The Werewolf Game
Game #2834: Werewolves of London
This private game is moderated by The_Spider. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 8 rounds.
Det Smithwright
Day 3
By London Bridge these confounded murderers have led me on a wild goose chase. It seems I let a wee bit of success spoil my keen insight. It shant happen again Old Boy, thats a promise we must make ourselves, and doubly insure it goes a lot better than that lose an inch off our thighs New Years promise. Tut Tut Smithwright tis no time for these vibrant musing, you've got work to do chap.
Constable Spidleyboo arrived rather early at my doorstep this morning in his usual befuddled manner. He spoke more in gasps than in senetences formed from the proper King's English. After settling him down with a firm but compassionate pat on the back, I listened to him as he told me of the finding of another body. It seems they found Irish J's body also down by the docks. "Odd, since, no boats were scheduled in or out to Jolly old Ireland on this evening...by God it's almost as if he walked here from the island"
Now the stakes were getting higher, the group looked to me for reassurance, at least most of them. Was my rival still amongst the hopeful. I inquired around and found that indeed, The Seer is still on the case as well
Signed
Det Smitwright
YOu guys are 1 for 2 and you still have the Seer, Carry on gents
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 19:49:46---
Day 3
By London Bridge these confounded murderers have led me on a wild goose chase. It seems I let a wee bit of success spoil my keen insight. It shant happen again Old Boy, thats a promise we must make ourselves, and doubly insure it goes a lot better than that lose an inch off our thighs New Years promise. Tut Tut Smithwright tis no time for these vibrant musing, you've got work to do chap.
Constable Spidleyboo arrived rather early at my doorstep this morning in his usual befuddled manner. He spoke more in gasps than in senetences formed from the proper King's English. After settling him down with a firm but compassionate pat on the back, I listened to him as he told me of the finding of another body. It seems they found Irish J's body also down by the docks. "Odd, since, no boats were scheduled in or out to Jolly old Ireland on this evening...by God it's almost as if he walked here from the island"
Now the stakes were getting higher, the group looked to me for reassurance, at least most of them. Was my rival still amongst the hopeful. I inquired around and found that indeed, The Seer is still on the case as well
Signed
Det Smitwright
YOu guys are 1 for 2 and you still have the Seer, Carry on gents
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 19:49:46---
I'm going to try to be less intense this round.
Voting bj...
Voting bj...
I will try to be more intense....
For the sake of discussion let's assume that Cami Bob Chunnie celt and smithy are human... They all voted for the wolf shot in round 1....I am human...I say we shoot someone Not on this list...
will re read everything and vote Hari later...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
For the sake of discussion let's assume that Cami Bob Chunnie celt and smithy are human... They all voted for the wolf shot in round 1....I am human...I say we shoot someone Not on this list...
will re read everything and vote Hari later...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
Well, I'm screwed, aren't I.
And there's probably nothing I can do to convince you I'm human until you vote me off, and realize your mistake (har!).
I *personally* don't mind, seeing as I'm probably a sucky player who is currently spending all her time defending herself rather than look at other suspecting wolves.
Well, that *may* be true. That's for me to decide, and you to find out whether YOU'RE making the right choice
*and personally, I'll be quite surprised if I'm not killed, seeing my apparent actions right now in which I consider myself to posses no responsibility of seeing as I may or may not have been sleeping and/or dead at the time*
If that post made ANY sense...well, I'll be surprised.
Voting an SPV until we hear the identities, and in the meantime, off to write some excuses
SPV
So, apparently I wasn't on in time to change. Do we know OldCustard's identity yet?
Sarcastic is the one word that defines me.
So, apparently I wasn't on in time to change. Do we know OldCustard's identity yet?
Sarcastic is the one word that defines me.
Good Grief Juice ..what was that^.....Sounded like a whole lot of NOTHING....
If the wolves didn't throw a fellow wolf under the bus in round 1
then the 2 remaining wolves are in this group,,,
Juice
Cat (Not feeling it)
Debc
Harri
Koin
Gut says Juice and Harri...But debc and koin are there too....
we need to shoot one of these 4....
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
If the wolves didn't throw a fellow wolf under the bus in round 1
then the 2 remaining wolves are in this group,,,
Juice
Cat (Not feeling it)
Debc
Harri
Koin
Gut says Juice and Harri...But debc and koin are there too....
we need to shoot one of these 4....
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
Ok the wolves seem to be really cunning in this game.
It is not as logical as we seem to be looking at it.
