The Werewolf Game
Game #3284: Hunters and Demons
This private game is moderated by bRIN. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 7 rounds.
RFM -Thanks Spider
Apologies, I thought I posted this earlier but it must not have saved.
Hael wasn't sure if he could continue the fight. He hadn't managed to save one soul yet. But fight he would -
Round 1:1 Human shot
Round 1:2 Seer survives
Round 2:1 Human shot
Round 2: 2 Seer survives
Round 3: 1 Human shot
Round 3: 2 Seer survives.
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 19:10:21---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Apologies, I thought I posted this earlier but it must not have saved.
Hael wasn't sure if he could continue the fight. He hadn't managed to save one soul yet. But fight he would -
Round 1:1 Human shot
Round 1:2 Seer survives
Round 2:1 Human shot
Round 2: 2 Seer survives
Round 3: 1 Human shot
Round 3: 2 Seer survives.
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 19:10:21---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
RFM
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Music being eaten isn't a total shock since she basically was the only clear in the game.
Will SPV
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Will SPV
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Perhaps the most egregious and sad timeout i've seen in awhile....i don't get why this is like pulling teeth, but i guess I should have learned by now.
Well, the wolves ignored any and all seer hunting in the most pivotal seer hunting round, so that should tell us something. If music was the seer she was pretty moot anyway.
My SPV will be for Hooves, I meant to vote Stewie at the end but i had to give my bro a lift and i didnt slip back home in time. I had reservations that maybe Deb was a wolf and someone was 'in the know' on it, we'll say, so I was a little unsure of how strongly i should suspect Hooves. With Deb being a human, a Hooves/Celt combo is pretty reasonable imo.
Lol Celt may have just given himself away by viewing the music eating as 'sensible'
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 09:04:57---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Well, the wolves ignored any and all seer hunting in the most pivotal seer hunting round, so that should tell us something. If music was the seer she was pretty moot anyway.
My SPV will be for Hooves, I meant to vote Stewie at the end but i had to give my bro a lift and i didnt slip back home in time. I had reservations that maybe Deb was a wolf and someone was 'in the know' on it, we'll say, so I was a little unsure of how strongly i should suspect Hooves. With Deb being a human, a Hooves/Celt combo is pretty reasonable imo.
Lol Celt may have just given himself away by viewing the music eating as 'sensible'
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 09:04:57---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Hmm, I don't get the music eating myself. Certainly a confusing one.
I had a feeling someone was gonna vote me late last round. And I had to vote deb to ensure my survival.
Anyway, I'm gonna go back over the previous rounds and see if I missed anything.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
I had a feeling someone was gonna vote me late last round. And I had to vote deb to ensure my survival.
Anyway, I'm gonna go back over the previous rounds and see if I missed anything.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
The music eating makes much sense for me as well. Nobody was going to vote for music as she is certainly human, so there is more chance to randomly shoot a wolf when she is still alive. It is good to clear the seer, but also good to clear known humans.. in my opinion
I'll wait and see to where my vote goes next
I'll wait and see to where my vote goes next
Surely by this point in the game, you guys have formed your own opinions and don't need to play the 'wait and see' game?
Almost everyone has been suspect this game through either lack of activity (in some cases), continuous procrastination, (in some cases), and at least the appearance of actively avoiding the game (in some cases ).
Would like to hear what Smithy has, as whether human or wolf, he will at least make his opinions heard.
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Almost everyone has been suspect this game through either lack of activity (in some cases), continuous procrastination, (in some cases), and at least the appearance of actively avoiding the game (in some cases ).
Would like to hear what Smithy has, as whether human or wolf, he will at least make his opinions heard.
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Just going to put in a SPV for right now.
Will reread the rounds and return later..
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
Will reread the rounds and return later..
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
Something isn't sitting right with me about celts posts in the last round.
I can't quite figure out why though. I just have a hunch that he may be a wolf. Then again its hard to gain any evidence when there is nothing being said.
