The Werewolf Game
Game #2603: WWG: A Thanksgiving Fiasco
This private game is moderated by The_Spider. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 7 rounds.
Ank's dish was never questioned at the dinner table, mainly because he "accidently" brought the wrong kind of mushrooms. He took a few too many......well quite a bit more than a few too many. He spends his days locked up in an asylum, beleiving he is a dolphin space traveller from the future piloting his very own rocket ship.
Before the Lions were even down by 20, four people had excused themselves from the table.
Ankit was NOT the seer
Good Luck
bradon182001 - Pumpkin Pie
caberet - Cranberry Sauce (my favorite)
debc1 - Mashed Potatoes and gravy
Evita - Hard Apple Cider
GreenApples27 - Orange Juice (freshly squeezed)
HarryPutter - Maple Syrup
ka-ching - Candied Sweet Potatoes (my dad makes great Sweet Potatoes)
Longhorn_fan - Rolls
rolugomi - Pudding
Smithy - Alcohol (rather generic but ok)
snowmonster - Corn Casseroles
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 15:22:50---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
Before the Lions were even down by 20, four people had excused themselves from the table.
Ankit was NOT the seer
Good Luck
bradon182001 - Pumpkin Pie
caberet - Cranberry Sauce (my favorite)
debc1 - Mashed Potatoes and gravy
Evita - Hard Apple Cider
GreenApples27 - Orange Juice (freshly squeezed)
HarryPutter - Maple Syrup
ka-ching - Candied Sweet Potatoes (my dad makes great Sweet Potatoes)
Longhorn_fan - Rolls
rolugomi - Pudding
Smithy - Alcohol (rather generic but ok)
snowmonster - Corn Casseroles
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 15:22:50---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
kk I've got a not-so-purely fish vote on Bradon, but nothing serious. I'll pretty much be inactive until my morning, just letting you know.
See my posts last round for any suspicions I do and do not have. Please and thanksyou.
See my posts last round for any suspicions I do and do not have. Please and thanksyou.
Interesting night kill. ankit didn't really suspect anyone. He voted for Harry though.
I am going to vote for someone now, because my Dad is mad at me, and he might not let me back on the computer. So, I am going to put a vote in for Evita. Makes the most sense to me right now.
I am going to vote for someone now, because my Dad is mad at me, and he might not let me back on the computer. So, I am going to put a vote in for Evita. Makes the most sense to me right now.
I'm placing a somewhat fish vote for rolugomi this round. Not "really" suspicious of him, but he started last round by voting for me, and even though he kinda explained why he was voting for me, it was a confusing explanation. Later, he changed his vote to join the majority - which killed a human. Doesn't mean he's a wolf or was acting like a wolf, but for now, I don't really have any solid suspects. I'd like to know what ka-ching means by a not-so-purely fish vote for Bradon. . . . if she's suspecting her, it would be nice to know why. . .
Going out of town tomorrow "Saturday", so if I don't log on this is why. I'll be busy getting ready for the out of town trip, so I'm not sure if I'll be able to get on the computer. So. . . . I won't be posting until Sat. evening/night. . . . I hope I"m not considered inactive - I won't have access to a computer.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Going out of town tomorrow "Saturday", so if I don't log on this is why. I'll be busy getting ready for the out of town trip, so I'm not sure if I'll be able to get on the computer. So. . . . I won't be posting until Sat. evening/night. . . . I hope I"m not considered inactive - I won't have access to a computer.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
I'm starting off against snowie again, until a better option presents itself.
Just love each other
Just love each other
I must say that I'm starting to get leery of bradon. But my Round 1 antics may have helped save her from the dinner table. I'm placing a SPV on someone. Will check back to see who looks wolfie.
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Looks like everybody has their own thing going on and so far no cooperation. None of our hypotheses seem to overlap. C'mon, everybody, teamwork!
Snowy... here:
P.S. I might be able to go for a Rolu vote. Maybe. In a rush. Bye!
Snowy... here:
See my posts last round for any suspicions I do and do not have. Please and thanksyou.
