The Werewolf Game
Game #2327: C&I()XVII)Stewie's Last Huzzah
This private game is moderated by StewieGriffin. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.
This game finished in 10 rounds.
Once again a very quick night :O
*rawr*
*rawr*
We have one very active wolf on our hands. I have no suspicions yet, but we'll see how the round plays out.
Evidently from the fact that we're still playing, auntiesis was a human... I was unsure of her, and didn't really want to get involved in the votes, as I figured my judgement would be biased as she'd been gunning for me all game. I also have to admit I was wrong about ppjones - his last log in was two days ago, so he's cleared by this night round. His supposed activity in later rounds never surfaced, though.
I've been back through the round and kind of elaborated and reinforced on the "sure/unsure" list.
Players I believe to be human:
Ppjones Cleared by log-in times
Demonlord Cleared by log-in times
Masoni Voted for jervis in rounds 2 and 3, and was voted for by tahomac
Bradon Was the first to vote for caberet in round 2
Wolverine Voted for jervis round 2, cleared by log-in times according to Marc
Cinn Voted for jervis in round 2 and early in round 3, stated suspicion of tahomac early in round 4
And of course I know myself to be human, but can't prove it that easily to everyone else. My best offerings are Marc's lack of suspicion towards me, and tahomac's vote and suspicion of me.
This leaves us with just chang, talanpoe and superleaf in the "unsure" category. Regardless of legitimacy of excuse, chang and talanpoe have both been pretty inactive for most of the game, and when there are few suspicions it's always quite likely we have an inactive wolf. Superleaf joined the vote for jervis in round 3 quite early - he was the third to do so. There was quite a lot of suspicion of masoni at that point and I think it would have been too early for a wolf to condemn a fellow wolf, so that suggests he might be human. Not definite on this point, though.
So in summary... i think our prime candidates are chang and poe, with superleaf a little behind in third.
---This message was edited on 2011-01-23 03:53:34---
I've been back through the round and kind of elaborated and reinforced on the "sure/unsure" list.
Players I believe to be human:
Ppjones Cleared by log-in times
Demonlord Cleared by log-in times
Masoni Voted for jervis in rounds 2 and 3, and was voted for by tahomac
Bradon Was the first to vote for caberet in round 2
Wolverine Voted for jervis round 2, cleared by log-in times according to Marc
Cinn Voted for jervis in round 2 and early in round 3, stated suspicion of tahomac early in round 4
And of course I know myself to be human, but can't prove it that easily to everyone else. My best offerings are Marc's lack of suspicion towards me, and tahomac's vote and suspicion of me.
This leaves us with just chang, talanpoe and superleaf in the "unsure" category. Regardless of legitimacy of excuse, chang and talanpoe have both been pretty inactive for most of the game, and when there are few suspicions it's always quite likely we have an inactive wolf. Superleaf joined the vote for jervis in round 3 quite early - he was the third to do so. There was quite a lot of suspicion of masoni at that point and I think it would have been too early for a wolf to condemn a fellow wolf, so that suggests he might be human. Not definite on this point, though.
So in summary... i think our prime candidates are chang and poe, with superleaf a little behind in third.
---This message was edited on 2011-01-23 03:53:34---
Smithy I have pretty much come to the same conclusion as you. I would put you at the bottom of the list.
Questions are:
1. Do we have a wolf who has sat back and let the game play out as there hasn't been much suspicion towards them but they have voted almost every round - chang.
2. Do we have a wolf who has hardly been voting but contributing a little in the day rounds - talanpoe
3. Do we have an active wolf who has been posting throughout the game but only voting about half the rounds as they really haven't had any suspicion thrown their way - superleaf
From my standpoint and looking at the questions above my suspicions are in the following the order - talanpoe/chang and superleaf. I am about 50/50 between chang and talanpoe right now.
From the few games I have played with chang, in my mind he doesn't seem to be playing the same this game. He hasn't claimed to be the seer or really said anything to make him seem like a wolf. To me that makes him suspicious. Maybe RL has gotten in his way and he has used it to his advantage or he really hasn't had the time to put himself in the game as he usually does. However talanpoe seems to be trying to stay low and avoid suspicion. Until round 5 he hasn't had much suspicion thrown his way. Last round his comment about me trying to push the limits seems a bit odd. I don't know if he is just trying to respond to my early vote for him or if he was just trying to brush it off and hope the votes didn't continue his way.
In round 2 when cabaret saw the votes going her way she did try to defend herself, however after rereading her posts it didn't scream to me a human trying to defend themselves. Its like she didn't try hard enough to convince us. I guess I am feeling the same about talanpoe. For this reason I am voting talanpoe again this round, but my vote is subject to change.
Either way, however we all vote we should be able to win this game as humans.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Questions are:
1. Do we have a wolf who has sat back and let the game play out as there hasn't been much suspicion towards them but they have voted almost every round - chang.
2. Do we have a wolf who has hardly been voting but contributing a little in the day rounds - talanpoe
3. Do we have an active wolf who has been posting throughout the game but only voting about half the rounds as they really haven't had any suspicion thrown their way - superleaf
From my standpoint and looking at the questions above my suspicions are in the following the order - talanpoe/chang and superleaf. I am about 50/50 between chang and talanpoe right now.
