong time like dachser. Need to get my chops in early before I become "goat chops" for the wolves.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 16:59:20---
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
I don't feel all that strongly that minlo was a wolf, but If you don't play you pay in the day!. (That could be a human motto to go with the wolve's "If you can't beat them, eat them."
I am going to vote early for Mythmaster. I think he voted without cause for Huffle (likely a human) and seemed to be in the right place at the wrong time like dachser. Need to get my chops in early before I become "goat chops" for the wolves.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-25 16:59:20---
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
CAUTION! Newbie Question!
I see at the bottom where you can see who is online now but how can you tell the 5, 15 and 30 minute time frame?
I see at the bottom where you can see who is online now but how can you tell the 5, 15 and 30 minute time frame?
Oh darn =(
I am a suspect *snaps fingers*
That stinks...I CAN say I am not a wolf...but it's not like that actually has any bearing =P
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
I am a suspect *snaps fingers*
That stinks...I CAN say I am not a wolf...but it's not like that actually has any bearing =P
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
If you click on the more users link, you get the expanded list Mom (I feel pretty funny calling you that!).. On and off line is just one tell people try to use to have a little strategy. Some wolves could have voted just after noon and been long gone when the night round ended so it is not foolproof. Just help the humans win and things should work out as long as you don't become wolfie chow.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Well I'm a human but you might as well vote for me because I didn't realize the day was 48 hours and I don't like waiting that long.
zonahobo wrote:
I don't feel all that strongly that minlo was a wolf, but If you don't play you pay in the day!. (That could be a human motto to go with the wolve's "If you can't beat them, eat them."
Very Funny!
also wrote:
If you click on the more users link, you get the expanded list Mom (I feel pretty funny calling you that!)..
Extremely Funny!!!
So since Cyndy was on in the last 30 minutes she would have been on during the night phase thus making her a possible wolf?
I don't feel all that strongly that minlo was a wolf, but If you don't play you pay in the day!. (That could be a human motto to go with the wolve's "If you can't beat them, eat them."
Very Funny!
also wrote:
If you click on the more users link, you get the expanded list Mom (I feel pretty funny calling you that!)..
Extremely Funny!!!
So since Cyndy was on in the last 30 minutes she would have been on during the night phase thus making her a possible wolf?
Well if Cyndy was on in the last 30 mins. that could mean a very good possiblity that Cyndy is a wolf. I mean Cyndy already voted(for zonarita) So it could be.
Something else that I notice(and I think was already mentioned) but Cyndy was the only one to vote for Zonarita...right?
Time heals ALL wounds
Something else that I notice(and I think was already mentioned) but Cyndy was the only one to vote for Zonarita...right?
Time heals ALL wounds
doesnt seem like much is goin on so ill wait to vote till later so ill come check back in the morning to c if anyone has any ideas.
I'll go huffle again for the heck of it.
Having Mocha and Witty out kind of takes a lot of the "chat" out of the game I guess. I would switch to Cyndy if some of the rest were leaning that way. Maybe Myth was just a victim of bad timing. I wonder if our seer picked anything up? We have plenty of time to think about it. I'm not dead set on Myth.. just wanted to get the ball rolling.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Good morning all. That was a fast night round. Sorry I can't help in clearing anyone. Once I left work yesterday, I didn't arrive home until late last night.
I am not too keen on voting for myth, zonahobo. I do believe that he was just fish voting and happened to do it really early in the round.
GCcrazygurl wrote:
That is very true GC, but don't put all your belief in that option. In the last game I was in, I got accused that way and it was just bad timing for logging in for me. I was not a wolf, but it was very hard to prove it. The time delay is "a few hours". We do know that could be very short timing. In our last game, one round of night lasted no more than 1hr and 30mins.
There is not very much to go on right now. I am unsure of cyndy, as that could be a frame since she was the only one to not follow pattern. But that is just an observation right now.
Edited to add color.
Edit again. I am sad to see mocha gone and I believe you may be right rita. Zonarita, did you catch any other screen shots for the 2 hours prior to the night round ending? I don't know if you want to post that info, if you have it, but I believe it would prove to be very useful.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 06:24:41---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I am not too keen on voting for myth, zonahobo. I do believe that he was just fish voting and happened to do it really early in the round.
GCcrazygurl wrote:
Well if Cyndy was on in the last 30 mins. that could mean a very good possiblity that Cyndy is a wolf. I mean Cyndy already voted(for zonarita) So it could be.
Something else that I notice(and I think was already mentioned) but Cyndy was the only one to vote for Zonarita...right?
Something else that I notice(and I think was already mentioned) but Cyndy was the only one to vote for Zonarita...right?
That is very true GC, but don't put all your belief in that option. In the last game I was in, I got accused that way and it was just bad timing for logging in for me. I was not a wolf, but it was very hard to prove it. The time delay is "a few hours". We do know that could be very short timing. In our last game, one round of night lasted no more than 1hr and 30mins.
There is not very much to go on right now. I am unsure of cyndy, as that could be a frame since she was the only one to not follow pattern. But that is just an observation right now.
Edited to add color.
Edit again. I am sad to see mocha gone and I believe you may be right rita. Zonarita, did you catch any other screen shots for the 2 hours prior to the night round ending? I don't know if you want to post that info, if you have it, but I believe it would prove to be very useful.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 06:24:41---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Cinnamon wrote:
While he may indeed have been just fishing in round 1, it does not appear as though he is too interested in participating in the rest of the game considering the posts he has made so far this round. Since he's already voted , I'm not too sure that we'll be seeing much more from him this round either, but I'll give him the chance to clarify before I make any finial decisions. What does everyone else think?
mythmaster wrote:
mythmaster wrote:
So how about it Myth... do you want to stay and play?
I am not too keen on voting for myth, zonahobo. I do believe that he was just fish voting and happened to do it really early in the round.
While he may indeed have been just fishing in round 1, it does not appear as though he is too interested in participating in the rest of the game considering the posts he has made so far this round. Since he's already voted , I'm not too sure that we'll be seeing much more from him this round either, but I'll give him the chance to clarify before I make any finial decisions. What does everyone else think?
mythmaster wrote:
Well I'm a human but you might as well vote for me because I didn't realize the day was 48 hours and I don't like waiting that long.
mythmaster wrote:
I'll go huffle again for the heck of it.
So how about it Myth... do you want to stay and play?
Mythmaster, you don't sound very enthusiastic about our game. I remember a certain wolf a little RASCAL in our last game had the same strategy. A little "Fine! Go ahead and shoot me!"...
And those who don't wish to participate only hinder the humans. Therefore my vote goes to mythmaster (unless more evidence comes out against cyndy or christina)
And your post:
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 09:36:46---
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
And those who don't wish to participate only hinder the humans. Therefore my vote goes to mythmaster (unless more evidence comes out against cyndy or christina)
And your post:
I'll go huffle again for the heck of it.
That's not really a good reason to vote for someone. Just because you fished for them in the first round doesn't mean they are a wolf and that you vote for them again...
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 09:36:46---
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
mythmaster wrote:
Only question that I have at the time:
If you know that you don't like having long rounds why wouold you even join? It's not like the time frame was hidden...But if someone doesn't want to be here, why keep them here?
It's just slowing down the process(some). In my opinion, it seems that we would spend too much time wondering about this person(Mythmaster)and loose site of the game.*that is coming from another game that I came across. Everyone was so worried about the person who wanted out that they all lost site of the game*
I'm not saying that it's going to happen here, but I think it is something to think about.
Edit: It is too early and I couldn't spell once again...and I added some color and smilely
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 10:06:22---
Time heals ALL wounds
Well I'm a human but you might as well vote for me because I didn't realize the day was 48 hours and I don't like waiting that long.
Only question that I have at the time:
If you know that you don't like having long rounds why wouold you even join? It's not like the time frame was hidden...But if someone doesn't want to be here, why keep them here?
It's just slowing down the process(some). In my opinion, it seems that we would spend too much time wondering about this person(Mythmaster)and loose site of the game.*that is coming from another game that I came across. Everyone was so worried about the person who wanted out that they all lost site of the game*
I'm not saying that it's going to happen here, but I think it is something to think about.
Edit: It is too early and I couldn't spell once again...and I added some color and smilely
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 10:06:22---
Time heals ALL wounds
I'm just going to go for mythmaster, he does sound suspicious to me.... This game is really active and it is really hard for me because I have to go to school, sorry if i miss a lot guys.
Hey, sorry I wasn't on for a while. Life has been busy and my vacation has been going well. I think that GC has a very good point about "not losing sight of the game." Just keep in focus no matter what you are doing. Great to at least see some convo in here.
Livin' that mom-life...
Livin' that mom-life...
It was my fault for not reading the game time, if you don't want to shoot me you don't have to but I really won't be around too much. The only problem I have with 48 hour days is that everyone waits till theres like 5 hours left and then decides to do a vote that they easily could have made hours ago.
I understand what you are saying myth, but I do feel you are human and I would hate to lose a fellow human in the game. But on the other hand its hard to keep a fellow human around who doesn't want to participate. We still have a lot of players left, and you don't have to vote if you don't want to. I know you already did and you can't take it back, only change it to help us. But as long as we can continue to get a majority without you, for now it won't matter if you do vote. I do believe that as the rounds go on they won't take as long, since more and more info will present itself. For now, I will reserve from voting you out just yet.
