The Werewolf Game
Game #2603: WWG: A Thanksgiving Fiasco
This private game is moderated by The_Spider. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 7 rounds.
Well, nothing more for me to add.....good luck
bradon182001 - Pumpkin Pie
caberet - Cranberry Sauce (my favorite)
debc1 - Mashed Potatoes and gravy
Evita - Hard Apple Cider
GreenApples27 - Orange Juice (freshly squeezed)
ka-ching - Candied Sweet Potatoes (my dad makes great Sweet Potatoes)
Longhorn_fan - Rolls
---This message was edited on 2011-11-22 07:22:15---
bradon182001 - Pumpkin Pie
caberet - Cranberry Sauce (my favorite)
debc1 - Mashed Potatoes and gravy
Evita - Hard Apple Cider
GreenApples27 - Orange Juice (freshly squeezed)
ka-ching - Candied Sweet Potatoes (my dad makes great Sweet Potatoes)
Longhorn_fan - Rolls
---This message was edited on 2011-11-22 07:22:15---
Finally! Gosh, what was the hold up? Everyone is active... there's no point in trying to time out the nights...
And wow, I didn't expect snowmonster to be eaten. Thought for sure caberet or I would be a gonner. I am glad I wasn't eaten, but I kind of wanted to be eaten, because then every dead person would be a male, and every living person would be a female. But alas, it wasn't so.
Anyways, I will dig to see why snowmonster was eaten. And ha! Harry was a wolf. I was actually scared near the end of the round that Harry was human... glad I stuck to my guns.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 15:56:19---
And wow, I didn't expect snowmonster to be eaten. Thought for sure caberet or I would be a gonner. I am glad I wasn't eaten, but I kind of wanted to be eaten, because then every dead person would be a male, and every living person would be a female. But alas, it wasn't so.
Anyways, I will dig to see why snowmonster was eaten. And ha! Harry was a wolf. I was actually scared near the end of the round that Harry was human... glad I stuck to my guns.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 15:56:19---
... i'll just say i still love ties :p anyways my connection's gone soon so i'll have to leave it at that until after school tomorrow
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
omg I feel stupid. I gave his midterm exam/absence from the game way too much credit.
This changes my entire outlook on the game, btw. My first inkling is Evie, possibly... deb? But I should look back first. hold on, gotta check something.
This changes my entire outlook on the game, btw. My first inkling is Evie, possibly... deb? But I should look back first. hold on, gotta check something.
Well, if I was going to take a very simplistic and assuming approach, I would say Bobbi, caberet and debc1 are all human. We have three bullets left, and Evita, ka-ching and Longhorn_fan. Evita not voting was strange. If I was a human and a tie was presented in front of me, I would definitely jump to make the final decision... at least then I knew a human was making the final decision. So she would be my number one suspect at the moment. After her is ka-ching. ka-ching followed Harry's vote for me, then changed to caberet after Harry changed to her...
The most human in my opinion is caberet, as last round I really don't feel she was putting an act up to make herself seem human. I think her posts against Harry were genuine. Then the next most human would be debc1. She has been playing like she always does as human, and she voted Harry yesterday when she could've voted caberet and most probably gotten away with it. Then I still think Bobbi sounds like a human in her posts, even though she didn't vote for him.
That leaves me with Longhorn_fan who could really swing both ways...
The most human in my opinion is caberet, as last round I really don't feel she was putting an act up to make herself seem human. I think her posts against Harry were genuine. Then the next most human would be debc1. She has been playing like she always does as human, and she voted Harry yesterday when she could've voted caberet and most probably gotten away with it. Then I still think Bobbi sounds like a human in her posts, even though she didn't vote for him.
That leaves me with Longhorn_fan who could really swing both ways...
Definitely changes my thoughts with Snowy getting eaten, I'm becoming suspicious of Deb and Evie as well, but more so Longhorn fan. She commented that "I do fell putter might be a wolf.." Was she setting it up to look like she was suspicious of HP in case he lost the tie? I do have to believe now that Cab and GA are human (well, I think so anyway) and I'm unsure of what to think about Ching.I'm not jumping on anyone just yet, need to give this a lot more thought. I'll be back.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Updated VL
Red = Known Werewolf!
Whlte = Unknown Role
Green = Known Human
Olive = Probable (IMHO) Human
Blue = No Vote
Orange = My Main Suspicions
I thought for sure that GA or I would be eaten. Or bradon. For the time being I consider ka-ching and Longhorn the most likely suspects for nighttime feeders and have voted accordingly.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 16:28:31---
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Red = Known Werewolf!
