The Werewolf Game
Game #3406: Ghosts in the Graveyard
This private game is moderated by SqueeLover. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 6 rounds.
Whov was not the Undertaker.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 15:46:28---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 15:46:28---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Only thing whov did was to point out that Col SPVed after we knew the seer had fallen. And he's only played 10 games of WW, so maybe he felt threatened and wanted her gone? Then again, the database says he's been wolfy twice out of the 8 it lists, so he would have some kind of experience in wolfing.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 12:23:17---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 12:23:17---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Can't tell if night timed out or just was really close. No reason to do anything other than wait for everybody else.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
celtichero wrote:
This has been nagging at me too. How would NC have been able to find a quote like that when it had been less than 15 minutes since the first post? If she's human, she wouldn't have known who would be eaten, so she'd have to have found that reference really, really fast. It could be that she remembered it from before, but given that we know the wolves can communicate (somewhat) with each other, I feel like if she was part of the wolf team, they would have planned to do this beforehand.
Voting NoComment.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Although I do think it's curious how quickly NC had that reference ready to go.
This has been nagging at me too. How would NC have been able to find a quote like that when it had been less than 15 minutes since the first post? If she's human, she wouldn't have known who would be eaten, so she'd have to have found that reference really, really fast. It could be that she remembered it from before, but given that we know the wolves can communicate (somewhat) with each other, I feel like if she was part of the wolf team, they would have planned to do this beforehand.
Voting NoComment.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Hey
Seems plausible
Will wait for others
This space is intentionally left blank.
Seems plausible
Will wait for others
This space is intentionally left blank.
How do you guys check past games database? I can only see 2-3 recent games and the last 10 games I've played.
And everyone seems to be active, I don't think the night timed out.
And everyone seems to be active, I don't think the night timed out.
celtichero wrote:
Aishadit wrote:
I'm 99.99% sure it did. If it didn't time out, it came extremely close to doing so. I saw when the night had 7 min to go, and 7-8 min later I got the notification that a new round had started, so I think it's safe to assume it did.
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Can't tell if night timed out or just was really close. No reason to do anything other than wait for everybody else.
Aishadit wrote:
And everyone seems to be active, I don't think the night timed out.
I'm 99.99% sure it did. If it didn't time out, it came extremely close to doing so. I saw when the night had 7 min to go, and 7-8 min later I got the notification that a new round had started, so I think it's safe to assume it did.
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Aishadit wrote:
HarryPutter made a database of all the games ever. Link
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 12:52:04---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
How do you guys check past games database? I can only see 2-3 recent games and the last 10 games I've played.
HarryPutter made a database of all the games ever. Link
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 12:52:04---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
AlienChipBrain wrote:
Thanks
And nocomment could have just remembered that line from 4wheels since it was a recent game. It's not like he admitted something he wasn't supposed to know at that point in the round,
Aishadit wrote:
HarryPutter made a database of all the games ever. Link
How do you guys check past games database? I can only see 2-3 recent games and the last 10 games I've played.
HarryPutter made a database of all the games ever. Link
Thanks
And nocomment could have just remembered that line from 4wheels since it was a recent game. It's not like he admitted something he wasn't supposed to know at that point in the round,
Tossing a vote on Col for now but could do a NoComm vote.
My wiki trail is now public! :D
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Colange hasnt been on in two days. Either wolves were waiting for a login so they could camouflage themselves more, or else if Colange is a wolf and didn't vote, then that's why the round timed out. (Does it work that way?)
Anyway, NC's reference was surprisingly quick, but yes it could've been something remembered from a recent game. Will wait to see what NC has to say about it.
Also want to wait to hear from some of the other players before I vote... We've got plenty of time.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 13:35:57---
Anyway, NC's reference was surprisingly quick, but yes it could've been something remembered from a recent game. Will wait to see what NC has to say about it.
Also want to wait to hear from some of the other players before I vote... We've got plenty of time.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 13:35:57---
miscellanea wrote:
Yes, it does work that way. (And I accidentally saw that he hasn't been on in two days when checking his game scores, but I wasn't sure if I should bring it up)
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Colange hasnt been on in two days. Either wolves were waiting for a login so they could camouflage themselves more, or else if Colange is a wolf and didn't vote, then that's why the round timed out. (Does it work that way?)