I am going to go out on a limb and vote Celt at least for now.
I also don't get cats delight with the ties l,
as spider has mentioned. It just seems strange.
I just get the feeling I am missing something important in this game. I just can't figure out what it is yet.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
I can't quite figure out why though. I just have a hunch that he may be a wolf. Then again its hard to gain any evidence when there is nothing being said.
I am going to go out on a limb and vote Celt at least for now.
I also don't get cats delight with the ties l,
as spider has mentioned. It just seems strange.
I just get the feeling I am missing something important in this game. I just can't figure out what it is yet.
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
Ok reading trough everything again I made up my mind.
My vote goes to whooves too. There was no real grounding to the suspicion of deb that I am aware of. As whooves matches the log in date 'today' info from last round and was well aware of music being human (comment 'music had better not be the seer'). I am -for now- voting whooves
My vote goes to whooves too. There was no real grounding to the suspicion of deb that I am aware of. As whooves matches the log in date 'today' info from last round and was well aware of music being human (comment 'music had better not be the seer'). I am -for now- voting whooves
Myself, I disagree with the music eating making sense. Even though music was inactive, usually wolves will use an inactive player to their advantage. I have played in many of the earlier games where inactive players actually benefit the wolves in the late rounds - especially when it comes down to a "must lynch" situation. If there is a known inactive player, the wolves will know that the inactive will not help the humans because they have not played for the entire game - like music did. Why take out an inactive player when that missing vote will not help the humans, especially when the remaining active players can possibly (and has happened often) will vote for each other leaving the wolf to join one of the humans and "game over".
Stewie, in many games I've played with Cat, he does love ties.
Malood, using log in times is not accurate as I explained in the last round. Many of us do not rely on log in times and some games state not to even mention them.
Right now I'm going to hold my vote to see what others have to say.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
Stewie, in many games I've played with Cat, he does love ties.
Malood, using log in times is not accurate as I explained in the last round. Many of us do not rely on log in times and some games state not to even mention them.
Right now I'm going to hold my vote to see what others have to say.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
Ok froggy good to hear all of this, right in the end it can benefit the wolves a great deal to have an inactive player I didn't think of that. But a player known to be human is not helpful to the wolves.. In this case the benefits of the inactivity overrule.
My vote is still not fixed.
My vote is still not fixed.
None of this is really relevant at this stage, the wolves needed to find the seer, (if music is the seer she's useless anyway), so why throw a pivotal night vote away hunting someone who is either not the seer (or a useless seer). The wolves had a 1/7 chance on sheer luck of hitting the seer, but knock out music, its 1/6, and surely they have made deductions to reduce the likely seer candidates to 3 or 4. Commendable though it may have been to eliminate an inactive in principle, it was foolish to throw away good odds for the most important seer hunt vote of the game....It even seems the wolves were conflicted. One voted to eliminate the inactive, one, for unknowable reasons, felt this game needed a pointless 24 hour night.
The only person, Im, now less sure, but still leaning human on is Malood. No one else has done much of anything to sound human, though I suppose Smithy comes the closest, but that is not saying anything strong at this stage. Maybe Ill do pair analysis or a deb list, but i really don't feel like it, surely everyone must have at least ONE idea of substance they can be willing to share at this point.
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The only person, Im, now less sure, but still leaning human on is Malood. No one else has done much of anything to sound human, though I suppose Smithy comes the closest, but that is not saying anything strong at this stage. Maybe Ill do pair analysis or a deb list, but i really don't feel like it, surely everyone must have at least ONE idea of substance they can be willing to share at this point.
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
hmm guess your right Spider. Then celt is indeed collecting more suspicion points to think of it as sensible. (-even though I was on the same train )
I guess, out of necessity... ill post a deb list, not sure if i feel like doing pair analysis, and I'm not going through the game again, so this is based on my current perception of what has happened...apologies if i misstated something.