I would much prefer shooting a wolf if we can deduce who is one. Just because myth wants out, the wolves will know if he's human, and if so, its a way too easy vote for the wolves to jump on that bandwagon. I will wait a few more hours to see what may come up before making a vote.
And yes that means whoever has decided to vote myth out so far looks very suspicious as a wolf, to me right now. But my opinion of those players may change as the game goes on.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I would much prefer shooting a wolf if we can deduce who is one. Just because myth wants out, the wolves will know if he's human, and if so, its a way too easy vote for the wolves to jump on that bandwagon. I will wait a few more hours to see what may come up before making a vote.
And yes that means whoever has decided to vote myth out so far looks very suspicious as a wolf, to me right now. But my opinion of those players may change as the game goes on.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I agree that voting for myth because he may not be too active isn't a great idea, it gives the wolves a potential free pass if myth isn't a wolf. Although, he isn't a known human...quite a dilemma. I'm sorry to see Mocha gone unfortunately, her posts were quite helpful last game. First off I'm going to be looking at people's posts involving voting myth off and seeing if any wolves are enjoying their ride on that bandwagon.
Thank you foy clarifying Myth and well said Cinn
I too would hate to vote for someone that I feel is human vs. someone that seems more wolfish with that said I think I'll wait just a little bit longer for some "Who's the wolf?" discussion before I vote.
For now this is how i'm leaning..
Cyndy or Christina b/c they seem most likely to be wolves since they were on during the night phase
Myth - even though I believe he is human he confesses that he won't be very active and isn't that why we voted off minlo in the first round?
My head is spinning
I'll check back soon
I too would hate to vote for someone that I feel is human vs. someone that seems more wolfish with that said I think I'll wait just a little bit longer for some "Who's the wolf?" discussion before I vote.
For now this is how i'm leaning..
Cyndy or Christina b/c they seem most likely to be wolves since they were on during the night phase
Myth - even though I believe he is human he confesses that he won't be very active and isn't that why we voted off minlo in the first round?
My head is spinning
I'll check back soon
mythmaster wrote:
Spoken like a human - but maybe hidding a bad nighttime habit?
I guess if we are voting you out this round we aren't getting much chance to really think who we ought to be getting rid of someone who of course wants to win this game. If you are willing to stay and check in that's better than not letting us know. You will get credit for winning this game if you are human and we humans win. Meanwhile someone is going to eat one of us in 24 hours and it might be me getting eaten - I actually like to play the game and think two days is a great time.
Cin I do have all but one hour of the screens I was gone picking up lunch during that time. I've been pulling out only who is playing so it is not so overwhelming. However, anyone could delete or add someone to the list and I'm not sure I'd like being accused of that. I saw that happen in a previous game. (Also they are on the computer at my daughter's house - I return there Monday.) I do think the delay on rounds is random - otherwise it wouldn't make sense having a delay.
Mom, not being active is very harmful for us humans - Wolves leave inactives around and then there is no one to vote off the wolves toward the end of the game. Inactives do that - help wolves win - Maybe Myth might be a later vote - I'm not really sure. In our last game Cyndy wasn't too active - in fact the win round was prolonged because she didn't vote - nor was she that active during the game. I'm leaning toward her but feel like saying so makes me look bad. I think the screen was a good indication of at least one wolf.
I'm not in a hurry to vote and I have some more RL to deal with so I'll be back. Keep posting your thoughts.
Hope you continue to have a great time Witty.
Celebrate the moment!
Well I'm a human but you might as well vote for me because I didn't realize the day was 48 hours and I don't like waiting that long.
Spoken like a human - but maybe hidding a bad nighttime habit?
I guess if we are voting you out this round we aren't getting much chance to really think who we ought to be getting rid of someone who of course wants to win this game. If you are willing to stay and check in that's better than not letting us know. You will get credit for winning this game if you are human and we humans win. Meanwhile someone is going to eat one of us in 24 hours and it might be me getting eaten - I actually like to play the game and think two days is a great time.
Cin I do have all but one hour of the screens I was gone picking up lunch during that time. I've been pulling out only who is playing so it is not so overwhelming. However, anyone could delete or add someone to the list and I'm not sure I'd like being accused of that. I saw that happen in a previous game. (Also they are on the computer at my daughter's house - I return there Monday.) I do think the delay on rounds is random - otherwise it wouldn't make sense having a delay.
Mom, not being active is very harmful for us humans - Wolves leave inactives around and then there is no one to vote off the wolves toward the end of the game. Inactives do that - help wolves win - Maybe Myth might be a later vote - I'm not really sure. In our last game Cyndy wasn't too active - in fact the win round was prolonged because she didn't vote - nor was she that active during the game. I'm leaning toward her but feel like saying so makes me look bad. I think the screen was a good indication of at least one wolf.
I'm not in a hurry to vote and I have some more RL to deal with so I'll be back. Keep posting your thoughts.
Hope you continue to have a great time Witty.
Celebrate the moment!
Oh my...I wish my life weren't so busy right now...I am missing all this wonderous discussion!
First off...in defense of myself: Well, I have no defense =P I can't really say anything to prove I'm a human, and not a wolf other than try to be as active as possible. I understand that one must be suspicious of everybody. But I CAN say beyond a shadow of a doubt that I am NOT a wolf. And I don't lie ;)
After reading everything, I am finding myself leaning towards Cinnamon's logic. I too, have been a victim of bad timing in previous games so am very hesitant to vote someone off just because they were on close to the time of the round ending.
However, it does seem that Cyndy has not and is not being very active, so I may possibly vote for her just for inactiveness :p
I'm not in a hurry to vote either, so I will continue to see how things play out.
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
First off...in defense of myself: Well, I have no defense =P I can't really say anything to prove I'm a human, and not a wolf other than try to be as active as possible. I understand that one must be suspicious of everybody. But I CAN say beyond a shadow of a doubt that I am NOT a wolf. And I don't lie ;)
After reading everything, I am finding myself leaning towards Cinnamon's logic. I too, have been a victim of bad timing in previous games so am very hesitant to vote someone off just because they were on close to the time of the round ending.
However, it does seem that Cyndy has not and is not being very active, so I may possibly vote for her just for inactiveness :p
I'm not in a hurry to vote either, so I will continue to see how things play out.
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
I understand the restraint of you guys about voting for mythmaster. Rascal said it best:
And now my suspicions turn to girl63160. In round one she said
And I'd like to apologize for any past and future accusations...we're all just trying to protect ourselves
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
it gives the wolves a potential free pass if myth isn't a wolf.
However, isn't inactivity and nonchalantness (is that a word?) the reason we shot minlo?And now my suspicions turn to girl63160. In round one she said
I think we should go with a majority vote this round though. So, does anyone know who was the first to vote? I saw it, but forgot to remember the name... If someone remembers that, I think I will vote for that person just because of voting first. Of course, I will look more and see if there's anyone else who seems suspicious.
And this round: I'm just going to go for mythmaster, he does sound suspicious to me....
Does this sound like rascal's wolf strategy to anyone? However, I don't think I'll vote for you just yet.And I'd like to apologize for any past and future accusations...we're all just trying to protect ourselves
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
I really cant say right now it seems like there is alot of possible canidates for bieng a wolf . Im not sure if myth is tryin to play us or really is a human and just wants out if thats so i really hate to vote him out this early just because ive played with him before and he is a very strong player. So for now i will wait back and c if we can gather any other ideas
Dach, I think in round 1, its almost always a "fish" vote no matter how you look at it. Round 2 is usually not much better, unless some humans are cleared, in which case you can reread possible wolves posts and start to dissect them.
You are right about why minlo was voted out of round 1. As I said before, I feel myth is telling the truth about being human, but I would prefer he remain for now. We can easily reach a majority without 1 human being completely active for a few rounds. If the wolves want to choose to eat him and end his "suffering" then so be it. But, myth hasn't come back to really say he wants out after his post. He just said he doesn't like 48 hour days. I still don't want to vote for him yet.
I agree completely with your reasoning about girl. I, myself, have wondered about her posts. I am leaning towards her right now. In fact, I am going to vote for her now.
Rascal, you don't seem to be saying a lot this game. Is that because you haven't been accused yet? Mocha gets eaten and we all seem to lose our tongues, or least our ability to create suspicions around anyone, including ourselves.
As always, my vote is always open for change, if I see enough reason to change it.
I'll check back in a few hours to see what has happened.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
You are right about why minlo was voted out of round 1. As I said before, I feel myth is telling the truth about being human, but I would prefer he remain for now. We can easily reach a majority without 1 human being completely active for a few rounds. If the wolves want to choose to eat him and end his "suffering" then so be it. But, myth hasn't come back to really say he wants out after his post. He just said he doesn't like 48 hour days. I still don't want to vote for him yet.
I agree completely with your reasoning about girl. I, myself, have wondered about her posts. I am leaning towards her right now. In fact, I am going to vote for her now.
Rascal, you don't seem to be saying a lot this game. Is that because you haven't been accused yet? Mocha gets eaten and we all seem to lose our tongues, or least our ability to create suspicions around anyone, including ourselves.
As always, my vote is always open for change, if I see enough reason to change it.
I'll check back in a few hours to see what has happened.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I guess that's what I'm trying to do...take the lead, accuse people, and create suspicions and leads to go on.