Yes, it does work that way. (And I accidentally saw that he hasn't been on in two days when checking his game scores, but I wasn't sure if I should bring it up)
My wiki trail is now public! :D
AlienChipBrain wrote:
I thought about holding off on that too, since your login time was the only reason I chickened out on voting for you in round 5 of last game so obviously this can be misleading
But I figured hey I'll bring it up and if it's irrelevant we can all ignore it
EDIT: Also this wouldn't be hard to fake and put suspicion on Colange with all the wolves being somewhat in communication so I'm taking less stock by it than I may have in other games.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 13:51:49---
miscellanea wrote:
Yes, it does work that way. (And I accidentally saw that he hasn't been on in two days when checking his game scores, but I wasn't sure if I should bring it up)
Colange hasnt been on in two days. Either wolves were waiting for a login so they could camouflage themselves more, or else if Colange is a wolf and didn't vote, then that's why the round timed out. (Does it work that way?)
Yes, it does work that way. (And I accidentally saw that he hasn't been on in two days when checking his game scores, but I wasn't sure if I should bring it up)
I thought about holding off on that too, since your login time was the only reason I chickened out on voting for you in round 5 of last game so obviously this can be misleading
But I figured hey I'll bring it up and if it's irrelevant we can all ignore it
EDIT: Also this wouldn't be hard to fake and put suspicion on Colange with all the wolves being somewhat in communication so I'm taking less stock by it than I may have in other games.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 13:51:49---
miscellanea wrote:
If a wolf does not vote during the night, the night will time out (note that the night lasts an hour longer than the last wolf's vote, so if they vote when there's less than an hour in the night, the night will time out). Someone gets eaten no matter if any/all wolves vote (if no wolves vote, the computer eats the first person alphabetically on the list).
It could be, but the howler has to send zillions of PMs, so I'd guess they probably aren't doing a whole lot of strategizing.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 13:58:38---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
AlienChipBrain wrote:
I thought about holding off on that too, since your login time was the only reason I chickened out on voting for you in round 5 of last game so obviously this can be misleading
miscellanea wrote:
Yes, it does work that way. (And I accidentally saw that he hasn't been on in two days when checking his game scores, but I wasn't sure if I should bring it up)
Colange hasnt been on in two days. Either wolves were waiting for a login so they could camouflage themselves more, or else if Colange is a wolf and didn't vote, then that's why the round timed out. (Does it work that way?)
Yes, it does work that way. (And I accidentally saw that he hasn't been on in two days when checking his game scores, but I wasn't sure if I should bring it up)
I thought about holding off on that too, since your login time was the only reason I chickened out on voting for you in round 5 of last game so obviously this can be misleading
If a wolf does not vote during the night, the night will time out (note that the night lasts an hour longer than the last wolf's vote, so if they vote when there's less than an hour in the night, the night will time out). Someone gets eaten no matter if any/all wolves vote (if no wolves vote, the computer eats the first person alphabetically on the list).
EDIT: Also this wouldn't be hard to fake and put suspicion on Colange with all the wolves being somewhat in communication so I'm taking less stock by it than I may have in other games.
It could be, but the howler has to send zillions of PMs, so I'd guess they probably aren't doing a whole lot of strategizing.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 13:58:38---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Obviously there is a reason to look at colange but unless he returns it's unlikely to generate any friction, same problem we had with wheels. I'd worry about him flipping human and us being in round 4 with little intel.
The NC suspicion definitely makes sense but it's an unusual one, I'm not sure how to weigh up the different readings of it. Want to hear NCs comments on it
The NC suspicion definitely makes sense but it's an unusual one, I'm not sure how to weigh up the different readings of it. Want to hear NCs comments on it
Ok thanks for clearing some of that up for me, Alien.
Smithy wrote:
I would agree. Seems like the wolves are letting us take out the inactive/less threatening humans and focusing on eating the bigger players.
Obviously there is a reason to look at colange but unless he returns it's unlikely to generate any friction, same problem we had with wheels. I'd worry about him flipping human and us being in round 4 with little intel.
I would agree. Seems like the wolves are letting us take out the inactive/less threatening humans and focusing on eating the bigger players.
AlienChipBrain wrote:
Regular human, or undertaker?
Regular human. I'll fix that, haha.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 15:45:20---
Whov was human, though I'm sure you knew that
Regular human, or undertaker?
Regular human. I'll fix that, haha.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 15:45:20---
You know, with the seer dead, we could just vote Alien. There's, like, a 95% chance she's a wolf since she's either wolf or seer in EVERY game
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Yeesha wrote:
Actually, it's a 41% chance (not counting this game).
