The Werewolf Game
Game #3113: C&I(XXXII) Heart and Soul
This private game is moderated by StewieGriffin. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 8 rounds.
RFM
Thanks Hydra. cab was a good ol fashioned in yo face with a can of mace, make you cry all around the place Cowboy/human.
Better luck this time.
Fixed it, thanks for the correction Radio. My bad everyone.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 13:43:56---
All fields of science are just applied physics.
Thanks Hydra. cab was a good ol fashioned in yo face with a can of mace, make you cry all around the place Cowboy/human.
Better luck this time.
Fixed it, thanks for the correction Radio. My bad everyone.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 13:43:56---
All fields of science are just applied physics.
Was inactive. Don't know how, but the email notifications were turned off. So anyways, SPV
All fields of science are just applied physics.
All fields of science are just applied physics.
I thought Cowboys were the good guys. SPV for now.
I will now resume lurking silently.
I will now resume lurking silently.
Wow - Bobbi was one of the people at the top of my list and Cab was human as well...
That leaves 7 of us left with 2 being the wolves and our Seer must still be in the game since Stewie has not said otherwise. Stewie, can you confirm that our Seer is still alive?
My thoughts based on comments, defensiveness, and votings:
cccgirl - human
Radio - human
frog - (me) I know I'm human
Habs - human (?) due to the argument between her and ziggy a now known wolf but that could have been staged?
cat -?
Hydra - ?
Scrub - ?
Just my list but I've been wrong lots of times!
Edit: fixed spelling error.
Not much to go on and no flags to me. I'm going to wait until more have posted to see if anyone has any thoughts on who may be a wolf. Kind of thinking of Scrub for my vote, but not sure and it is getting down to where we humans have to get it right.
Back later.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 12:56:12---
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
That leaves 7 of us left with 2 being the wolves and our Seer must still be in the game since Stewie has not said otherwise. Stewie, can you confirm that our Seer is still alive?
My thoughts based on comments, defensiveness, and votings:
cccgirl - human
Radio - human
frog - (me) I know I'm human
Habs - human (?) due to the argument between her and ziggy a now known wolf but that could have been staged?
cat -?
Hydra - ?
Scrub - ?
Just my list but I've been wrong lots of times!
Edit: fixed spelling error.
Not much to go on and no flags to me. I'm going to wait until more have posted to see if anyone has any thoughts on who may be a wolf. Kind of thinking of Scrub for my vote, but not sure and it is getting down to where we humans have to get it right.
Back later.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 12:56:12---
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
First off, my sincere apologies for missing last round, which is uncharacteristic of me. I was at a hotel at an event, and only had my phone, which would NOT log into the site properly for some reason.
That said, SPV'ing for Scrub for now. I want to catch up and re-read the rounds, then hopefully do some analysis.
That said, SPV'ing for Scrub for now. I want to catch up and re-read the rounds, then hopefully do some analysis.
The seer is still in the game. Unless I state the seer's ID, i haven't yet. The seer is still in the game, that won't change, it has not changed in eight years and i won't change now.
Stewie.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 13:53:45---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
Stewie.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 13:53:45---
"If you wish to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first invent the universe." Carl Sagan
Scrub, please explain your last post of last round when I asked you why you suspected Radio guy and you said
[quote]not radioguy. He is who cab voted for. I am more interested in the people voting Cab.[/quote]
Yet you voted scrub and prior to doing so stated
[quoteRead through everything. I am changing to radioguy.[/quote].
So which is it? You suspect him or you don't? If you do why? Voting cab does not a wolf make.
And no, my squabble with zig was not a set up. I just thought her reason for voting for me was ridiculous. She way over reacted to what I said and began to twist it around. Like I said at that point I begin to suspect she may be a wolf but did not want to place what would look like a retaliatory vote.
I am leaning Scrub or Hydra at this point.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
[quote]not radioguy. He is who cab voted for. I am more interested in the people voting Cab.[/quote]
Yet you voted scrub and prior to doing so stated
[quoteRead through everything. I am changing to radioguy.[/quote].