I literally have no time left here, sorry. Look back a round and read what I've said before. I'll catch up to you in the morning.P.S. I might be able to go for a Rolu vote. Maybe. In a rush. Bye!
rolugomi wrote:
Joining the stewie vote. not my first choice but i'd rather there's a definite majority, just in case
I found this post by rolugomi quite strange. (Just in case what?) There was already a 3 vote majority on Stewie when he posted this and placed the 4th vote. No further comments or votes followed his (except Sp[der's reveal that Stewie was human.) I have previously voiced my suspicion of rougomi last round, so this comment did catch my attention. I will be back, so I'm not going to vote just yet, will wait to see what others think
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Joining the stewie vote. not my first choice but i'd rather there's a definite majority, just in case
I found this post by rolugomi quite strange. (Just in case what?) There was already a 3 vote majority on Stewie when he posted this and placed the 4th vote. No further comments or votes followed his (except Sp[der's reveal that Stewie was human.) I have previously voiced my suspicion of rougomi last round, so this comment did catch my attention. I will be back, so I'm not going to vote just yet, will wait to see what others think
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
wow quick night or was there a night??
bobi is talking so i am not suspecting her, but she has honed her skills, so i don't know
don't know about snow/rolo thing
will wait a little
This space is intentionally left blank.
bobi is talking so i am not suspecting her, but she has honed her skills, so i don't know
don't know about snow/rolo thing
will wait a little
This space is intentionally left blank.
I think Rolu meant in case of the vote being hijacked by wolves without a clear majority, or in case of a player contributing greatly ending up shot.
I normally say if we get a couple rounds in without any real suspicions of anyone, there's a good chance a couple of our wolves are laying low. However, whether or not this statement is correct, I've never really bothered to check...
Haven't got time for anything substantial at the moment so just throwing out a fish vote for now, will be back on again in the morning.
I normally say if we get a couple rounds in without any real suspicions of anyone, there's a good chance a couple of our wolves are laying low. However, whether or not this statement is correct, I've never really bothered to check...
Haven't got time for anything substantial at the moment so just throwing out a fish vote for now, will be back on again in the morning.
Just gonna fish for now....
I'll be more active this round
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
I'll be more active this round
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
To your comment about wolves staying low, Smithy, I feel like both rolugomi and HarryPutter have been less vocal and inclusive in the discussions than usual. Not that there are much discussions in this game so far anyway... I think we went backwards after round one.
I definitely think a majority is necessary, to either catch a wolf, or try work out partnerships. What the wolves obviously want is a spread of votes with no real significance. Easier to not clear people that way, or catch wolves. So, why should we give the wolves what they want? Markus stirred the pot in round one, and the wolves got rid of him. Clearly the wolves are opting for a more peaceful win here. And I feel rolugomi and HarryPutter are two that could be playing to that. I also suspect Evita, but my vote is the vote on her right now, and I am looking for a majority.
With all that being said, I am changing to rolugomi.
caberet voted for HarryPutter
GreenApples27 voted for rolugomi
HarryPutter voted for GreenApples27
ka-ching voted for bradon182001
rolugomi voted for snowmonster
Smithy voted for debc1
snowmonster voted for rolugomi
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 00:14:56---
I definitely think a majority is necessary, to either catch a wolf, or try work out partnerships. What the wolves obviously want is a spread of votes with no real significance. Easier to not clear people that way, or catch wolves. So, why should we give the wolves what they want? Markus stirred the pot in round one, and the wolves got rid of him. Clearly the wolves are opting for a more peaceful win here. And I feel rolugomi and HarryPutter are two that could be playing to that. I also suspect Evita, but my vote is the vote on her right now, and I am looking for a majority.
With all that being said, I am changing to rolugomi.
caberet voted for HarryPutter
GreenApples27 voted for rolugomi
HarryPutter voted for GreenApples27
ka-ching voted for bradon182001
rolugomi voted for snowmonster
Smithy voted for debc1
snowmonster voted for rolugomi
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 00:14:56---
Come on, GA. I'd never play the "wolf who lays low" card, I have way too big of an ego for that.
Thinking of a tie...
Feeling pretty certain Chingi is human.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 01:33:53---
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
Thinking of a tie...