I doubt that bj is a wolf especially after the occurence of the last round.
Voting for chunnie for now
How sure are you that no wolf voted for bookworm in the first round Har?
Maybe one of the initial voters for bookworm was a wolf but decided to not change their vote last minute since it will eventually arise suspicion when bookworm is voted out?
So we can't be certain
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 18:56:51---
It is not as logical as we seem to be looking at it.
I doubt that bj is a wolf especially after the occurence of the last round.
Voting for chunnie for now
How sure are you that no wolf voted for bookworm in the first round Har?
Maybe one of the initial voters for bookworm was a wolf but decided to not change their vote last minute since it will eventually arise suspicion when bookworm is voted out?
So we can't be certain
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 18:56:51---
True cami was that YOU??????
Why chunnie over my top 4 suspects????
and catnip why vote Chunnie without posting????
add cami to that list....
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
Why chunnie over my top 4 suspects????
and catnip why vote Chunnie without posting????
add cami to that list....
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
Bob OC was human^^^^...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
Cami coincidentally you didnt vote early in the previous rounds and then said THIS>>>
....."How sure are you that no wolf voted for bookworm in the first round Har?
Maybe one of the initial voters for bookworm was a wolf but decided to not change their vote last minute since it will eventually arise suspicion when bookworm is voted out?
So we can't be certain ..."
This is a little disturbing...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
....."How sure are you that no wolf voted for bookworm in the first round Har?
Maybe one of the initial voters for bookworm was a wolf but decided to not change their vote last minute since it will eventually arise suspicion when bookworm is voted out?
So we can't be certain ..."
This is a little disturbing...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
Gonna vote for bj.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
I pride myslef on not making sense
I think I will change to chunnie also, seeing as my appeal currently isn't needed and makes no sense
Big words fascinate me
I think I will change to chunnie also, seeing as my appeal currently isn't needed and makes no sense
Big words fascinate me
Har, your top 4 suspects follow the same logic of which OC was voted out...
If this happens 4 more times the wolves will be victorious.
Although one of those may be a wolf and I am not disputing that chance... my gut instinct tells me to go with chunnie especially since he has not survived very far in games lately as a human
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 20:02:52---
If this happens 4 more times the wolves will be victorious.
Although one of those may be a wolf and I am not disputing that chance... my gut instinct tells me to go with chunnie especially since he has not survived very far in games lately as a human
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 20:02:52---
We are looking at this too narrowly, and I'm not just saying that because my names on the list.
I think bj is human, chunnie I dont know. He played like this when he was human in another game I played with him, but he seems experienced enough to do that on purpose.
The bob voters are not necessarily wolves, if I were a wolf I would have thrown book under the bus or at least not voted in a majority. The book voters (smithy, cam, chunnie) are competent enough to do the same. Not suggesting they are wolves, just not dismissing them yet.
Edit: Seer is still here, so spving random.
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 20:11:47---
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
I think bj is human, chunnie I dont know. He played like this when he was human in another game I played with him, but he seems experienced enough to do that on purpose.
The bob voters are not necessarily wolves, if I were a wolf I would have thrown book under the bus or at least not voted in a majority. The book voters (smithy, cam, chunnie) are competent enough to do the same. Not suggesting they are wolves, just not dismissing them yet.
Edit: Seer is still here, so spving random.
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 20:11:47---
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
Why has chunnie got three votes?!
So far his crimes seem to have been
1. voted for a wolf
2. used logic
As I said he certainly isn't cleared but we'd need a good reason to override the fact that he was instrumental in getting a wolf shot.
Voting juice. Her posts this round have done nothing to alleviate suspicion.
EDIT: Spidleyboo, I can't help but feel that most of the story was written for my amusement.
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 20:16:51---
So far his crimes seem to have been
1. voted for a wolf
2. used logic
As I said he certainly isn't cleared but we'd need a good reason to override the fact that he was instrumental in getting a wolf shot.
Voting juice. Her posts this round have done nothing to alleviate suspicion.
EDIT: Spidleyboo, I can't help but feel that most of the story was written for my amusement.
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 20:16:51---
Atleast part of it was
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I thought OC was a wolf for that same reason Smithy....
Does the lack of participation from Debc...and Harri...seem odd to anyone else????
I agree with Smithy ...Piling on chunnie doesn,t make sense...
which makes me wonder about those voting him....Especially Cami....
Spidleypoo "AT LEAST" is 2 words!!!!
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
I agree with Smithy ...Piling on chunnie doesn,t make sense...
which makes me wonder about those voting him....Especially Cami....