After last game, cinn, I have a lot of respect for your opinion. So if you find my argument convincing, I will follow your logic and not vote for myth. I'm changing to girl. And irish, I hope you're right about myth being a strong player, because that's a pretty wolfish statement if myth is a wolf (maybe we'll need to know this in the future...kitty)
I just remembered something: Rascal asked earlier "What are the chances of me being a wolf 2 games in a row?" The answer is 3/15, or 1/5. It will always be 1/5. It's that funny thing about probability: it has no bias. Like flipping a coin: if you get 99 heads in a row, there's still a 50/50 chance of heads or tails on the next toss.
EDIT: I just (re)voted, and noticed something. Mythmaster voted for huffle, who's not been remotely as talkative as she usually is...suspicion?
Tomorrow is my Braingle-versary!
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 17:57:02---
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
After last game, cinn, I have a lot of respect for your opinion. So if you find my argument convincing, I will follow your logic and not vote for myth. I'm changing to girl. And irish, I hope you're right about myth being a strong player, because that's a pretty wolfish statement if myth is a wolf (maybe we'll need to know this in the future...kitty)
I just remembered something: Rascal asked earlier "What are the chances of me being a wolf 2 games in a row?" The answer is 3/15, or 1/5. It will always be 1/5. It's that funny thing about probability: it has no bias. Like flipping a coin: if you get 99 heads in a row, there's still a 50/50 chance of heads or tails on the next toss.
EDIT: I just (re)voted, and noticed something. Mythmaster voted for huffle, who's not been remotely as talkative as she usually is...suspicion?
Tomorrow is my Braingle-versary!
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 17:57:02---
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
I am having a good time, Zona, thanks for the wishes! I will, however, be heading back home tonight and will get back into the regular routine of things. I think that you are right about people losing their tongues once the most active and talkative player is out. Makes it a lot harder to think when you don't have as many people thinking. (If that makes sense ) Continue to talk things over. I'll probably check back in on the game in 5 hours or so.
Livin' that mom-life...
Livin' that mom-life...
Yes, Dach, Myth didn't exactly help his cause by voting Huffle again without stating a reason. If Myth were a wolf, I would expect a couple dissenting opinions from other players (other wolves?) since they want to protect their kind. Cinamon30 stated she "felt" Myth was a human. From what? Surely not his behavior this game. As an experinced player, his non-interest in us voting for him could easily be a bluff. Cinamon30 could be trying to move us into voting for a human. It is possible at this point.
I think we should stay the course with Myth and maybe use him later as our special request from Witty, some of the posts already made might be useful suspicion if we really knew at some point whether he was wolf or human.
I think wolves will go with the flow when the humans are taking out another human and will try to distract humans if the humans are on to something and be generally reluctant to vote along with a majority.
Myth was in the wrong place at the right time and has a couple "random" votes at Huffle to his credit. He seems the most suspicious of all to all, but those trying to keep him in the game because of "feelings". I wouldn't ask other players to follow my feelings. Why should they?
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
I think we should stay the course with Myth and maybe use him later as our special request from Witty, some of the posts already made might be useful suspicion if we really knew at some point whether he was wolf or human.
I think wolves will go with the flow when the humans are taking out another human and will try to distract humans if the humans are on to something and be generally reluctant to vote along with a majority.
Myth was in the wrong place at the right time and has a couple "random" votes at Huffle to his credit. He seems the most suspicious of all to all, but those trying to keep him in the game because of "feelings". I wouldn't ask other players to follow my feelings. Why should they?
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Well said hobo. With all your logic and reasoning, I have to wonder if you are a wolf in human clothing.
As for how each player votes, its entirely up to them. I am certainly not the only one who expressed concern in voting out myth at this point. Its not an easy decision to make, but I have said why I made mine. There is no proof for anyone who is who, until a round ends and we see who got eaten. And don't let us forget our seer. Whether they divined myth or not, who knows. I do believe someone said last round that myth would have been a good choice because he voted so early. Maybe someone who has chosen to agree with my opinions are trying to tell us something. As irish said, myth is a strong player, as I have encountered him in past games as well.
Whether others choose to follow is up to them. I merely stated my opinion as others have as well. We can certainly reach a majority without myth at this point.
Anywho, I'll check back later and see what else is happening.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
As for how each player votes, its entirely up to them. I am certainly not the only one who expressed concern in voting out myth at this point. Its not an easy decision to make, but I have said why I made mine. There is no proof for anyone who is who, until a round ends and we see who got eaten. And don't let us forget our seer. Whether they divined myth or not, who knows. I do believe someone said last round that myth would have been a good choice because he voted so early. Maybe someone who has chosen to agree with my opinions are trying to tell us something. As irish said, myth is a strong player, as I have encountered him in past games as well.
Whether others choose to follow is up to them. I merely stated my opinion as others have as well. We can certainly reach a majority without myth at this point.
Anywho, I'll check back later and see what else is happening.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Being my second game, I am now realizing how valuable/condemning the list of confirmed humans was during my first game. This is still very much like a fish vote. I have a desire to vote for cyndy for laying so low in the discussion, but that is a possible bias from last game as well. I can see me voting for myth just because he could be a wolf and will not be hunting for wolves as strongly as the rest of us. I can see me voting for girl because she is also a potential wolf and we a few of us are finding suspicion in her actions...this is tough when no one has been cleared.
Rascalian, where is your head. I hope its not hiding in some hairy head. We have had one human cleared so far: GCcrazy. Zonarita cleared her. If we can get a majority before the day ends by Braingle time, we may be able to clear 2 more: Huffle & cyndy who both haven't been on since yesterday. Of course that means night would have to end before they log on as well.
I have been reading over both rounds so far. We have a few talkers amongst us: myself, Mom2Ozzy, Zonarita & Zonahobo. Rascalian isn't far behind. We have not heard much from Christina, cyndy, GCcrazy, girl, Huffle or irish at all. Dach is starting to come around this round as well. Mocha was also a talker, but sadly she is gone, but if you listen you may hear a little whisper from far far away.
I think we need to all get involved and not be afraid to step up and make posts, whether they are suspicious or not. Don't think because you don't post much you go unnoticed. Its actually the opposite, which is not a good thing. I would encourage everyone to participate as much as possible. The more discussion and suspicion we create, the better the game goes. Remember, its supposed to be fun and challenging. Well fun anyways. Not everyone loves a good challenge, but I sure do. Its not all about the winning...............................oops, did I just say that out loud. Of course its all about winning!
So, do we want to go down that road and start suspecting those less talkative a little more? I am unsure at this point. Any thoughts or suggestions? Hmmmm, something I will now go and ponder.
Edited for color. Edited again to add the blue text.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 20:36:53---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I have been reading over both rounds so far. We have a few talkers amongst us: myself, Mom2Ozzy, Zonarita & Zonahobo. Rascalian isn't far behind. We have not heard much from Christina, cyndy, GCcrazy, girl, Huffle or irish at all. Dach is starting to come around this round as well. Mocha was also a talker, but sadly she is gone, but if you listen you may hear a little whisper from far far away.
I think we need to all get involved and not be afraid to step up and make posts, whether they are suspicious or not. Don't think because you don't post much you go unnoticed. Its actually the opposite, which is not a good thing. I would encourage everyone to participate as much as possible. The more discussion and suspicion we create, the better the game goes. Remember, its supposed to be fun and challenging. Well fun anyways. Not everyone loves a good challenge, but I sure do. Its not all about the winning...............................oops, did I just say that out loud. Of course its all about winning!
So, do we want to go down that road and start suspecting those less talkative a little more? I am unsure at this point. Any thoughts or suggestions? Hmmmm, something I will now go and ponder.
Edited for color. Edited again to add the blue text.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 20:36:53---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Mom, by the way, I forgot to tell you I still haven't found my magical force shield. After the night round I still didn't find much to help me. However, I tried looking to the stars for help, and thought I saw a little glimmer of hope, but yet again.......... nothing. Maybe this round will uncover something of great use to me. I'll keep a close eye out. I still have my twig, and I know what you're thinking.................no its not mochas nose. I have managed to stay clear of poking my eyes, but I have come close a few times. I just had an idea, maybe I'll use it to poke some of our less talkative players. Lets see if that causes something to happen.
*Goes ahead to poke Christina, cyndy, GCcrazy, girl, Huffle & Irish. Dach, if you don't speed up soon, you're next to be poked.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
*Goes ahead to poke Christina, cyndy, GCcrazy, girl, Huffle & Irish. Dach, if you don't speed up soon, you're next to be poked.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
*is poked* lol
In all honesty, this is only the second time I have really been on my computer and had time to check the game today =P
I must say, that Myth seems to be acting suspicious and he voted for Huffle "for the heck of it" which, imo, is quite suspicious. Now, since he seems to posses a distinct lack of interest in the game and seemingly *wants* to get voted out...he would most likely be acting suspicious on purpose, and is probably human. Or, he could be feigning disinterest with the very hopes that our logic will lean that way,and we won't vote him off when in reality he is actually a wolf I rather agree with hobo's logic on this...whether that puts me under suspicion or no, it is the truth.
However, I am also rather agreeing that girl's posts are suspicious and her behaviour strange o_O. So...I am STILL going to hold my vote off due to too many choices!