Feeling pretty certain Chingi is human.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 01:33:53---
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
I feel Bobbi as human at the moment, based on her posts. She's really the only one I would trust to trust.
My best three guesses for wolves before were rolugomi, Harry and Evita. However, after reviewing round one, that doesn't seem credible, considering HarryPutter contributed to the Evita majority. I just don't see a wolf throwing another wolf under the bus so quickly. So I was going to swap Evita with snowmonster, but then that would contradict rolugomi, since rolugomi went for the snowmonster vote. So I think there's something very wrong with my initial three suspects.
So, I got to thinking what possible teams were, if my two top suspects, rolugomi and Harry, were both wolves. And I couldn't really pick a third member of that group. Of course people like caberet or Longhorn_fan would fit the bill, but there was no one that stood out. So I think maybe only one of these two is a wolf. So... I don't know if I should keep rolugomi in the majority now that I'm having doubts. But, I'm listening to my girl Bobbi ( ) and she's leaning that way, and I'm looking for a majority, and what's better than to go with the one who's suspected by the one person I'm confident is human?
So, rolugomi continues to receive my vote. I won't get on for the rest of the round, so hopefully something good comes of this round... If you end up deciding to turn on me while I sleep (in which case I'll be waiting in the dead talkbox to tut you when you also arrive) then I say look out for rolugomi, Harry, Evita and snowmonster. I think there's a good chance two wolves are in there. Definitely not all three wolves though. But don't turn on me. I think I'm genuinely starting to get somewhere. Give me a little bit more time. Hopefully we get a wolf this round... it'll open a lot more options for us next round.
My best three guesses for wolves before were rolugomi, Harry and Evita. However, after reviewing round one, that doesn't seem credible, considering HarryPutter contributed to the Evita majority. I just don't see a wolf throwing another wolf under the bus so quickly. So I was going to swap Evita with snowmonster, but then that would contradict rolugomi, since rolugomi went for the snowmonster vote. So I think there's something very wrong with my initial three suspects.
So, I got to thinking what possible teams were, if my two top suspects, rolugomi and Harry, were both wolves. And I couldn't really pick a third member of that group. Of course people like caberet or Longhorn_fan would fit the bill, but there was no one that stood out. So I think maybe only one of these two is a wolf. So... I don't know if I should keep rolugomi in the majority now that I'm having doubts. But, I'm listening to my girl Bobbi ( ) and she's leaning that way, and I'm looking for a majority, and what's better than to go with the one who's suspected by the one person I'm confident is human?
So, rolugomi continues to receive my vote. I won't get on for the rest of the round, so hopefully something good comes of this round... If you end up deciding to turn on me while I sleep (in which case I'll be waiting in the dead talkbox to tut you when you also arrive) then I say look out for rolugomi, Harry, Evita and snowmonster. I think there's a good chance two wolves are in there. Definitely not all three wolves though. But don't turn on me. I think I'm genuinely starting to get somewhere. Give me a little bit more time. Hopefully we get a wolf this round... it'll open a lot more options for us next round.
Gotta go with the rolugomi vote, can't shake that feeling and with the exception of HP being extremely quiet (for him) rolu is the only one that I feel is acting "different" than when he is human.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
To be fair to Putter, I don't think he'd intentionally play the inactive wolf, so I don't think his inactivity makes him suspicious. I'm not saying I'm sure he's human, but I don't agree with that particular reasoning.
Not really feeling the vote on Rolu either. Last time I remember playing with him as a wolf, he did seem very "wolfy" throughout (although he managed to survive to the end on his own because we foolishly fell for his early sacrifice of a fellow wolf) - he doesn't seem that way this time. Obviously it's possible he's changed his game, or my radar is off, but he just seems human this time.
Trouble is, I can't really come up with a better alternative. Will go back through the previous two rounds shortly and see if anything comes up.
Not really feeling the vote on Rolu either. Last time I remember playing with him as a wolf, he did seem very "wolfy" throughout (although he managed to survive to the end on his own because we foolishly fell for his early sacrifice of a fellow wolf) - he doesn't seem that way this time. Obviously it's possible he's changed his game, or my radar is off, but he just seems human this time.