So which is it? You suspect him or you don't? If you do why? Voting cab does not a wolf make.
And no, my squabble with zig was not a set up. I just thought her reason for voting for me was ridiculous. She way over reacted to what I said and began to twist it around. Like I said at that point I begin to suspect she may be a wolf but did not want to place what would look like a retaliatory vote.
I am leaning Scrub or Hydra at this point.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
Thanks for the confirmation about the Seer, Stewie.
I'm probably going to vote for Scrub but I want to give him the chance to post first. When I check back, if he hasn't posted, I'm going to vote SPV for him.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
I'm probably going to vote for Scrub but I want to give him the chance to post first. When I check back, if he hasn't posted, I'm going to vote SPV for him.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
Why you keep on voting me HABS?
All fields of science are just applied physics.
All fields of science are just applied physics.
Hydra1234 wrote:
Well, you are one of two possibilities on her list. It could be you are more suspicious to her, or perhaps she has another reason not to vote for scrub. Food for thought.
The currently most suspicious person on my list is scrub, for the repeated instances of statement and actual vote not agreeing. One or possibly twice, I could chalk it up to simple mistakes. But to see this so regularly is quite interesting.
Now finally, keeping very recent previous games in mind, while I appreciate Froggy's assurances that I am human (good call, thanks), I do not consider them sufficient enough to write her off as a human. She makes it very easy to trust her, regardless of true identity. No immediate suspicions, but I am stating my thoughts to encourage all players to not forget that outside of an emphatic declaration from a Seer, there is no reason to clear anyone of suspicion out of "gut feelings." I only used Froggy as an example in light of her well proven skills at being easily trustworthy (which is to her credit), and her recent statement of trust that I am a human as well. I certainly am a human, but only take a Seer's word for it.
For the time being, I am keeping my eye on Scrub. I will change my vote to him if he does not soon reply. I see that he is apparently online (or has been recently), so perhaps I won't have too long to wait.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 17:00:24---
I will now resume lurking silently.
Why you keep on voting me HABS?
Well, you are one of two possibilities on her list. It could be you are more suspicious to her, or perhaps she has another reason not to vote for scrub. Food for thought.
The currently most suspicious person on my list is scrub, for the repeated instances of statement and actual vote not agreeing. One or possibly twice, I could chalk it up to simple mistakes. But to see this so regularly is quite interesting.
Now finally, keeping very recent previous games in mind, while I appreciate Froggy's assurances that I am human (good call, thanks), I do not consider them sufficient enough to write her off as a human. She makes it very easy to trust her, regardless of true identity. No immediate suspicions, but I am stating my thoughts to encourage all players to not forget that outside of an emphatic declaration from a Seer, there is no reason to clear anyone of suspicion out of "gut feelings." I only used Froggy as an example in light of her well proven skills at being easily trustworthy (which is to her credit), and her recent statement of trust that I am a human as well. I certainly am a human, but only take a Seer's word for it.
For the time being, I am keeping my eye on Scrub. I will change my vote to him if he does not soon reply. I see that he is apparently online (or has been recently), so perhaps I won't have too long to wait.
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 17:00:24---
I will now resume lurking silently.
Hydra1234 wrote:
Because your posts make no sense! You are going to join the majority? Really? Any wolf can pile on. What do you decide when there is nobody. That is the question.
For me, I am looking closely at who piled on to the snow/cab vote, which ended up between two humans. This still leads me to Cat.
Why you keep on voting me HABS?
Because your posts make no sense! You are going to join the majority? Really? Any wolf can pile on. What do you decide when there is nobody. That is the question.
For me, I am looking closely at who piled on to the snow/cab vote, which ended up between two humans. This still leads me to Cat.
I an the seer. I divined Snow, cccgirl, cab and HABS. Cccgirl is human. HABS is wolf. Good luck guys. Wish I could have made it to the end.
Hmm, theory time! I'm going to assume that different people are the Seer, and see what conclusions can possibly be determined. The point of this is to analyze posts and voting records in the light of a said person being the Seer, and see if it conclusively implicates anyone of being a wolf. Consistently directed votes at an individual after the first round would be a good thing to find.