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
In all honesty, this is only the second time I have really been on my computer and had time to check the game today =P
I must say, that Myth seems to be acting suspicious and he voted for Huffle "for the heck of it" which, imo, is quite suspicious. Now, since he seems to posses a distinct lack of interest in the game and seemingly *wants* to get voted out...he would most likely be acting suspicious on purpose, and is probably human. Or, he could be feigning disinterest with the very hopes that our logic will lean that way,and we won't vote him off when in reality he is actually a wolf I rather agree with hobo's logic on this...whether that puts me under suspicion or no, it is the truth.
However, I am also rather agreeing that girl's posts are suspicious and her behaviour strange o_O. So...I am STILL going to hold my vote off due to too many choices!
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
Wow everything seems to happen when I'm not here!
It seems to me accusations are what makes this game tick so so at the risk of being bitten here goes.....
We've got 2 strong camps going on right now:
Those wanting to vote for myth [mainly for his disinterest] and those wanting to vote for girl [she doesn't seem too active either]
It seems both sides feel strongly about who they chose and why, strong enough to have actually cast a vote.
Hobo does not want to keep myth around b/c he may later be a useful inactive tool for the wolves.
Cinn and Dach {and this pains me to say } seem to be actually protecting myth by throwing girl out there in front of the firing squad, which makes them look sorta wolfish themselves. Both of them have made allusions to others behaving wolfish... Cinn said something to Rascalian and Hobo. Dachs mentioned quiet huffle. Now I don't know if they are just trying to spur some speculation or if it's just friendly banter, but it has set my mind to wondering about them.
Also lets not forget about cyndy folks, She's got two strikes as far as I'm concerned:
All we have seen of her was a quick hello early in the game and a log in that puts her very close to the end of the first round
Edited to add: I truly believe Cyndy is a wolf and that is how I am going to vote for this round. She is the only one I would feel no regrets about voting for.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 22:18:38---
It seems to me accusations are what makes this game tick so so at the risk of being bitten here goes.....
We've got 2 strong camps going on right now:
Those wanting to vote for myth [mainly for his disinterest] and those wanting to vote for girl [she doesn't seem too active either]
It seems both sides feel strongly about who they chose and why, strong enough to have actually cast a vote.
Hobo does not want to keep myth around b/c he may later be a useful inactive tool for the wolves.
Cinn and Dach {and this pains me to say } seem to be actually protecting myth by throwing girl out there in front of the firing squad, which makes them look sorta wolfish themselves. Both of them have made allusions to others behaving wolfish... Cinn said something to Rascalian and Hobo. Dachs mentioned quiet huffle. Now I don't know if they are just trying to spur some speculation or if it's just friendly banter, but it has set my mind to wondering about them.
Also lets not forget about cyndy folks, She's got two strikes as far as I'm concerned:
All we have seen of her was a quick hello early in the game and a log in that puts her very close to the end of the first round
Edited to add: I truly believe Cyndy is a wolf and that is how I am going to vote for this round. She is the only one I would feel no regrets about voting for.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-26 22:18:38---
Mom, I am merely stating my observations and not cohorting with fellow wolves. Now they may be wolves, but I have no way of knowing that at this point for sure. Just suspicions, but very very small ones for now.
I am not really trying to protect myth, as much as I am trying to not vote out a fellow human. Albeit, one that doesn't seem to want to play, but has said nothing further to that idea. I think that I am not the only one "protecting" myth and maybe I am reading more into others agreeing with me than I should.
Anywho, I am off to bed, so I'll see whats happening in the morning. Good night all.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I am not really trying to protect myth, as much as I am trying to not vote out a fellow human. Albeit, one that doesn't seem to want to play, but has said nothing further to that idea. I think that I am not the only one "protecting" myth and maybe I am reading more into others agreeing with me than I should.
Anywho, I am off to bed, so I'll see whats happening in the morning. Good night all.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Ok my vote has been cast... now we have 3 camps....
mom i agree with u i believe cindy is a strong candidate to b a wolf she has all the signs. I will say i do belive myht is not a wolf just wants to b killed so for now id rather vote for someone i really feel is a wolf so ill vote cindy.
Have you heard the saying: "Many hands make light work"? Well, this would be "Many posts make thoughtful brains"
Livin' that mom-life...
Livin' that mom-life...
Votes at this time -
cinnamon30 voted for girl63160
dachshund2k3 voted for girl63160
irishsofty voted for cyndy296
Mom2Ozzy voted for cyndy296
zonahobo voted for mythmaster
girl63160 voted for mythmaster
mythmaster voted for Hufflepuffle
I've read the posts and need to reread again for innuendo.
First my vote this round is in honor of Mocha - As a leader last game (not to run that in the ground - when someone came in and explained there lack of time on site - she was the first to wish them well and understand their situation - howbeit I don't think that effected her thinking.) I'm not thinking girl's on line time makes her suspicious - however I read the paranoia going on and honestly don't want to defend anyone either - especially since I don't really know for sure and have my own RL issues.
I had hoped for a post of some sort from Cyndy - but there has been nothing - with 16 hours maybe there'll be something in the morning. My vote, I'm leaning toward Cyndy - it is the one, removing previous game behavior, I'd have voted for this hand.
Mocha stated
Celebrate the moment!
cinnamon30 voted for girl63160
dachshund2k3 voted for girl63160
irishsofty voted for cyndy296
Mom2Ozzy voted for cyndy296
zonahobo voted for mythmaster
girl63160 voted for mythmaster
mythmaster voted for Hufflepuffle
I've read the posts and need to reread again for innuendo.
First my vote this round is in honor of Mocha - As a leader last game (not to run that in the ground - when someone came in and explained there lack of time on site - she was the first to wish them well and understand their situation - howbeit I don't think that effected her thinking.) I'm not thinking girl's on line time makes her suspicious - however I read the paranoia going on and honestly don't want to defend anyone either - especially since I don't really know for sure and have my own RL issues.
I had hoped for a post of some sort from Cyndy - but there has been nothing - with 16 hours maybe there'll be something in the morning. My vote, I'm leaning toward Cyndy - it is the one, removing previous game behavior, I'd have voted for this hand.
Mocha stated
Hey! Give me my nose back!!! *grabs nose from Cin* That was mine first! *nose grows longer*Rita, I enjoy playing with you more and more with each post you make! I love the quote by the way, so very true (I think I've heard it before, somewhere...) At first I was very curious why you were thinking cIn, but then I read that you actually wrote cYn, and it made more sense. I will have to keep the two straight in my mind.
Celebrate the moment!
Well, I said my vote for Myth is not in concrete, and it isn't. I agree Cindy was another in the wrong place at the right time and maybe should be voted out first.
I still think Myth was suspicious and "humans" attempting to defend him more suspicious. If he's good at this game, show me the money!
He should at least explain his "heck of it" votes. He might be a good one for our seer to check out. It might be a wolf ploy to act like he is not interested in the human's day time and can pick off humans at night. It also does not seem suspicious when he doesn't get eaten at night because.. Gee, why would the wolves eat a disinterested player.
It's funny how after one night it seems like we have seven wolves and three humans!
So, changing my vote to Cindy.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
I still think Myth was suspicious and "humans" attempting to defend him more suspicious. If he's good at this game, show me the money!
He should at least explain his "heck of it" votes. He might be a good one for our seer to check out. It might be a wolf ploy to act like he is not interested in the human's day time and can pick off humans at night. It also does not seem suspicious when he doesn't get eaten at night because.. Gee, why would the wolves eat a disinterested player.
It's funny how after one night it seems like we have seven wolves and three humans!
So, changing my vote to Cindy.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
GM All !
Looks like there was some thoughtful pondering going on during the night.
I'm going to go grab so coffee before I sit down to read the posts
Looks like there was some thoughtful pondering going on during the night.
I'm going to go grab so coffee before I sit down to read the posts
Bo, I love reading your posts. I do hope you are a human and not a very clever wolf. BTW, who are the 3 "likely" humans you mentioned. Assuming one of them is you. I have to admit, I am a little puzzled as to why you chnaged your vote to cyndy. From your last post you seem more suspicious of myth and myself than cyndy. Its not adding up to me at the moment.
Its interesting to see how many thought myth may be a wolf using the "I want out ploy" as a possible wolf tactic. But now it seems some don't fully agree on that and are voting for a different player. I like that everyone doesn't come to a quick majority and cast other suspicions around as well. Just curious though, zonarita, why pick on cyndy and not huffle for not posting so far this round. I wonder if both of them are trying to stay away from braingle to try and get themselves proven as human. Cyndy made 2 posts in Round 1 and Huffle made 3 posts. It can't be you chose cyndy over Huffle because myth was voting huffle again without a really good reason behind it. If that was the case, then you would probably believe myth is a wolf trying to lead a human vote, so why not get rid of myth instead. I am just thinking out loud here, to see if anything makes any sense at the moment. Neither of their posts have been useful at all.
With that said, I do agree with wanting to vote out cyndy, as she is one of the less talkative players I mentioned previously. But using your line of reasoning zonarita, girl & huffle fall into the same category. Both haven't posteed much. I will keep my vote as is. The last time I kept changing my vote, it seemed I was more suspicious, and as it turned out I was human.
If you are using the theory both Christina & cyndy are most suspicious because of the logon screen you captured, then I would hope they are on the previous 2 hours of screen captures you have, minus the break you took. I know you said those captures are on your daughters computer, so either you have an awesome memory or you are reluctant to post everything you saw. But on the other hand as someone said, I believe it was zonarita, once you post the screen shots they can be edited to add or delete people. So I understand not wanting to give that info.
