The Werewolf Game
Game #3406: Ghosts in the Graveyard
This private game is moderated by SqueeLover. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 6 rounds.
Alien was human. Three wolves remain.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 10:12:23---
Sunshine glistening, the illumination eyes see forming pictures and pictured Forms. Seeing eyes illuminate the glistening shining sun.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 10:12:23---
Sunshine glistening, the illumination eyes see forming pictures and pictured Forms. Seeing eyes illuminate the glistening shining sun.
Deb being human was a shock to me. That blew my suspicion out the window! Celt had some pretty weird comments last round and I am saying towards him. Tem was again inactive and is most likely a wolf but I think we know this and it would be a wasteful vote this round as it's must linch. Let's get an active wolf and then get tem next round if we can!
Wow Alien got eaten? That was not who I was guessing.
Tem actually logged in yesterday but I havent seen her around yet. I feel similarly that an active wolf should be our target this round. I agree with some suspicious comments/voting activity from celt but I can't really read the Alien vote.
EDIT: Thinking about it, Alien was one of probably two people with zero suspicions on her last round, so actually targeting her makes sense.
I'll expound on celt suspicions later if it looks like a vote for him is on the table.
I don't have much on Col, Aisha, or Yeesha. Smithy still seems human but at this point wouldn't be surprised if he and celt were both wolves and laying low.
Want to hear other thoughts before I place any sort of vote.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 11:04:45---
Tem actually logged in yesterday but I havent seen her around yet. I feel similarly that an active wolf should be our target this round. I agree with some suspicious comments/voting activity from celt but I can't really read the Alien vote.
EDIT: Thinking about it, Alien was one of probably two people with zero suspicions on her last round, so actually targeting her makes sense.
I'll expound on celt suspicions later if it looks like a vote for him is on the table.
I don't have much on Col, Aisha, or Yeesha. Smithy still seems human but at this point wouldn't be surprised if he and celt were both wolves and laying low.
Want to hear other thoughts before I place any sort of vote.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 11:04:45---
Also, am not against a Tem vote. If we're reasonably certain she's a wolf, then it may make sense to take it just to keep us alive another round.
Each human has a 50/50 chance of picking a wolf to shoot...
Each human has a 50/50 chance of picking a wolf to shoot...
People who pushed for Deb over Tem are the obvious candidates here.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
Perhaps I'm overthinking the Tem shoot... If we're all pretty certain she's a wolf, then might as well make it a done deal. I feel silly for not taking that shot last round, but it felt like a repeat of Fun and 4wheels votes with no guarantee that it would pay off.
Will wait a few hours to see if anyone shows up to dispute this... Still haven't heard from half the group. I'll put a vote on her in a while if nothing changes.
If she's not a wolf then we got seriously tricked this game.
Will wait a few hours to see if anyone shows up to dispute this... Still haven't heard from half the group. I'll put a vote on her in a while if nothing changes.
If she's not a wolf then we got seriously tricked this game.
Will check in later
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 14:17:20---
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 14:17:20---
miscellanea wrote:
EDIT: Thinking about it, Alien was one of probably two people with zero suspicions on her last round, so actually targeting her makes sense.
On tem? He clearly said he thought celt, deb and tem are wolfy
EDIT: Thinking about it, Alien was one of probably two people with zero suspicions on her last round, so actually targeting her makes sense.
On tem? He clearly said he thought celt, deb and tem are wolfy
Aishadit wrote:
Sorry, to clarify... I meant no one suspected Alien. Celt suspected me, a good chunk of us suspected deb, celt, and tem, and I think Yeesha got a deb vote. So Alien was one of the few really seeming human last round.
miscellanea wrote:
EDIT: Thinking about it, Alien was one of probably two people with zero suspicions on her last round, so actually targeting her makes sense.
On tem? He clearly said he thought celt, deb and tem are wolfy
EDIT: Thinking about it, Alien was one of probably two people with zero suspicions on her last round, so actually targeting her makes sense.
On tem? He clearly said he thought celt, deb and tem are wolfy
Sorry, to clarify... I meant no one suspected Alien. Celt suspected me, a good chunk of us suspected deb, celt, and tem, and I think Yeesha got a deb vote. So Alien was one of the few really seeming human last round.