Cat - This is supposed to be your round big guy, so let's hear what you have to say. The vote on Deb would be more suspicious if Cat wasn't so fond of ties, and i think it was essentially an MoO plus two votes on celt at the time, so while he could have been protecting celt, there is no real pressing reason to think he was acting out of anything other than his tie love, which is his prerogative, though i lose some patience for it, when he suggests others should worship ties the way he does. All that said, nothing he has done makes him sound human, but the questionable things he has done arnt necessarily wolfy (for him).
Celt - Probably close to the top of the suspects list. Although he himself hadn't done anything very suspect (prior to this round), the scramble of votes (mainly hooves') seemed a bit haphazard and their motive questionable (so then what was their motive? to protect Celt?) Harry seems to have something to say on Celt, but more on that in a minute. This round he posts something indicating he thought Music was a reasonable night vote, which i insist she wasn't, so I find this also questionable. On top of that, he places an SPV and dashes off (not the first dash off of the game for him either), which I always find suspect.
Froggy - Ive formed very little opinion of Froggy as of yet. Im not sure if i view her attempts to keep music in as a suspect dubious or not. She has in the previous game, commendably, reframed from doing her typical identity strategy, so i won't read anything into what she has or hasn't said as of yet. On the whole, she comes off more human than not, but I'm talking fractionally here.
Harry This guy We've had a disagreement in the past about something that you view as log in related that i don't, so ill try not to dwell on it, but, you have seemed to be 'actively' avoiding this game. This is the kind of game it has been easy to duck and weave so its a strategy that could easily work for you here. Still, though I'm not inclined, yet, to really believe you are a wolf, out of sheer principled indignation, my chances of voting you are beginning to steadily climb
Malood Ive made my piece known on Malood last round, I still view her as the most likely human out of the bunch. Its not a stone cold lock, but its a rock cool barricade
Stewie Stewie is tough for me, because he ALWAYS sounds like a wolf. I have no objections to a Stew vote if it comes to it, but for now Ill put it neutral and give it a rethink later
Hooves Probably my top wolf suspect, and doubly so if Celt flips wolf. The whole aura of last round's Deb vote was odd. We and Hooves' surely knew Music was a human at that stage, so there could have been nothing really suspect about Deb's vote (it probably could have been viewed as LESS suspect because she clearly WASNT saving a wolf). As I said before, her comment about 'i hope music isn't the seer' reads very strange given her only defendable reason for voting Deb was if she missed the evidence that Music was cleared and thought she was being protected..so why have these incongruent concerns, especially as Deb isn't someone Hooves' has shown a consistent inclination to vote for early on a whim. Her vote was so alarming I almost feel Im on the wrong track because it's never that easy
Smithy - Has seemed the most human so far, though that isn't saying much, given he really has 1 or 2 posts of substance. At least he's someone i can riff off of .
If I had to guess, Celt, Hooves....the third one no idea, one of Cat/Stew, Harry is on the radar, but id prefer he is the late arriving cavalry to a hiding wolf
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 14:45:18---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Cat - This is supposed to be your round big guy, so let's hear what you have to say. The vote on Deb would be more suspicious if Cat wasn't so fond of ties, and i think it was essentially an MoO plus two votes on celt at the time, so while he could have been protecting celt, there is no real pressing reason to think he was acting out of anything other than his tie love, which is his prerogative, though i lose some patience for it, when he suggests others should worship ties the way he does. All that said, nothing he has done makes him sound human, but the questionable things he has done arnt necessarily wolfy (for him).
Celt - Probably close to the top of the suspects list. Although he himself hadn't done anything very suspect (prior to this round), the scramble of votes (mainly hooves') seemed a bit haphazard and their motive questionable (so then what was their motive? to protect Celt?) Harry seems to have something to say on Celt, but more on that in a minute. This round he posts something indicating he thought Music was a reasonable night vote, which i insist she wasn't, so I find this also questionable. On top of that, he places an SPV and dashes off (not the first dash off of the game for him either), which I always find suspect.
