Brain Teasers
Mr. Froopaloop's Band
Logic-Grid
Logic Grid puzzles come with a handy interactive grid that will help you solve the puzzle based on the given clues.Logic-Grid
Hans Ernest Froopaloop, Jr.'s second cousin, Wolfgang Amadeus Froopaloop, is the conductor of the Hans Ernest Froopaloop, Sr. the Third High School band. Five members of the band, Audrey, Brenda, Charlotte, Dawn, and Edith, are girls in grade 9, each one plays a wind instrument, and each wind instrument was rented from a different music store. Each girl has a brother in grade 11 (Victor, Walter, Xavier, Yoshi, and Zeke, in some order) and they each play a different string instrument. From smallest to largest, the string instruments are the violin, the guitar, the cello, the harp, and the piano. Here are some facts:
1. Victor, whose sister isn't the trumpet player, plays the only string instrument larger than that of the boy whose sister rented from the store on the west end of town but smaller than that of Brenda's brother. Brenda didn't rent from the store on the east end of town.
2. Three consecutively sized string instruments, from smallest to largest, are the one played by the saxophone player's brother, the one played by the boy whose sister rented from the store on the east end of town, and the one played by Charlotte's brother. Charlotte didn't rent from the store on the west end of town. Xavier's sister doesn't play the saxophone.
3. Dawn, who isn't the clarinet player, didn't rent from the store on the east end of town. Victor's sister, who isn't Dawn, didn't rent from the store on the north end of town.
4. Xavier doesn't play the violin or the piano. The trombone player's brother isn't Xavier or Yoshi. The brother of the trombone player (who isn't Edith) doesn't play the violin. Edith didn't rent from the store on the east end of town.
5. Victor's sister, who isn't the one who rented from the store in the center of town, doesn't play the clarinet. The saxophone player is neither the one who rented from the store on the north end of town nor Walter's sister.
The question is:
Who plays the flute and who rented from the store on the south end of town?
1. Victor, whose sister isn't the trumpet player, plays the only string instrument larger than that of the boy whose sister rented from the store on the west end of town but smaller than that of Brenda's brother. Brenda didn't rent from the store on the east end of town.
2. Three consecutively sized string instruments, from smallest to largest, are the one played by the saxophone player's brother, the one played by the boy whose sister rented from the store on the east end of town, and the one played by Charlotte's brother. Charlotte didn't rent from the store on the west end of town. Xavier's sister doesn't play the saxophone.
3. Dawn, who isn't the clarinet player, didn't rent from the store on the east end of town. Victor's sister, who isn't Dawn, didn't rent from the store on the north end of town.
4. Xavier doesn't play the violin or the piano. The trombone player's brother isn't Xavier or Yoshi. The brother of the trombone player (who isn't Edith) doesn't play the violin. Edith didn't rent from the store on the east end of town.
5. Victor's sister, who isn't the one who rented from the store in the center of town, doesn't play the clarinet. The saxophone player is neither the one who rented from the store on the north end of town nor Walter's sister.
The question is:
Who plays the flute and who rented from the store on the south end of town?
Answer
Edith plays the flute, which she rented from the store on the south end of town.From fact 1, Victor's sister didn't rent from the store on the west end. From fact 3, it's not on the north end. From fact 5, it's not in the center. From fact 1, Victor's instrument is the next smallest after Brenda's brother's, but from fact 2, the instrument played by the boy whose sister rented from the store on the east end is the next smallest after Charlotte's brother's. So Victor's sister must have rented from the store on the south end.
From fact 1, Brenda couldn't have rented from the store on the east end. From fact 2, it couldn't be Charlotte. From fact 3, it couldn't be Dawn. From fact 4, it couldn't be Edith. So it must be Audrey.
From fact 1, Victor's sister couldn't be Brenda. From fact 3, it couldn't be Dawn. From fact 1, Victor's instrument is the next largest after the one whose sister rented from the store on the west end, but from fact 2, Charlotte's brother's is the next largest after the one whose sister rented from the store on the east end. We have already
determined that Victor's sister rented from the store on the south end, while Audrey rented from the store on the east end. So Victor's sister must be Edith.
Continuing in this fashion, we can determine that there is only one possible solution:
Audrey plays the clarinet, which she rented from the store on the east end of town, and her brother, Xavier, plays the harp.