This round has been really slow. I plan to vote for tem by the end of the evening whether or not anyone else checks in.
Oops sorry I misunderstood, thanks for clarifying.
The order of people who voted for deb : smithy, misc, aishadit, celt, and yeesha (which ended the round early)
Smithy: started the vote, probably didn't expect a majority to form on her so quickly.
Misc: joined the deb vote but called it a tie even though tem had 3 votes but there's only 2 votes on deb at this point.
Aishadit: I joined the vote because I was suspecting both celt and deb and I thought shooting tem is a bad idea. It became a tie.
Celt: somehow got convinced to join the deb vote despite being completely against it. Deb was the new majority.
Yeesha: had her suspicions on deb before but wanted to vote tem, voted deb to end the round early.
Smithy started it, misc gave it momentum, I made it a tie, celt made it a majority and yeesha gave the last vote that cuts the round early. So everyone is suspicious right now.
But Celts reason to vote is the most suspicious of the lot in my opinion.
Yeesha was suspicious too, I was leaning human on her because I thought she is acting too obvious to be a wolf. Maybe in this situation the obvious wolf is an obvious wolf.
So far I suspect celt mostly, yeesha is possibly another wolf. Third wolf is better at not being wolfy.
Will comb through previous rounds in the morning.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 18:19:38---
The order of people who voted for deb : smithy, misc, aishadit, celt, and yeesha (which ended the round early)
Smithy: started the vote, probably didn't expect a majority to form on her so quickly.
Misc: joined the deb vote but called it a tie even though tem had 3 votes but there's only 2 votes on deb at this point.
Aishadit: I joined the vote because I was suspecting both celt and deb and I thought shooting tem is a bad idea. It became a tie.
Celt: somehow got convinced to join the deb vote despite being completely against it. Deb was the new majority.
Yeesha: had her suspicions on deb before but wanted to vote tem, voted deb to end the round early.
Smithy started it, misc gave it momentum, I made it a tie, celt made it a majority and yeesha gave the last vote that cuts the round early. So everyone is suspicious right now.
But Celts reason to vote is the most suspicious of the lot in my opinion.
Yeesha was suspicious too, I was leaning human on her because I thought she is acting too obvious to be a wolf. Maybe in this situation the obvious wolf is an obvious wolf.
So far I suspect celt mostly, yeesha is possibly another wolf. Third wolf is better at not being wolfy.
Will comb through previous rounds in the morning.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 18:19:38---
miscellanea wrote:
Who were you guessing?
Wow Alien got eaten? That was not who I was guessing.
Who were you guessing?
Aishadit wrote:
I was thinking that, with all the more experienced players being eaten, that if Smithy were human he'd be on the chopping block; same for celt if he were human. My next guess was that it would have been Yeesha if both Smith and celt were wolves. I think I was not thinking Alien because of that comment of Yeesha's about if Alien isn't the seer she's probably a wolf, but that wasnt reasoning it was just sort of subconscious.
miscellanea wrote:
Who were you guessing?
Wow Alien got eaten? That was not who I was guessing.
Who were you guessing?
I was thinking that, with all the more experienced players being eaten, that if Smithy were human he'd be on the chopping block; same for celt if he were human. My next guess was that it would have been Yeesha if both Smith and celt were wolves. I think I was not thinking Alien because of that comment of Yeesha's about if Alien isn't the seer she's probably a wolf, but that wasnt reasoning it was just sort of subconscious.
Aishadit wrote:
I definitely agree that celt's sudden switch to deb was pretty suspicious.
And I didn't copy this over for the record so I don't have evidence, but right after I posted last round that I was going to try to make a competitive tie with a celt vote (I think celt had one from Colange? and tem had two from Alien and Yeesha), then celt jumped in with a tem vote. But once the tables turned to deb, celt agreed with Smithy and jumped to deb.
Either the wolves have a good strategy this game and are using the PMs to their full advantage, or else theyre just sitting back and laughing at us making mountains out of molehills.
Celt tops my list for general suspicion; I could also go Tem. I will be back on tonight but won't be on tomorrow so I will pick one before bed.
Oops sorry I misunderstood, thanks for clarifying.
The order of people who voted for deb : smithy, misc, aishadit, celt, and yeesha (which ended the round early)
Smithy: started the vote, probably didn't expect a majority to form on her so quickly.