Spidleypoo "AT LEAST" is 2 words!!!!
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
In the last game where Deb was a wolf she was actually quite active, possibly more so than usual... Harri on the other hand, yes it does seem a little suspicious, and I know he's done this a couple times as a wolf before.
Similarly, cat has contributed almost nothing to the game, which he did the two times he was wolf recently. I'm not sure how his activity as a human compares though.
Similarly, cat has contributed almost nothing to the game, which he did the two times he was wolf recently. I'm not sure how his activity as a human compares though.
I guess I agree that piling on chunnie may not be completely helpful but the same is piling on babyjuice really
Wow. A guy helps get a wolf shot in round 1, puts forward a reasonable theory to help find wolves, but which was never guaranteed to find a wolf in ONE round, and the moment he slips up and votes a human, he's automatically a wolf? wth... I never said I was sure about OC... I wouldn't have switched my vote so many times last round if I was... I actually suspected bj and koin more but I couldn't get a majority on them so I had no choice but to try for OC
Yes, I have had exams before while I was a wolf. Big surprise. And I wouldn't let nights end so quickly for the short period I'm busy, so there is a huge gap in logic and inconsistency that no rational person can come to terms with.
Considering this, my top suspect is smithy. He's using the old piggy back off the strongest human (who has thus far been chunnie), and he's going to use him as a shield the rest of the game with persistent defence tactics.
He's my vote Har is acting far more odd than usual...he must sincerely wants to help to make up for his mistakes last game, but I'm starting to doubt it since I disagree with nearly all his suspects.
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 21:17:41---
Considering this, my top suspect is smithy. He's using the old piggy back off the strongest human (who has thus far been chunnie), and he's going to use him as a shield the rest of the game with persistent defence tactics.
He's my vote Har is acting far more odd than usual...he must sincerely wants to help to make up for his mistakes last game, but I'm starting to doubt it since I disagree with nearly all his suspects.
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 21:17:41---
Smithy, Camille and celtic are human. I'd stake my braingle account on that.
SirHar has been odd, but he seems human.
The ones I'm weary of are bj, koin, cat and Harri.
SirHar has been odd, but he seems human.
The ones I'm weary of are bj, koin, cat and Harri.
Okay, seriously, what. Putter's using the old "vague words to sound clever but really mean absolutely nothing" trick.
Camillee wrote:
We actually have a reason to suspect juice, and no reason to think she's human. With chunnie we have no reason to suspect him, and a reason to think he's human.
Camillee wrote:
I guess I agree that piling on chunnie may not be completely helpful but the same is piling on babyjuice really
We actually have a reason to suspect juice, and no reason to think she's human. With chunnie we have no reason to suspect him, and a reason to think he's human.
Their meanings are self-evident And I should already be cleared because I didn't vote for bookworm, so any claims against me are pretty weak.
I can't even tell if you're joking or not.
I invented the concept of bussing my team mates Well-known and verifiable fact
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 21:32:06---
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 21:32:06---
Who would have thought such a genius would be incapable of changing tactics from one game to another?
Anyway, I'm not all that suspicious of you, as silly as you're being. (As much as I hate to use night lengths, your comment about the short first night is kind of inescapable.) It's your rather ludicrous suspicion of me that I was more questioning of.
Anyway, I'm not all that suspicious of you, as silly as you're being. (As much as I hate to use night lengths, your comment about the short first night is kind of inescapable.) It's your rather ludicrous suspicion of me that I was more questioning of.
hey
i checked earlier and it was still night(while i was still at work)
also i am a little rattled(hubby's health)
i am not sure about the chin vote he was actually trying...but i am always leery of people leading the charge
i think i will go with cat again...he seems to defy the odds of being a wolf like in EVERY game
is subject to change
edit
baby, that made no sense to me
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 21:46:16---
This space is intentionally left blank.
i checked earlier and it was still night(while i was still at work)
also i am a little rattled(hubby's health)
i am not sure about the chin vote he was actually trying...but i am always leery of people leading the charge
i think i will go with cat again...he seems to defy the odds of being a wolf like in EVERY game
is subject to change
edit
baby, that made no sense to me
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 21:46:16---
This space is intentionally left blank.
It's not really a tactic, I'm just a selfish player so I'd be willing to sac any of my partners esp. if I perceive them to be inactive and weak
What bothers me right now is that all the suspects being mentioned are just those who would put up the least resistance, or would have the least chance of surviving due to their playing style. That could just be coincidence, but I find that very hard to believe
Okay, reading this over, something doesn't add up. Why would the wolves eat scrub and jayo before our only begotten son (chunnie)?
