Brain Teasers Optical Illusions Puzzle Hunts Codes & Ciphers Mechanical Puzzles
Personal Links
Browse Teasers
Search Teasers

For the Smell of Soup

Situation puzzles (sometimes called lateral thinking puzzles) are ones where you need to ask lots of yes or no questions to figure out what happened in the situation. These are good puzzles for groups where one person knows the puzzle and answers the questions.


Puzzle ID:#34842
Fun:**** (3.1)
Difficulty:*** (2.24)
Submitted By:OldChinaHand*****
Corrected By:reptile5000




A beggar was given a piece of bread, but nothing to put on it. Hoping to get something to go with his bread, he went to a nearby inn and asked for a handout. The innkeeper turned him away with nothing, but the beggar sneaked around to the kitchen window where he saw a large pot of soup cooking over the fire. He held his piece of bread through the window and over the steaming pot, hoping to thus capture a bit of flavor from the good-smelling vapor.

Suddenly the innkeeper seized him by the arm and accused him of stealing soup.

"I took no soup," said the beggar. "I was only smelling the vapor."

"Then you must pay for the smell," answered the innkeeper.

The poor beggar had no money, so the angry innkeeper called for the magistrate.

Now at that time an elder knight named Chistpin was serving as magistrate, as most able bodied men were with the Baron in the Holy Land on yet another crusade, and came over and heard the innkeeper's complaint and the beggar's explanation.

"So you demand payment for the smell of your soup?" summarized Chistpin after listening to both men.

"Yes my lord!" insisted the innkeeper. "My soup is good and it is costly to make, so the rich smells must also be costly and have a value too."

"Payment for the smell? Indeed all things have value, but what would be a fair value for just the smell of a pot of soup? That is the problem here."

Just then something behind him caught Sir Chistpin's attention as a customer paid for his ale and was leaving. "Ah, yes. Yes indeed, there is a fair payment for just the smell of your soup".

How could there be a fair value for just the smell of cooking soup?


The elder knight looked at both the beggar and the innkeeper, and then back to where the sound of a coin, tossed on a table as a customer paid for his ale and left, had caught his attention.

"Innkeeper, I, Sir Chistpin, acting magistrate of Lincolnshire, have found a just and fair payment for the smell of your soup, and I will pay it to you myself," said Chistpin. Taking two large gold coins from a small leather pouch, the Innkeeper's eye sparkled, and Chistpin said, "I will pay for the rich smell of your costly soup with the rich sound of money." Thus Sir Chistpin rang the two coins together loudly, and then he put them back into his pouch; with the price of justice paid, sent the beggar on his own way and left the innkeeper to his own means.


What Next?


See another brain teaser just like this one...

Or, just get a random brain teaser

If you become a registered user you can vote on this brain teaser, keep track of
which ones you have seen, and even make your own.



Jan 12, 2007

that was great. it seemed more like a story than a teaser though.
Jan 12, 2007

You are leaving yourself open to other* answers. (If you know what I mean ) If I say more, it will sound like correcting your teaser, in public! But, it does sound like a terrific answer! No put down, intended.
Jan 12, 2007

I've heard this before as a jewish folktale but I really like it and you phrased it nicely I think
Jan 13, 2007

I really liked this one. Good job.
Jan 15, 2007

Gr8 teaser China. U always have good ones.
Jan 15, 2007

That was absolutely brilliant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This one is most definitly going to my favorites.
Jan 17, 2007

Haha, I like this one.
Jan 17, 2007

Great teaser. I heard it before but it was still great.
Jan 18, 2007

I thought that the perfect payment for a delicious smell would be a compliment. It's certainly worth more than the sound of money.
Jan 22, 2007

I wanted the beggar to have soup with his bread... oh well.

The innkeepers face probably helped the bread be swallowed easier!
Jan 30, 2007

Nice job - I really enjoyed that one.
Feb 01, 2007

That was really a top one.
Feb 03, 2007

yeah, this was in a book, i forgot the name, though, but good job anyways
Feb 03, 2007

good one.

A local fast food place has a "free smells" sign in the window...the beggar should check it out.
Feb 06, 2007

how do you come up with such good ideas
Feb 07, 2007

Nice story... did you figure it out yourself or is the nice twist from some cool story?
Feb 07, 2007

Besides ...I thought he was going to fart in the inn...!

Paying the smell with another smell which can be produced due to good meals! ;)
Apr 05, 2007

great teaser! i havent seen a teaser you made that wasnt good keep it up
Sep 05, 2007

Very clever, indeed!! Loved it!
Oct 24, 2007

Good Job onte story/teaser
Oct 24, 2007

Good Job onte story/teaser
Aug 18, 2009

I liked it! I got it right because there is a similar riddle in our textbooks.( korean text books.)
Aug 23, 2009

Great teaser/story
May 31, 2012

The hint doesn't really help. The hint should be that Chistpin heard something that helped him figure it out.
May 02, 2013

It was in an Urdu book. urdu is a language, but I LOVE this GREAT teaser. gud job!!
Jun 30, 2016

Superb one...Great Thinking..

Back to Top

Online Now
13 users and 726 guests

Users In Chat
Follow Braingle!
Tap into all 20,000+ of our brain teasers, riddles and puzzles on your iPhone or iPad.
Braingle in the iTunes App Store
Copyright © 1999-2017 | FAQ | Widgets | Links | Green | Subscribe | Contact | Privacy | Conditions | Advertise | Braingle Time: 1:40 pm
Sign In Create a free account