Misc: joined the deb vote but called it a tie even though tem had 3 votes but there's only 2 votes on deb at this point.
Aishadit: I joined the vote because I was suspecting both celt and deb and I thought shooting tem is a bad idea. It became a tie.
Celt: somehow got convinced to join the deb vote despite being completely against it. Deb was the new majority.
Yeesha: had her suspicions on deb before but wanted to vote tem, voted deb to end the round early.
Smithy started it, misc gave it momentum, I made it a tie, celt made it a majority and yeesha gave the last vote that cuts the round early. So everyone is suspicious right now.
But Celts reason to vote is the most suspicious of the lot in my opinion.
Yeesha was suspicious too, I was leaning human on her because I thought she is acting too obvious to be a wolf. Maybe in this situation the obvious wolf is an obvious wolf.
So far I suspect celt mostly, yeesha is possibly another wolf. Third wolf is better at not being wolfy.
Will comb through previous rounds in the morning.
The order of people who voted for deb : smithy, misc, aishadit, celt, and yeesha (which ended the round early)
Smithy: started the vote, probably didn't expect a majority to form on her so quickly.
Misc: joined the deb vote but called it a tie even though tem had 3 votes but there's only 2 votes on deb at this point.
Aishadit: I joined the vote because I was suspecting both celt and deb and I thought shooting tem is a bad idea. It became a tie.
Celt: somehow got convinced to join the deb vote despite being completely against it. Deb was the new majority.
Yeesha: had her suspicions on deb before but wanted to vote tem, voted deb to end the round early.
Smithy started it, misc gave it momentum, I made it a tie, celt made it a majority and yeesha gave the last vote that cuts the round early. So everyone is suspicious right now.
But Celts reason to vote is the most suspicious of the lot in my opinion.
Yeesha was suspicious too, I was leaning human on her because I thought she is acting too obvious to be a wolf. Maybe in this situation the obvious wolf is an obvious wolf.
So far I suspect celt mostly, yeesha is possibly another wolf. Third wolf is better at not being wolfy.
Will comb through previous rounds in the morning.
I definitely agree that celt's sudden switch to deb was pretty suspicious.
And I didn't copy this over for the record so I don't have evidence, but right after I posted last round that I was going to try to make a competitive tie with a celt vote (I think celt had one from Colange? and tem had two from Alien and Yeesha), then celt jumped in with a tem vote. But once the tables turned to deb, celt agreed with Smithy and jumped to deb.
Either the wolves have a good strategy this game and are using the PMs to their full advantage, or else theyre just sitting back and laughing at us making mountains out of molehills.
Celt tops my list for general suspicion; I could also go Tem. I will be back on tonight but won't be on tomorrow so I will pick one before bed.
Sorry I haven't been active a lot. Had a busy day and I'll be offline until Monday since tomorrow's Sunday.
Echoing what Colange said, I'm not really sure what to think now that Deb was human. I think I'll put a vote on Celt since that seems to be the general consensus and I won't be able to change it. Sorry I can't be of more help.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
Echoing what Colange said, I'm not really sure what to think now that Deb was human. I think I'll put a vote on Celt since that seems to be the general consensus and I won't be able to change it. Sorry I can't be of more help.
"my Cat ate a Bonk and bouncy on the street into splat tree pls refund"
I went ahead with a vote on celt. Will try to check in again tomorrow morning, no guarantees.
The people who pushed most for Deb over Tem are very clearly the ones to be looked at here. I weighed the risks of Deb, which I did put in my foursome of potential wolves. If either Yeesha or Misc is a human, their votes on me have already effectively lost us the game, so I'm voting Yeesha.
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
"I need to be myself. I can't be no one else." - Noel Gallagher
My last thoughts before bed.
I've waffled back and forth between tem and celt the last few rounds. Without having played much with celt, I don't know how to read him. As this game has gone, all the people who would probably have the best reads were eliminated swiftly. I can say that a lot of people have been somewhat quiet this game, which has made it next to impossible to read anyone, so the few times that anyone has done anything reasonably inexplicable, I've felt it was suspicious.