Froggy - Ive formed very little opinion of Froggy as of yet. Im not sure if i view her attempts to keep music in as a suspect dubious or not. She has in the previous game, commendably, reframed from doing her typical identity strategy, so i won't read anything into what she has or hasn't said as of yet. On the whole, she comes off more human than not, but I'm talking fractionally here.
Harry This guy We've had a disagreement in the past about something that you view as log in related that i don't, so ill try not to dwell on it, but, you have seemed to be 'actively' avoiding this game. This is the kind of game it has been easy to duck and weave so its a strategy that could easily work for you here. Still, though I'm not inclined, yet, to really believe you are a wolf, out of sheer principled indignation, my chances of voting you are beginning to steadily climb
Malood Ive made my piece known on Malood last round, I still view her as the most likely human out of the bunch. Its not a stone cold lock, but its a rock cool barricade
Stewie Stewie is tough for me, because he ALWAYS sounds like a wolf. I have no objections to a Stew vote if it comes to it, but for now Ill put it neutral and give it a rethink later
Hooves Probably my top wolf suspect, and doubly so if Celt flips wolf. The whole aura of last round's Deb vote was odd. We and Hooves' surely knew Music was a human at that stage, so there could have been nothing really suspect about Deb's vote (it probably could have been viewed as LESS suspect because she clearly WASNT saving a wolf). As I said before, her comment about 'i hope music isn't the seer' reads very strange given her only defendable reason for voting Deb was if she missed the evidence that Music was cleared and thought she was being protected..so why have these incongruent concerns, especially as Deb isn't someone Hooves' has shown a consistent inclination to vote for early on a whim. Her vote was so alarming I almost feel Im on the wrong track because it's never that easy
Smithy - Has seemed the most human so far, though that isn't saying much, given he really has 1 or 2 posts of substance. At least he's someone i can riff off of .
If I had to guess, Celt, Hooves....the third one no idea, one of Cat/Stew, Harry is on the radar, but id prefer he is the late arriving cavalry to a hiding wolf
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 14:45:18---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
catmandon voted for The_Spider
celtichero voted for Malood
Malood voted for whoviandeb
StewieGriffin voted for celtichero
The_Spider voted for whoviandeb
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
celtichero voted for Malood
Malood voted for whoviandeb
StewieGriffin voted for celtichero
The_Spider voted for whoviandeb
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I am having a difficult time getting into this game. I was feeling more of a wolf vibe on deb than on celt, and I'm not sure if Stewie was in the mix at that time (I'd have to go back and see how things looked when I voted). I was wrong, so the suspicion is understandable, but not correct.
I am going to place a vote for HP, who usually at least attempts to be helpful, but has don't nothing yet. Perhaps being called out by more than just Spider will wake him up. (I miss Jayo, he usually gets things going.)
It's a disease, not a punch line
I am going to place a vote for HP, who usually at least attempts to be helpful, but has don't nothing yet. Perhaps being called out by more than just Spider will wake him up. (I miss Jayo, he usually gets things going.)
It's a disease, not a punch line
Got some Friday juice in me but I'll try to keep this coherent.
The deb vote last round was kinda weird as it's linchpin was so undoubtedly flawed. Obviously stewie did what he had to do at the end of the round to save himself whatever his ID, and froggy came in with the initial vote/reasoning and then wasn't around later to see the counter arguments, but cat and whovians votes are harder to justify.
I'll have a go at a deb list too, we can't keep waiting for something to happen.
Cat - has a love of ties it seems and I guess his vote for Deb came early enough that it wasn't important enough to be that big a red flag.
Celt - is a piece in a couple of potential wolf jigsaws as motivation for the deb vote but they would be pretty brazen plays. I don't read much into his comment about the eating, I agree it was a bad choice but it wasn't completely left field.