Trouble is, I can't really come up with a better alternative. Will go back through the previous two rounds shortly and see if anything comes up.
rolu does sound interesting, but I am also questioning harry's inactivity and also evi's. It is odd that they are not posting anything solid and thoughtful. Smithy is very "I don't know" but I don't see that as weird, persay. I do feel strongly about forming a majority though so on that quote I will vote rolu.
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Like what you love, and love what you got.
Nope nope nope. Not feeling Harry to be a wolf at all. He's be taking charge a whole lot more.
Rolu... oh, that's tough call. Kinda could feel it, kinda could not. I'd rather go for Bradon, actually. She's relatively quiet. Not quite timid, absolutely not, but not.... as boisterous as she could be? (excuse inaccurate wording; I just woke up.)
Uhm, what else, what else? Oh, yeah, Green's team strategy. Not a bad idea, but I think you'll be chasing your tail if you try to do that. I think all the players here know better than to be obvious with alliances as wolves.
Gotta run for now. Catch up again soonish, I hope. It's Saturday; who knows?
Rolu... oh, that's tough call. Kinda could feel it, kinda could not. I'd rather go for Bradon, actually. She's relatively quiet. Not quite timid, absolutely not, but not.... as boisterous as she could be? (excuse inaccurate wording; I just woke up.)
Uhm, what else, what else? Oh, yeah, Green's team strategy. Not a bad idea, but I think you'll be chasing your tail if you try to do that. I think all the players here know better than to be obvious with alliances as wolves.
Gotta run for now. Catch up again soonish, I hope. It's Saturday; who knows?
Well look at that, people finally start to actually play and come up with majorities and suspects, and the majority ends up being on me.
I'll try to address any possible suspicions against me now.
1. Inactive. As I've learned through playing games, I'm a very good wolf-hunter.....at times. Why? I need activity, to form opinions on people, see patterns and possible plans. There hasn't been much of that. Also I need to see the activity as it occurs, so I can keep up with it. I have trouble reading through a whole round. I haven't been able to come up with many suspects, so I haven't been saying much.
2. On another note, once I think I may have found a wolf, I become stubborn about that. In this case my suspect is snowmonster. If we were both to remain in the game, I would probably vote her again and again until a better suspect came up or my suspicions proved wrong. Do I have evidence? No, just a feeling, which is why my argument sounds so weak.
So, GA, you say you want a majority? Why not snow?
Regarding ching's new post, I could go with a bradon majority too, so that's my vote.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 09:11:02---
Just love each other
I'll try to address any possible suspicions against me now.
1. Inactive. As I've learned through playing games, I'm a very good wolf-hunter.....at times. Why? I need activity, to form opinions on people, see patterns and possible plans. There hasn't been much of that. Also I need to see the activity as it occurs, so I can keep up with it. I have trouble reading through a whole round. I haven't been able to come up with many suspects, so I haven't been saying much.
2. On another note, once I think I may have found a wolf, I become stubborn about that. In this case my suspect is snowmonster. If we were both to remain in the game, I would probably vote her again and again until a better suspect came up or my suspicions proved wrong. Do I have evidence? No, just a feeling, which is why my argument sounds so weak.
So, GA, you say you want a majority? Why not snow?
Regarding ching's new post, I could go with a bradon majority too, so that's my vote.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 09:11:02---
Just love each other
i would post something like that Lh, i just don't have any right now, and i can't pull myself together to think because i'm sick anyways, i don't think Harry would be this inactive as a wolf, i'd be more worried if he was overactive :p Rolu's a possibility, and i'm getting biased against Ga cause he's after me :p (which from my view means i know he's hunting a human), anyways i'll be back later to vote (no voting me for not voting please, i'll be here i promise)
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
Rolugomi, you're asking GA to form a majority on me, going by your "feeling". That's asking a lot from anyone. I voted for you, for my own reasons. I felt you weren't explaining your vote for me enough - and I never asked anyone to join in to form a majority against you. So, if you get shot, and you end up being human, let's see who jumped in to take you down. . . could be other humans, could be wolves, but it would be something to consider. If it's true that you're stubborn once you have a suspect, then I suppose that's good enough reason to vote for me. I accept that. I've seen others with that same mentality. . .. they fixate on one person, are convinced they are a wolf, and will not vote for anyone else. I get it. . . . not my style of playing, but I get that it is a style others go with. More than not though, they are wrong, like in this case. Can't prove that I'm human. . . . and of course, I know you cannot just take my word.