1. Habs is the Seer
This possibility is intriguing, but doesn't seem conclusive. The majority of her votes have been Hydra (interesting), but any time she voted for someone else her stated reason was either an "SPV" or a "gut" feeling. In every case of not voting Hydra, her vote has been for someone who has been confirmed as human since. If she is the Seer, then she must have the misfortune of divining people who get eaten quite often. In which case, it's possible the only wolf she has divined thus far would be Hydra.
2. Catmandon is the Seer
There is little evidence for this. His votes have consistently been majorities for humans, with the exceptions of the Spider (who was eaten) and zig (a wolf). He has been very sparse in posting, often withholding a vote until identities are confirmed. This could be the behavior of a Seer who is trying to mask his identity, but so far his voting patterns and reasons for voting haven't been very Seer-like. If he is a wolf, then the vote for zig could have been strategic to avert suspicion. But then again, he didn't vote for zig in the round that zig was shot...
3. cccgirl is the Seer
Hmm... Not much here. Her voting has been fairly random, and she did not vote last round. Her posts make little indication of having any particular suspicions for anyone. She even expressed surprise at zig being a wolf. Not very Seer-like, again. (My suspicions for her are increased slightly)
4. Hydra is the Seer
Well well well. It's not an unheard of tactic for a Seer to be a bit vague and sometimes confusing in posts, but that's a poor tactic as it would make such a person an easy suspicion for wolf. It is interesting to observe that with only one exception, everyone Hydra has voted for thus far is still in the game. He seems to have made it a point in most cases to avoid majorities, and has drawn attention for the one time he joined a majority. If he is the Seer, his posts give little guidance as to who is a likely suspect for being a wolf.
5. I am the Seer?
Well if I were the Seer, I'd admit to being a poor one. So far my votes have either been SPVs or reactions to suspicious behavior. I didn't even vote for zig, allowing instead for the computer to arbitrate the three way tie. It was fortunate to say the least that a wolf was shot. I have also not expressed any suspicion at anyone in particular other than for obviously suspicious activity, aside from the reminder in my previous post for everyone not to just accept anyone as Human because they are easy to trust (no hard feelings, Froggy. I can't help that you're a great example of someone easy to trust). So if I am the Seer, the only thing I can emphatically state is that Radioguy is not a wolf. That sort of makes me wish I were the Seer, but I'd hope not to be so poor at finding the wolves if I were.
6. Scrub is the Seer
Not getting much here. His voting and posting have been confusing and contradictory, and other than for myself for a vague reason, his votes since the first round have been for whoviandeb, who was recently eaten. Honestly, I'm getting more of a wolf vibe from him. If he is the Seer, then yikes.
scrub88 wrote (emphasis added):
-------------
So there we have it. My impressions of the game interpreted through the possibility of any given person being the Seer. Take it or leave it, but hopefully this may foster some intelligent discussion. May the wolves be found and eliminated. The humans need to win a game for once in a while.
EDIT: Fixed formatting
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 17:38:42---
I will now resume lurking silently.
1. Habs is the Seer
This possibility is intriguing, but doesn't seem conclusive. The majority of her votes have been Hydra (interesting), but any time she voted for someone else her stated reason was either an "SPV" or a "gut" feeling. In every case of not voting Hydra, her vote has been for someone who has been confirmed as human since. If she is the Seer, then she must have the misfortune of divining people who get eaten quite often. In which case, it's possible the only wolf she has divined thus far would be Hydra.
2. Catmandon is the Seer
There is little evidence for this. His votes have consistently been majorities for humans, with the exceptions of the Spider (who was eaten) and zig (a wolf). He has been very sparse in posting, often withholding a vote until identities are confirmed. This could be the behavior of a Seer who is trying to mask his identity, but so far his voting patterns and reasons for voting haven't been very Seer-like. If he is a wolf, then the vote for zig could have been strategic to avert suspicion. But then again, he didn't vote for zig in the round that zig was shot...