Froggy - has not been super active but that's consistent with last couple games where she was a human. Also stirred up the Deb vote early lastround which, though incorrect, suggests human
Putter - needs to step it up, has been suspiciously absent and not offered anything when he has posted.
Malood - as I said last round (and I agree with spid's strengthening of what I said) her post about log-ins points human
Smithy - splendid chap
Stewie - from what I remember does have a tendency to post cautiously but seems especially so this game. I still think he's a good vote (though as I said earlier his deb vote last round had to be done so doesn't add any extra weight)
Spid - lots of vinegar and other liquids which suggest human
Whovian - has seemed disengaged which could explain the deb vote or could be carelessness from someone who isn't genuinely wolfhunting. Good candidate if celt is a wolf but less so if he's human.
I would definitely consider froggy malood and spid off the table for now. Reluctant on a whovian vote as this depends on Celt's ID and if they're both wolves her rescue mission was pretty barefaced. Tempted to return to a stewie vote but I'm gonna poke the bear and go putter to see if we can get things cooking.
The deb vote last round was kinda weird as it's linchpin was so undoubtedly flawed. Obviously stewie did what he had to do at the end of the round to save himself whatever his ID, and froggy came in with the initial vote/reasoning and then wasn't around later to see the counter arguments, but cat and whovians votes are harder to justify.
I'll have a go at a deb list too, we can't keep waiting for something to happen.
Cat - has a love of ties it seems and I guess his vote for Deb came early enough that it wasn't important enough to be that big a red flag.
Celt - is a piece in a couple of potential wolf jigsaws as motivation for the deb vote but they would be pretty brazen plays. I don't read much into his comment about the eating, I agree it was a bad choice but it wasn't completely left field.
Froggy - has not been super active but that's consistent with last couple games where she was a human. Also stirred up the Deb vote early lastround which, though incorrect, suggests human
Putter - needs to step it up, has been suspiciously absent and not offered anything when he has posted.
Malood - as I said last round (and I agree with spid's strengthening of what I said) her post about log-ins points human
Smithy - splendid chap
Stewie - from what I remember does have a tendency to post cautiously but seems especially so this game. I still think he's a good vote (though as I said earlier his deb vote last round had to be done so doesn't add any extra weight)
Spid - lots of vinegar and other liquids which suggest human
Whovian - has seemed disengaged which could explain the deb vote or could be carelessness from someone who isn't genuinely wolfhunting. Good candidate if celt is a wolf but less so if he's human.
I would definitely consider froggy malood and spid off the table for now. Reluctant on a whovian vote as this depends on Celt's ID and if they're both wolves her rescue mission was pretty barefaced. Tempted to return to a stewie vote but I'm gonna poke the bear and go putter to see if we can get things cooking.
I would consider a Celt vote as well as a Harry vote...I agree with the hooves thing (the foundation of her being a wolf lies with Celt being a wolf, so might as well strike at Celt first)...I also think Cat is trying to skate by as well and he is way up my wolf radar. Wolves have the easiest time hiding when the humans let them, this is the primary reason people need to post, even it just seems pointless, every post makes the wolves work harder to stay camouflaged (and you shoot the ones who refuse to try)
I will actually return to an MoO as a place holder.
Celt, Harry, Hooves, Cat, Stew.........Frogs, Chap, Malood
is my current shoot hierarchy
oh Harry has two votes.....thats fine with me, but now I feel better about my vote switch, as he won't be able to coast on a hastily constructed 'voting to save myself' post
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 18:11:57---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I will actually return to an MoO as a place holder.
Celt, Harry, Hooves, Cat, Stew.........Frogs, Chap, Malood
is my current shoot hierarchy
oh Harry has two votes.....thats fine with me, but now I feel better about my vote switch, as he won't be able to coast on a hastily constructed 'voting to save myself' post
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 18:11:57---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Reading through the above posts raises a bit of a red flag to me so I'm going to tie it up with a vote for Celt.