Brenda plays the saxophone, which she rented from the store in the center of town, and her brother, Yoshi, plays the cello.
Charlotte plays the trombone, which she rented from the store on the north end of town, and her brother, Zeke, plays the piano.
Dawn plays the trumpet, which she rented from the store on the west end of town, and her brother, Walter, plays the violin.
Edith plays the flute, which she rented from the store on the south end of town, and her brother, Victor, plays the guitar.
Hide Answer Show Answer
What Next?
View a Similar Brain Teaser...
If you become a registered user you can vote on this brain teaser, keep track of which ones you have seen, and even make your own.
Solve a Puzzle
Comments
nicly written, but only one problem:
1. Victor, whose sister isn't the trumpet player, plays the ONLY string instrument larger than that of the boy whose sister rented from the store on the west end of town but smaller than that of Brenda's brother. Brenda didn't rent from the store on the east end of town.
that does imply at first, the this would be the biggest string instrument. going on in the fact, you tell us, there is an even bigger one, which causes troubles, because now Victor's is not the "ONLY" bigger instrument any more.
1. Victor, whose sister isn't the trumpet player, plays the ONLY string instrument larger than that of the boy whose sister rented from the store on the west end of town but smaller than that of Brenda's brother. Brenda didn't rent from the store on the east end of town.
that does imply at first, the this would be the biggest string instrument. going on in the fact, you tell us, there is an even bigger one, which causes troubles, because now Victor's is not the "ONLY" bigger instrument any more.
hmm, going on in solving i come to the point, that is not solvable.
Girls, instruments, shops ... all no porblem. but the three brothers "Walter, Yoshi and Zeke" cannot be connected in just one configuration.
Victor and Yoshi are no problem too ...
We just know, Yoshi plays either Violin or Cello, Zeke the same and additional Piano and Walter plays either Violin or piano ...
Girls, instruments, shops ... all no porblem. but the three brothers "Walter, Yoshi and Zeke" cannot be connected in just one configuration.
Victor and Yoshi are no problem too ...
We just know, Yoshi plays either Violin or Cello, Zeke the same and additional Piano and Walter plays either Violin or piano ...
The way you've worded the clues is very awkward and unclear. Every one of them is a negative. Each time I've come by to solve, I cannot. It would be helpful to have at least one hint.
The way clue 1 is worded takes some careful reading before you figure out that it means those three instruments are consecutive in size. E.g., if X is the only integer larger than Y but smaller than Z, then it means that X-1 must be Y and X+1 must be Z. So clue 1 means that three consecutively sizes string instruments, from smallest to largest, are the one played by the boy whose sister rented from the store on the west end of town, Victor's instrument, and the one played by Brenda's brother.
Once you understand that clue, you can then realize that three instruments are listed in clue 1, and three are listed in clue 2. There are only five instruments total, so at least one string instrument (and possibly more) MUST be listed in both clues. Looking at the possible overlaps, and the fact that Brenda didn't rent from the east store and Charlotte didn't rent from the west store, the only overlap that's possible is for Brenda to be the saxophone player. That means the string instrument order, from smallest to largest, is west store, Victor, Brenda (who plays saxophone), east store, and finally Charlotte. So the girl who rented from the west store has a brother who plays violin, Charlotte's brother plays piano, and the rest all fit in between.
Then once you know a fact about all five string instruments, fitting in the rest becomes a simple matter of elimination. The tricky part is understanding clue 1 correctly.
Once you understand that clue, you can then realize that three instruments are listed in clue 1, and three are listed in clue 2. There are only five instruments total, so at least one string instrument (and possibly more) MUST be listed in both clues. Looking at the possible overlaps, and the fact that Brenda didn't rent from the east store and Charlotte didn't rent from the west store, the only overlap that's possible is for Brenda to be the saxophone player. That means the string instrument order, from smallest to largest, is west store, Victor, Brenda (who plays saxophone), east store, and finally Charlotte. So the girl who rented from the west store has a brother who plays violin, Charlotte's brother plays piano, and the rest all fit in between.
Then once you know a fact about all five string instruments, fitting in the rest becomes a simple matter of elimination. The tricky part is understanding clue 1 correctly.
To post a comment, please create an account and sign in.
Follow Braingle!