From the few games I have played with chang, in my mind he doesn't seem to be playing the same this game. He hasn't claimed to be the seer or really said anything to make him seem like a wolf. To me that makes him suspicious. Maybe RL has gotten in his way and he has used it to his advantage or he really hasn't had the time to put himself in the game as he usually does. However talanpoe seems to be trying to stay low and avoid suspicion. Until round 5 he hasn't had much suspicion thrown his way. Last round his comment about me trying to push the limits seems a bit odd. I don't know if he is just trying to respond to my early vote for him or if he was just trying to brush it off and hope the votes didn't continue his way.
In round 2 when cabaret saw the votes going her way she did try to defend herself, however after rereading her posts it didn't scream to me a human trying to defend themselves. Its like she didn't try hard enough to convince us. I guess I am feeling the same about talanpoe. For this reason I am voting talanpoe again this round, but my vote is subject to change.
Either way, however we all vote we should be able to win this game as humans.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
I've just remembered something. Near the end of the first round, caberet posted:
As I said at the time, I don't really think begging everyone to arbitrarily shoot someone else just to save yourself is a wise course to take, but even less so if the person you are asking to be shot is a fellow wolf. If cab and chang were both wolves would she really be so ruthless to try and sacrifice him in the very first round? She could argue that it would then make her look human for the rest of the game, but I'm not sure anyone would do that so early on. This suggests chang might be human.
Cinn wrote:
This was my thought, too. He's posted a few times without really contributing much - seems like he's trying to appear active without getting too involved.
EDIT: For these reasons and those that cinn posted above, I will join her vote for talanpoe.
---This message was edited on 2011-01-23 05:43:25---
Yikes - There are still 2 votes on me? Help! Someone please change your vote to changhill! I'm hardly ever shot in this game, the wolves usually enjoy eating me instead. Someone? Please!
As I said at the time, I don't really think begging everyone to arbitrarily shoot someone else just to save yourself is a wise course to take, but even less so if the person you are asking to be shot is a fellow wolf. If cab and chang were both wolves would she really be so ruthless to try and sacrifice him in the very first round? She could argue that it would then make her look human for the rest of the game, but I'm not sure anyone would do that so early on. This suggests chang might be human.
Cinn wrote:
However talanpoe seems to be trying to stay low and avoid suspicion.
This was my thought, too. He's posted a few times without really contributing much - seems like he's trying to appear active without getting too involved.
EDIT: For these reasons and those that cinn posted above, I will join her vote for talanpoe.
---This message was edited on 2011-01-23 05:43:25---
cinnamon30 wrote:
Either way, however we all vote we should be able to win this game as humans.
I agree, Cinn and once again will trust your judgment. I would have looked at Superleaf's final comment in the last round as an attempt to make himself look innocent, but do like your reasoning at this point.
Sorry, Sis, I really thought I had you figured out, but once again have proven myself wrong.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
Either way, however we all vote we should be able to win this game as humans.
I agree, Cinn and once again will trust your judgment. I would have looked at Superleaf's final comment in the last round as an attempt to make himself look innocent, but do like your reasoning at this point.
Sorry, Sis, I really thought I had you figured out, but once again have proven myself wrong.
Formula for success: rise early, work hard, strike oil. J. Paul Getty
I believed I was cleared before. Marc (our seer) gave me a vote of confidence before and he must have divined my identity. Please don't waste your time over me there is a more important wolf out there.
Superleaf, I have reread all of Marc's posts and I don't see anywhere where he gave you a vote of confidence. Can you point out where that post is exactly?
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Knowledge is not power. The USE of knowledge is power.
Marc amended superleaf's "human / unsure" list, and didn't add Superleaf to the "unsure" list. I'm not sure if that's what superleaf is referring to, neither am I sure if it constitutes Marc implying superleaf is human or simply forgetting to add him into considerations after copy-pasting superleaf's list. Still, superleaf, of our three candidates general consensus is that you're third in line, so don't go getting over defensive and making everyone nervous.
Smithy wrote:
Guilty as charged, but hopefully I can help with the last one.
The reason Gumby isn't smiling is because Deb is keeping him captive against his will.
His supposed activity in later rounds never surfaced, though.
Guilty as charged, but hopefully I can help with the last one.
The reason Gumby isn't smiling is because Deb is keeping him captive against his will.
cinnamon30 wrote:
Hahaha, that will never escape me, in my defense it was only twice that I've said I was seer when I wasn't. The first time proved successful, the last time not so much. Like I said this past week we were in a big audit that was consuming most of my time. But I am here now, my only worry is that is Talan proves to be human and I prove to be human... that people will need to seriously need to re evaluate their standards as to who are wolf or not. But that still two rounds away...
At this point I will go ahead and put in my vote and hope for the best.
*rawr*
From the few games I have played with chang, in my mind he doesn't seem to be playing the same this game. He hasn't claimed to be the seer or really said anything to make him seem like a wolf. To me that makes him suspicious. Maybe RL has gotten in his way and he has used it to his advantage or he really hasn't had the time to put himself in the game as he usually does.
Hahaha, that will never escape me, in my defense it was only twice that I've said I was seer when I wasn't. The first time proved successful, the last time not so much. Like I said this past week we were in a big audit that was consuming most of my time. But I am here now, my only worry is that is Talan proves to be human and I prove to be human... that people will need to seriously need to re evaluate their standards as to who are wolf or not. But that still two rounds away...
At this point I will go ahead and put in my vote and hope for the best.
*rawr*
I'm going to vote for talanpoe. Let's hope this is our last one
Im votin for talanpoe and see where tht takes us. If he/she is the wolf the game should be over.
You cannot post messages in previous rounds.
Follow Braingle!