3. cccgirl is the Seer
Hmm... Not much here. Her voting has been fairly random, and she did not vote last round. Her posts make little indication of having any particular suspicions for anyone. She even expressed surprise at zig being a wolf. Not very Seer-like, again. (My suspicions for her are increased slightly)
4. Hydra is the Seer
Well well well. It's not an unheard of tactic for a Seer to be a bit vague and sometimes confusing in posts, but that's a poor tactic as it would make such a person an easy suspicion for wolf. It is interesting to observe that with only one exception, everyone Hydra has voted for thus far is still in the game. He seems to have made it a point in most cases to avoid majorities, and has drawn attention for the one time he joined a majority. If he is the Seer, his posts give little guidance as to who is a likely suspect for being a wolf.
5. I am the Seer?
Well if I were the Seer, I'd admit to being a poor one. So far my votes have either been SPVs or reactions to suspicious behavior. I didn't even vote for zig, allowing instead for the computer to arbitrate the three way tie. It was fortunate to say the least that a wolf was shot. I have also not expressed any suspicion at anyone in particular other than for obviously suspicious activity, aside from the reminder in my previous post for everyone not to just accept anyone as Human because they are easy to trust (no hard feelings, Froggy. I can't help that you're a great example of someone easy to trust). So if I am the Seer, the only thing I can emphatically state is that Radioguy is not a wolf. That sort of makes me wish I were the Seer, but I'd hope not to be so poor at finding the wolves if I were.
6. Scrub is the Seer
Not getting much here. His voting and posting have been confusing and contradictory, and other than for myself for a vague reason, his votes since the first round have been for whoviandeb, who was recently eaten. Honestly, I'm getting more of a wolf vibe from him. If he is the Seer, then yikes.
scrub88 wrote (emphasis added):
For me, I am looking closely at who piled on to the snow/cab vote, which ended up between two humans. This still leads me to Cat.
Huh. You've never voted for catmandon before, nor expressed much suspicion in him. Maybe you could be the seer, but this statement is as confusing as has been your trademark this game. How can you say you are "still" being led to catmandon if you've never apparently been lead to him before? On the other hand... maybe you are the Seer after all... I'm confused now. But for now, I am still more suspicious of you as a wolf. Let the discussion ensue! This will be interesting...-------------
So there we have it. My impressions of the game interpreted through the possibility of any given person being the Seer. Take it or leave it, but hopefully this may foster some intelligent discussion. May the wolves be found and eliminated. The humans need to win a game for once in a while.
EDIT: Fixed formatting
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 17:38:42---
I will now resume lurking silently.
scrub88 wrote:
What, wait a minute. I've been ninja'd. So, scrub is claiming to be the Seer now. This does make things interesting. If HABS is really a wolf (very interesting indeed!), then that would leave Hydra, catmandon or Froggy as the final wolf, assuming my innocence (which I must assume, honestly). Among the three, Hydra has been the most confusing, but also has been the most voted by HABS. This would make catmandon a likely possibility, coinciding with scrub's comment. Very, very interesting
EDIT: Okay, I'll vote for HABS now. The only possibilities are that scrub is telling the truth (and will be eaten), or he will survive as a clear wolf. The only other possibility is that the remaining wolf won't take him out, just hoping to throw suspicion on him. However, that is risky to the point of suicidal. Would be a gutsy move for a wolf, but would likely end the game real fast in humanity's favor. I like this thought...
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 17:49:12---
I will now resume lurking silently.
I an the seer. I divined Snow, cccgirl, cab and HABS. Cccgirl is human. HABS is wolf. Good luck guys. Wish I could have made it to the end.
What, wait a minute. I've been ninja'd. So, scrub is claiming to be the Seer now. This does make things interesting. If HABS is really a wolf (very interesting indeed!), then that would leave Hydra, catmandon or Froggy as the final wolf, assuming my innocence (which I must assume, honestly). Among the three, Hydra has been the most confusing, but also has been the most voted by HABS. This would make catmandon a likely possibility, coinciding with scrub's comment. Very, very interesting
EDIT: Okay, I'll vote for HABS now. The only possibilities are that scrub is telling the truth (and will be eaten), or he will survive as a clear wolf. The only other possibility is that the remaining wolf won't take him out, just hoping to throw suspicion on him. However, that is risky to the point of suicidal. Would be a gutsy move for a wolf, but would likely end the game real fast in humanity's favor. I like this thought...