One belief I do have about this whole game is that I would rather keep suspicious talking players around, human or wolf, than those who don't contribute much at all, even if they are human. It makes for a more interesting and harder game to play. I love a good challenge than a way too easy fight. And yes that means I am talking about myth as well. Since Christina, cyndy, myth, girl, huffle and irish have all posted but not very much, they are the ones who seem the most likely to not keep around. I don't see any one of them jumping to the top of the list, so it doesn't matter which one to vote for first. None of them are proven human or wolf.
Anywho, after all the rambling, my vote will remain the same. There are too many people who seem very suspicious as wolves for right now. I don't know who seems more suspicious than others. Again, those I see as suspicious are all about equal on the suspicious meter. I do see a few players wanting to follow, but haven't decided which way to lean for them. I will keep a closer eye on those players next round, if I survive the night.
I am loving the fact that players are thinking for themselves and not necessarily following the "leader".
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Its interesting to see how many thought myth may be a wolf using the "I want out ploy" as a possible wolf tactic. But now it seems some don't fully agree on that and are voting for a different player. I like that everyone doesn't come to a quick majority and cast other suspicions around as well. Just curious though, zonarita, why pick on cyndy and not huffle for not posting so far this round. I wonder if both of them are trying to stay away from braingle to try and get themselves proven as human. Cyndy made 2 posts in Round 1 and Huffle made 3 posts. It can't be you chose cyndy over Huffle because myth was voting huffle again without a really good reason behind it. If that was the case, then you would probably believe myth is a wolf trying to lead a human vote, so why not get rid of myth instead. I am just thinking out loud here, to see if anything makes any sense at the moment. Neither of their posts have been useful at all.
With that said, I do agree with wanting to vote out cyndy, as she is one of the less talkative players I mentioned previously. But using your line of reasoning zonarita, girl & huffle fall into the same category. Both haven't posteed much. I will keep my vote as is. The last time I kept changing my vote, it seemed I was more suspicious, and as it turned out I was human.
If you are using the theory both Christina & cyndy are most suspicious because of the logon screen you captured, then I would hope they are on the previous 2 hours of screen captures you have, minus the break you took. I know you said those captures are on your daughters computer, so either you have an awesome memory or you are reluctant to post everything you saw. But on the other hand as someone said, I believe it was zonarita, once you post the screen shots they can be edited to add or delete people. So I understand not wanting to give that info.
One belief I do have about this whole game is that I would rather keep suspicious talking players around, human or wolf, than those who don't contribute much at all, even if they are human. It makes for a more interesting and harder game to play. I love a good challenge than a way too easy fight. And yes that means I am talking about myth as well. Since Christina, cyndy, myth, girl, huffle and irish have all posted but not very much, they are the ones who seem the most likely to not keep around. I don't see any one of them jumping to the top of the list, so it doesn't matter which one to vote for first. None of them are proven human or wolf.
Anywho, after all the rambling, my vote will remain the same. There are too many people who seem very suspicious as wolves for right now. I don't know who seems more suspicious than others. Again, those I see as suspicious are all about equal on the suspicious meter. I do see a few players wanting to follow, but haven't decided which way to lean for them. I will keep a closer eye on those players next round, if I survive the night.
I am loving the fact that players are thinking for themselves and not necessarily following the "leader".
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I see that girl has since logged on in the last few hours and changed her vote from myth to cyndy as well. No post or explanation one way or the other as to why she changed her vote. Interesting................. Not even a post to try to defend herself against myself & myth voting for her.
Edited to add comment after Interesting............
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 09:08:32---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Edited to add comment after Interesting............
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 09:08:32---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Ok .. got some coffee in me now
Grrr... everytime I sit down to write something.... "Mom, I want breakfast" "Mom, turn on the Wii" "Mom, fight this bad guy for me!"
Sorry had to vent
Anyway,
Cinn wrote
(I added the bold)
My reasoning is kind of a combo of inactive list and logon list
Out of those six Christina, myth, girl and irish have at least posted something this round. Cyndy and huffle are absolute no shows, but huffle wasn't on the logon list .Cyndy was, and that's why she's at the top of mine
Grrr... everytime I sit down to write something.... "Mom, I want breakfast" "Mom, turn on the Wii" "Mom, fight this bad guy for me!"
Sorry had to vent
Anyway,
Cinn wrote
One belief I do have about this whole game is that I would rather keep suspicious talking players around, human or wolf, than those who don't contribute much at all, even if they are human. It makes for a more interesting and harder game to play. I love a good challenge than a way too easy fight. And yes that means I am talking about myth as well. Since Christina, cyndy, myth, girl, huffle and irish have all posted but not very much, they are the ones who seem the most likely to not keep around. I don't see any one of them jumping to the top of the list, so it doesn't matter which one to vote for first. None of them are proven human or wolf.
(I added the bold)
My reasoning is kind of a combo of inactive list and logon list
Out of those six Christina, myth, girl and irish have at least posted something this round. Cyndy and huffle are absolute no shows, but huffle wasn't on the logon list .Cyndy was, and that's why she's at the top of mine
Yes Cinn an explanation of defense would have been nice but deducing her reasoning for changing her vote is not very hard
Oh boy...my brain is not working this morning >_<
Well...after more pondering, I am going to hold off voting for Myth (even though to me...he seems the most suspicious) and go for girl, following Cinnamon's reasoning. Girl seems even more suspicious now that she has logged on and changed her vote without so much as a word o_O
So while Myth has dropped off my radar for the moment, I am still keeping close watch on him.
Also...I am going to be gone most of the day today (shopping and all that fun stuff ) So I am getting my vote in now. If I come back with still more time left, and more evidence has been uncovered, I may change my vote...since girl is not concrete
Have a wonderful day everyone! see you in a few hours!
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
Well...after more pondering, I am going to hold off voting for Myth (even though to me...he seems the most suspicious) and go for girl, following Cinnamon's reasoning. Girl seems even more suspicious now that she has logged on and changed her vote without so much as a word o_O
So while Myth has dropped off my radar for the moment, I am still keeping close watch on him.
Also...I am going to be gone most of the day today (shopping and all that fun stuff ) So I am getting my vote in now. If I come back with still more time left, and more evidence has been uncovered, I may change my vote...since girl is not concrete
Have a wonderful day everyone! see you in a few hours!
When you realize you want to spend the rest of your life with somebody, you want the rest of your life to start as soon as possible. -Nora Ephron
I see where everyone is coming from and one of the only things that is bothering me is why would myth want out of the game if he was a wolf? I don't know if any of you have been a wolf in pass games or not(or even thought about it like this) but being a wolf you have the "Upper hand." The wolves could have some sort of strategy or they could just pick(eat) off the people they just don't like.
Imo, I don't see a reason for keeping someone who doesn't want to play in the game. Vote for them and let them get out, that's what happens in mostly all the games. But seeing that some think that myth is indeed human, I think we should wait until the next round comes and see who the wolves choose to eat. Then try and go on from there.
As for Cyndy, it is really bad timing or Cyndy is in fact a wolf and is getting their vote as human and wolf at the same time. For what reason is beyond me. Personlly if I was a wolf, I would most likely get on at different times. But not everyone thinks the way I do.
I don't really know who I want to vote for. Of course Cyndy was my first choice. Then myth said that he didn't want to play anymore, so I thought of him. But after reading and thinking, I don't really want to vote for him at the moment. I think that I'm going to stick with my first thought and go with Cyndy.
Time heals ALL wounds
Imo, I don't see a reason for keeping someone who doesn't want to play in the game. Vote for them and let them get out, that's what happens in mostly all the games. But seeing that some think that myth is indeed human, I think we should wait until the next round comes and see who the wolves choose to eat. Then try and go on from there.
As for Cyndy, it is really bad timing or Cyndy is in fact a wolf and is getting their vote as human and wolf at the same time. For what reason is beyond me. Personlly if I was a wolf, I would most likely get on at different times. But not everyone thinks the way I do.
I don't really know who I want to vote for. Of course Cyndy was my first choice. Then myth said that he didn't want to play anymore, so I thought of him. But after reading and thinking, I don't really want to vote for him at the moment. I think that I'm going to stick with my first thought and go with Cyndy.
Time heals ALL wounds
Mom, I figured as to why she changed her vote, but a post to say why she wated to would have been nice. Would it have changed my vote for her, probably not. But I would have at least like to have been given a reason to reconsider my vote, with some kind of post from her.
And yes cyndy was on the logon list but that is not enough to say she is a wolf. Now I have no idea one way or the other, but the others listed on that list were on as well. They could have very well have been on-line for the whole 2 -3 hours prior. Its just that when zonarita captured the list they had all obviously either updated or changed screens to show in the 5 or 15 mins. window. That's why I would prefer to see the logon list for the 2-3 hours prior as that is most useful. We know there is a delay after the last wolf votes. We don't know for how long as it is always random. However, I don't believe it would not be less than 30mins, as that would have been pointless since the whole reason for the delay was so people couldn't use the logon screens to catch a wolf.
All those shown on-line, regardless of which time slot it is, doesn't help us. Just because cyndy was online in the 30 mins prior may have been wrong place at the wrong time. But , she could also be a wolf that may have been caught. I don't know at this point.