My wiki trail is now public! :D
You know, with the seer dead, we could just vote Alien. There's, like, a 95% chance she's a wolf since she's either wolf or seer in EVERY game
Actually, it's a 41% chance (not counting this game).
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Sorry work has been nuts past few days. Will have to be back tomorrow for some more detail.
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams.
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams.
Of course the wolves left me in because they knew I'd appear suspicious. And I guess I do look suspicious with that quote. But, those saying how "quickly" I came up with it actually have no way to tell how long it took me to find it. It did take me a while to find it, I didn't post immediately after I logged in. I just remembered that in a recent game wheels said she'd eat Spider first if she was wolf.
I would vote someone suspecting me, but then I realize everyone has a right to suspect me since my comment did seem a bit weird. Will vote from bottom of list with no votes.
...Aaand that's still someone who voted me. Oh well.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 16:00:19---
I just ate enough cookies to give a mouse diabeetus
I would vote someone suspecting me, but then I realize everyone has a right to suspect me since my comment did seem a bit weird. Will vote from bottom of list with no votes.
...Aaand that's still someone who voted me. Oh well.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 16:00:19---
I just ate enough cookies to give a mouse diabeetus
Totally lost track of time and thought we was on night still. Ooops. Lets have a read through....
I'd just like to point out that I have only played 10 games of wwg. Firstly I thought that if you was a wolf you had to vote and secondly it's a fair enough assumption from the wolves to place the focus on a relatively noob and an easy vote. My suspicions are still celt and deb and possibly no comment. Will wait until morning before voting
Honestly I feel like just the fact that NC admits the comment looks suspicious is suspicious. She also said it took her a while to find it, but she posted less than 15 minutes after the round started, and she says she didn't post immediately either. If she's human, why would she defend the statement that much (and in that way?)
Also, maybe it's just me, but I've noticed the people that tend to make the "ugh, the wolves are so annoying" statements are wolves.
Edit: Also she voted randomly even though we don't have our seer...
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 18:27:35---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Also, maybe it's just me, but I've noticed the people that tend to make the "ugh, the wolves are so annoying" statements are wolves.
Edit: Also she voted randomly even though we don't have our seer...
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 18:27:35---
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Colange is back.
And I honestly don't like using login times to figure out who the wolf is because 1) the game takes measures against this stuff
2) it's against the point of this game.
Honestly it's been more unreliable than reliable in the past.
Colange wrote:
I don't get what you mean
And I honestly don't like using login times to figure out who the wolf is because 1) the game takes measures against this stuff
2) it's against the point of this game.
Honestly it's been more unreliable than reliable in the past.
Colange wrote:
I'd just like to point out that I have only played 10 games of wwg. Firstly I thought that if you was a wolf you had to vote and secondly it's a fair enough assumption from the wolves to place the focus on a relatively noob and an easy vote. My suspicions are still celt and deb and possibly no comment. Will wait until morning before voting
I don't get what you mean
Aishadit wrote:
Makes sense. And really it doesn't clear or condemn Colange anyway so we can just choose to ignore that.
I'd like to know why Colange suspects deb and celt.
Colange is back.
And I honestly don't like using login times to figure out who the wolf is because 1) the game takes measures against this stuff
2) it's against the point of this game.
Honestly it's been more unreliable than reliable in the past.
And I honestly don't like using login times to figure out who the wolf is because 1) the game takes measures against this stuff
2) it's against the point of this game.
Honestly it's been more unreliable than reliable in the past.
Makes sense. And really it doesn't clear or condemn Colange anyway so we can just choose to ignore that.
I'd like to know why Colange suspects deb and celt.
My thoughts atm
NoComm
NoComment's post reminds me of a post I'd expect wolfy Rove to make (whether that's incriminating or not I don't know). Yeesha is right that her post happened less than 15 minutes after the RFM post, so either it didn't actually take her that long, or she was wolfy, knew who was getting eaten, and found it in the night.
Colange
Colange's post was worded strangely, but I think the gist of it is "I'm pretty much a noob, if I was a wolf I would have voted, and it's not unreasonable to assume the wolves are trying to put the focus on me, an inexperienced person." One thing I don't get is why he says "My suspicions are still celt and deb..." I checked; he hadn't voiced any suspicions up until this point. This reminds me a lot of NoComm's post; like Col said, he hasn't played many games (granted, a couple were wolfy ones), so maybe he was trying to copy another wolf's defense?