Whlte = Unknown Role
Green = Known Human
Olive = Probable (IMHO) Human
Blue = No Vote
Orange = My Main Suspicions
I thought for sure that GA or I would be eaten. Or bradon. For the time being I consider ka-ching and Longhorn the most likely suspects for nighttime feeders and have voted accordingly.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 16:28:31---
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Thank you for the wonderfully colour coded lists, caberet. They are a great help to see what's been happening in the game.
Now, I might rethink my suspicion of Evita. Due to your list, it looks like it would be unlikely that Evita and Harry were wolves together, since Harry was part of that Evita majority... Hm. I'll reread round one to see why Harry voted Evita.
EDIT: Harry voted Evita when there were no votes on her, and didn't log back in for the rest of the round. So, they could very well be wolves together still. Her actions last round made me feel uneasy. I'm going to log in a vote for ka-ching, my second top suspect, because I have a few doubts over Evita, but not really ka-ching.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 16:53:46---
Now, I might rethink my suspicion of Evita. Due to your list, it looks like it would be unlikely that Evita and Harry were wolves together, since Harry was part of that Evita majority... Hm. I'll reread round one to see why Harry voted Evita.
EDIT: Harry voted Evita when there were no votes on her, and didn't log back in for the rest of the round. So, they could very well be wolves together still. Her actions last round made me feel uneasy. I'm going to log in a vote for ka-ching, my second top suspect, because I have a few doubts over Evita, but not really ka-ching.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 16:53:46---
Green's second post basically is where I'm at, and I don't have time at the moment to say more, sorry. I'll be back in an hour or less.
Well, I'm heading off to a Latin exam (second to last one... ) and I'll be back in less than 5 hours. Hopefully everyone has logged on and given their opinions by then!
hey
well i think evi, but since no one else does, well why not? i am just going to go with my gut
This space is intentionally left blank.
well i think evi, but since no one else does, well why not? i am just going to go with my gut
This space is intentionally left blank.
I'm going to log in a vote for ka-ching, my second top suspect, because I have a few doubts over Evita, but not really ka-ching.
I'm not going to give you a hard time for suspecting me; I definitely deserve that like a slap in the face. However, there is no way I'd defend Harry that hard against that many outspoken people. It would have been suicide if I were a wolf. Obviously. What else do I have? not much, I guess.
Also, what are your misgivings about Evie? and if you have some for her and not me, I'm your top suspect, yah? haha
There are a couple things that make me think Evie, one being the refusal to vote last round; another might be the whole "I never lie" conversation between Evie and Putter in Round 3 (?). I agree, Cab's probably human. Not entirely sure about Bobbi, but it would appear she's human now. Longhorn is a question mark; I've not felt any weird vibes from deb, either, but I guess that could happen. Evie is the only solid look I have now.
Look, I really wish I could talk more but I have to be out of here. I won't be back for a while. Consider this my place holder. haha
Edit before I go. I really can't see deb, who has "gone with her gut" all game long, being a wolf at all. That really doesn't make sense to me. I think she's human.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 17:52:38---
GreenApples27 wrote:
ka-ching wrote:
But it remains to be seen how many legs kaching has...
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 18:04:11---
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Thank you for the wonderfully colour coded lists, caberet. They are a great help to see what's been happening in the game.
I'm glad you find them helpful!ka-ching wrote:
There are a couple things that make me think Evie...Not entirely sure about Bobbi, but it would appear she's human now. Longhorn is a question mark; I've not felt any weird vibes from deb, either, but I guess that could happen. Evie is the only solid look I have now...I really can't see deb, who has "gone with her gut" all game long, being a wolf at all. That really doesn't make sense to me. I think she's human.
If ching is a werewolf like I think she is, her drawn out 'clearing' of deb is probably to get us to waste a round shooting deb.But it remains to be seen how many legs kaching has...
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 18:04:11---
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Got to come back.
Look at deb's playing. Let it speak for itself. No, I don't want you to waste a round on her. I want you to avoid shooting her, because I think she's human. I won't ask you to take my word for it; what I will ask of you is that you take a look at what's really going on, whether it's me that said it or not. All I'm concerned about right now is shooting wolves. So far this game, my track record has basically just sucked, but now the process of elimination seems to be making things almost obvious.
