Braingle: The Werewolf Game

The Werewolf Game #2807

This game is moderated by Rhythmic. Please read the rules and contact the moderator with any questions or concerns about this game.

Voting Discussion
This game finished in 6 rounds.

Discussion of Round #2

Round: 0 1 2 3 4 5 6

Author

Message

Rhythmic

Posted: 08:53PM Oct 3, 2012

Welcome to Round 2!

Voting for Round #1
Day
21kaldridge21 voted for babyjuice
babyjuice voted for Izzie
Fawn_Rose voted for Yetiman811
GrizzlyBear0630 voted for Longhorn_fan
HABS2933 voted for 21kaldridge21
Izzie voted for MrsBlondie
JJPutz voted for HABS2933
joseph_r03 voted for JJPutz
MimseyMcCormack voted for Fawn_Rose
MrsBlondie voted for PYTHON
SirHar voted for GrizzlyBear0630
snowmonster voted for Longhorn_fan
Yetiman811 voted for snowmonster
At dusk, Longhorn_fan was shot with the silver bullet.

Night
MrsBlondie was eaten before dawn.

Longhorn_fan and MrsBlondie were human. Neither one was the seer. MrsBlondie was an Oracle

---This message was edited on 2012-10-04 10:57:47---

"Music should always be an adventure." - Coleman Hawkins

Yetiman811

Posted: 08:56PM Oct 3, 2012

Well, let me state the obvious for everyone: Har is a wolf. However, the question is whether we should shoot him now or search for the rest. I personally like the plan of keeping him alive until the end, that way we have a surefire extra round to work with.

HABS2933

Posted: 08:57PM Oct 3, 2012

I am not sure if night timed out or not,, but if it didn't it was close. The wolves may have planned to have night time out to point us in the direction of an inactive player as a wolf. I think I will just place a random vote for now.

Whaddayaat

GrizzlyBear0630

Posted: 08:59PM Oct 3, 2012

while I'm all for finding the wolfs, how do you know Har is a wolf?

babyjuice

Posted: 09:00PM Oct 3, 2012

Yetiman811 wrote:

While I'm going back to look through last round, mind an explanation?

Yetiman811

Posted: 09:02PM Oct 3, 2012

GrizzlyBear0630 wrote:

while I'm all for finding the wolfs, how do you know Har is a wolf?

The night timed out. I know because I was timing it. It ended exactly on the dot it was set to time out. Har is the only person who didn't sign in at all today. Therefore, we can have the assumption that he is a wolf.

babyjuice

Posted: 09:05PM Oct 3, 2012

...and I'm not gonna ask why you were timing the rounds

I haven't played many games with Har, will he put fellow wolves under the bus?

Yetiman811

Posted: 09:08PM Oct 3, 2012

babyjuice wrote:

...and I'm not gonna ask why you were timing the rounds

I haven't played many games with Har, will he put fellow wolves under the bus?

I have no clue. This is the only game I've played with him too, but it's always good to have an ace in these games.

babyjuice

Posted: 09:10PM Oct 3, 2012

Let me do a little searching...

GrizzlyBear0630

Posted: 09:11PM Oct 3, 2012

Yetiman811 wrote:

GrizzlyBear0630 wrote:

while I'm all for finding the wolfs, how do you know Har is a wolf?

NO NO NO, people keep saying this and I have to keep reminding people, the wolves have a talk box...they can plan and strategize, so 2 out the the 3 wolfs voting for one person and the 3rd not voting so night times out is completely possible...I'm not defending har, just saying to condemn him as a wolf just because night timed out isn't enough...

HABS2933

Posted: 09:15PM Oct 3, 2012

GrizzlyBear0630 wrote:

I agree totally, that is not to say Har isn't a wolf, but his not being on could be coincidental. As I pointed out as well as Grizzly, the wolves could have planned to have night time out. I think we should leave Har alone for now. My vote for Fawn is totally random and does not mean I suspect her in the least. She has been quiet so far, but not reading anything into that.

Whaddayaat

JJPutz

Posted: 09:16PM Oct 3, 2012

↑↑↑
I agree with grizz.
SPV for meh twin.

North Korea, eat a Snickers. You're a bit nuclear terroristic when you're hungry.

JJPutz

Posted: 09:17PM Oct 3, 2012

BTW, HABS is that you in your avi?