I will check back before the round ends to see how this tie holds up - or gets broken and by whom...
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
I will check back before the round ends to see how this tie holds up - or gets broken and by whom...
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
The Music eating is just a low risk low reward eating in my opinion. The wolves sacrificed a seer chance to knock out a guaranteed human, and if the game gets to it, takes a luck factor out of it.
Harry voiced suspicions of me and then just dipped so I'm switching my vote over to him.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Harry voiced suspicions of me and then just dipped so I'm switching my vote over to him.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Are all 3 wolves really cowering, this would be a sickening display
..... (post celt post thoughts)
Yes...I mean thats one way to look at it, but that was not 'assumed' in your off the cuff remark at the start of the round, so its odd that you are trying to retroactively analyze something that really doesn't need to be analyzed any longer, and it does not defend the nature of your earlier post.
Now there is a hasty vote by Celt (who still has not made any analytical contributions...in a way convenient for him...) Im okay with the current status quo....I could vote either one, Celt out of suspicion, Harry out of 'really '
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 18:57:40---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
..... (post celt post thoughts)
Yes...I mean thats one way to look at it, but that was not 'assumed' in your off the cuff remark at the start of the round, so its odd that you are trying to retroactively analyze something that really doesn't need to be analyzed any longer, and it does not defend the nature of your earlier post.
Now there is a hasty vote by Celt (who still has not made any analytical contributions...in a way convenient for him...) Im okay with the current status quo....I could vote either one, Celt out of suspicion, Harry out of 'really '
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 18:57:40---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Word of general wwg advice.....when its round 4, and the seer (at least is not yet confirmed dead...it could be music i suppose)....dont put the only guy who hasn't posted in a majority
Harry never leaves himself this vulnerable as a wolf, so this strikes me more as a wolf attack (unless they are piling on reading our words and trying to get ahead of it)....in any case...waiting for the Big H
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Harry never leaves himself this vulnerable as a wolf, so this strikes me more as a wolf attack (unless they are piling on reading our words and trying to get ahead of it)....in any case...waiting for the Big H
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
OK. I'm going to try an make myself a deb list, even though I am never any good at these really.
Cat. I have played with him as long as I can remember. I know that means nothing but he's acting the same he always does.
Not too sure. Slighy leaning wolf. Hr just doesn't sit right with nr at the moment.
Out of ten I guess 6/4.
Celtic. Although as I stated earlier this round. Something sounds fishy about his comments the previous round to me
Out of ten. 7.5/2.5. Wolf.
"Legs". Doesn't really strike me as suspicious. Just usual in between/not kowing what to do. Leaning slightly towards human scale. Out of ten, I would say 3.5/6.5 human.
Harry. I mentioned below.
Malood. I am not really familiar with there style of play, as I have only played a handful of games with them. But seeing as how this is a list. Out of pure elimination and nothing else, I will lean towards human. Only slightly. 5.5/4.5.
Smithy. Whist probably being informative, also just doesn't sit right with me. In a game like this, it's too easy for a wolf to pull curtains over players eyes. For that reason alone. I am gonna lean towards the wolf side. 6.5/4.5.
This is actually tougher than I thought.
Anyway on to Spid. I was thinking he was a wolf in the earlier rounds, but now... I'm not convinced, his actions and words are always genuine, rather he's on the good side or not. For that reason, he's always hard yo predict. But reading through the previous posts. I'm pretty sure he's human.
3/7 out of ten.
Whovi. Nothing really jumps out at me,
could go either way at the moment.
If I was to guess. I would say the wolves are between. Celtic and Cat and smithy.
And to a lesser extent, who, and a harry.
Not too sure about Malood. I just haven't played enough with them tobknow their style of play.
I guess there's my list for what it's worth.