I tried a test one day to see what would happen. I logon Monday - Friday when I get to work. I stay logged on all day until I leave. I do a lot of work on the computer at times so I can usually keep an eye on the game. So I refresh my screen every so often. I wondered if I kept the same screen up, without refreshing, would it still show me as on-line. So here's what I did, after an hour or so, I opened another internet page and went to braingle, without logging myself in again, and checked the logon screen. It did not show me in the list even though I was still logged on. Therefore, if you are going to use logon screens, you need to see the last 2-3 hours of a night round, capturing the screens every 30 mins.
So because zonarita only gave us the last 30 mins prior, I don't think its enough for me to change my vote to cyndy this round. But from the looks of it, she will probably be shot this round anyway.
I hope that all makes sense.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
And yes cyndy was on the logon list but that is not enough to say she is a wolf. Now I have no idea one way or the other, but the others listed on that list were on as well. They could have very well have been on-line for the whole 2 -3 hours prior. Its just that when zonarita captured the list they had all obviously either updated or changed screens to show in the 5 or 15 mins. window. That's why I would prefer to see the logon list for the 2-3 hours prior as that is most useful. We know there is a delay after the last wolf votes. We don't know for how long as it is always random. However, I don't believe it would not be less than 30mins, as that would have been pointless since the whole reason for the delay was so people couldn't use the logon screens to catch a wolf.
All those shown on-line, regardless of which time slot it is, doesn't help us. Just because cyndy was online in the 30 mins prior may have been wrong place at the wrong time. But , she could also be a wolf that may have been caught. I don't know at this point.
I tried a test one day to see what would happen. I logon Monday - Friday when I get to work. I stay logged on all day until I leave. I do a lot of work on the computer at times so I can usually keep an eye on the game. So I refresh my screen every so often. I wondered if I kept the same screen up, without refreshing, would it still show me as on-line. So here's what I did, after an hour or so, I opened another internet page and went to braingle, without logging myself in again, and checked the logon screen. It did not show me in the list even though I was still logged on. Therefore, if you are going to use logon screens, you need to see the last 2-3 hours of a night round, capturing the screens every 30 mins.
So because zonarita only gave us the last 30 mins prior, I don't think its enough for me to change my vote to cyndy this round. But from the looks of it, she will probably be shot this round anyway.
I hope that all makes sense.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
With 5 hrs 42 mins to go:
Christina_S voted for girl63160
cinnamon30 voted for girl63160
dachshund2k3 voted for girl63160
Rascalian voted for girl 63160
GCcrazygurl09 voted for cyndy296
girl63160 voted for cyndy296
irishsofty voted for cyndy296
Mom2Ozzy voted for cyndy296
zonahobo voted for cyndy296
zonarita voted for cyndy296
mythmaster voted for Hufflepuffle
I'm doing my posts as edits because this round could end at any moment.
As of right now, cyndy only needs 1 more vote for a majority. However, I will not cast that vote "just to speed the game up" because I am more suspicious of girl. Earlier this round, we pretty much decided not to vote myth out just because he was pretty inactive, however that's what we're doing to cyndy right now. I'm not trying to defend cyndy, but if I could get people to vote for mythmaster again, I would.
I realized these first rounds are mostly fishing and inactives, but who among us has moved the majority from myth, to girl, and now to cyndy?
Zonarita started the accusations against cyndy; zonahobo, mom, and GC all then followed suit with their posts. Irish and girl followed the leader but did not post.
To me, that makes Zonarita, Irish, and girl the most suspicious.
And sorry I can't get on as much. My mom doesn't think this is very productive activity. I now seem to be the middle ground in posting: cinn said
And yes, cinn that was us who accused girl, who hasn't defended herself at all this round
Oh, and neither cyndy nor huffle have voted yet.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:06:32---
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
Christina_S voted for girl63160
cinnamon30 voted for girl63160
dachshund2k3 voted for girl63160
Rascalian voted for girl 63160
GCcrazygurl09 voted for cyndy296
girl63160 voted for cyndy296
irishsofty voted for cyndy296
Mom2Ozzy voted for cyndy296
zonahobo voted for cyndy296
zonarita voted for cyndy296
mythmaster voted for Hufflepuffle
I'm doing my posts as edits because this round could end at any moment.
As of right now, cyndy only needs 1 more vote for a majority. However, I will not cast that vote "just to speed the game up" because I am more suspicious of girl. Earlier this round, we pretty much decided not to vote myth out just because he was pretty inactive, however that's what we're doing to cyndy right now. I'm not trying to defend cyndy, but if I could get people to vote for mythmaster again, I would.
I realized these first rounds are mostly fishing and inactives, but who among us has moved the majority from myth, to girl, and now to cyndy?
Zonarita started the accusations against cyndy; zonahobo, mom, and GC all then followed suit with their posts. Irish and girl followed the leader but did not post.
To me, that makes Zonarita, Irish, and girl the most suspicious.
And sorry I can't get on as much. My mom doesn't think this is very productive activity. I now seem to be the middle ground in posting: cinn said
We have a few talkers amongst us: myself, Mom2Ozzy, Zonarita & Zonahobo. Rascalian isn't far behind. We have not heard much from Christina, cyndy, GCcrazy, girl, Huffle or irish at all. Dach is starting to come around this round as well. Mocha was also a talker, but sadly she is gone, but if you listen you may hear a little whisper from far far away.
And I hope I don't get poked with that stick And yes, cinn that was us who accused girl, who hasn't defended herself at all this round
Oh, and neither cyndy nor huffle have voted yet.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:06:32---
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
I totally agree with you dach about not voting for cyndy to speed the game up. I am keeping my vote as well because I think she is more suspicious. I still think myth is human, but I will consider voting for him at some point, because he wants out of the game.
Edited to add color again.
Edited again to add blue text.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:03:32---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Edited to add color again.
Edited again to add blue text.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:03:32---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I believe Mom was the first to vote cyndy, then irish, then rita then Bo. However, Mom was not the first to start the whole thinking of cyndy is suspicious. In my opinion, I think that was rita. But that doesn't mean I believe she is a wolf either.
As for girl, I believe that was you and I dach who started that vote.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
As for girl, I believe that was you and I dach who started that vote.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
It would seem at this point we have 2 very distinct groups. I believe there is at least 1 wolf in each group. So the question becomes, can all the humans from these 2 groups pull together and figure out the wolves so we can win this game? I hope we can.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:07:17---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:07:17---
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Maybe you're right cinn that mom was the first to vote cyndy, but rita started the post accusing her, giving reason behind the vote. Mom's post at cyndy is after rita's. Irish and girl followed suit, but with no explanation, and that is why they are suspicious to me.
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
The voting this round
mythmaster voted for Hufflepuffle
Christina_S voted for girl63160
cinnamon30 voted for girl63160
dachshund2k3 voted for girl63160
Rascalian voted for girl63160
girl63160 voted for cyndy296
irishsofty voted for cyndy296
Mom2Ozzy voted for cyndy296
zonahobo voted for cyndy296
zonarita voted for cyndy296
We've broken into two camps - If by changing my vote I could tie the vote - I'd let the computer decide. There are 5 more hours.
Christina wrote -
In this game - if you are a wolf - you must lie - so your comment makes no defense. People who would never lie just don't play this game. smile - sorry, just calling it as I see it.
Cin wrote
First Between Christina and Cyndy - I choose Cyndy - maybe it was cause she voted for me. 2nd her two? post were right next to each other and could of been an edit. Third Both huffle and Cyndy came in toward the end of the round last game. Four - I don't have an awesome memory and I'm not reluctant - I'm not sure what you are suggesting here?(The computer is mine, it is at my daughter's house - I go there for a week at a time to watch her kids - Sometimes I am too lazy to carry everything back to my house. I've even washed my clothes at her house so as not to have to carry them home to wash them and carry something else back over to her house.) Do hope this clears up your questions about my thinking.
Maybe some of us (I'm including myself) are strong pushing and others don't want to get it in - RL has a way of doing that. It took awhile for me to play this game - My first shot no matter what I said I was it. I was too. Then the second time I was shot again - it makes one feel uncared about - like the popularity thing back in high school. Anyway, there are times when this game is really fun - in the beginning it can be a game that is not to much fun - Maybe Myth was the right vote afterall. Just thinking on screen.
Mom wrote
Celebrate the moment!
mythmaster voted for Hufflepuffle
Christina_S voted for girl63160
cinnamon30 voted for girl63160
dachshund2k3 voted for girl63160
Rascalian voted for girl63160
girl63160 voted for cyndy296
irishsofty voted for cyndy296
Mom2Ozzy voted for cyndy296
zonahobo voted for cyndy296
zonarita voted for cyndy296
We've broken into two camps - If by changing my vote I could tie the vote - I'd let the computer decide. There are 5 more hours.
Christina wrote -
First off...in defense of myself: Well, I have no defense =P I can't really say anything to prove I'm a human, and not a wolf other than try to be as active as possible. I understand that one must be suspicious of everybody. But I CAN say beyond a shadow of a doubt that I am NOT a wolf. And I don't lie ;)
In this game - if you are a wolf - you must lie - so your comment makes no defense. People who would never lie just don't play this game. smile - sorry, just calling it as I see it.