---This message was edited on 2015-02-23 17:49:12---
I will now resume lurking silently.
scrub88 wrote:
What dose everyone think??
Is he truly the seer or a wolf??
If we vote HABS and he is hunan,then it's 2 more down.
Why was I not divined??
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
I an the seer. I divined Snow, cccgirl, cab and HABS. Cccgirl is human. HABS is wolf. Good luck guys. Wish I could have made it to the end.
What dose everyone think??
Is he truly the seer or a wolf??
If we vote HABS and he is hunan,then it's 2 more down.
Why was I not divined??
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
There have only been so many rounds, cat. Judging by his recent post, you were next on his list. It is intriguing to me that his list of divinations are for the most part still alive.
I will now resume lurking silently.
I will now resume lurking silently.
So, scrub, which rounds did you divine who? I'm just curious since snow and cab were eaten/shot so those identities were already known to all of us.
I'll be interested in hearing your reply as I've played in too many games where the "Seer" card has been played by a wolf trying to force the real Seer to come out which leads to a night Seer wolf snack...
Well? For some reason, I just don't believe you because we already knew 2 of the identities that you listed. I also agree with what Radio posted as to you being our Seer.
I'm going to go back through all the rounds and read your posts as well as all your voting patterns and anyone you might have tried to protect.
I would strongly suggest that no one else votes since it only takes 4 votes. We do not want the wolves to swoop in and shoot another human. We all need to figure out this Seer/scrub issue.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
I'll be interested in hearing your reply as I've played in too many games where the "Seer" card has been played by a wolf trying to force the real Seer to come out which leads to a night Seer wolf snack...
Well? For some reason, I just don't believe you because we already knew 2 of the identities that you listed. I also agree with what Radio posted as to you being our Seer.
I'm going to go back through all the rounds and read your posts as well as all your voting patterns and anyone you might have tried to protect.
I would strongly suggest that no one else votes since it only takes 4 votes. We do not want the wolves to swoop in and shoot another human. We all need to figure out this Seer/scrub issue.
SMILE and people will wonder what you are up to!
You know what go ahead and vote me. You will see I am a human which will prove Scrub a wolf. Here would be no reason for a true human to target a player they are unsure about.
I would then look at Radio guy who quickly jumped on the vote for me or ccgirl who has been "cleared" by the "seer".
I am not the seer just a plain ol.' Human.
I just think Hydra may be a wolf.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
I would then look at Radio guy who quickly jumped on the vote for me or ccgirl who has been "cleared" by the "seer".
I am not the seer just a plain ol.' Human.
I just think Hydra may be a wolf.
Maybe the dog only brings the ball back because he thinks you like throwing it.
scrub88 wrote:
Wow. I've never known Scrub (or really anyone) to falsely make such a claim. Whether wolf or human, it's clear suicide, so I take him at his word.
Voting HABs. Scrub, it's been nice knowing ya.
P.S. If people are right about Cat, then that would mean all 3 wolves were in a 3 way tie Round 2. That would be AMAZING.
I an the seer. I divined Snow, cccgirl, cab and HABS. Cccgirl is human. HABS is wolf. Good luck guys. Wish I could have made it to the end.
Wow. I've never known Scrub (or really anyone) to falsely make such a claim. Whether wolf or human, it's clear suicide, so I take him at his word.
Voting HABs. Scrub, it's been nice knowing ya.
P.S. If people are right about Cat, then that would mean all 3 wolves were in a 3 way tie Round 2. That would be AMAZING.
Guess I'll finish this..
Sure hope he is a wolf.
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
Sure hope he is a wolf.
The early bird gets the worm,but the second rat gets the cheese..
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!