Look at deb's playing. Let it speak for itself. No, I don't want you to waste a round on her. I want you to avoid shooting her, because I think she's human. I won't ask you to take my word for it; what I will ask of you is that you take a look at what's really going on, whether it's me that said it or not. All I'm concerned about right now is shooting wolves. So far this game, my track record has basically just sucked, but now the process of elimination seems to be making things almost obvious.
I'm going to go with the Ching vote, just need to be careful about ending the round prematurely. I'd also be willing to go with a Longhorn fan vote if anyone else agrees with my thoughts about her. I'll check back in a while but meanwhile voting Ching.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 18:24:06---
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Well ching over evi? interesting. Evi has not been acting human to me. Ching is hard to get a read on but I find that more suspicious than evi in some ways.
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Like what you love, and love what you got.
I have been thinking between the two all day as I waited for the night to end. I think ching is more dangerous right now. Cab and GA....you guys did not get eaten because you were suspects. To eat you would have cleared you. That would be my thought. EDIT: Thinking on that note it is obvious in the snowmonster vote. She had no suspicion on cab and voted harry. Ching would be my vote in thinking the logic of the kill. I am holding vote to not end round.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 19:44:21---
Like what you love, and love what you got.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 19:44:21---
Like what you love, and love what you got.
hey
well not much activity
i am sticking with evi
edit
won't be on till sometime tomorrow afternoon
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 22:24:35---
This space is intentionally left blank.
well not much activity
i am sticking with evi
edit
won't be on till sometime tomorrow afternoon
---This message was edited on 2011-11-21 22:24:35---
This space is intentionally left blank.
I don't understand how we were both suspects, Longhorn? We shot the wolf... so we should've been eaten... I don't get why we weren't. But I'm not complaining.
So, what I'm getting is that ka-ching thinks Evita and Longhorn, Longhorn thinks Evita and ka-ching, I wonder if Evita thinks it's ka-ching and Longhorn..?
I'm fine with the ka-ching majority. I'm pretty sure she's a wolf, so it's feels good for me.
So, what I'm getting is that ka-ching thinks Evita and Longhorn, Longhorn thinks Evita and ka-ching, I wonder if Evita thinks it's ka-ching and Longhorn..?
I'm fine with the ka-ching majority. I'm pretty sure she's a wolf, so it's feels good for me.
Here are some postings by Smithy that might be significant:
Round 2
Round 3
Nothing is set in stone, I just wanted to point out these postings in case anyone decided to mislead folks next round...
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Round 2
I'm going to vote Evi again, purely because of her perennial near-inactivity despite being on Braingle frequently.
Smithy could NOT have divined Evita R1 because he voted for her. The seer has to divine a different person than they vote for, otherwise the divination blanks out when you hit Save. So the Evita vote was purely a fishRound 3
Not really feeling the vote on Rolu either...but he just seems human this time
He may have divined Rolu. I don't really see why people are voting for Bobbi..,Switching my vote to Putter. I said earlier he isn't suspicious for not being around, but he is suspicious for not contributing when around - he's made three posts this round while contributing barely a thought.
This sounded like he'd divined bradon. Or he'd divined Putter and just had a feeling about bradon?Nothing is set in stone, I just wanted to point out these postings in case anyone decided to mislead folks next round...
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
I believe he had a feeling about Bobbi - if he had divined her as a human then he would've voted rolugomi that round to save Bobbi. And if he had divined rolugomi, he would've voted Bobbi to save rolugomi. So, I conclude he divined neither of them.
Longhorn_fan wrote:
haha On the one hand, if I were a wolf, I'd be dangerous. As a human, I'm not dangerous, in that nobody's going to listen to anything I say for the rest of the game and I can respect that. My record stinks, this game. But you've gotta pull out of this idea of voting for me; you're just wrong.
haha Look at me. I have no defence. This is ridiculous. You've just got to take my word for it, here. As a wolf, I would never let myself get to this pleading and begging stage. It just doesn't work as a game tack.
They were suspects basically only to me. (At least I was the only really outspoken one?) Haha They're really not anymore. REALLY not. So yeah, the eating makes almost perfect sense for me as a wolf. Then again, I think it's too obvious. Anyway. Actually, no, I probably would've eaten Bobbi. Some people were suspecting Snowy (for some odd reason I never fully got), but next to nobody suspected Bobbi. I hope I'm making sense.
I have no defence. haha This is ridiculous.