Wouldn't be very surprised if they were both wolfy.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 18:58:43---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
NoComm
NoComment's post reminds me of a post I'd expect wolfy Rove to make (whether that's incriminating or not I don't know). Yeesha is right that her post happened less than 15 minutes after the RFM post, so either it didn't actually take her that long, or she was wolfy, knew who was getting eaten, and found it in the night.
Colange
Colange's post was worded strangely, but I think the gist of it is "I'm pretty much a noob, if I was a wolf I would have voted, and it's not unreasonable to assume the wolves are trying to put the focus on me, an inexperienced person." One thing I don't get is why he says "My suspicions are still celt and deb..." I checked; he hadn't voiced any suspicions up until this point. This reminds me a lot of NoComm's post; like Col said, he hasn't played many games (granted, a couple were wolfy ones), so maybe he was trying to copy another wolf's defense?
Wouldn't be very surprised if they were both wolfy.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-13 18:58:43---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
I don't get that either
I didn't realize I did anything to cast suspicion or surprisingly I don't think Celt has either.
At this point I could go col or no but will wait a while
This space is intentionally left blank.
I didn't realize I did anything to cast suspicion or surprisingly I don't think Celt has either.
At this point I could go col or no but will wait a while
This space is intentionally left blank.
I'm guessing that was based on Sky's first post R2. ("Eating made me think deb/celt as likely to eat Spid.")
My wiki trail is now public! :D
My wiki trail is now public! :D
I'd really like to hear from the group of guys. We've got 16 hours.
The Yeesha/NC dynamic is interesting. Definitely want to delve into the "Sunday Crew", ie Alien, NC, Tem, and Yeesha, later in the round.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
It could be from sky's post
It is a little weak
Hitting dan then who is not something I think Celt would do
I am thinking some of the newer ones
I won't be voting for Celt
Probably not sky nor smithy
Maybe not ash
Misc seems like the last game I played with her
Like for col to expound on his theory
This space is intentionally left blank.
It is a little weak
Hitting dan then who is not something I think Celt would do
I am thinking some of the newer ones
I won't be voting for Celt
Probably not sky nor smithy
Maybe not ash
Misc seems like the last game I played with her
Like for col to expound on his theory
This space is intentionally left blank.
celtichero wrote:
I'm actually not part of the Sunday Crew. Dunno if that clears me or adds more suspicion, but I'll just say it.
Yeesha wrote:
I meant I didn't post immediately after I logged in.
Also, remember when you said that anything you said came off as wolfy? It seems to me that since you know the experience so well, that you might give me the benefit of the doubt.
Keeping as is.
I just ate enough cookies to give a mouse diabeetus
The Yeesha/NC dynamic is interesting. Definitely want to delve into the "Sunday Crew", ie Alien, NC, Tem, and Yeesha, later in the round.
I'm actually not part of the Sunday Crew. Dunno if that clears me or adds more suspicion, but I'll just say it.
Yeesha wrote:
Honestly I feel like just the fact that NC admits the comment looks suspicious is suspicious. She also said it took her a while to find it, but she posted less than 15 minutes after the round started, and she says she didn't post immediately either. If she's human, why would she defend the statement that much (and in that way?)
Also, maybe it's just me, but I've noticed the people that tend to make the "ugh, the wolves are so annoying" statements are wolves.
Edit: Also she voted randomly even though we don't have our seer...
Also, maybe it's just me, but I've noticed the people that tend to make the "ugh, the wolves are so annoying" statements are wolves.
Edit: Also she voted randomly even though we don't have our seer...
I meant I didn't post immediately after I logged in.
Also, remember when you said that anything you said came off as wolfy? It seems to me that since you know the experience so well, that you might give me the benefit of the doubt.
Keeping as is.
I just ate enough cookies to give a mouse diabeetus
I'm more attributing the Sunday Crew as people whose profile pics and signatures are essentially all the same things.
Wanna hear what the other gents have to say.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 00:02:40---
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Wanna hear what the other gents have to say.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 00:02:40---
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
I'm not particularly placated by colange's explanation (besides the fact that humans as well as wolves should log in during the night), would also like to hear some elaboration on his suspicions. At the moment it still feels like a shot in the dark.