Cin wrote
If you are using the theory both Christina & cyndy are most suspicious because of the logon screen you captured, then I would hope they are on the previous 2 hours of screen captures you have, minus the break you took. I know you said those captures are on your daughters computer, so either you have an awesome memory or you are reluctant to post everything you saw. But on the other hand as someone said, I believe it was zonarita, once you post the screen shots they can be edited to add or delete people. So I understand not wanting to give that info.
First Between Christina and Cyndy - I choose Cyndy - maybe it was cause she voted for me. 2nd her two? post were right next to each other and could of been an edit. Third Both huffle and Cyndy came in toward the end of the round last game. Four - I don't have an awesome memory and I'm not reluctant - I'm not sure what you are suggesting here?(The computer is mine, it is at my daughter's house - I go there for a week at a time to watch her kids - Sometimes I am too lazy to carry everything back to my house. I've even washed my clothes at her house so as not to have to carry them home to wash them and carry something else back over to her house.) Do hope this clears up your questions about my thinking.
I see that girl has since logged on in the last few hours and changed her vote from myth to cyndy as well. No post or explanation one way or the other as to why she changed her vote. Interesting................. Not even a post to try to defend herself against myself & myth voting for her.
Maybe she didn't think it would matter - maybe when she voted it was to tips the scales away from her so she could have another round. Maybe some of us (I'm including myself) are strong pushing and others don't want to get it in - RL has a way of doing that. It took awhile for me to play this game - My first shot no matter what I said I was it. I was too. Then the second time I was shot again - it makes one feel uncared about - like the popularity thing back in high school. Anyway, there are times when this game is really fun - in the beginning it can be a game that is not to much fun - Maybe Myth was the right vote afterall. Just thinking on screen.
Mom wrote
Sorry had to vent
lol - boy do I know RL (real life)
Celebrate the moment!
Sorry for the double post - you all do it a lot
My prev post I've been typing on for an hour - lots of interruptions.
Dach -
You are following Cin - your logic if applied to you would say Cin is a wolf and you followed her and very quickly I might add. And that was before all the discussion - so manybe you've give us a clue - I hope someone picks up on this if I'm gone next round.
I'm glad I don't think that way usually - but maybe that is the way you play? = just wanted to point it out. smile
Cin wrote -
Edit - add color and correct small grammer boos.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:28:28---
Celebrate the moment!
My prev post I've been typing on for an hour - lots of interruptions.
Dach -
Zonarita started the accusations against cyndy; zonahobo, mom, and GC all then followed suit with their posts. Irish and girl followed the leader but did not post.To me, that makes Zonarita, Irish, and girl the most suspicious.
You are following Cin - your logic if applied to you would say Cin is a wolf and you followed her and very quickly I might add. And that was before all the discussion - so manybe you've give us a clue - I hope someone picks up on this if I'm gone next round.
I'm glad I don't think that way usually - but maybe that is the way you play? = just wanted to point it out. smile
Cin wrote -
It would seem at this point we have 2 very distinct groups. I believe there is at least 1 wolf in each group. So the question becomes, can all the humans from these 2 groups pull together and figure out the wolves so we can win this game? I hope we can.
I'm not sure I believe there is a wolf in each group - a house devided against itself would fall. Jesus quote I do agree the humans must come together - but who do you trust - talkers sort of run the game and in many games are eaten - this might be one of them.Edit - add color and correct small grammer boos.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 10:28:28---
Celebrate the moment!
No matter what you do in this game, you can be accused of being a wolf.
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
"I know not with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." ~~Albert Einstein
Thanks for clearing some things up zonarita. I didn't expect you to comment on the whole cyndy-Christina theory I posted. That was more of me thinking out loud. I don't think any of us can figure out anyone's entire way of thinking. If it was that easy, I am sure the humans would win more often.
I just don't want to flip flop my voting and try to stick to my original line of thinking. I agree that cyndy is a good candidate to vote for. You know yourself, when I flip flop, it seems I am a wolf, as the last game you thought so. Now, every game is different and I am not saying you shouldn't find me suspicious. I don't exactly make it easy for myself, but there's no fun if I don't make posts.
No matter what any of us say, at some point or other, someone will find something we said or a vote we made suspicious. It is the nature of hte game.
Anyway, I am off to poke around some more. Look out, it could be you next.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I just don't want to flip flop my voting and try to stick to my original line of thinking. I agree that cyndy is a good candidate to vote for. You know yourself, when I flip flop, it seems I am a wolf, as the last game you thought so. Now, every game is different and I am not saying you shouldn't find me suspicious. I don't exactly make it easy for myself, but there's no fun if I don't make posts.
No matter what any of us say, at some point or other, someone will find something we said or a vote we made suspicious. It is the nature of hte game.
Anyway, I am off to poke around some more. Look out, it could be you next.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I don't think that you can really trust any one in these games. You have the wolves who keep their identities a secret, in fear of they are going to get shot.
Then you who some who are inactive(and are wolf or they are human...but mostly human) and people vote them off because they are inactive and they just help the wovles even more.
How many times do you think we have seen the inactive player? How do we know that it is not part of a plan...to have an inactive player that the wolves keep around because the inactive is one of them? *I've seen it happen before*
Now I've got too many ideas dancing in my head.
I need time to think things through. Honestly, I think I just confused myself.
Time heals ALL wounds
Then you who some who are inactive(and are wolf or they are human...but mostly human) and people vote them off because they are inactive and they just help the wovles even more.
How many times do you think we have seen the inactive player? How do we know that it is not part of a plan...to have an inactive player that the wolves keep around because the inactive is one of them? *I've seen it happen before*
Now I've got too many ideas dancing in my head.
I need time to think things through. Honestly, I think I just confused myself.
Time heals ALL wounds
To tell the truth, I wasn't really following anyone's particular train of thought when I chose cyndy.
I wrote
My reasoning may be somewhat flawed since i'm still trying to wrap my head around how the time thing works but, I was just going with who seemed to be the most logical suspect to me. From the beginning of the round my 3 picks have been cyndy, myth and christina. Girl never entered into my mind b/c frankly , I forgot about her untill Dach and Cinn brought her up but their reasoning just wasn't enough to sway me. Not to mention they were begining to exhibit unsavory behavior themselves making me reluctant to follow suit.
Bo wrote
Now i'm not saying they are wolves but i'll admit it did make me stop and think
So , not wanting to jump on anyone's band wagon I made a decision from my list of three and built my own wagon
I wrote
My reasoning is kind of a combo of inactive list and logon list
Out of those six Christina, myth, girl and irish have at least posted something this round. Cyndy and huffle are absolute no shows, but huffle wasn't on the logon list .Cyndy was, and that's why she's at the top of mine
Out of those six Christina, myth, girl and irish have at least posted something this round. Cyndy and huffle are absolute no shows, but huffle wasn't on the logon list .Cyndy was, and that's why she's at the top of mine
My reasoning may be somewhat flawed since i'm still trying to wrap my head around how the time thing works but, I was just going with who seemed to be the most logical suspect to me. From the beginning of the round my 3 picks have been cyndy, myth and christina. Girl never entered into my mind b/c frankly , I forgot about her untill Dach and Cinn brought her up but their reasoning just wasn't enough to sway me. Not to mention they were begining to exhibit unsavory behavior themselves making me reluctant to follow suit.
Bo wrote
Yes, Dach, Myth didn't exactly help his cause by voting Huffle again without stating a reason. If Myth were a wolf, I would expect a couple dissenting opinions from other players (other wolves?) since they want to protect their kind. Cinamon30 stated she "felt" Myth was a human. From what? Surely not his behavior this game. As an experinced player, his non-interest in us voting for him could easily be a bluff. Cinamon30 could be trying to move us into voting for a human. It is possible at this point.
Now i'm not saying they are wolves but i'll admit it did make me stop and think
So , not wanting to jump on anyone's band wagon I made a decision from my list of three and built my own wagon
Well I read over everything and I have decided to put my vote in for girl63160.
I'm going to go ahead and post since it looks like this round could end any minute. Sorry I wasn't around yesterday. I was incredibly sick, and last game I learned that posting when you're sick is not a good idea.
Well, I'm off to read all the discussion and make my decision.
Well, I'm off to read all the discussion and make my decision.
Maybe I'll get a post in. I switched because deep down, I am a team player and it looked like the team wasn't batting Myth at the moment. The very reason I started Myth was to see how many or who would go along and how many resist. I realize that for some people, they just like to call their own shots. We do have longer rounds, so it really isn't necessary to jump quickly unless you know you are going to be gone for awhile.
Early in the game, none of us but wolves have a certain knowledge of the humans. They may not vote at all if it isn't necessary. They are working very hard at seeming like humans in the day and I think they usually actively participate in discussion because that is their best defense from the silver bullet. Now a wolf could be soneone that just doesn't like posting at all. They could sleep in the day and come around just to vote. Some players, human and wolf, go completely inactive and you get those long night rounds.
Well, this round could end so I am going to post. Hope I make it to another day, but if not, get those wolves humans!
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Early in the game, none of us but wolves have a certain knowledge of the humans. They may not vote at all if it isn't necessary. They are working very hard at seeming like humans in the day and I think they usually actively participate in discussion because that is their best defense from the silver bullet. Now a wolf could be soneone that just doesn't like posting at all. They could sleep in the day and come around just to vote. Some players, human and wolf, go completely inactive and you get those long night rounds.
Well, this round could end so I am going to post. Hope I make it to another day, but if not, get those wolves humans!