I have been thinking between the two all day as I waited for the night to end. I think ching is more dangerous right now.
haha On the one hand, if I were a wolf, I'd be dangerous. As a human, I'm not dangerous, in that nobody's going to listen to anything I say for the rest of the game and I can respect that. My record stinks, this game. But you've gotta pull out of this idea of voting for me; you're just wrong.
haha Look at me. I have no defence. This is ridiculous. You've just got to take my word for it, here. As a wolf, I would never let myself get to this pleading and begging stage. It just doesn't work as a game tack.
Cab and GA....you guys did not get eaten because you were suspects. To eat you would have cleared you. That would be my thought.
They were suspects basically only to me. (At least I was the only really outspoken one?) Haha They're really not anymore. REALLY not. So yeah, the eating makes almost perfect sense for me as a wolf. Then again, I think it's too obvious. Anyway. Actually, no, I probably would've eaten Bobbi. Some people were suspecting Snowy (for some odd reason I never fully got), but next to nobody suspected Bobbi. I hope I'm making sense.
I have no defence. haha This is ridiculous.
lol, so, want me to throw the last vote for Ching Ching Ga? no worries i'll wait.
But anyways my vote would be there if it didn't end the round now be nice and don't kill me while i'm not looking :p and Ga... everybody but me could be wolves some are just not as likely as others, like you and Cab are turning pretty unlikely and Ching is very possible... and should she turn out to be human... then both wolves are extremely likely to be out of Lh, Deb, and Bradon, i'd probably go for Lh cause she gives me the least amount of arguments for saying human... but i dunno, anyways consider my vote Ching Chingish
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
But anyways my vote would be there if it didn't end the round now be nice and don't kill me while i'm not looking :p and Ga... everybody but me could be wolves some are just not as likely as others, like you and Cab are turning pretty unlikely and Ching is very possible... and should she turn out to be human... then both wolves are extremely likely to be out of Lh, Deb, and Bradon, i'd probably go for Lh cause she gives me the least amount of arguments for saying human... but i dunno, anyways consider my vote Ching Chingish
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
In my opinoin you can not claim you are human in this game. That is a sure way to get shot.
Evi said I give the least amount of arguements for being human. I am wolf hunting, that should be arguement enough.
Most likely it is not cab as she was very addament about the harry vote. If she is a wolf, that is one nasty wolf to be so gun-ho about throwing another wolf under the bus.
If GA is a wolf then he is spending alot of time trying to "brainwash" us with his thoughts. I would think he is human.
Evi still has some activity levels that concern me. I agree with the votes in that she needs more attention.
Ching is a very likly canidate at this point. I can almost see a wolfish smile comming out in her posts.
Deb, well I am not sure about her. She has been somewhat quiet and some posts have been very uneventful.
Bradon, another one I am not sure of. She does seem to post in a helpful manner but I keep hearing about "bradon, the wolf hunter". After all, this is what caused all the fuss in round one....is that snow voted for her. "why would a human vote for a wolf catcher". Have not seen a line that draws me to that conclusion this game. She did side with me on my suspects last round: Cab, harry, ching, evi, deb. But I know GA was feeling some of these as well.
I did not get much from Smithy's posts as seer. I know one does not just want to come out and say "I am the seer" (cab excluded) haha. In some ways I do not really think he divined any wolfs, except maybe harry. This is why none of his posts were solid....even the one about harry was hard to connect what he was saying.
Still holding vote for time being. Would vote CHING but do not want to end round yet
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Evi said I give the least amount of arguements for being human. I am wolf hunting, that should be arguement enough.
Most likely it is not cab as she was very addament about the harry vote. If she is a wolf, that is one nasty wolf to be so gun-ho about throwing another wolf under the bus.
If GA is a wolf then he is spending alot of time trying to "brainwash" us with his thoughts. I would think he is human.
Evi still has some activity levels that concern me. I agree with the votes in that she needs more attention.
Ching is a very likly canidate at this point. I can almost see a wolfish smile comming out in her posts.
Deb, well I am not sure about her. She has been somewhat quiet and some posts have been very uneventful.
Bradon, another one I am not sure of. She does seem to post in a helpful manner but I keep hearing about "bradon, the wolf hunter". After all, this is what caused all the fuss in round one....is that snow voted for her. "why would a human vote for a wolf catcher". Have not seen a line that draws me to that conclusion this game. She did side with me on my suspects last round: Cab, harry, ching, evi, deb. But I know GA was feeling some of these as well.
I did not get much from Smithy's posts as seer. I know one does not just want to come out and say "I am the seer" (cab excluded) haha. In some ways I do not really think he divined any wolfs, except maybe harry. This is why none of his posts were solid....even the one about harry was hard to connect what he was saying.