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 21:27:23---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
Cat. I have played with him as long as I can remember. I know that means nothing but he's acting the same he always does.
Not too sure. Slighy leaning wolf. Hr just doesn't sit right with nr at the moment.
Out of ten I guess 6/4.
Celtic. Although as I stated earlier this round. Something sounds fishy about his comments the previous round to me
Out of ten. 7.5/2.5. Wolf.
"Legs". Doesn't really strike me as suspicious. Just usual in between/not kowing what to do. Leaning slightly towards human scale. Out of ten, I would say 3.5/6.5 human.
Harry. I mentioned below.
Malood. I am not really familiar with there style of play, as I have only played a handful of games with them. But seeing as how this is a list. Out of pure elimination and nothing else, I will lean towards human. Only slightly. 5.5/4.5.
Smithy. Whist probably being informative, also just doesn't sit right with me. In a game like this, it's too easy for a wolf to pull curtains over players eyes. For that reason alone. I am gonna lean towards the wolf side. 6.5/4.5.
This is actually tougher than I thought.
Anyway on to Spid. I was thinking he was a wolf in the earlier rounds, but now... I'm not convinced, his actions and words are always genuine, rather he's on the good side or not. For that reason, he's always hard yo predict. But reading through the previous posts. I'm pretty sure he's human.
3/7 out of ten.
Whovi. Nothing really jumps out at me,
could go either way at the moment.
If I was to guess. I would say the wolves are between. Celtic and Cat and smithy.
And to a lesser extent, who, and a harry.
Not too sure about Malood. I just haven't played enough with them tobknow their style of play.
I guess there's my list for what it's worth.
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 21:27:23---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
I think Cat is a good bet for a wolf
Celt is playing the way wolves like to play...they wait and wait and wait, but if a concrete situation arises (they have to save themselves) they swoop in, make the 'forced move' and leave easy peesy.
Im having a hard time imaging Harry let himself go out like this as a wolf, like a chump to be frank. He's lucky the Phils are in a rain delay so ill be up later to save him if need be, provided he brings it
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Celt is playing the way wolves like to play...they wait and wait and wait, but if a concrete situation arises (they have to save themselves) they swoop in, make the 'forced move' and leave easy peesy.
Im having a hard time imaging Harry let himself go out like this as a wolf, like a chump to be frank. He's lucky the Phils are in a rain delay so ill be up later to save him if need be, provided he brings it
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I have played enough with harry to agree, it doesn't seem like something he would do. But at the same time, I don't know why he's so quiet. I'm but sure what to make of the situation. I guess I will say 6/4 out or ten, simply because of how unusually quiet he is being
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 21:53:40---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
---This message was edited on 2018-05-18 21:53:40---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
I will say that I am not a wolf.
But I'm not sure of anyone that is..
(but maybe who I am already voting for)
Wish I was the seer!
---This message was edited on 2018-05-19 01:50:49---
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
But I'm not sure of anyone that is..
(but maybe who I am already voting for)
Wish I was the seer!
---This message was edited on 2018-05-19 01:50:49---
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
Ok I'm going away for the day so I'll switch my vote to fixated from this point on.
My final vote is going to celt. Because I am not that familiar with the play style of any of you, I am not ultra-convinced. Though I agree there seem to be some red flags. So to tie it up I now vote on celt.
Day
It takes 5 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
catmandon voted for The_Spider
celtichero voted for HarryPutter
froggygg voted for celtichero
Malood voted for celtichero
Smithy voted for HarryPutter
StewieGriffin voted for celtichero
The_Spider voted for catmandon
whoviandeb voted for HarryPutter
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
My final vote is going to celt. Because I am not that familiar with the play style of any of you, I am not ultra-convinced. Though I agree there seem to be some red flags. So to tie it up I now vote on celt.