The last game showed we should sometimes go with the simple explanation and not second guess too much, I'm not sure whether Occam would point to NC's comment being a frame up or incredibly quick quote find but my gut is telling me it's suspect, and the subsequent comments don't really help (the post 15 mins in wasn't as quick as it could have been?). Putting a second vote on NC.
Should be on again this afternoon, I want to get a deb list together as there are a few players that have escaped scrutiny thus far.
AlienChipBrain voted for Colange
NoComment voted for Yeesha
Smithy voted for NoComment
Yeesha voted for NoComment
Totals
NoComment : 2
Non-voters/Inactives: Aishadit, celtichero, Colange, debc1, miscellanea, Skybet, tEMfLAks
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 03:53:38---
The last game showed we should sometimes go with the simple explanation and not second guess too much, I'm not sure whether Occam would point to NC's comment being a frame up or incredibly quick quote find but my gut is telling me it's suspect, and the subsequent comments don't really help (the post 15 mins in wasn't as quick as it could have been?). Putting a second vote on NC.
Should be on again this afternoon, I want to get a deb list together as there are a few players that have escaped scrutiny thus far.
AlienChipBrain voted for Colange
NoComment voted for Yeesha
Smithy voted for NoComment
Yeesha voted for NoComment
Totals
NoComment : 2
Non-voters/Inactives: Aishadit, celtichero, Colange, debc1, miscellanea, Skybet, tEMfLAks
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 03:53:38---
I'm around. Will review properly and post thoughts in the next couple of hours.
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams.
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams.
NoComment wrote:
Can a comment be as suspicious as that? Could be a slam dunk. Surely it would be very strange to expect to be eaten in round 2. Also it's the wolves prerogative to leave in players who would attract the bullet.
As for Colange, I am not sure he is able to firm up his suspicions that eloquently due to being new to the game, I am not convinced that's grounds enough to shoot him yet.
Voting NC.
p.s. Hopefully over the next couple of days my workload will reduce and will be able to spend a bit more time on the game.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 04:53:20---
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams.
Of course the wolves left me in because they knew I'd appear suspicious.
Can a comment be as suspicious as that? Could be a slam dunk. Surely it would be very strange to expect to be eaten in round 2. Also it's the wolves prerogative to leave in players who would attract the bullet.
As for Colange, I am not sure he is able to firm up his suspicions that eloquently due to being new to the game, I am not convinced that's grounds enough to shoot him yet.
Voting NC.
p.s. Hopefully over the next couple of days my workload will reduce and will be able to spend a bit more time on the game.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 04:53:20---
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams.
I think I suspect deb and celt every game . To be honest I dont have any theories behind my suspicions other than a hunch. But there are plenty more people who could be suspect here. The quietness always convinces me that they are hiding something. Sky being unusually quiet, nothing from team either! I am going to vote no comment for now, as this seems like a good option
Good morning Will probably switch to NC soon.
Edit: Where is Tem?
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 07:55:56---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Edit: Where is Tem?
---This message was edited on 2020-10-14 07:55:56---
My wiki trail is now public! :D
I think when NC said that they didn't post "immediately" after login, was not to say that they already had the quote and waited to post but that the delay from login to post time was due to the time needed to find the post. It seems like this was misunderstood by a few people.
Nevertheless, I don't think NC's defense is very strong and seems to be carefully worded to divert suspicion without actually giving reasons for doing so.
Will check back in about an hour to give NC time to make a last defense, but I intend to vote that way.
Nevertheless, I don't think NC's defense is very strong and seems to be carefully worded to divert suspicion without actually giving reasons for doing so.
Will check back in about an hour to give NC time to make a last defense, but I intend to vote that way.
My only real hesitation with just casting off NC is that it would've been an extreme overplaying of a hand. Framing 4Wheels of all people just to get yourself shot the next round is a pretty horrific strategy.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Deb list time baby, not a huge amount to go on so no ground breaking insights.