And the whole tem thing has just been agonizing. After voting out two other inactives just to have them both be human, I can't justify shooting tem in this "do or die" round just on her lack of activity. It's highly likely that the long nights are due to her absence... But there are still two other wolves still alive besides her, if she is a wolf at all. So again, it comes down to either we can shoot tem and hope for the best, or maybe reach out and try to snag one of the wolves from the active players.
I've decided to stick to my vote for celt. I thought about jumping over to Tem and just setting up a little tie, but my thoughts are that so far, a good chunk of people have found celt suspicious, but only two of us have voted for him. Perhaps everyone (like me) was waiting to hear from more people, but at this point it's probably too late. Or else celt is actually a wolf, and the other wolves aren't going to bus him.
If we have even one vote from a human on another human, all the wolves have to do is rush in with their votes to lock in the shot, and they win. My thought is that since this hasnt happened yet, it's either because tem is a wolf and the other wolves can't force a majority, or that celt is a wolf and his partners won't bus him.
Since we have a 2-person celt majority and so far it doesnt seem like the wolves are jumping to end the round, my suspicions are still the same. Of course the wolves could be tem, Smithy, and Col, in which case it's totally still on the table.
If I am wrong, and celt is human, then I'll freely admit that I goofed up majorly in my reads. Feel free not to jump on board with my ideas because I am the person with the least experience here.
And if anyone wants to vote tem.... I'm ok with that as an option. I'll check back in the morning but fully expecting this round to be done before then.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 23:42:39---
I've waffled back and forth between tem and celt the last few rounds. Without having played much with celt, I don't know how to read him. As this game has gone, all the people who would probably have the best reads were eliminated swiftly. I can say that a lot of people have been somewhat quiet this game, which has made it next to impossible to read anyone, so the few times that anyone has done anything reasonably inexplicable, I've felt it was suspicious.
And the whole tem thing has just been agonizing. After voting out two other inactives just to have them both be human, I can't justify shooting tem in this "do or die" round just on her lack of activity. It's highly likely that the long nights are due to her absence... But there are still two other wolves still alive besides her, if she is a wolf at all. So again, it comes down to either we can shoot tem and hope for the best, or maybe reach out and try to snag one of the wolves from the active players.
I've decided to stick to my vote for celt. I thought about jumping over to Tem and just setting up a little tie, but my thoughts are that so far, a good chunk of people have found celt suspicious, but only two of us have voted for him. Perhaps everyone (like me) was waiting to hear from more people, but at this point it's probably too late. Or else celt is actually a wolf, and the other wolves aren't going to bus him.
If we have even one vote from a human on another human, all the wolves have to do is rush in with their votes to lock in the shot, and they win. My thought is that since this hasnt happened yet, it's either because tem is a wolf and the other wolves can't force a majority, or that celt is a wolf and his partners won't bus him.
Since we have a 2-person celt majority and so far it doesnt seem like the wolves are jumping to end the round, my suspicions are still the same. Of course the wolves could be tem, Smithy, and Col, in which case it's totally still on the table.
If I am wrong, and celt is human, then I'll freely admit that I goofed up majorly in my reads. Feel free not to jump on board with my ideas because I am the person with the least experience here.
And if anyone wants to vote tem.... I'm ok with that as an option. I'll check back in the morning but fully expecting this round to be done before then.
---This message was edited on 2020-10-17 23:42:39---
Last game taught us to follow your gut but my gut has had a shocker this game. Surprised deb flipped human, I don't really want to take anyones vote for her into consideration because I still think it was the sensible option at the time.
Like misc said, the fact the wolves haven't piled on suggests one of celt or yeesha is a wolf so I go wjth one of those votes. Gut is telling me celt is more suspect than yeesha but my confidence this game is down so I want to have another read through to check my conclusion.
Like misc said, the fact the wolves haven't piled on suggests one of celt or yeesha is a wolf so I go wjth one of those votes. Gut is telling me celt is more suspect than yeesha but my confidence this game is down so I want to have another read through to check my conclusion.
Celt gets my vote. I have been quite suspicious for the last few rounds and this round is no different. I dont believe tem is immune, but I think it's better to shoot an active wolf than an inactive wolf at this point.
Celts "let's focus on the people who voted deb" is the part that's worrying me.
If celt turns out to be human I will eat my shorts!
Celts "let's focus on the people who voted deb" is the part that's worrying me.
If celt turns out to be human I will eat my shorts!
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!