If you're trying to convince others to form a majority on me, then I have no other choice but to keep my vote on you. I won't be around later - so I have no control (LOL) over how others may vote or change their vote. So, I may be shot when I return. . . . . that's fine. But I will stress, I am human. If you're going to form a majority on me, or anyone else - and that includes rolugomi, at least have something more than a feeling. He's a good player, as I. I'm not the best, but I'm active and I try my best. I believe most to all in this game do as well. I say most, because I'm not familiar with everyone here.
Cheers - and have a great Saturday folks!
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 09:28:37---
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
If you're trying to convince others to form a majority on me, then I have no other choice but to keep my vote on you. I won't be around later - so I have no control (LOL) over how others may vote or change their vote. So, I may be shot when I return. . . . . that's fine. But I will stress, I am human. If you're going to form a majority on me, or anyone else - and that includes rolugomi, at least have something more than a feeling. He's a good player, as I. I'm not the best, but I'm active and I try my best. I believe most to all in this game do as well. I say most, because I'm not familiar with everyone here.
Cheers - and have a great Saturday folks!
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 09:28:37---
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
morning
going with evi this round - quite until someone says something about her
This space is intentionally left blank.
going with evi this round - quite until someone says something about her
This space is intentionally left blank.
Snow I've changed my vote away from you, and thinking it through more I think I suspected you on the basis of your so sure defense of bradon, who seems more wolfish now, especially considering her last post.
She said I'm playing different, but I honestly don't think we've played enough games together for her to for that opinion.
Just love each other
She said I'm playing different, but I honestly don't think we've played enough games together for her to for that opinion.
Just love each other
Haha Fixation is the word for Rolu. I've never seen a more insistent player. On one hand, Rolu's style is very very different from mine (that "predatory" instinct about it), but on the other, (the feeling stuff through posts rather than... analytical logic) he's totally up my alley.
Anyway, I didn't come here to talk about Rolu's playing style.
Not excited about a snowmonster vote, either, but then again, I'm not as experienced with her and I'm definitely having a hard time getting used to her play. Still think Bradon's the way to go if we've got to pick somebody other than Rolu. Debating, though, whether or not just to go with the majority. It's not quite too late to change, but it's unlikely. Keeping tabs on the game in the last hours.
deb, if you knew Evie, you'd know that's exactly the way she plays, especially as a human. I was a wolf with her in our last game together; this doesn't make me an expert, but I don't see wolf in her at this point. Not atall.
haha Rolu. So why not just go the more direct route and shoot Bradon, THEN make that call on Snowy?
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 10:37:17---
Anyway, I didn't come here to talk about Rolu's playing style.
Not excited about a snowmonster vote, either, but then again, I'm not as experienced with her and I'm definitely having a hard time getting used to her play. Still think Bradon's the way to go if we've got to pick somebody other than Rolu. Debating, though, whether or not just to go with the majority. It's not quite too late to change, but it's unlikely. Keeping tabs on the game in the last hours.
deb, if you knew Evie, you'd know that's exactly the way she plays, especially as a human. I was a wolf with her in our last game together; this doesn't make me an expert, but I don't see wolf in her at this point. Not atall.
haha Rolu. So why not just go the more direct route and shoot Bradon, THEN make that call on Snowy?