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 22:11:07---
What bothers me right now is that all the suspects being mentioned are just those who would put up the least resistance, or would have the least chance of surviving due to their playing style. That could just be coincidence, but I find that very hard to believe
Okay, reading this over, something doesn't add up. Why would the wolves eat scrub and jayo before our only begotten son (chunnie)?
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 22:11:07---
There are 2 suspect groups:
Bob voters:
Bj
Me
Chunnie voters:
Camillee
Cat
I think we need to broaden this group. Smithy, book voter, and harry, whose earlier comment about the short night makes sense, I think are human. The chunnie vote really makes no sense here, and neither does cams logic, so Im voting her.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
Bob voters:
Bj
Me
Chunnie voters:
Camillee
Cat
I think we need to broaden this group. Smithy, book voter, and harry, whose earlier comment about the short night makes sense, I think are human. The chunnie vote really makes no sense here, and neither does cams logic, so Im voting her.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
HarriDansker wrote:
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 22:25:51---
Okay, reading this over, something doesn't add up. Why would the wolves eat scrub and jayo before our only begotten son (chunnie)?
I know what you mean... I was honestly expecting to be eaten round 1. Either the wolves are being incredibly lackadaisical or they figure I'm being too involved to be the seer...
---This message was edited on 2012-11-28 22:25:51---
Deb c ...Hari,,,, cami...Juice ..koin in that order...I will vote juice to save chunnie I will be off work in time to change my vote at the end of the round...
Harri most of what you say I take with a grain of salt....
Chunnie seems sincere
cat (not feeling it)
celt (nah)
Cami(bothers me)
Debc(bothers me)
Koin (bothers me)
Juice (I like her but don't trust her)
leaving my vote on harry but I will make back for the end of the round...if chunnie is still tied with juice or someone else I will change my vote....
good night schmucks....
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
Harri most of what you say I take with a grain of salt....
Chunnie seems sincere
cat (not feeling it)
celt (nah)
Cami(bothers me)
Debc(bothers me)
Koin (bothers me)
Juice (I like her but don't trust her)
leaving my vote on harry but I will make back for the end of the round...if chunnie is still tied with juice or someone else I will change my vote....
good night schmucks....
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
SirHar wrote:
Harri most of what you say I take with a grain of salt....
You take all facts with a grain of salt, so I actually view this as a compliment
Harri most of what you say I take with a grain of salt....
You take all facts with a grain of salt, so I actually view this as a compliment
I'm modifying my list from last round. This is just how I view people left in the game... not necessarily how you should view them!
babyjuice
koin_era345
catmandon
debc1
HarriDansker
SirHar
glowingredbob
celtichero
Smithy
Camillee
chunnie
Likely wolf
Neutral
Likely human
Looking over my list, I realized that Jayo was one of those I had in purple last round when I suggested the seer divine people in that group. Don't think a wolf would want to take out a human in that group if there was a wolf in there. Taking that into consideration, and the fact that I no longer suspect those who were in blue last round, my theory kinda falls apart unless both bj and koin are wolves. It could be completely wrong, but until someone provides a reasonable alternative, I have to stand by it.
babyjuice
koin_era345
catmandon
debc1
HarriDansker
SirHar
glowingredbob
celtichero
Smithy
Camillee
chunnie
Likely wolf
Neutral
Likely human
Looking over my list, I realized that Jayo was one of those I had in purple last round when I suggested the seer divine people in that group. Don't think a wolf would want to take out a human in that group if there was a wolf in there. Taking that into consideration, and the fact that I no longer suspect those who were in blue last round, my theory kinda falls apart unless both bj and koin are wolves. It could be completely wrong, but until someone provides a reasonable alternative, I have to stand by it.
Post from babyjuice deleted on 2012-11-29 06:35:32.
Now juice is deleting posts without reposting them, leaving no comment despite being in a tied majority?!
There are certainly a lot of things about this game that aren't making sense...
There are certainly a lot of things about this game that aren't making sense...
bj, might I make a suggestion? If you're really human, and you want a way out of this for both of us, how about switching to koin? He's the only other person I'd vote at this point. If you switch to him, I'll do the same and then the majority would be solely on him.
morning
like my vote as is
This space is intentionally left blank.
like my vote as is
This space is intentionally left blank.