Still holding vote for time being. Would vote CHING but do not want to end round yet
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Longhorn_fan wrote:
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
In my opinoin you can not claim you are human in this game. That is a sure way to get shot.
lol, i never said i was definitely cleared, but i may consider myself human when posting my viewpoints, no? i don't have to suspect myself considering the "you are a human" message when i enter the game do i? I am by no means cleared btw, imo you should be more wary if i was MORE active *is somehow always suspected because of her activity level even though it's the same at all roles* :p
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
Longhorn:
Apparently not, since that's been my argument and you still can't seem to get past it. haha
I agree; Cab's probably human. Although the tie last round was between her and Harry. Why wouldn't she prefer he be shot, human or not? I agree that Cab's a human; I don't entirely agree about why we think so. haha
More of a flustered cry of anguish, actually. haha >.-
Deb's pretty much always that way.
Bobbi's at the bottom of the suspect list. Like, as in a last resort, imo. haha
By the way, Green, yeah, interesting triangle we have here; three people pointing at the other two. I guarantee you I'm an innocent one in this. Longhorn and Evie are pointing at each other, so this either is an unspoken scheme (likely to happen) or one of them's human. There is no way they both are human, though. It just can't be.
Evie:
---This message was edited on 2011-11-22 08:53:16---
I am wolf hunting, that should be arguement enough.
Apparently not, since that's been my argument and you still can't seem to get past it. haha
Most likely it is not cab as she was very addament about the harry vote. If she is a wolf, that is one nasty wolf to be so gun-ho about throwing another wolf under the bus.
Ching is a very likly canidate at this point. I can almost see a wolfish smile comming out in her posts.
Ching is a very likly canidate at this point. I can almost see a wolfish smile comming out in her posts.
I agree; Cab's probably human. Although the tie last round was between her and Harry. Why wouldn't she prefer he be shot, human or not? I agree that Cab's a human; I don't entirely agree about why we think so. haha
More of a flustered cry of anguish, actually. haha >.-
Deb's pretty much always that way.
Bobbi's at the bottom of the suspect list. Like, as in a last resort, imo. haha
By the way, Green, yeah, interesting triangle we have here; three people pointing at the other two. I guarantee you I'm an innocent one in this. Longhorn and Evie are pointing at each other, so this either is an unspoken scheme (likely to happen) or one of them's human. There is no way they both are human, though. It just can't be.
Evie:
*is somehow always suspected because of her activity level even though it's the same at all roles* :p
Oh, Evie, so true. hahaha
---This message was edited on 2011-11-22 08:53:16---
Look, I'm double posting for emphasis. Look at this board, here. Make your decision already. If you're going to shoot me, shoot. Why are we waiting around for seven hours? Generating confusion for seven hours isn't the way to win a werewolf game. Everybody's weighed in. No excuses, people. Somebody either pull the trigger or turn the bus around.
I agree with GA's take on Smithy's divinations. I was rethinking my round 1 defense of shooting bradon. But she has done little to no wolf hunting this game. I thought that Smithy had cleared her though, so didn't pursue that avenue. Looks like we have quite a few suspects after all.
Longhorn and bradon both have dismal voting records this game.
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Longhorn and bradon both have dismal voting records this game.
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
You give me too much credit. I wish I were known as a wolf killer, but alas my record is not that great, but I am a wolf hunter, yep, that's what I am. And I believe you are, too, Cab, at least this game you are. And I feel the same about GA, this game now. However, I've been fooled by both of you in the past, but at this stage of the game I'm trying not to second guess myself. My belief at this point is the remaining two wolves are Longhorn fan and Ching. Whether I'm right or wrong, only time will tell. I do agree with Ching, though about one thing. It's time for somebody either pull the trigger or turn the bus around. No real sense in prolonging this that I can see.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
The seer is dead. Everyone who's going to post has posted. Please someone end this round. And wolves, if we've all logged onto Braingle today, please don't make us wait through a long night.
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Ok I am going to pull it. Sorry chingy.
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Holy Lord Its A Miracle
Ching voted to protect Harry surely she was a wolf......Do you guys really think such a whiz of a cook as Ching could have ruined our sweet potatoes...Well Alas
YOU SHOT A HUMAN
Your latest failure has put this game into
MUST LYNCH
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Ching voted to protect Harry surely she was a wolf......Do you guys really think such a whiz of a cook as Ching could have ruined our sweet potatoes...Well Alas
YOU SHOT A HUMAN
Your latest failure has put this game into
MUST LYNCH
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!