North Korea, eat a Snickers. You're a bit nuclear terroristic when you're hungry.

babyjuice

Posted: 09:18PM Oct 3, 2012

BTW, HABS is that you in your avi?

babyjuice

Posted: 09:19PM Oct 3, 2012

↑↑↑
I agree with grizz.
SPV for meh twin.

HABS2933

Posted: 09:21PM Oct 3, 2012

Yes that is me, many many moons ago (as can be discerned from the lovely early 80s decor).

Whaddayaat

Yetiman811

Posted: 09:22PM Oct 3, 2012

If you don't agree with me, fine. I'm just saying that Har is extremely large in my book of suspects right now. Also, if the wolves strategized their play so that the night would time out, then they were really pushing the doubt factor in my opinion. What are the chances that the night just happens to time out, and Har is the only person to not sign in?

Izzie

Posted: 09:52PM Oct 3, 2012

random vote, subject to change.

˙ǝızzı(p) ¿y ahora? the new refrigerator came. If you need me, i will be playing in the box.

snowmonster

Posted: 09:55PM Oct 3, 2012

I agree with those that feel it's more than likely a set up for SirHar. I've seen it done many times. Wolves will purposely allow the night to time out, so those that have not logged on yet, will look like wolves. This is not to say SirHar can't be a wolf - it's just that it's too early to tell if he is or is not, and can't base our decision of him, on how the night round ended.

I will place another SPV vote this round, but not until later. At this point, I don't have any suspicions.

Take all sorrow out of life and you take away all richness, and depth, and tenderness. The capacity of sorrow belongs to our grandeur. It is the furnace that melts hearts together in love. In loving memory of my dear friend Guy - take care Goobs . .

Yetiman811

Posted: 10:28PM Oct 3, 2012

Alright, I'll go SPV too

GrizzlyBear0630

Posted: 10:46PM Oct 3, 2012

spv for now

21kaldridge21

Posted: 11:25PM Oct 3, 2012

Spv for now

"Got a secret? Can you keep it?"

PYTHON

Posted: 03:26AM Oct 4, 2012

Thanks everyone who helpedme not to get shot last round. I just couldn't get on in time to check if the game had started or not. Quite different to Sleepless Nights 8! It is likely that the wolves will use an inactive as cover to let the rounds time out now. I will SPV for now but that is subject to change.

How many accounts do you have on Braingle?

HABS2933

Posted: 04:58AM Oct 4, 2012

snowmonster wrote:

UNLESS . . . we have VERY clever wolves who let the night time out on purpose to make it look like SirHar is a wolf, knowing it would make some of us doubt that he really is and not vote for him when in fact he really is a wolf.

I personally doubt that Har is a wolf, and don't even know it was him that was being set up - it is a fairly good bet someone will not log on especially during the early rounds, the wolves were just playing the odds of this happening and trying to set up whomever that happened to be.

I hae a few ideas but it is still early in the game. As I don't know this player and have never (to my recollection) played with him/her I am not sure if what I am seeing as suspicious may just be the way he/she plays.

I most likely won't be back for 7-8 hrs but will be back on as soon as I get home.

Whaddayaat

Fawn_Rose

Posted: 05:07AM Oct 4, 2012

Hi all I voted for SirHar.

joseph_r03

Posted: 07:01AM Oct 4, 2012

SPV for now.

Izzie

Posted: 10:54AM Oct 4, 2012

to jj and babyjuice, we just lost the mets farm team to toronto

at this point i am keeping my svp for joseph
however it it still possible that i might change it

˙ǝızzı(p) ¿y ahora? the new refrigerator came. If you need me, i will be playing in the box.

snowmonster

Posted: 11:34AM Oct 4, 2012

Ok, placing an SPV vote for Grizzlybear. Don't suspect him at all, at this point. My vote could change before the round ends, but I doubt it.

Where is SirHar? Been MIA for 2 days now. . . . .

HABS2933

Posted: 02:30PM Oct 4, 2012

snowmonster wrote:

Where is SirHar? Been MIA for 2 days now. . . . .

IT is rather quiet without him around isn't it? Not like him to stay in the background.
Has he been online at all? Or just not playing the game?