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 10:37:17---
Switching my vote to bradon
bradon182001 voted for rolugomi
caberet voted for HarryPutter
debc1 voted for Evita
GreenApples27 voted for rolugomi
HarryPutter voted for bradon182001
ka-ching voted for bradon182001
Longhorn_fan voted for rolugomi
rolugomi voted for bradon182001
Smithy voted for debc1
snowmonster voted for rolugomi
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
bradon182001 voted for rolugomi
caberet voted for HarryPutter
debc1 voted for Evita
GreenApples27 voted for rolugomi
HarryPutter voted for bradon182001
ka-ching voted for bradon182001
Longhorn_fan voted for rolugomi
rolugomi voted for bradon182001
Smithy voted for debc1
snowmonster voted for rolugomi
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
Listen to Ching Ching she's smart i'll put a vote on Bradon in order to tie the majorities
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
rolugomi wrote:
I DID NOT defend Bradon and suggest she was human. I simply got hammered for placing a random fish vote for her. . . . In fact, if you go look, I even asked Caberet why she was so sure Bobby was human. . . . Bobby could very well be a Wolf. I think, if you want to look at anyone that was defending Bradon, you should look at Caberet. She stressed how good a wolf hunter Bradon was. . . . she is the one that had a fit because I voted for her. . . So, please do not state that I was in defense of Bobby! Don't twist this around. . . . . If bobby is a wolf, then she's a wolf! If you guys feel she is, then go for it! And this is not to get bradon shot - I'm just saying, you guys need to go with what you have - if anyone is looking wolfish, etc. then go for it. This post of yours rolugomi, makes me wonder even more about you.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Snow I've changed my vote away from you, and thinking it through more I think I suspected you on the basis of your so sure defense of bradon, who seems more wolfish now, especially considering her last post.
She said I'm playing different, but I honestly don't think we've played enough games together for her to for that opinion.
She said I'm playing different, but I honestly don't think we've played enough games together for her to for that opinion.
I DID NOT defend Bradon and suggest she was human. I simply got hammered for placing a random fish vote for her. . . . In fact, if you go look, I even asked Caberet why she was so sure Bobby was human. . . . Bobby could very well be a Wolf. I think, if you want to look at anyone that was defending Bradon, you should look at Caberet. She stressed how good a wolf hunter Bradon was. . . . she is the one that had a fit because I voted for her. . . So, please do not state that I was in defense of Bobby! Don't twist this around. . . . . If bobby is a wolf, then she's a wolf! If you guys feel she is, then go for it! And this is not to get bradon shot - I'm just saying, you guys need to go with what you have - if anyone is looking wolfish, etc. then go for it. This post of yours rolugomi, makes me wonder even more about you.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
Snow hardly defended bradon - unless they're both wolves and snow placed an early vote on a fellow wolf to 'clear' her in case one or the other was later shot and IDed.
Yes, I did make a deal about the early vote. It was originally just a pseudo-justification for an almost fish vote. But then snows responses were (to me) very suspicious. She seemed to be taking a more arrogant tome than I can remember usually associating with her postings. So I stayed on her and made a fuss. The majority turned away from her late in the round after she finally started sounding like her usual self.
Don't know if the above makes snow a wolf or not. Or bradon a wolf or not.
My suspicions as to the wolves can be summed up as:
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Yes, I did make a deal about the early vote. It was originally just a pseudo-justification for an almost fish vote. But then snows responses were (to me) very suspicious. She seemed to be taking a more arrogant tome than I can remember usually associating with her postings. So I stayed on her and made a fuss. The majority turned away from her late in the round after she finally started sounding like her usual self.
Don't know if the above makes snow a wolf or not. Or bradon a wolf or not.
My suspicions as to the wolves can be summed up as:
"I discovered I scream the same whether I'm about to be devoured by a Great White or if a piece of seaweed touches my foot." Axl Rose
Oh, is THAT what Rolu was talking about? haha I thought I had missed some innocuous sentence in one of Snowy's previous posts or something. Nah, I think that whole Round 1 instance was blown dreadfully out of proportion. If anybody was acting suspiciously, I'd say it would have been Cab, but I still lean human on her anyway.
rolugomi wrote:
Just so you all recall my last post:
bradon182001 wrote:
I do believe rolugomi is not playing as he has in the past when he was human, but he is right, we haven't played that many games together, and I don't think he was ever a wolf in the games we did share. That's why his play so far has caught my attention.
However if you guys want to go ahead and shoot me, then so be it. I'm not a wolf, and Spider will reveal that if I'm shot, but I would suggest (recommend, really) that you take a close look at who started the ball rolling against me. For a "not-so-purely fish vote" Ching is pretty insistent. And to say I'm not as boisterous as I normally am is a weak excuse for getting me shot. I would like to see a human win, but shooting me isn't going to achieve that.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Snow I've changed my vote away from you, and thinking it through more I think I suspected you on the basis of your so sure defense of bradon, who seems more wolfish now, especially considering her last post.