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Just what I noticed
Irish not on today
Cyndy not 2days
Online in the last 5 minutes
zonarita, mocha613, joshmayesh, Braingirl07, Mom2Ozzy,
Online in the last 15 minutes
swagman10, clashup, menz, tick, TEJackFry123, mythmaster, BIGNEFAN, 2hot4u, air_up_there_jr, zonahobo, cartoon, draggon, danl331, green_apple873, Xpurrt, bluecottoncandy, USER1, soccerkate, phobophobia421, glowtmickey, AndrewWalker, BadBunnee02, FatHead, ldshort, Thor_MULS, mikster678, icestar12, jerryr, cazoodles, strategery, friesaregood,
Online in the last 30 minutes
knopfregal, silent2012, garrgor, ICUB42, CatsAreCute, AJones, sarah7, Holo, CHRISTA94, ikramazeem, balameenu, thefiltah, jhillyoshi, puppy_luvr1236, Stacker98, drgizmo, Matttoy, mykidsmom, KayakWV77, robertlv1, Spectrix, dropyou, sakura19, Superwolf26, Ehebil, MiraStetson, tweety69, TanCW, doubleugh, ppjones, emready1, battle000111, kjean, bradon182001, xoxoaquaxoxo, tishadclova, The_Big_Cheese, jppbl, PAP3, devilsadvocate, SirGwain, caulker, rooster010, Hufflepuffle
You can see I've not completed cleaning this up.
I'm wondering now if we have two humans? This is so evenly divided - Huffle could make it a computer vote and Cyndy sway it to girl or huffel can end the round. and we starte again - but wondering who will be eaten? I think I'm on the wolves list with Cin, Bo Mom poss - unless this round told them something I can not see.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 12:35:22---
Celebrate the moment!
Irish not on today
Cyndy not 2days
Online in the last 5 minutes
zonarita, mocha613, joshmayesh, Braingirl07, Mom2Ozzy,
Online in the last 15 minutes
swagman10, clashup, menz, tick, TEJackFry123, mythmaster, BIGNEFAN, 2hot4u, air_up_there_jr, zonahobo, cartoon, draggon, danl331, green_apple873, Xpurrt, bluecottoncandy, USER1, soccerkate, phobophobia421, glowtmickey, AndrewWalker, BadBunnee02, FatHead, ldshort, Thor_MULS, mikster678, icestar12, jerryr, cazoodles, strategery, friesaregood,
Online in the last 30 minutes
knopfregal, silent2012, garrgor, ICUB42, CatsAreCute, AJones, sarah7, Holo, CHRISTA94, ikramazeem, balameenu, thefiltah, jhillyoshi, puppy_luvr1236, Stacker98, drgizmo, Matttoy, mykidsmom, KayakWV77, robertlv1, Spectrix, dropyou, sakura19, Superwolf26, Ehebil, MiraStetson, tweety69, TanCW, doubleugh, ppjones, emready1, battle000111, kjean, bradon182001, xoxoaquaxoxo, tishadclova, The_Big_Cheese, jppbl, PAP3, devilsadvocate, SirGwain, caulker, rooster010, Hufflepuffle
You can see I've not completed cleaning this up.
I'm wondering now if we have two humans? This is so evenly divided - Huffle could make it a computer vote and Cyndy sway it to girl or huffel can end the round. and we starte again - but wondering who will be eaten? I think I'm on the wolves list with Cin, Bo Mom poss - unless this round told them something I can not see.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 12:35:22---
Celebrate the moment!
I see huffle made it sorry to hear you're not feeling well.. you've got a lot of reading to do, we have been quite active today.. lol.. i'll keep checking back, very interested in how huffle votes, gonna go do some more teasers
Edited to add: Cyndy seems to be our only no show this round
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 12:43:47---
Edited to add: Cyndy seems to be our only no show this round
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 12:43:47---
Yes, it looks like Cyndy has been a "no-show" on Braingle for the past two days. She is probably human and just the kind of player wolves like to keep in the game. I figure Girl is probably human, but at least she is a voting human. I see her as the least harmful human of the two. The wolves drool for the night and don't like long day rounds. For one of us, this is our last hurrahh, so why hurry it!
(Just fixing a typo .. )
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 13:28:37---
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
(Just fixing a typo .. )
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 13:28:37---
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Oof, that was a lot of posts to read through, and I'm not terribly convinced that anyone is a wolf. It looks like my two choices are cyndy and girl, so I'll probably vote for one of them.
I have to admit that I've been suspicious of cyndy since round 1 when she randomly voted for zonarita. Maybe it truly was a random vote, but from last game she knew that zonarita was a strong player, so if she was a wolf, zonarita would have been a logical choice. At the same time, I do agree with cinnamon (I think) that the log-on list doesn't mean everything. The last wolf to vote could have voted 45 minutes or more before that screenshot was taken so everyone on the list could very well be human. In short, it leaves us in the same place we were before with everyone being suspicious.
Girl definitely seems pretty eager to go with the majority. Last round it seems that she was too lazy to even look who the majority had voted for, but wanted to go for the majority no matter what, and this round she quickly jumped on mythmaster and then changed her vote to cyndy without any explanation (though probably to save herself).
Neither of them really sticks out as being a wolf, but I think the scales are tipping just a tiny bit in girl's direction. She's awfully eager to go with the majority and that certainly is a very wolfish trait. Even if she's not a wolf, she certainly isn't going to add much to our discussion.
EDIT: So now that votes are tied between cyndy and girl. I'm all for the computer deciding if no one else votes, and meanwhile I'll be going over all the posts again to see if anyone besides cyndy or girl sticks out.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 14:02:08---
I have to admit that I've been suspicious of cyndy since round 1 when she randomly voted for zonarita. Maybe it truly was a random vote, but from last game she knew that zonarita was a strong player, so if she was a wolf, zonarita would have been a logical choice. At the same time, I do agree with cinnamon (I think) that the log-on list doesn't mean everything. The last wolf to vote could have voted 45 minutes or more before that screenshot was taken so everyone on the list could very well be human. In short, it leaves us in the same place we were before with everyone being suspicious.
Girl definitely seems pretty eager to go with the majority. Last round it seems that she was too lazy to even look who the majority had voted for, but wanted to go for the majority no matter what, and this round she quickly jumped on mythmaster and then changed her vote to cyndy without any explanation (though probably to save herself).
Neither of them really sticks out as being a wolf, but I think the scales are tipping just a tiny bit in girl's direction. She's awfully eager to go with the majority and that certainly is a very wolfish trait. Even if she's not a wolf, she certainly isn't going to add much to our discussion.
EDIT: So now that votes are tied between cyndy and girl. I'm all for the computer deciding if no one else votes, and meanwhile I'll be going over all the posts again to see if anyone besides cyndy or girl sticks out.
---This message was edited on 2008-01-27 14:02:08---
When girl suggested a majority vote in the first round there still had not been any active voting except for the early voters all of the "real" voting took place while she was at school and the day ended before she could even cast a vote. With the time delay for the night it's possible that ended before she got home as well.
Cyndy was one of the early no reason just fishing voters and has not even been back since she did that.
Cyndy was one of the early no reason just fishing voters and has not even been back since she did that.
In case I'm silenced, I really do think we have split on two not very helpful humans at this point. I still think the "disinterested human" post was a bluff by Myth who is a wolf and Cinn may have helped rescue him because (although a seemingly very nice person) is a wolf this game. Christina seemed to come in towards the end and pitch in with the wolves. That could be very suspicious. Myth voting for Huffle is strange and I wonder if she will actually vote.
The wolves can only remove one player this night, so there should be plenty of survivors to keep the heat on.
The last wolf game (Dingoe game) I was in, the humans went to the very end and did not shoot one wolf. Very humbling! I was the seer taken out in the first round.
For all we know, girl is the seer. That ought to trouble us a bit.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
The wolves can only remove one player this night, so there should be plenty of survivors to keep the heat on.
The last wolf game (Dingoe game) I was in, the humans went to the very end and did not shoot one wolf. Very humbling! I was the seer taken out in the first round.
For all we know, girl is the seer. That ought to trouble us a bit.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Another interesting thought... When myth switched his vote without giving any reason behind it, it was to girl, and he had a choice between two names. When girl switched her vote it was to the majority (at the time) but who else was she to switch it to? Herself? Now the only person left to vote is cyndy.... Hmmm.. I wonder how she will vote?
Good point Mom. I noticed "disinterested" Myth, who dislikes the round going all the way, in and not changing his vote to end the round. We may have left his trail a bit early this round. Time will tell.
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
Join the Zona Force--Dedicated to fun and friendly Braingling!
I wish Monday would hurry up and get here... My kids are driving me nutz
Well either way it goes this has been a very interesting round
Well either way it goes this has been a very interesting round
My word, it took me forever to read through all those posts! Great to see that you are all keeping active.
Dusk had come and the vote was tied. Girl and Cyndy were to duel this out. Back to back they faced each other, drew their swords and shot each other! And the end result was the death of Girl. Was Girl a human, werewolf, or the all-important seer?
Livin' that mom-life...
Dusk had come and the vote was tied. Girl and Cyndy were to duel this out. Back to back they faced each other, drew their swords and shot each other! And the end result was the death of Girl. Was Girl a human, werewolf, or the all-important seer?
Livin' that mom-life...
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!