Aishadit - not very familiar with their game, has posted a few times without really saying too much, seems pretty normal from memory
AlienChipBrain - has been freely sharing thoughts, sounds pretty organic, getting human vibes.
celtichero - downplayed the eating talk, but he did the same in the original game when he was human. Does count against him sligthly but nothing else is raising alarms
Colange - inactivity in the timed out night counts against him but other than that pretty neutral on him. His most recent post sounds a bit more human but I would like more detail than a "hunch".
debc1 - on a couple people's radar, I think originally for the spid eating but I haven't verified one way or the other if that's reasonable. Her posting was a bit bare bones until her most recent one, and they all seem a little... I'm not sure of the right word, robotic? A bit cold? (no offence deb) Might look through some past games to compare tone
miscellanea - hasn't raised any red flags for me, posting pretty frequently, based on her previous gameplay (sample size: one) seems pretty in keeping though I wonder if she maybe was more investigative last game
NoComment - suspicious for reasons previously covered
Skybet - not hugely active due to work, this seems to happen sometimes regardless of role. No red flags have jumped out at me when he has posted. In fact the "slam dunk" comment sounds pretty human to me
tEMfLAks - very low activity as alien has just alluded to, suspiciously low, definitely need to hear more from her next round. Not much to assess based on what she has said although her comment last round seemed very uncertain.
Yeesha - pretty assertive on NC which seems human, obviously moreso if NC flips wolf. I remember thinking this in previous games and it hasn't gone wrong yet... And excellent idea to shoot alien whenever we know she's not seer.
Main conclusion is I want to hear more from a few suspiciously quiet players.
Aishadit - not very familiar with their game, has posted a few times without really saying too much, seems pretty normal from memory
AlienChipBrain - has been freely sharing thoughts, sounds pretty organic, getting human vibes.
celtichero - downplayed the eating talk, but he did the same in the original game when he was human. Does count against him sligthly but nothing else is raising alarms
Colange - inactivity in the timed out night counts against him but other than that pretty neutral on him. His most recent post sounds a bit more human but I would like more detail than a "hunch".
debc1 - on a couple people's radar, I think originally for the spid eating but I haven't verified one way or the other if that's reasonable. Her posting was a bit bare bones until her most recent one, and they all seem a little... I'm not sure of the right word, robotic? A bit cold? (no offence deb) Might look through some past games to compare tone
miscellanea - hasn't raised any red flags for me, posting pretty frequently, based on her previous gameplay (sample size: one) seems pretty in keeping though I wonder if she maybe was more investigative last game
NoComment - suspicious for reasons previously covered
Skybet - not hugely active due to work, this seems to happen sometimes regardless of role. No red flags have jumped out at me when he has posted. In fact the "slam dunk" comment sounds pretty human to me
tEMfLAks - very low activity as alien has just alluded to, suspiciously low, definitely need to hear more from her next round. Not much to assess based on what she has said although her comment last round seemed very uncertain.
Yeesha - pretty assertive on NC which seems human, obviously moreso if NC flips wolf. I remember thinking this in previous games and it hasn't gone wrong yet... And excellent idea to shoot alien whenever we know she's not seer.
Main conclusion is I want to hear more from a few suspiciously quiet players.
My only reason for a deb suspicion is purely because she is normally much more vocal. The quietness worries me. Sorry deb I might be totally wrong but you normally get a lot more involved. Celt I just have a bee in my bonnet around the time you got me eaten in my very first game (I will get over this I promise )
Sticking to NC but with only 2 hours left anything could happen
Switching to NC
My wiki trail is now public! :D
My wiki trail is now public! :D
Checking in. We've only got 2 hours so I'm not going to vote yet on NC, since a good chunk of people havent weighed in yet.
celt's point about NC was good, but it still looks like NC is going to get shot this round unless something astounding happens in the next hour or so.
Suspecting Yeesha if NC is human, celt if NC is wolf.
celt's point about NC was good, but it still looks like NC is going to get shot this round unless something astounding happens in the next hour or so.
Suspecting Yeesha if NC is human, celt if NC is wolf.
Smithy wrote:
...you know I was kidding, right?
Smithy's list seems pretty reasonable as far as I can see. NoCom definitely seems like the way to go this round, and I'll honestly be surprised if she's not a wolf at this point.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
... And excellent idea to shoot alien whenever we know she's not seer.
...you know I was kidding, right?
Smithy's list seems pretty reasonable as far as I can see. NoCom definitely seems like the way to go this round, and I'll honestly be surprised if she's not a wolf at this point.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Just going to end the round now. Nothing is going to change substantially in an hour to save NC, and there is reasonable suspicion.
NoComment was human.
Sunshine glistening, the illumination eyes see forming pictures and pictured Forms. Seeing eyes illuminate the glistening shining sun.
Sunshine glistening, the illumination eyes see forming pictures and pictured Forms. Seeing eyes illuminate the glistening shining sun.
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!