She said I'm playing different, but I honestly don't think we've played enough games together for her to for that opinion.
She said I'm playing different, but I honestly don't think we've played enough games together for her to for that opinion.
Just so you all recall my last post:
bradon182001 wrote:
Gotta go with the rolugomi vote, can't shake that feeling and with the exception of HP being extremely quiet (for him) rolu is the only one that I feel is acting "different" than when he is human.
I do believe rolugomi is not playing as he has in the past when he was human, but he is right, we haven't played that many games together, and I don't think he was ever a wolf in the games we did share. That's why his play so far has caught my attention.
However if you guys want to go ahead and shoot me, then so be it. I'm not a wolf, and Spider will reveal that if I'm shot, but I would suggest (recommend, really) that you take a close look at who started the ball rolling against me. For a "not-so-purely fish vote" Ching is pretty insistent. And to say I'm not as boisterous as I normally am is a weak excuse for getting me shot. I would like to see a human win, but shooting me isn't going to achieve that.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Sorry if I seamed arrogant. . . but when someone is blasted for a fish vote, and basically called out to be a wolf simply for that reason, I think anyone would get defensive. Arrogant. . . . . . that's fine if that's how you viewed my posts. If I WAS arrogant - at least it was in defending myself, and not in attacking anothers fish vote.
At this point, I have a few people I suspect as wolves and a few I really feel are human. But I have no proof, and my gut feeling on these players isn't strong enough for me to share yet.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
At this point, I have a few people I suspect as wolves and a few I really feel are human. But I have no proof, and my gut feeling on these players isn't strong enough for me to share yet.
Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love.
I think I like dis.
Either way, we'll know something pretty good. Imo.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 12:57:25---
Day
It takes 6 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
bradon182001 voted for rolugomi
caberet voted for HarryPutter
debc1 voted for Evita
Evita voted for bradon182001
GreenApples27 voted for rolugomi
HarryPutter voted for bradon182001
ka-ching voted for bradon182001
Longhorn_fan voted for rolugomi
rolugomi voted for bradon182001
Smithy voted for debc1
snowmonster voted for rolugomi
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
It takes 6 votes to select someone to be shot with the silver bullet.
bradon182001 voted for rolugomi
caberet voted for HarryPutter
debc1 voted for Evita
Evita voted for bradon182001
GreenApples27 voted for rolugomi
HarryPutter voted for bradon182001
ka-ching voted for bradon182001
Longhorn_fan voted for rolugomi
rolugomi voted for bradon182001
Smithy voted for debc1
snowmonster voted for rolugomi
Nobody has been shot with the silver bullet yet.
Either way, we'll know something pretty good. Imo.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 12:57:25---
I don't really see why people are voting for Bobbi. As far as I can see, the only reasoning against her this round is the not-exactly-watertight "She's relatively quiet. Not quite timid, absolutely not, but not.... as boisterous as she could be? " I'd say Bobbi usually slips into the "active but not bossing things" role.
EDIT: Switching my vote to Putter. I said earlier he isn't suspicious for not being around, but he is suspicious for not contributing when around - he's made three posts this round while contributing barely a thought.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 13:55:40---
EDIT: Switching my vote to Putter. I said earlier he isn't suspicious for not being around, but he is suspicious for not contributing when around - he's made three posts this round while contributing barely a thought.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 13:55:40---
well evi might very well play like that either way its no biggie
i will wait to see how this bobi/rolo/snow thing shakes out
This space is intentionally left blank.
i will wait to see how this bobi/rolo/snow thing shakes out
This space is intentionally left blank.
Smithy wrote:
If either bradon or rolu is shot, it'll tell us what we need to know and we can make inferences based on that, which is why I pushed for the tie. I thought that went without saying Apparently not.
Plus I haven't been paying attention till this round, so I don't have much to go on yet. Patience, Smithy.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 14:22:56---
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
EDIT: Switching my vote to Putter. I said earlier he isn't suspicious for not being around, but he is suspicious for not contributing when around - he's made three posts this round while contributing barely a thought.