Day
It takes 5 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
catmandon voted for The_Spider
celtichero voted for HarryPutter
froggygg voted for celtichero
Malood voted for celtichero
Smithy voted for HarryPutter
StewieGriffin voted for celtichero
The_Spider voted for catmandon
whoviandeb voted for HarryPutter
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
Poking the bear didn't work as the bear is still AWOL. Not sure what to do now, getting a bit spooked on my putter vote as it is tantamount to a 4th round inactive shot albeit with a bit more welly because of who it is. Also given how little he's participated I don't think we'd learn much if he flipped human going into must lynch. Plus the two people voting with me I don't trust (ID wise).
Cat's last post sounds kinda cryptic but I'm not buying an attack on spid and I'm not quite sure what he's trying to say. Think he's a good option and less dependent on other IDs.
Gonna shift stew slightly towards human after his deb list. Still a candidate but not a top priority this round.
Celt still a decent shout based on possible groupings, and even if he did flip human we learn a bit. I don't think his play has been different to his normal play though.
EDIT: Switching to Cat, for now at least. Still 3 and a half hours to go so still some time for the north americans to wake up and chip in and I don't want to pile on celt.
---This message was edited on 2018-05-19 05:27:44---
Cat's last post sounds kinda cryptic but I'm not buying an attack on spid and I'm not quite sure what he's trying to say. Think he's a good option and less dependent on other IDs.
Gonna shift stew slightly towards human after his deb list. Still a candidate but not a top priority this round.
Celt still a decent shout based on possible groupings, and even if he did flip human we learn a bit. I don't think his play has been different to his normal play though.
EDIT: Switching to Cat, for now at least. Still 3 and a half hours to go so still some time for the north americans to wake up and chip in and I don't want to pile on celt.
---This message was edited on 2018-05-19 05:27:44---
Well if harry is gone this long, I doubt it's intentional , as a strategy at least. I intend to vote celt, but we must give harry the full round to make it back
Remember if the person we shoot presumably celt , is human, next round is must lynch...hmm I'm also definitely ok with a cat vote, he's too reckless for must lynch to be honest
NEVER SPV IN MUST LYNCH
---This message was edited on 2018-05-19 07:23:28---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Remember if the person we shoot presumably celt , is human, next round is must lynch...hmm I'm also definitely ok with a cat vote, he's too reckless for must lynch to be honest
NEVER SPV IN MUST LYNCH
---This message was edited on 2018-05-19 07:23:28---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Sorry friends long weekend is camping for me till tmr. I will vote Celt to save myself
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
catmandon voted for The_Spider
celtichero voted for HarryPutter
froggygg voted for celtichero
HarryPutter voted for celtichero
Malood voted for celtichero
Smithy voted for catmandon
StewieGriffin voted for celtichero
The_Spider voted for catmandon
whoviandeb voted for HarryPutter
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
celtichero voted for HarryPutter
froggygg voted for celtichero
HarryPutter voted for celtichero
Malood voted for celtichero
Smithy voted for catmandon
StewieGriffin voted for celtichero
The_Spider voted for catmandon
whoviandeb voted for HarryPutter
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
Well I suppose that settles matters....though it may explain the hilarious time out of the previous night
I hate swoop and saves (even for yourself ) and you weren't really in the line of fire any longer. The reason for your absence is understandable but it's still annoying you couldn't marshall together a thought or two.
I began this post intending to seal celts doom but now i will weigh this, because the fact that you actually were mostly unable to log on takes away my 'pride' defense for you
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
I hate swoop and saves (even for yourself ) and you weren't really in the line of fire any longer. The reason for your absence is understandable but it's still annoying you couldn't marshall together a thought or two.
I began this post intending to seal celts doom but now i will weigh this, because the fact that you actually were mostly unable to log on takes away my 'pride' defense for you
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Oh I guess it's pointless anyway, shaving 6 minutes off the round , sorry celt
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Round 4:1 - a Demon has been exorcised.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
Your love gave me memories too beautiful to forget.
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!