Whaddayaat

babyjuice

Posted: 03:54PM Oct 4, 2012

Izzie wrote:

to jj and babyjuice, we just lost the mets farm team to toronto

at this point i am keeping my svp for joseph
however it it still possible that i might change it

Coinkydink? I think NOT

SirHar hasn't been online in two days

JJPutz

Posted: 03:57PM Oct 4, 2012

to jj and babyjuice, we just lost the mets farm team to toronto

WHAT????????

North Korea, eat a Snickers. You're a bit nuclear terroristic when you're hungry.

babyjuice

Posted: 04:46PM Oct 4, 2012

Lol, it's alright.

Mets FTW

21kaldridge21

Posted: 04:47PM Oct 4, 2012

I find it interesting that mimsey has been on today but has not posted or voted

"Got a secret? Can you keep it?"

HABS2933

Posted: 04:51PM Oct 4, 2012

21kaldridge21 wrote:

I find it interesting that mimsey has been on today but has not posted or voted

EXACTLY, that is why I personally don't like using log in times to determine anything, just because someone is online does not mean they are playing the game. One of our "inactive" wolves may be very active indeed.

---This message was edited on 2012-10-04 17:09:24---

Whaddayaat

snowmonster

Posted: 05:06PM Oct 4, 2012

Are you thinking memsey is acting wolfish, HABS?

MimseyMcCormack

Posted: 05:14PM Oct 4, 2012

Sorry, signed on my phone but had to go to class before I could even get to the game and I didn't exit out of it completely...SPV for now, going to do some homework and hopefully check back and see if anything has changed

This statement is false!

HABS2933

Posted: 05:16PM Oct 4, 2012

snowmonster wrote:

Are you thinking memsey is acting wolfish, HABS?

No,, not Mimsey. I was thinking that Yeti may be a wolf. As I stated, I have never played with him, but I find it interesting that in the first round, he was adamantly opposed to voting off Python for being somewhat inactive, and this round that is exactly the reason he wants to vote Har. Not sure if it means anything or not, or if I am reading into it. Just a thought. Why is it okay for Python to be inactive but not Har? As I said, I am not ready to follow up on it, nor am I suggesting anyone else does either.
If Har is not on, there is a reason; and I don't think it has anything to do with being a wolf. I've seen him as a human and as a wolf, he doesn't stop blathering (no ofense Har) no matter what his role.

---This message was edited on 2012-10-04 18:34:12---

Whaddayaat

GrizzlyBear0630

Posted: 05:41PM Oct 4, 2012

Suspecting yeti, jj, babyjuice, and python...just want to throw out my suspicions in case I don't make it through the night....

babyjuice

Posted: 05:47PM Oct 4, 2012

I have a mild suspicion for Fawn_Rose...

It's still a bit early though for a full out explanation

snowmonster

Posted: 06:16PM Oct 4, 2012

Thanks for explaining your thoughts HABS. Personally, I hadn't made the connection you did, with Yeti. Something to consider, I suppose. This round though, I'm keeping my SPV vote. I don't want to take a chance and form a majority when I'm not really suspicious of Yeti, or anyone.

HABS2933

Posted: 06:38PM Oct 4, 2012

The whole JJ and Babyjuice having the same avi and signature and mirroring each others posts seems to me a bit contrived. It may be cute or funny or a post or two, but they have been doing it all round.

Whaddayaat

Yetiman811

Posted: 07:14PM Oct 4, 2012

HABS2933 wrote:

snowmonster wrote:

Are you thinking memsey is acting wolfish, HABS?

I can understand your suspicions, but I never said to vote for Har right now. I said that he could be saved for a later round when we need an extra round. I wanted to protect PY because he usually doesn't show up some rounds, and he almost nearly gets shot or eaten in the first round. Plus, I'm a firm believer in everyone getting one vote during the first round unless evidence shows otherwise

JJPutz

Posted: 07:21PM Oct 4, 2012

HABS, were twins. duh.

North Korea, eat a Snickers. You're a bit nuclear terroristic when you're hungry.

HABS2933

Posted: 07:30PM Oct 4, 2012

JJPutz wrote:

HABS, were twins. duh.

That is my point JJ, at what point did the two of you decide to become twins? You must have discussed it, I doubt it just happened.

---This message was edited on 2012-10-04 19:42:46---

Whaddayaat

babyjuice

Posted: 07:50PM Oct 4, 2012

Years and years and years... and you never left me no messages, you never sent no letters, you... oops, getting carried away.

A few weeks ago. 'course we discussed it. It's all part of a master plan of ours and a few of our friends