If either bradon or rolu is shot, it'll tell us what we need to know and we can make inferences based on that, which is why I pushed for the tie. I thought that went without saying Apparently not.
Plus I haven't been paying attention till this round, so I don't have much to go on yet. Patience, Smithy.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 14:22:56---
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
Btw Harri, are we on the same team this time or are you a wolf? if we're finally on the same team it's a miracle
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
What if we're both human?
Or all three of us?
If it comes to finding someone who's posted but is laying low, just waiting to see what happens and not making any decisions, debc1 is a good suspect too.
Just love each other
Or all three of us?
If it comes to finding someone who's posted but is laying low, just waiting to see what happens and not making any decisions, debc1 is a good suspect too.
Just love each other
I hope you're telling the truth, Evi
Well if one or both of you is human, we can start probing those who started the majorities more (that doesn't necessarily mean who got the first vote) and it'll give us somewhere to start. Reading over the past couple rounds, I haven't found much to work with yet. All I'm saying is at least give me a chance to contribute before you shoot me for not contributing.
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
Well if one or both of you is human, we can start probing those who started the majorities more (that doesn't necessarily mean who got the first vote) and it'll give us somewhere to start. Reading over the past couple rounds, I haven't found much to work with yet. All I'm saying is at least give me a chance to contribute before you shoot me for not contributing.
Index for WW/WTB databases - https://ksteven.github.io/playground/ (Data refreshed: 2021-12-07)
HarryPutter wrote:
The tie is irrelevant, either way you will have one piece of information to work with. I think if anything ties give less information because it brings into play another variable, whether or not players would be willing to take 50-50 risks, as well as giving people an excuse for not offering any reasoning or insight with their votes. Besides I was talking about your contribution this round, not speculating on future rounds, although I realised after my vote that you do usually start slowly. The vote's pretty harmless at this stage.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 15:01:37---
If either bradon or rolu is shot, it'll tell us what we need to know and we can make inferences based on that, which is why I pushed for the tie. I thought that went without saying Apparently not.
The tie is irrelevant, either way you will have one piece of information to work with. I think if anything ties give less information because it brings into play another variable, whether or not players would be willing to take 50-50 risks, as well as giving people an excuse for not offering any reasoning or insight with their votes. Besides I was talking about your contribution this round, not speculating on future rounds, although I realised after my vote that you do usually start slowly. The vote's pretty harmless at this stage.
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 15:01:37---
HarryPutter wrote:
If either bradon or rolu is shot, it'll tell us what we need to know and we can make inferences based on that, which is why I pushed for the tie. I thought that went without saying Apparently not.
Thing is, if you shoot me, you shoot a human, that's what it will tell you, and if you are human, I don't think you want to keep shooting other humans, right? Just saying...
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
If either bradon or rolu is shot, it'll tell us what we need to know and we can make inferences based on that, which is why I pushed for the tie. I thought that went without saying Apparently not.
Thing is, if you shoot me, you shoot a human, that's what it will tell you, and if you are human, I don't think you want to keep shooting other humans, right? Just saying...
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
HarryPutter wrote:
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
I hope you're telling the truth, Evi
i never lie
It's when you draw it you realize what it really looks like
The dwindling guests had hatched an idea. Perhaps the foods just arnt poorly prepared, but deliberatly tainted. It was Rolu who was rather fesity at the dinner table, perhaps he has an ulterior and bitter motive for coming to this feast. What better food to contaminate than the dessert, so that one must simply say he is full and be at no risk. They tossed Rolu from the table and demanded he never come back. A small helping of his dubious pudding remained. As they say, the proof is in the pudding and what they learned was this, Rolu meant no harm.
The guests fidgeted nervously, for three good dishes have been removed from the feast, and the Werewolfs, stood at full strength
YOU SHOT A HUMAN
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 15:46:24---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
The guests fidgeted nervously, for three good dishes have been removed from the feast, and the Werewolfs, stood at full strength
YOU SHOT A HUMAN
---This message was edited on 2011-11-19 15:46:24---
Can you imagine what I would do if I could do all I can - Sun Tzu
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!