We still haven't heard from cat this round, despite the fact he's put in a rather important but somewhat unjustifiable vote. I feel like not enough is being made of this.
cat's being cat... pointless posts when he makes pointless votes... figures there'd be no post when he makes a significant vote... could be wolf, could be human... idk...
Edit: Trying not to be too close-minded here... I could be very wrong about the bj/koin thing... If someone wants to start a majority on cat, I'd consider joining...
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 11:40:55---
Edit: Trying not to be too close-minded here... I could be very wrong about the bj/koin thing... If someone wants to start a majority on cat, I'd consider joining...
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 11:40:55---
I agree with chunnies list of humans with the exception of Cami...The round ends at 5 my time I should be back to change mt vote if necessary...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
SirHar, last round you said:
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 11:48:04---
after re reading round 1 I am clearing the following...
Cami, Bob, and probably Celt ...These three dont have the balls to throw a fellow wolf under the bus in round 1
What's changed since then?
Cami, Bob, and probably Celt ...These three dont have the balls to throw a fellow wolf under the bus in round 1
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 11:48:04---
I'd favour a vote for either juice or cat, especially over the still seemingly pointless shooting of chunnie, but if we both changed to cat we'd still be left with a 3-3...
It could hurt to try, but maybe Har and/or a couple others would join eventually. Changing to cat...
babyjuice voted for chunnie
Camillee voted for chunnie
catmandon voted for chunnie
celtichero voted for babyjuice
Smithy voted for babyjuice
chunnie voted for catmandon
debc1 voted for catmandon
glowingredbob voted for koin_era345
HarriDansker voted for Smithy
koin_era345 voted for Camillee
SirHar voted for HarriDansker
PS: If cat is a wolf, my suspicion of bj would drop significantly...
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 12:56:19---
babyjuice voted for chunnie
Camillee voted for chunnie
catmandon voted for chunnie
celtichero voted for babyjuice
Smithy voted for babyjuice
chunnie voted for catmandon
debc1 voted for catmandon
glowingredbob voted for koin_era345
HarriDansker voted for Smithy
koin_era345 voted for Camillee
SirHar voted for HarriDansker
PS: If cat is a wolf, my suspicion of bj would drop significantly...
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 12:56:19---
If and when we get a second wolf we can reevaluate all our (many) suspects. For now will switch to cat and hope for the best.
Err still hesitant to step in and save someone. I'm tempted to just shoot cat because I hate his play style and I'd prefer chunnie in the game, but I'm trying to remain objective
To be honest, that's a perfectly legitimate reason to break the tie. Even from a tactical perspective, I'm sure it's easier to get a read on players that ACTUALLY POST SOMETHING, so keeping cat in the game could prove more problematic later on. From a personal perspective, which I often like to take, it's definitely a good enough reason.
Cat is not High on my list of suspects ...But I would have him shot as a human than chunnie shot as a human...
You owe me one chunnie....
And in responce to your previous post A lot has happened since round 1
Bob in his last post in one sounded human to me..
Celt has sounded like human celt
Cami I am still leery of...
any other questions????
I still think the 2 wolves are in the Juice Koin Debc Harry Group...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
You owe me one chunnie....
And in responce to your previous post A lot has happened since round 1
Bob in his last post in one sounded human to me..
Celt has sounded like human celt
Cami I am still leery of...
any other questions????
I still think the 2 wolves are in the Juice Koin Debc Harry Group...
the stronger the fed govt gets the less you free you will be,,,,This is a no brainer...
True enough, Smithy. Voting cat
I'll switch to Koin I guess
Who is cat?????
Btw I posted something enitrely non-relevant to the game, and decided it was better off deleted. Sorry
EDIT: ...nevermind. But cat hasn't posted like anything .
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 15:14:27---
Who is cat?????
Btw I posted something enitrely non-relevant to the game, and decided it was better off deleted. Sorry
EDIT: ...nevermind. But cat hasn't posted like anything .
---This message was edited on 2012-11-29 15:14:27---
And he probably won't. Just need 1 vote to end the round, and everyone's voted. Why not vote him and end it now?
I much prefer a cat vote to either bj or chunnie. I dont know for sure that chunnie is human, but either way the vote had no reasoning behind it. Everyone has voted, no point in not ending the round.
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
Happy ever after in the marketplace, Desmond lets the children lend a hand. Molly stays at home and does her pretty face, and in the evening she's the singer with the band!
Sorry but Cat was indeed human, however
Good Riddance
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Good Riddance
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!